10 Recent Movie Recasts That Worked Perfectly

The new Cassie Lang was arguably the best part of Quantumania.

Grace Caroline Currey As Super Hero Mary - Shazam: Fury Of The Gods
Warner Bros.

When making a movie, everyone will do everything that they can to make sure the final product looks as good as it possibly can. Whether it's CGI, costumes, locations etc., everything on screen has to look as real as possible. However, despite everyone's best efforts, there will always be at least one aspect that requires the audience to suspend their disbelief.

And this is no truer than when a character has been recast. When someone rocks up on screen looking completely different to how they did before, you just kind of have to roll with it like nothing has happened.

We're not talking a recast in terms of complete franchise reboots, or the same character at a different age, we're talking full recasts of characters that by all logic should look (or sound) the same as they did before. It happens all the time, and while you would imagine this would be one hell of a hurdle for a movie to overcome, recent years have seen plenty of successful transitions from one actor to another.

10. Kathryn Newton As Cassie Lang - Ant-Man & The Wasp: Quantumania

Ant-Man and the Wasp Quantumania
Marvel Studios

When Emma Fuhrmann took over as Cassie Lang from Abby Ryder Fortson for Avengers: Endgame, it was easy to see why. There had been a huge five year gap since the last time she was on screen, and so when Scott Lang returned home from his involuntary quantum sabbatical, it wouldn't have made sense to find Cassie the same age.

What was more questionable was that Marvel Studios then recast the character again, with Kathryn Newton bringing Ant-Man's daughter to life in Quantumania. The studio rightly came under scrutiny for how the news was delivered to Fuhrmann (reportedly she found out at the same time as everyone else), but it was ultimately a strong decision.

Cassie was to assume a much different role in the threequel, and as a teenager in the MCU was required to be independent, awkward, sarcastic, and effortlessly charming. Fortunately, Kathryn Newton brought all of this and more to the role.

This recast seemed to signal that Cassie was set for a (excuse the pun) much bigger role in the MCU going forward, which seems as though it is barrelling right towards a Young Avengers team up. Simply put, Newton is a bigger name with more experience to bring to the franchise than Fuhrmann, though you do have to question whether Marvel couldn't have just cast Kathryn Newton in Endgame to begin with.


9. Huck Milner As Dash Parr - Incredibles 2

Dash Incredibles 2
Pixar

From Ant-Man and the Wasp to Avengers: Endgame, Cassie Lang was recast because the character grew up but the actor didn't. In the case of Incredibles 2 however, the exact opposite was true for Dash, as Spencer Fox had grown 14 years between movies, while for the character it had been mere seconds.

Naturally, in this time the young boy had grown up a lot and his voice had changed, making it impossible for him to reprise his role as Dash. Instead another young man was brought into the Pixar family in Huck Milner, in what was his big screen acting debut.

Whereas Violet, Dash's sister, didn't have the same problem as her voice was provided by that of an adult actor, the younger brother was ultimately replaced without many even realising. Realistically, isn't this the best case scenario for any recast voice actor?

Dash wasn't the only character recast for the sequel, as the voice of Rick Dicker was taken over by Jonathan Banks. The original actor, Bud Luckey, sadly passed away shortly before Incredibles 2 was released in 2018, but Banks brought the same drawl as he did to Breaking Bad's Mike Ehrmantraut to make his own performance memorable.


8. Jonathan Groff As Agent Smith - The Matrix: Resurrections

The Matrix Resurrections Smith
Warner Bros.

This is the first of two entries on this list in which a character previously played by Hugo Weaving had to be recast. After so many years, Keanu Reeves and Carrie-Ann Moss returned as Neo and Trinity in a fourth Matrix and while Agent Smith also returned, Weaving was unable to commit to the role.

Unfortunately, The Matrix: Resurrections posed a scheduling conflict for the Lord of the Rings actor. Laurence Fishburne was also unable to return as Morpheus, but while the movie worked around so that the character Yahya Abdul-Mateen II played was technically different, Jonathan Groff was brought in as a straight swap to replace Weaving.

