10 Reasons Why Batman Fans Are Always Wrong About Everything

The Joker

Among my peers, I am the Batman fan. A lot of the time, however, I am also the only Batman fan (or comic book fan in general). So taking things to the Internet instead of driving my friends crazy allows for great discussions to occur with other Gothamites - though, unfortunately, there's no escaping the venomous conversations there, either. Batman fans can quickly become mama bear if and/or when their perceived notion of Batman is challenged. Take the casting of Ben Affleck as precedence, and how the news quickly rose to the top of the Twittersphere.

It doesn't end with Ben Affleck, of course - there are lots of notions that Batman fans tend to get antsy about. Here are the top 10 most sensitive Batman-related arguments amongst Batman purists, many of which a lot of fans seem to have got totally and utterly wrong...

10. Batman Voice Acting

Kevin Conroy Batman Arkham Origins 600x332

Firstly, I will state this before I get a fanboy Batarang to the back of the head - to me, Kevin Conroy & Mark Hamill are Batman and the Joker. They have voiced these characters throughout the DC Animated Universe TV series such as Batman: The Animated Series/The Adventures of Batman & Robin/The New Batman Adventures, Superman: The Animated Series, Batman Beyond, Static Shock, Justice League, Justice League Unlimited, as well as the various video game extensions and into new ones such as Batman: Arkham Asylum and Batman: Arkham City. These are the voices that I have grown up with and as such have set the standard on how these characters should be portrayed. However, when Conroy is not voicing the Dark Knight, does that mean we should discount the television show or video game in advance? Of course not, Diedrich Bader did a great job as Batman in Batman: The Brave and the Bold, his bass voice bringing strength and confidence to Batman's character during his various team-ups. Another great is Bruce Greenwood, who was arguably better-suited than Conroy as Batman in Batman: Under the Red Hood and the Young Justice series. Greenwood's gravel-throated Batman always speaks with conviction, whether he is pleading with Jason Todd to consider his actions or scolding Robin's tactics. As for the Joker, check out Troy Baker's rendition of the Joker's monologue from Alan Moore's The Killing Joke...

9. Casting

joker_heath_ledger

A comedian as Batman? Are they crazy? Why so serious, Bat fans? The media and fans were absolutely shocked back in 1989 with the studio casting Michael Keaton as Batman. No muscles? No problem! Rubber suits for everyone! The fact is the movie was successful and still revered by some fans as the iconic Batman movie (though some Batman fans may be wrong about that, too). The same backlash occurred when casting news broke about Heath Ledger as the Joker. Few can argue that his Joker in Christopher Nolan's take on Batman wasn't the highlight of the entire series, and Ledger posthumously won an Oscar for the role. I cannot predict the future, so I won't go so far as to say Batfleck will be successful in portraying an "older, more experienced Batman." However, given fandom's track record thus far, the outburst of fans on the Internet may be eating their words by the time the next movie swoops into cinemas.

8. Batman Is The Most Hardcore Of All DC Superheroes

Dark Knight For a man who watched his parents get gunned down in front of him as a child, Bruce Wayne's life was thrust into a journey of pain and determination. There are many points to argue alongside this, perhaps the greatest being Frank Miller's The Dark Knight Returns, which showcases an aged Batman taking down a gang of street punks and their hulking leader, his final confrontation with the Joker, and eventually an all-out knuckle-chucking between Batman and Superman (which has been referenced as source material for the upcoming Batman vs. Superman film). Also, Batman delivered a one-punch knockout to Green Lantern Guy Gardner in Justice League #5, which was later animated here in Batman: Brave and the Bold... However, Batman was not always so grim and gritty - lest we forget Adam West's time as the Caped Crusader? Sure, he was Batman-smart enough to pack Shark Repellent Bat-Spray when going in to combat, but for a man whose parents were murdered he sure likes to dance a lot while in costume. There are various other clips that can be referenced here, but perhaps none are as great a nod to the campy series than those spoofed in The Simpsons here and this tip-of-the-hat Radioactive Man clip here.

