10 Reasons You're Wrong About Avatar

The style IS the substance, OK?

Avatar Jake Neytiri
20th Century Fox

Believe it or not, we're barely a year away from the 10-year anniversary of James Cameron's mammoth epic Avatar hitting cinemas.

Though it scored consistent critical acclaim, won three Oscars and remains the highest-grossing film of all time by a huge margin, in recent years there's been considerable backlash against Avatar as a film that, somehow, isn't as good as we all remember.

And sure, Avatar's far from a perfect film, but what isn't? The tidal wave of hate and derision surrounding the blockbuster in recent years could be readily dismissed as a vocal minority rallying against something simply because it's popular, but that theory feels like a bit of a cop-out.

After all, the oddly passionate disdain for Avatar is well-documented in the general population as much as it is in film enthusiast circles, even if it ultimately feels like many are thinking about the movie - and what it represents - all wrong.

Look no further than the Star Wars prequels to see how much the Internet loves to sneer at a badly-made movie, but Avatar's vitriolic reception is wholly unearned, and here's why...

10. It's More Than "Dances With Wolves In Space"

Avatar Jake Sulley
20th Century Fox

Both before and after its release, Avatar was mocked as being nothing more than "Dances with Wolves in space", "Pocahontas in space" or even "Ferngully in Space", with many criticising Cameron's script for being overly derivative of "white saviour" movies in particular.

Though few would champion Avatar's plot as wildly original, this is a rather reductive assessment of the movie's narrative.

Yes, it's not particularly unique, but given the staggering complexity of the world Cameron has created, utilising a common, elemental series of tropes is actually a pretty smart way to keep things grounded.

After all, aren't the majority of the most successful movies ultimately just rehashing classic good vs. evil and "chosen one" stories? And does that really matter as long as it's well-executed?

Moreover, while Avatar's spinal story is typical, the surrounding elements are anything but: the sci-fi genre twist, the central trans-human premise and the sheer weight of the world itself.

Many understandably assumed that Avatar would bomb at the box office for being "too weird", but honestly, keeping the core plot simple and easily digestible to a huge international audience is probably why it turned out so successful.

And given the sheer mind-boggling number of moving parts in this movie, an overly complex story could've made it too exhausting for its own good.


9. Jake Sully Is Supposed To Be A Blank Slate

Avatar Jake Sam Worthington
Fox

Remember Sam Worthington? While nobody expected him to be winning any Oscars after his fairly workmanlike performance in Avatar as protagonist Jake Sully, that is ultimately exactly what the movie required.

Much like Keanu Reeves' Neo in The Matrix, Sully is effectively a blank slate, an understated self-insert for the audience to project themselves onto throughout the adventure.

While his recently-deceased brother was the genius with a PhD, Jake is our "in" to Pandora, proving how everybody and anybody can lose themselves in this world.

Again like Neo, Jake has a clearly-drawn arc which, while predictable, easily allows the audience to identify with him along his journey. Much like the plot, he's not particularly complex or animated, and that's honestly exactly what the movie needs.

After all, the movie isn't about Jake: it's about Pandora.


8. World-Building = Substance

Avatar Jungle
Fox

Avatar is frequently cited as a "style over substance" movie, a rather pat and insincere term which ignores the fact that sufficient style can itself amount to substance in some cases.

What Avatar lacks in nuanced plotting and characterisation it more than compensates for with both its technical mastery and the sheer breadth and depth of its world-building, which in blockbuster terms is pretty much second-to-none.

Pandora is without question one of Hollywood's most impeccably-conceived worlds, teeming with exotic, beautifully rendered flora and fauna to the extent that some viewers even reported depression that Pandora wasn't a real place.

While there will be few who don't remember the awe of seeing Pandora's floating mountains for the first time, it's the smaller, obsessive details that really make the world feel as lived-in as it does.

Pandora's natural ecosystem is an endless source of fascination, and honestly the most hype-inducing aspect of the upcoming sequels.


7. Unobtanium Isn't Stupid

Avatar Unobtanium
Fox

Many were quick to rag on Cameron for daring to name the Macguffin mineral the humans want to harvest from Pandora "Unobtanium", deeming it emblematic of Cameron's generally un-finessed and on-the-nose screenplay.

It's a goofy name, sure, but Cameron wasn't wrong to use it or being overly glib in doing so. Unobtanium has been used in both science and science fiction for more than a half-century to describe a rare resource that's extremely difficult to extract.

Anyone thinking that Cameron's being anything less than playful - and, more to the point, scientifically accurate - is simply incorrect. It was likely intended to be both a nod to the sci-fi he grew up with, and also a tip of the hat to any scientists watching the movie.

Furthermore, it's not exactly a million miles away from the very real chemical element Dysprosium, which is derived from the Greek word "dysprositos", meaning "hard to get" (due to the difficulty involved in extracting it).

You might think Unobtanium is a bit daft, but at the end of the day, this wasn't a case of Cameron being an idiot or assuming the audience was. He could've avoided all the hullabaloo by just calling it Dysprosium, yes, but the path of least resistance has never been Cameron's way, has it?


6. It Doesn't Lack Cultural Impact

Avatar Neytiri
Fox

Almost a decade since Avatar's release, it's frequently stated that despite its astronomical box office success, the film lacks cultural impact and quickly evaporated from the collective consciousness.

While Avatar may not have the penetration of, say, Star Wars or Marvel, it's important to remember that Avatar is just a single movie, and honestly, how many original IPs have been as fervently discussed as it has?

Moreover, it successfully spearheaded the "3D revolution" in cinemas - short-lived though it was - and resulted in an uptick in movies featuring extensive use of performance-capture technology.

