10 Reasons Blair Witch Is A Crushing Disappointment
A glorified remake.
Two months ago, nobody had any idea that another Blair Witch film was in the works. Then suddenly it was revealed at Comic-Con in late July that the highly-anticipated found footage movie The Woods was, in fact, a secret sequel.
The hype train since has been immense, from rapturous early reviews through to a viral marketing campaign that has attempted (in vain) to replicate the original 1999 movie's success.
Sadly, despite any card-carrying horror fan wanting this movie to be a great resurgence of a doomed franchise (after 2000's horrendous Book of Shadows follow-up killed most studio interest), it's aggressively mediocre at best, and a troubling sign of Hollywood's crushing lack of originality at its worst.
That's not to say a sequel couldn't be an improvement, but for all of the pre-release excitement, this is one horror sequel that falls dispiritingly flat.
Here are 10 reasons Blair Witch is a crushing disappointment...
10. It's A Remake Pretending To Be A Sequel
There's an unfortunate recent trend of studios attempting to exploit our nostalgia for classic films by releasing "sequels" that are more or less remakes with a slightly modern twist. Blair Witch is one such film.
Essentially a soft reboot of the franchise despite how fervently it pretends to be a follow-up, the film largely recycles what worked the first time (creepy noises outside the campers' tents, piles of rocks and twig figurines being discovered, the campers getting lost, and plenty more in the ending portion that's too spoilerific to discuss) to largely diminished effect.
That's probably the worst thing that can be said of the new film: it feels incredibly lazy, and while it might prove effective enough for younger audiences who haven't seen the original, to fans of the first film it just feels like an insult.
9. The Characters Are Totally Forgettable
Say what you want about the original movie, but one of its biggest strengths is that it featured well-developed characters with a real sense of humanity. This is part of what made it so effective.
Unfortunately the new movie's expanded roster of characters are largely just stereotypically good-looking fodder for the Blair Witch and feel much more like "movie protagonists" than the more normal-looking Heather, Mike and Josh from the original.
Without heading to Google, it's tough to even remember the names of the new characters, and there's little to them as people beyond, "Heather's brother", "the obnoxious black guy", "the two weirdos" and so on.
The original made us care about its protagonists and so the end result proved so much more viscerally affecting, yet here most of the characters are just forgettable ciphers, such that at points you might even end up rooting for the Blair Witch.
8. Cliched & Predictable Jump Scares
There are way, way too many jump scares in this movie, especially earlier on, by way of countless fake-outs where someone is being pranked, which make the film feel extremely lazy from the outset with their overwhelming cheapness.
Again, it might work for teen audiences who aren't so acquainted with the tropes of the horror genre and found footage in particular, but to anyone old enough to have experienced the emergence of found footage, it will all feel woefully old-hat.
This is one of the most compelling pieces of evidence that this new Blair Witch really isn't much more than a cynical exercise in selling a classic movie back to audiences with the least amount of effort possible.
7. It's Visually Incoherent (And Has No Excuse To Be)
Probably the most common complaint about the original movie (other than "nothing happens") is the abundance of shaky cam which, combined with the low-budget filmmaking, results in a number of visually incoherent scenes.
It's a fair complaint, though fans ultimately concede on the whole that this is mitigated by the film's effective tension and the fact it was made for just $60,000.
The new Blair Witch doesn't have the same defense, having been made for a crisp $5 million and yet returning to the same tricks in order to avoid showing the audience much at all as the characters frantically run away from the titular creature.
While the shakiness of the original was more acceptable given its budget, this time around the tactic feels a lot cheaper, because with glossy cinematography and cinematic lighting, there's not much excuse to make the image this intentionally incoherent so often.
Now, the film does ultimately reveal a lot more of the Blair Witch than the original, but it still feels like a massive waste of modern tech that so much of it is rendered intentionally muddy through shaky cam and digital video glitches.
6. It Doesn't Resolve The Original's Questions
This new movie's big hook is that the new protagonist, James, is the younger brother of the original film's Heather, and is desperate to find out what happened to her.
It's a decent enough set-up and could give way to a movie that sheds fascinating new light on the Blair Witch while also resolving what happened to Heather (as James rather optimistically still believes her to be alive).