7. Batman Hates Guns

Batman Guns This plot device was heavily explored in recent comics, as well as by the DC Comics Animated Universe (aka DCAU, Timmverse or Diniverse named after producer Bruce Timm and Paul Dini, respectively). The idea spurns from the fact that young Bruce Wayne watched his parents get gunned down in an alley, and thus gun crimes are the most abhorrent of all to the Batman. However, only the elite Batman fans know that at one point Batman himself used a gun (hey, he already has the belt, why not a holster?) back in October 1939 in a story written by none other than Batman creator Bob Kane. Loaded with silver bullets, Batman used it to exterminate a vampire problem.

Batman 2

Pretty cold to cap a guy in his sleep, don't you think? That's our Batman!

6. Batman Doesn't Kill

Batmanthecult1

This point was heavily discussed in an argument between Batman himself and the revived Jason Todd (Robin II, who was killed by the Joker). After the Joker paralyzed Barbara Gordon (Batgirl) and murdered Jason, Batman admitted that he was tempted to cross the line, but cited his personal code that if he begins to kill his enemies he will lose focus of his goal of protection, and will not be able to come back from it. Ultimately, he admits it would be "too easy." We just saw an image of Batman shooting a slumbering vampire - but it's not really killing if the person is undead, right? Well, in the dark graphic novel Batman: The Cult, Batman is brainwashed into joining Deacon Blackfire's underground followers and ultimately finds himself armed and unleashed into Gotham City, where he begins shooting upon civilians. Yes, we can submit that Batman was unaware of what he was doing, believing he was shooting villains when he was shooting innocent people. But the underlying theme is that Blackfire was able to get into Batman's subconscious, expose his vulnerabilities and ignite his darkest desires, as evidenced in Batman's thoughts: "It feels terrific. Should have done this a long time ago."

5. Batman Doesn't Need Help

Batman Robin Damian Death 600x302

This one is generally spoken by fans of the Nolan franchise and why Batman doesn't need a Robin. However, Batman has a lot of help in this franchise. Alfred prepares his gear, stitches him up, creates alibis et cetera. Lucius Fox designs all of his major equipment, including the Tumbler, Bat-Pod, The Bat and more. Commissioner Gordon provides intelligence, as well as helps divert the Gotham City Police Department, if necessary. In the comics, Oracle (formerly Batgirl) was Batman's main source of intelligence, using her computer hacking abilities to provide mapping, background information and other necessary secrets. Batman has had five Robins aid him, each of which has bailed Batman out of more than enough jams (including the previously mentioned Batman: The Cult), and Nightwing (the first Robin now grown up) continues to do so, even taking on the mantle of Batman when necessary. And then there are other Gotham allies like Catwoman, Huntress, Batwoman and Question, and globally the Batman Incorporated allies like Batwing and Knight and Squire. Even Frank Miller's The Dark Knight Returns proves that Robin is an essential part of Batman's legacy. Oh, and let's not forget Superman, Wonder Woman and the rest of the Justice League. Perhaps no one has better argued that Batman requires an a Robin than former Robin Tim Drake (now Red Robin). A young detective, Tim Drake is able to deduce that Bruce Wayne is Batman and Dick Grayson was Robin (Grayson had moved on to become Nightwing), Drake tried to get the Dynamic Duo to again partner after Jason Todd's death (the second Robin). While there was resistance between the superheroes to agree to partner, Batman was impressed with Drake's skills and took him under his mantle to become the third Robin. Finally, there's the Knightfall story arc where Batman has his back broken by Bane (the obvious source material used in The Dark Knight Rises) and Jean Paul Valley takes on the mantle of the Bat, and other allies such as Nightwing, Robin and Catwoman have to step up to fill in his shoes while Bruce underwent a miraculous healing process.

