10 Reasons The Dark Tower Bombed

The Gungslinger's cinematic post-mortem.

dark tower
Sony

It's been a month since The Dark Tower began its worldwide rollout, and now that it's premiered in almost 60 countries, it's safe to call the movie an undeniable box office bomb.

At the time of press, the $60 million sci-fi western has grossed approximately $90 million, presumably putting the kibosh on any plans for a movie franchise, as will be especially disappointing to the novel series' legion of dedicated fans.

So, what went wrong with bringing Stephen King's legendary fantasy franchise to the big screen? With an all-star cast, talented director, sensible budget and lack of serious competition in its early August slot, it really should've been smooth sailing to at least a passable $150-200 million worldwide haul.

Though the issues with the movie's quality were long-suspected ahead of time, plenty of far worse movies have made much more money, so there's clearly more to this story, and why audiences were so turned off by what, on paper, had the makings of a solid cult hit if not more.

From pre-production through to the final release, it's time to crowbar open The Dark Tower's fetid corpse and comprehensively run down what went wrong...


10. It Had Well-Known Production Troubles

Ron Howard and Nikolaj Arcel
Ron Howard / Sony

Few things can sink audience enthusiasm for a movie faster than well-documented production problems, especially in the age of social media where bad news spreads like wildfire.

For starters, it certainly didn't help that The Dark Tower was delayed from its original January 13th release date to February 17...and again to July 28th, and finally once more to its final date of August 4th.

As if that wasn't enough, Variety published an article mere days before the film's release detailing its laboured development, with director Nikolaj Arcel's first edit of the movie reportedly alarming producers, who spent extensive time in post-production trying to cut the film into a more coherent and marketable whole.

In addition, $6 million was spent on re-shoots to clarify the Gunslinger's backstory, decisively hammering home that the movie struggled all the way to the finish line.

That this news broke on the eve of the movie's release no doubt deterred many potential customers from parting with their cash, and likely deciding to wait for a VOD release instead, if at all.


9. The Atrocious Marketing Campaign

the dark tower movie
Warner Bros.

Though not every highly-anticipated blockbuster needs a litany of trailers dropping 9 months before release, it was a bizarre decision not to release the first official trailer until just three months ahead of the film hitting cinemas.

It didn't leave a huge amount of time to mount a marketing campaign, and while Sony and Columbia absolutely could've spent money on a "marketing blitz" in the weeks before its release, the film's advertising presence was oddly muted around release day, such that many online didn't even realise it was out.

And if all that wasn't bad enough, Variety's aforementioned report stated that co-financiers Sony and MRC both had to sign off on every aspect of the film's marketing, an unconventional agreement which one source referred to as a case of "too many cooks in the kitchen".

How a movie is marketed is typically more important to studios than the actual quality of the movie itself, and they totally dropped the ball here.


8. It Didn't Respect The Source Material (And Fans Knew It)

Dark Tower Jake Chambers
Columbia Pictures

Arguably the movie's biggest sin is simply failing to respect Stephen King's source novel series, for while a successful adaptation doesn't need to be 100% faithful, it does need to at least capture the spirit of the material.

From the outset, many fans were upset at how much the movie focuses on young Jake Chambers, presumably in an attempt to lure in younger audiences, rather than keep the Gunslinger himself front-and-center.

Ultimately the essence of King's story is stripped away in favour of a more generic young adult-esque fantasy tale, and thanks to the marketing actually making this abundantly clear, King's legion of fans largely decided to steer clear.


7. The PG-13 Rating

The Dark Tower Idris Elba
Sony

Further to the point about the movie being made for the teenage market, The Dark Tower was rated PG-13, ensuring that the gritty, often incredibly dark, adult nature of the source material was almost entirely excised.

From the goofy adventure movie tone through to the action sequences, nothing has any real weight or feels especially consequential, and it's especially embarrassing as the film was shot with a totally sensible $60 million budget, which should certainly have been enough for Sony to take the risk of an R-rating.

Considering that a franchise as seemingly dead as Mad Max was resurrected with the R-rated $150 million Fury Road, that Sony were too scared to spend 40% of that cost on a Dark Tower movie that actually captured the essence of King's novels is just incredibly sad.


6. It Was Deemed "Unfilmable" By Many

The Dark Tower CGI Image, unreleased movie
Sony Pictures

Considering how many attempts have been made over the last decade to bring The Dark Tower to the big screen, it shouldn't be surprising that many have deemed the series "unfilmable".