This was always going to be a difficult role for the actor, as Agent Smith's portrayal was such a distinct part of the original movies and made Smith such an iconic character, but they couldn't have brought in anybody better.

There was bound to be a great amount of scrutiny of Groff's performance, arguably more than any other. However, his charismatic performance actually allowed Smith to be a noteworthy plus among a sea of very mixed reviews for the return to the Matrix franchise.


7. Chris Evans As Buzz Lightyear - Lightyear

Lightyear 2022
Pixar

No one could have called it even just a few years ago, but after Toy Story 4 robbed the franchise of what would have been the perfect trilogy ending, followed by Lightyear failing to capture the imagination of audiences and the announcement of Toy Story 5, you can seemingly class the franchise as one of the many that has overstayed its welcome.

With the latest release, Lightyear underperformed both critically and commercially, with many people being unhappy that the titular voice had been recast.

It was a tough sell to bring anyone in to voice Buzz Lightyear instead of Tim Allen, particularly as this was supposedly the movie from which the famous toy was based, but there was some sound logic behind it. Namely, director Angus MacLane looked at the casting as if he were making a live-action Buzz Lightyear, and its hard to argue that Chris Evans wouldn't be perfect.

Since Lightyear wasn't technically a prequel, the movie wasn't bound to use Tim Allen's voice, and while it's understandable that fans would be confused and even frustrated about the actor's absence, you can't deny the talent and charisma that Chris Evans brought to the role.


6. Brian Hull As Dracula - Hotel Transylvania: Transformania

Hotel Transylvania 4: Transformania
Amazon Studios

Adam Sandler's career has been turbulent and inconsistent to say the least. The SNL legend had an insane start to his Hollywood career, with the likes of Billy Madison, Happy Gilmore, The Waterboy, and Big Daddy releasing over a span of just four years. Then later came the lows of Jack and Jill, Grown Ups, and more, before a renaissance of more dramatic roles in recent years.

That, and the actor's new deal with Netflix may have been the main reasons behind his leaving the Hotel Transylvania franchise after three movies. In his place came Brian Hull.

Rather than a typical voice actor, Hull was known for his Disney impressions on YouTube, and went viral with his covers of Let it Go and Hello. The fact that he was able to then go on to replace Adam Sandler in Hotel Transylvania 4 is a wonderful story, and directors Jennifer Kluska and Derek Drymon couldn't have been happier with his work with their slightly different take on the iconic character.

Since Dracula was transformed into a human during the events of the movie, it gave the opportunity to go in a slightly different direction. It couldn't have been an easy task to step into the shoes of one such as Adam Sandler, but it's hard to imagine anyone doing it as well as Brian Hull did.


5. Campbell Scott As Lewis Dodgson - Jurassic Park: Dominion

Jurassic World Dominion Jeff Goldblum
Universal

It has been 30 years since the initial release of Jurassic Park, one of the most successful, popular, and influential blockbusters of all time. It's one of the most famous movies in the history of movies, but there are still moments that are easy for fans to forget.

Unless you were a fan of Michael Crichton's novel, you probably wouldn't have even recognised the name Lewis Dodgson before Jurassic World: Dominion came out. Essentially, Dodgson ran a competing bioengineering company to InGen, and was a master of industrial espionage. In short, in the original movie Dodgson was the guy who gave Dennis Nedry the can of shaving foam and asked him to steal dinosaur embryos from Jurassic Park.

Along with the original big three returning in 2022 for Dominion, so too did Lewis Dodgson. Back in 1993, the villain was played by Cameron Thor, an actor who hasn't exactly had a prolific career since, with his last credit on IMDb coming a full decade ago. For the sixth movie in the franchise, the character was portrayed instead by Campbell Scott.

In the same way as Kathryn Newton's Cassie Lang, Scott brought more experience and a higher profile to the character in what was going to be a bigger role than ever before, and he portrayed the villain as detestable as he needed to be.


