10 Plot Holes That Almost Ruined Back To The Future

Back to the Future Back To The Future is one of the most beloved franchises in all of cinema history. It's fun, exciting and has captured people's imaginations for decades. It is also very flawed and filled with ridiculous head scraching plot holes which in most other films would see it laughed off as confusing stupidity. But luckily this isn't some other film series and Back To The Future is so darn good we'll forgive these plot holes until the end of time. Nonetheless let's look at the 10 plot holes that almost ruined Back To The Future

10. Marty Erased His Original Parents

awed Time travel in films is always a tricky subject. Different stories have different rules of how it works, and what you can and can€™t do. Back To The Future Part Two introduced the idea that after Biff stole the sports almanac and gave it to his younger self he unknowingly created an alternative timeline. Marty and Doc then fight to put things back as they were. Except they don€™t. Marty by this point was already living in an alternative version of 1985. At the end of Part One Marty is thrilled to be back in 1985 and find that his mother is slim, his father is successful and his brother is still Jimmy Olsen, having prevented him and his siblings being erased from time. But this is not exactly how things were at the start of the movie. When Marty sees his brother Dave is wearing a suit to work this comes as a shock to him. Marty has no memory of this version of reality. This therefore isn€™t Marty€™s version of reality and he doesn€™t really belong there anymore then he did the bad version of 1985 seen in Part Two. Marty has in effect erased the original versions of his family and Biff and everyone, Doc included, from time. Well at least from his perspective. It could be argued that he left the original versions of his family in their version of reality wondering where Marty disappeared to, never to be seen again. If Marty really wanted to fix time he€™d go back to 1955, stop his younger self interfering with his parents falling in love, bundle him into the Delorean and drop him off in front of the Doc€™s bullet ridden body. Of course there are never ending complications of €˜how would he be able to do this if he prevented etc etc...€™ but you get the point. There'll be more alternative reality based dilemmas coming up shortly!

9. Why Wasn€™t Old Jennifer Expecting Herself?

two jennifers When old Doc meets and talks to young Doc in Part Two it can be explained that old Doc simply forgot that his younger self had had a conversation with a random man he met on the street. That makes sense as the young Doc would have no reason to remember this interaction. What makes less sense is that the old version of Jennifer was shocked to see her younger self, and that it caused her to faint. Why wouldn't old Jennifer be aware of this? She surely would remember going in the time machine with Marty and Doc Brown wouldn't she? The Doc did his Men in Black memory zapper thing that he explained would make young Jennifer believe that her travelling in time was just a dream. She then woke up however and was trying to get out of her and Marty's future home in Hilldale. There's no way she's still think that was a dream, so why wouldn't the version of herself that was thirty years older know not to come in and make her younger self faint?

8. Why Don€™t George And Lorraine Recognise That Their Son Is Calvin Klein?

efef Marty accidently ends up in 1955 and almost prevents his own existence by inadvertently making it so his parents don€™t fall in love as they had originally. Mistakes happen, and once they€™ve happened one must do what they can to put things right. Marty does this, but to do it Marty has to meddle with time lots and lots more. So much so that he has to befriend his father and date his mother. He even does the whole Mr Miyagi thing with George and teaches him to be tough. George certainly didn€™t forget how to fight and remained dominant force over bully Biff for thirty years up until 1985. What George did forget however, along with Lorraine, Biff, Mr Strickland, Marty€™s maternal grandparents and uncles and aunts... and possibly Goldie Wilson is that Marty looks identical to that kid who went to Hill Valley High School for a week in 1955 and who sung at the Enchantment Under the Sea Dance. George should be have been worried when Lorraine had a baby that grew up looking just like the guy she dated at high school. Maybe there€™s a scene that happened in 1982 where George accuses Lorraine of an affair or Lorraine struggles to figure out if she got drunk in 1969 and had a one night stand with that Calvin Klein fella.