Sadly that sequel hook is basically just a lure to get fans of the original back for another go-around, because little in the way of additional context is lent to the first film, and the majority of the lingering threads are still left hanging when this film ends.
There's being subtle and vague, and then there's intentionally toying with the audience in the pursuit of money.
5. Too. Many. Cameras.
The original movie mined a lot of tension out of the fact that it was just three people getting lost in the woods with two cameras. There's a low-maintenance charm to it, and the fairly infrequent shift of perspectives made the viewer feel extremely immersed in what was going on.
Perhaps it's a comment on our ADD-addled culture that the new film features an absolute cr*p-tonne of cameras: there's one mounted on the ear of each camper, while some of them bring secondary cameras, and there's even a drone thrown in there for good measure.
While on one hand the ear-mounted cameras allow director Adam Wingard a lot of visual versatility, especially when the campers inevitably get separated, the constant perspective-shifting ultimately doesn't add much, and the addition of drones feels rather gimmicky and unnecessary.
The more pared-down thrills of the original are more effective, and in not fleeting so impatiently between cameras, the tension feels more sustained.
4. Only The Third Act Is Remotely Scary
Credit where credit is due: the final 20 minutes of this movie are genuinely creepy and will probably raise the pulse of even those cynics who had already given up on the film.
Unfortunately, though, this is the only scary part of the movie, and so audiences will have to ask themselves whether it's fair to be put through an hour of scare-free tedium for a fairly solid final reel.
Almost everything prior to the concluding sequence feels too familiar to be effective, and while it's always advantageous when a movie ends strong, it's still nowhere near enough to compensate for 75% of the movie being largely devoid of thrills despite what the marketing may tell you.
Speaking of which...
3. The Marketing Hype It Could Never Live Up To
Movie studios are by their nature going for the aggressive, hard sell when it comes to their latest projects, and the horror genre has been particularly obnoxious in this regard recently.
Who can forget when the 2013 Evil Dead remake's posters arrogantly claimed it was "The most terrifying film you will ever experience?" only for it to be a mildly above-average horror flick?
Blair Witch's trailers took a similarly irritating approach, using hilariously overzealous critic pull-quotes such as "a new beginning for horror films", "a truly terrifying cinematic experience" and most outrageously, "one of the scariest movies ever made."
It's an undeniably clever move by Lionsgate, who premiered the movie at this summer's Comic-Con when people still believed it was an original film called The Woods. That huge surprise no doubt enhanced the experience for the horror critics in attendance, some of whom are responsible for these aforementioned over-the-top comments.
Though the movie's reviews have since levelled out, it's fair to say that the pre-release hype was largely intended to get butts in seats, and given how the horror genre is rarely deterred by bad reviews, it seems like those rapturous claims have proven largely effective.
Lionsgate obviously won't care that it made the film overhyped and left audiences disappointed, because when a movie costs just $5 million, a juicy opening weekend can be enough to generate a colossal amount of profit.
Surprise, surprise, a movie's marketing lied to audiences. Who knew?
2. That Atrocious Ending
No spoilers here, but rest assured that Blair Witch concludes in depressingly predictable, lazy fashion, not only feeling overwhelmingly familiar but rather blatantly leaving itself open for more movies should it succeed at the box office (which it absolutely will).
Given the potential this film had to seriously expand the series' mythology, it instead opts for the most cliched and down-the-line conclusion possible, and is likely to be one of the movie's most complained-about aspects.
Anyone hoping for anything unique or interesting in the film's final moments should massively lower their expectations, because it's pure formula as far as both the genre and the franchise itself are concerned.
1. It's A Total Waste Of Adam Wingard's Talent
Adam Wingard has proven himself one of the most intriguing horror-thriller directors working today, what with his terrific two prior movies You're Next and The Guest.
What a huge comedown Blair Witch is from those works, then, clinging desperately to an established formula and reeking of studio mandate throughout.
Wingard was honest enough to admit in interviews that a big motivation behind making the film was because The Guest didn't do much business at the box office, and seeing the end result, that's none-too-surprising.
Hopefully he'll bounce back with his upcoming big-budget Death Note adaptation, because a filmmaker of his talent shouldn't be bothering himself with cynical "rebootquels" like this.
What did you think of Blair Witch? Shout it out in the comments!