4. Ross Marquand As Red Skull - Avengers: Infinity War

Avengers Infinity War Red Skull
Marvel Studios

There were some genuinely shocking moments throughout Avengers: Infinity War, but arguably none so jaw-dropping as the return of the Red Skull. The Captain America villain had been transported to Vormir at the end of The First Avenger, and now acted as something of a gatekeeper to the Soul Stone. Absolutely no one saw that coming.

He wasn't in the movie for too long, though he did return in Avengers: Endgame, but so good was the actor's performance that many fans didn't even realise it wasn't Hugo Weaving.

The Lord of the Rings actor portrayed the Red Skull way back in 2011, but wasn't willing to reprise his role eight years later. Like Dave Bautista for Guardians of the Galaxy, and Jennifer Lawrence for the X-Men movies, Weaving made no secret of the fact he hated his time sat in the make-up chair.

Instead, in came Ross Marquand, probably best known for his role as Aaron on The Walking Dead, and the actor didn't miss a beat. Hugo Weaving may have been unwilling to return, but thanks to Marquand, he wasn't missed in the slightest.


3. Grace Caroline Currey As Super Hero Mary - Shazam: Fury Of The Gods

Shazam Fury Of The Gods Mary
Warner Bros.

The entire premise of Shazam! as a character called for two different actors to portray the role. The superhero is a kid who bulks up after saying the magic word, and so for this you have Asher Angel playing protagonist Billy Batson in his normal form, and Zachary Levi in his super hero form.

The same principle applied to the rest of Billy's family when he powered them up at the end of the first movie. Naturally, the kids wouldn't have played their bigger super hero forms, however there was one exception in the sequel.

In Shazam!, Mary was played by Grace Caroline Currey until she transformed into Michelle Borth. At this time, Mary was roughly 17 or 18, and so by the time of Fury of the Gods was around 20.

While it makes sense for the kids to have adults playing their alter egos, there would be no reason for the already grown up Mary to change. In the sequel she was no longer a kid and so Super Mary was also played by Currey.

Allowing the actress to play both versions makes perfect sense.


2. Mads Mikkelsen As Gellert Grindelwald - Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets Of Dumbledore

Fantastic Beasts Gellert Grindelwald
Warner Bros.

It's amazing just how quickly the Fantastic Beasts franchise was run into the ground. The first new Wizarding World movie since The Deathly Hallows Part 2 released in 2015, and the sky seemed the limit, but numerous issues both on and off the screen have seen it crash through the floor rather than the ceiling.

One of the most contentious creative decisions was the casting of Johnny Depp as Gellert Grindelwald. This was never the most popular casting in the world, and the actor was eventually axed by Warner Bros. in favour of Mads Mikkelsen.

The Danish actor has experience with terrifying, awe-inspiring villains thanks to his time playing Hannibal Lecter, and was the perfect choice to replace Depp. Honestly, he was always the perfect choice and should have been in the role from the beginning.

The Secrets of Dumbledore was, by all accounts, a train wreck of a movie, but Mikkelsen was the one shining star.


1. Ryan Reynolds As Juggernaut - Deadpool 2

Deadpool 2 Juggernaut
Fox

By the time Fox's X-Men franchise limped over the finish line with Dark Phoenix and New Mutants, the universe's timeline was all over the place. Days of Future Past had meddled with time, and from then on it grew harder and harder to follow.

One property that seemed to stay outside of this however, was Deadpool. The fourth-wall breaking Merc with the Mouth knew of both James McAvoy and Patrick Stewart's versions of Professor X, and while the events of his movies definitely took place in the present, the young X-Men of the past still showed their faces.

So, Deadpool broke all the rules, and this allowed for the sequel to recast one key mutant to be far superior than he was before. All this writer has to say is "I'm the Juggernaut, bitch" and the spines of fans will shiver, as Vinnie Jones take on the Juggernaut just didn't work.

However, the character was way better in Deadpool 2. This time he was played by Ryan Reynolds, and was actually funny on purpose. There's still room for improvement, but compared to The Last Stand's iteration, it's night and day.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Shazam
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

This standard nerd combines the looks of Shaggy with the brains of Scooby, has an unhealthy obsession with the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and is a firm believer that Alter Bridge are the greatest band in the world.