4. Batman Always Has a Plan

superman-vs-batman When your allies are space cops or near-gods, it's no wonder that in order for Batman to be relevant on a team like the Justice League, he has to consistently use his brain to save the day. Various stories show Batman previously or behind-the-scenes initiating a contingency plan (like the Hellspores in the Supergirl storyline in Superman/Batman). Perhaps the most notable of these contingency plans, however, is from the Justice League storyline Tower of Babel, which later went on to become the DTV film Justice League: Doom. In story, Batman had created a contingency plan to take down every single member of the Justice League in case any one went rogue. The problem with such plans is that they can be stolen and exploited by your enemies, which is exactly what happened. Sure, the JLA survived the fight, but the end result was Batman's expulsion from the League for his part in the betrayal of his teammates. But what about those actual instances where Batman didn't have a plan? The aforementioned Knightfall was a good example where Bane was more prepared than the Bat, freeing the Arkham Asylum inmates and choosing when to strike. Batman was left scrambling to capture them all, and overtired and weak he ultimately fell before Bane as a result. Another tragic instance occurred during the Batman: Venom. Yes, this is the same super steroid Bane uses, but no, it is not a Bane story. In this story Batman actually fails to save a little girl because he simply wasn't strong enough, his years of perfecting his physique was not enough. The natural thing to do? Start hitting the juice! This trauma from failure had consumed Batman and turned him into something he hated, and it was only his immense will that allowed him to overcome the addiction. Didn't plan for all that, did he?

3. Batman Is Only As Good As His Rogues Gallery

3062493 Batman Rogues

Much of Batman's popularity has stemmed from the popularity of his villains, a fact DC has so much as admitted in their new DTV release Necessary Evil: Supervillains of DC Comics. Frank Gorshin, Cesar Romero and Burgess Meredith brought the Riddler, Joker and Penguin to life in Adam West's Batman TV series, while Paul Dini created fan favourite Harley Quinn and humanised Mr. Freeze in the fan-voted favourite episode "Heart of Ice" on Batman: The Animated Series.The latter Emmy-Award winning series, however, also featured many episodes without a super-villain at all; many episodes feature Batman taking on organised crime bosses like Rupert Thorne, dirty corporation heads like Roland Daggett or common criminals and thugs. By doing so, the show went back to Batman's roots, and proved time and time again that criminals at heart are nothing more than "a superstitious, cowardly lot." Batman ensured that evildoers knew that crime doesn't pay, be it a bank robbery or world domination.

2. The Batman Franchise Is Always Successful

Sad Batman

This one usually comes from the lovelorn Superman fans that have waited for a Nolan movie-style treatment (who now argue they may or may not have got one in Man of Steel this summer), but it also comes from the perhaps overconfident studio heads themselves. If a video game/movie/TV show comes out with a Bat-emblem, it will sell. That doesn't seem to be the case with Cartoon Network's Beware the Batman, which just recently took an unexplained hiatus from its regular schedule. Perhaps it is the CG animation (the same used for Green Lantern: The Animated Series which was cancelled after one season), the unfamiliar sidekicks or the lack of A-List Bat-villains, Beware has receded to the Batcave for now and Cartoon Network has yet to announce its return. And it has to be mentioned that not all ventures into video games were as successful as the current Arkham game franchise; the adaptations of Batman & Robin, Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker and the comic book-inspired Batman: Dark Tomorrow video games may not have been as negatively received as Superman 64, but they are just as easily forgettable.

1. Anyone Could Be Batman

Clint Eastwood Batman

This one phrase is perhaps what makes Batman such a fan-favourite: He's the everyman of comics. An everyman with billions of dollars in the bank. "If I tried hard enough, trained hard enough, I could be Batman" is a commonplace sentences amongst fans. But in reality, no, you couldn't. I hate to burst your bubble, but Bill Gates has all the resources and money, and he's not Batman, nor will he ever be. Okay, Gates had to amass his fortune during his lifetime and did not have time to train physically, but what if his son used the resources his dad gathered to then become Batman? His son would then have to master computer science much like his father, as well as criminology, forensics, chemistry, biology, botany, medicine, psychology, languages, and engineering fields such as civil, electrical and mechanical. Bruce Wayne may not have a doctorates in all of these fields, but he certainly knows more than most. And on top of the random luck of having that immense brain storage and the eidetic memory to recall it all when required, you have to be an Olympic-level athlete and have mastered physical skills including: man-hunting, rappelling, parkour, reconnaissance, ninjutsu, archery, knife-throwing, magician-level escapism... you get where I'm going with this. So in actuality, sure, someone could become Batman. But not anyone. And unfortunately, it probably won't be you. If you're capable of all of the above and have the financing, however, feel free to give it a go. Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor

Sven Adam Svantesson hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.