7. Where Are The Alternative Versions Of Doc, Marty And Jennifer In The Alternative 1985?

ohshit At the end of Part One Marty arrives back in 1985 to see his slightly younger self set off in the time machine which started his adventure in the past. In Part Two the Doc and Jennifer even interact with other versions of themselves. These scenes clearly establish that two versions of the same person can coexist in the same time period. What's less clear is whether upon entering into an alternative reality you replace the existence of the other version of yourself that was there already. Even though every version of the future the characters return to is technically an alternative timeline, we'll just examine the 'bad 1985' as it€™s the only reality they acknowledge as being an alternative reality. In the bad reality it€™s said that Doc has been committed and that Marty has been sent away by Biff to study in Europe. They never establish where the bad reality version of Jennifer is supposed to be when she is left on the porch outside what we can assume in this version of time is not her house. What isn't clear is whether another version of the Doc was sat in a mental institution, or whether another Marty was still studying in Europe. However long the Doc had been committed for it didn't change the fact that his dog Einstein was still at his home, and other then his dog bed being upturned not looking too worse for wear. You have to feel bad for the version of Marty that was happily studying abroad as you can be sure the rich Biff would give him hell upon his return to the US!

6. How Did Old Biff Return The Delorean to 2015?

old biff In Back To The Future Part Two Marty buys the sports almanac with the intention of placing a few bets in the past and guaranteeing he€™ll win. The Doc goes all moral on him and slaps him on the wrist, but unknown to them Old Biff is overhearing this and hatches his devious plan to make himself rich in his youth. Old Biff takes the almanac from the trash, steals the Delorean and successfully goes back in time to 1955 where he gives young Biff the book of sports facts. Having done this Old Biff then returns the time machine to 2015 where Marty and Doc use it to go to back to 1985. Once there they discover that the 1985 they have arrived in is the future based on how old Biff had changed the past in 1955. How was old Biff able to return the car to 2015? The Doc warns Marty in the bad 1985 that they cannot stop old Biff in 2015 as it would be the future of the bad universe, so how was old Biff able to return the car to the good version of time and not just wind up in a version of 2015 where he was already rich and powerful?

5. There Were Two Cars In 1885

bttf When the Doc gets stranded in 1885 he leaves a letter giving instructions to Marty where to find the Delorean and what needs to be done to repair it. Sure enough Marty, along with 1955 Doc find where the car was abandoned and fix it readying Marty to return to 1985. Before this can happen they discover that the Doc trapped in the past will be killed days after writing the letter so off Marty sets to the old west to rescue Doc Brown from an untimely death. A run in with a group of native Americans leave Marty with a punctured gas tank and no fuel to get the car up to the needed 88 mph, and sets up the whole films plot of finding a way of pushing the Delorean with a train. None of this was necessary! When Marty received this puncture he and Doc could have just made a short trip to where the version of the Delorean that Doc arrived in 1885 was and siphoned off the petrol! There's no reason to believe that the Doc had run out of petrol upon arriving in 1885, or any good reason why he would have emptied the tank before hiding it in the cave where he instructed Marty to find it. Between the two cars that existed in 1885 Doc and Marty could have easily had a working vehicle. All of these car repairs weren't actually needed either which bring us to the next point...

4. You Don't Need To Keep Time Traveling If You Can Just Send Letters

do not open In Back To The Future Marty faced a difficult decision of whether to tell the Doc that moments before he was transported back in time he had witnessed the older version of Emmet Brown gunned down. The younger Doc had warned Marty about telling him too much about his future, so Marty decided to write the Doc a letter which he could open in 1985. Doc proceeded to tear it up and Marty never got the chance to warn his friend of his impending doom. Upon returning to where he belonged Marty once again saw the Doc shot, but was delighted to discover that after leaving the past the Doc had had a change of heart and managed to retrieve the torn pieces of the letter, tape them together and buy himself a bullet proof vest. Why did he still allow himself to be shot? With his advanced knowledge of the future the Doc could have arranged to meet Marty anywhere else where the Libyans wouldn€™t have been able to find him and shoot him. Furthermore he could have stopped Marty getting trapped in the past. What€™s that I hear you say? Preventing Marty from time travelling in the first place would have meant that he couldn€™t write the letter that warned the Doc and therefore create a paradox that would destroy the universe. Oh would it? The Doc doesn't seem to think so as he wrote a letter to Marty that he received at the end of Part Two. Had Doc not sent this letter then surely Marty would have been trapped in 1955, and who's to say he wasn't supposed to end up stuck there? Saving Marty from 1955 could have just as easily led to the destruction of the universe. This whole mess of what happened in Part Three could have been avoided if upon realising that they would get a petrol leak, the Doc had gone back down to Western Union and said that he wanted to leave an additional note with the letter he was sending Marty. It could have read "Dear Marty, if you do decide to come and rescue me make sure you have a gas can with a couple of extra gallons...oh and some chocolate digestives would be nice too." Problem solved.