The series is simply so much more complex and ambitious than any other King creation, requiring an intricate understanding of the tone and world-building across the series, which would frankly make adapting, say, The Shawshank Redemption seem like a comparable piece of cake.

J.J. Abrams and Ron Howard have both made concerted efforts to get the film made over the years, and if forces as powerful as them can't get it done, it's perhaps a sign that a big Hollywood movie adaptation was never going to work.


5. An Unfinished Trailer Leaked Last October

Dark Tower Matthew McConaughey
Columbia Pictures

Some seven months before the film's first trailer was officially released, a rough-cut trailer was leaked online, which quickly went rival online and surely did more harm than good considering the rather "mixed" reception to it (to be kind).

Reddit is full of threads where die-hard Dark Tower fans decried the movie as a sacrilegious adaptation that seemed to misguidedly focus the story on Jake, and as one user so astutely put it, "Don't remember it being a YA novel."

This unfortunate leak so early put fans on the back foot long before any official marketing for the movie was released, and the fact that the official trailer didn't seem much better only poured more fuel on the fire.


4. The Worrying 95-Minute Run-Time

Dark Tower Idris Elba
Columbia Pictures

The movie's 95-minute run-time was revealed around two weeks before it hit cinemas, and while for plenty of films that's a perfect amount of time, it did feel rather on the scant side for something with source material this dense and elaborate, and it was likely one of the reasons why many didn't bother to see it.

It was yet another red flag to fans that this might be a bungled adaptation, and perhaps more casual audiences simply preferred to put their hard-earned cash towards a two-plus-hour blockbuster promising a little more bang for their buck.

When you slice off the credits, The Dark Tower doesn't even break 90 minutes, and true to expectations, it's clear that the end product was hacked to pieces in a desperate attempt to make it appeal to as wide an audience as possible. Ironically, the opposite seems to have happened, and it's a rushed, oft-nonsensical mess.


3. The Lack Of Interesting Female Characters

Dark Tower Kathryn Winnick
Columbia Pictures

Wonder Woman proved a few short months ago just how starved for potent heroines female moviegoers are, and how eagerly they'll buy a ticket to a movie with a compelling female character, by they a lead or not.

Now, nobody's saying that additional female characters needed to be shoehorned into the film, but would it have killed them to develop Jake's mother Laurie a little more beyond merely being an attractive blonde woman who gets killed by the Man in Black?

And what about Arra Champignon, who appears and disappears in and out of the film at a whim with almost zero character development at all? Terrible.

Perhaps including fan favourite character Susannah Dean would've given the movie the distaff boost it desperately needed, and at least added a few minutes to that meager run-time.


2. Critics Absolutely Savaged It

The Dark Tower Rotten Tomatoes
Sony & Rotten Tomatoes

It never helps its box office prospects when any movie gets a critical battering, and The Dark Tower ended up one of the worst-reviewed blockbusters this summer, scoring the same percentage approval as Tom Cruise's widely-derided The Mummy, and a slightly lower average rating. It even scored lower than Baywatch. Ouch.

Though studios are getting increasingly cagey about protecting their dubious movies by screening them last-minute or gagging the press with late embargoes, reviews for the film were nevertheless available before release day, largely destroying any last-minute hope fans and casuals alike had that the movie might be a pleasant surprise.

While bad reviews won't sink all types of films (kids' movies and the Transformers franchise, for instance), when it comes to a project that already left most people on the fence, the vocal pannings really just delivered the killing blow.


1. It Should've Been A TV Series

The Dark Tower Idris Elba
Sony

Tying in with that prior remark about The Dark Tower being "unfilmable", many feel that the franchise would've been better served with a long-form TV series rather than a single 95-minute movie.

Given that we're living through the golden age of TV right now, there really wouldn't have been a better time for HBO or Netflix to sink money into, say, a six-episode adaptation of the first book, which could distill the headier and more complex aspects of King's world in a slower, more controlled fashion.

Prior to the film's release, there were in fact plans for a TV series to be released next year, which would flesh out the movie's story more and have Idris Elba and Tom Taylor reprising their roles.

However, with the movie being a box office dud, it's pretty safe to say that those plans are all-but-dead, and it's unlikely they'll be able to lure Idris Elba back for more given the critical and commercial response to this first outing.

Again, audiences knew that the film was clearly trying to juggle too much at once, and when you can watch incredible new Game of Thrones episodes from the comfort of your bed, why even bother heading out to the movies at all, especially ones as dubious as this?

What did you think of The Dark Tower? A justified bomb or a misunderstood cult classic in the making? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.