Plus, if it really had no impact on society and culture, would Disney have spent $500 million on building an Avatar theme park? The movie may not be endlessly re-quoted in memes, but in the general population, it's certainly a movie that's stuck around.


5. It's More Complex Than You Remember

Avatar Sam Worthington
20th Century Fox

Nobody's going to suggest that Avatar's characters are particularly deep, nor that the film's central themes are anything less than sledgehammer-subtle, but the film is certainly a little more layered than most care to admit.

Avatar is actually a fairly paradoxical tale at its core, with Cameron's pro-environment, anti-technology message clashing somewhat with the fact that the movie itself was achieved with only the most state-of-the-art hardware and software available.

The neatest solution to this conundrum is that Cameron is rallying for complex technologies to be placed in the hands of "heroes" rather than soulless government stooges, which has obvious parallels to the nature of modern filmmaking blockbuster itself (where $200 million budgets too often end up given to hacks).

And let's face it, the guy who once called himself the King of the World after winning an Oscar is hardly above allegorising himself as a hero.

While many like to dismiss Avatar's screenplay as effectively being scrawled on a napkin by Cameron during a boozy dinner, if you break its constituent elements down, there is a lot to chew on here.

Again, it's not going to bake your noodle, but it's certainly more thoughtful than the film's detractors would have you believe.


4. Its Inclusiveness Deserves More Praise

Avatar Sam Worthington Dileep Rao
Fox

Avatar is a fascinating blockbuster for many reasons, but one aspect that's often lost in the shuffle is the movie's inclusive and diverse cast. Many years before representation became a major talking point in Hollywood, Cameron did it without any fuss or ceremony whatsoever.

The large ensemble cast includes Michelle Rodriguez (Latina), Dileep Rao (of Indian descent), Wes Studi (Cherokee), and of course, Zoe Saldana, CCH Pounder and Laz Alonso, who are black, alongside the usual white male contingent.

Save perhaps for the Fast and the Furious franchise, Avatar is more diverse than the overwhelming majority of the highest-grossing movies of all time. That's to say nothing of the decision to make Jake Sully a paraplegic, almost a decade before Hollywood finally gave us an amputee action hero with Dwayne Johnson's Skyscraper.

You can argue that the movie trips over this inclusion a little by having Jake spend most of the movie in an "able" body, but it's still neat to see such a wide cross-section of society depicted in the film. What's more, Cameron has promised that the sequels will be even more diverse.


3. It's The Ultimate Humanist Blockbuster

Avatar Ending
Fox

Many of Avatar's critics seem to be under the impression that James Cameron lost his way a bit with the movie and didn't really know what he was doing.

Yet just as with Titanic, the director's goal here was always to craft a broad, democratic cinematic spectacle that would get as many eyes on it as possible. After all, how many filmmakers have ever been allowed to make a $250 million tree-hugging epic?

He was never trying to make Blade Runner 2049: he wanted an easily understood movie that would resonate across cultural barriers and remind everyone that humans need to work together to preserve the planet.

Yes, it has cartoonish and stock elements, but when we look around us, are the cackling, hammy villains really that much of a stretch? And in a world ravaged by unsustainable climate issues, is it really a problem that Cameron's movie bears its bleeding heart on its sleeve?

By wrapping his urgent message around both a simple narrative and all those eye-watering visuals, it's felt that much deeper. While Avatar clearly didn't save Earth, its world-uniting plea for change is likely a big part of the reason why it turned out so successful.


2. It Was Totally Oscar-Worthy

Avatar Neytiri
Fox

It's a common sentiment nowadays that the Academy was smoking some fat reefer when they nominated Avatar for nine Oscars, and though its three eventual wins were only in crafts categories (Best Art Direction, Best Cinematography and Best Visual Effects), many view its Best Picture and Best Director nominations as a bit of a joke.

The thing is, it's far too easy to think about the Oscars in the context of their own typical, narrow standard of worthiness, even though a great movie is a great movie deserving of recognition no matter what.

Should Avatar have won Best Picture over The Hurt Locker? Probably not, but to say that its sweeping spectacle was merely an empty fireworks display is totally disingenuous.

That's probably why Cameron should've won the Best Director Oscar over Kathryn Bigelow, who nevertheless did a splendid job herself, becoming the first-ever woman to win Best Director as she did. It's far more common these days for the Oscars to split the Picture/Director spoils between movies, and that would've been a fair compromise in this case.

In a time where a more eclectic slate of films are winning Oscars than ever - Get Out, anyone? - can people genuinely still say that Avatar isn't an "Oscar movie"?


1. Home Viewings Will Never Do It Full Justice

Avatar Jake
Fox

Watching Avatar today at home, it's aged exceptionally well in a way few films with this much CGI manage to.

The expressiveness of the characters and the jelly in their eyes looks tangible, allowing the film to effortlessly leap over the uncanny valley, while water effects and other complex particle work still looks mind-bogglingly good.

And yet, some will insist that the film hasn't stood the test of time and simply feels "flat" when watched today. What they're forgetting, of course, is that not even the most sophisticated home cinema system can replicate the majesty of the theatrical 3D experience, all the more so if you saw it in IMAX.

The film was designed with big-screen 3D exhibition in mind, and so Cameron's slick motions and perspective tricks naturally lack the same impact viewed in 2D on a 50-inch TV at home. While nobody's saying this fully hand-waives the complaints, it's nevertheless an important piece of context that shouldn't be ignored.

Thankfully Cameron will almost certainly re-release Avatar in cinemas before the first sequel comes out, so if you were left a tad deflated after re-visiting the movie on Blu-ray, you'll probably be able to re-experience the epic the way it was meant to be seen soon enough.

What's your verdict on Avatar? Overrated or, oddly enough, underrated at this point? Shout it out in the comments!


In this post: 
Avatar
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.