3. With All Changes Made In 1955 and 1885, How Come Jennifer Was Still On The Swing Outside Her House?

the swinf When Marty, Doc and Jennifer returned to 1985 in Part Two they discovered the world as they knew it had changed, and they were now in an alternative version of 1985. To put things back as they were Doc and Marty went back to 1955 to stop old Biff€™s influence from drastically changing the future. They themselves did make some more changes to time they hadn€™t originally happened when Marty had accidentally gone back in time in Part One. For example Biff€™s friends got knocked out with sandbags, Biff crashed his car into another manure truck and one shop owner had sold an extra pair of binoculars. These may not be the biggest changes of time, but its hard to discuss time travel without mentioning the butterfly effect. Surely any of these changes would have made had big implications on the time period they left Jennifer in. But that€™s not all. After successfully stopping Biff become a millionaire Doc Brown is inadvertently sent back to 1885 creating another new version of events. Marty then learns that the Doc is killed in the past so goes back to rescue him, which would create another new timeline of events. The changes here are even more dramatic as an entire century of ripples through time would occur before Marty rejoined Jennifer in 1985. So...after three major changes to the past how on earth was Jennifer still asleep on the same porch bench where Marty had left her?

2. Why Did Marty Not Start To Disappear Earlier In The Film?

back to the future blu As mentioned before, time travel is a tricky subject to put over on screen. Establishing how it works can lead to inconsistencies, and Back To The Future has a load of them, and the way the films showed changes in time taking effect is one of these inconsistencies that makes little sense. In Part One we see Marty look at a photo of himself with his brother and sister. As the film progresses, starting with his eldest sibling they all start to disappear, effectively fading away from time. Later in parts Two and Three we see newspapers headlines, faxes and photos of grave stones magically alter themselves to reflect changes in time. The inconsistency comes in that other than the photo of Marty and his siblings all of the other changes are instantly. And whilst these instant changes are obviously just the simplest way to show the audience what has happened, they do nevertheless highlight a flaw in the way time is altered throughout the series. When Marty burns the sports almanac at the end of part two we see headlines instantly change to see that George McFly no longer dies and that the Doc is commended rather than committed. If changes in time are instant in their effect it suggests Marty wasted a lot of time trying to put things right in Part One when he didn€™t need to. These swift changes suggest that Marty's continued meddling in time in Part One was the reason his brother and sister continued to vanish from the photo. Had he left well alone after just his brother's hair disappeared he could have expected to return to 1985 t at worst find Dave was bald on top. The slow progression of change to the photo means that time was probably going to put itself right or Marty should have instantly vanished the moment he pushed his father from in front of that car.

1. Who Wrote Johnny Be Good Originally?

back This one is admitadly nit picking, but if you put something on film then you leave yourself open to it being nitpicked. At the Enchantment Under The Sea Dance Marty played and sung The Chuck Berry song Johnny Be Good. Mid way through the song, Marvin the singer who injured his hand calls up his cousin Chuck Berry and tells him to listen to Marty€™s song as it could be the new sound he is looking for. This situations, as tongue in cheek as it may be suggests that Chuck Berry plagiarised the song he had heard Marty play and later claim it as his own. In a classic case of what came first, the chicken or the egg type scenario the film creates a situation where Marty could not have played the song without knowing the Chuck Berry original. Chuck Berry meanwhile could not have written it unless he had overheard Marty play it. This is where Doctor Who fans would simply state €˜Wibbly wobbly timey winey€™ and move on. It seems good advice so let€™s do the same!

Contributor
Contributor

Hello! My name is David Pustansky. As well as writing for this site, I'm also an actor, presenter, writer, director and artist. So basically I love creative things where there's a story to be told. I run my own theatre company, The ImProDigies. Be sure to check our shows out. As I'm sure you'll see from my articles I often look into things with a unique and quirky perspective and have a strange attention to sometimes strange details. Enjoy!