10 Remakes That Should Never Have Happened
This is why Hollywood isn't allowed to play with all the nice things.
Hollywood is in the middle of a remake spree, and it doesn't look in any mood to stop, no matter how many horrendous reviews they receive. With dozens of reboots and remakes in the pipeline, including American Psycho, The Birds, and Scarface, audiences can be assured that classic films will be continuously ruined for as long as writers don't have any real inspiration to go on.
Whether they were unnecessary, unwanted, or simply bad films, most remakes go on to live in infamy. Often shedding everything that made the originals good in favour of flashy CGI and better technology, remakes tend to be critical bombs, particularly when compared with their older counterparts.
That's not to say that there aren't good remakes, quite the opposite. Many directors relish the chance to reimagine some of history's greatest films, fixing the problems that hampered the originals. Remakes often attract bigger budgets, allowing for more realistic violence, and better writers and actors that can improve on their predecessors.
Dredd, for example, produced one of the finest comic book adaptions to date, immeasurably improving in every way on the God-awful thing that Sylvester Stallone created. But for every True Grit or The Fly, that utilises new technology or simply a different perspective or directorial vision, there's a counterpart trying to simply cash in on the name of a classic film with a sloppy scene-for-scene recreation.
10. Carrie (2013)
The original Carrie, released in 1976, was a horror classic that earned a spot on the AFI 100 Thrills list. It told the story of a young girl that discovered her supernatural powers after being bullied at school for having her period. The film displayed issues of teenage angst and high school cruelty, finishing in the memorably gore-splattered prom scene.
Regarded as one of the best films of 1976, alongside other classics like Rocky, Taxi Driver, and All The President's Men, Carrie received widespread critical acclaim, currently holding a rating of 93% on Rotten Tomatoes. Fans of the book would have been disappointed, however, as it didn't stick as close to the Stephen King novel as some would have liked.
Recognising this issue, the 2013 remake had intentions to draw the script closer to the novel, but this was abandoned due to studio interference. Changes were subsequently made in order for the remake to cash in on the success of the original film, and the end result was simply a scene-for-scene remake of the 1976 film with a handful of references to the film's updated setting.
One of the more questionable aspects of the film was the choice of Chloe Grace Moretz as Carrie. Sissy Spacek, who played the 1976 film's title character, famously didn't wash her face at all during filming, and rubbed vaseline in her hair to make the character look like a complete outsider. Chloe Grace Moretz never achieved the same look, and looks more like one of the girls bullying her than the object of their ridicule.
9. Get Carter (2000)
Often cited as one of the greatest British films of all time, Get Carter stars Michael Caine as Jack Carter, a veteran Geordie gangster armed with a London accent thicker than a foot of bulletproof glass. Never taking issue with the darker side of the criminal underworld, Caine threatens to kill virtually everyone he comes across,.
If this had anybody but Michael Caine in the lead role, it would probably have gone under the radar when The Godfather was released the next year, but he manages to make the simple plot of a glorified revenge flick work. He might have as few lines as Tom Hardy in Mad Max, but Caine delivers them so effectively that he draws attention away from the shoddy acting typical of the 1970s, even when he's standing naked in a Newcastle street with a shotgun.
The American remake released in 2000 stars Sylvester Stallone, and boy is Michael Caine missed in this one. The main issue is the script, which was never particularly good to begin with. Most of the time Michael Caine is asking single-syllable questions and murdering people, but with the man that gave us glorious lines like "You're a Kentucky Fried Idiot" in the lead, it lacks the same intensity and force of character as the original.
Without Caine in the lead, the mostly unchanged plot of the film doesn't age well, and it's a shame to see a classic film butchered like a pig in a slaughterhouse.
8. The Wicker Man (2006)
Both incarnations of The Wicker Man have achieved cult status. The original 1973 film was one of the greatest horror films ever to be made, and has been labelled "the Citizen Kane of horror movies."
It has featured on Empire's list of the 500 Greatest Movies of All Time, and holds a critical rating of 90% on Rotten Tomatoes. Suffice to say, this film is absolute gold, and has gone down in cinematic history as a horror film of unparalleled quality.
The script is completely original and exceedingly well-written, maintaining tension and suspense throughout the film, and building up to an incredible climax. What made it stand out from other horror films of the time was the distinctive lack of terror throughout the film. The inhabitants of the remote island create unease, but never outright attempt to scare the audience. This atmosphere contributed towards creating a film that the late Christopher Lee would consider to be his best film.
You would think that remaking a film of such quality would require a director that wanted to pay homage to the original, but add his own spin. Well, in 2006 Neil LaBute released his remake, and his spin took the form of Nicholas Cage.
Instead of the tense, intelligent horror of 1973, audiences received a film so laughable that it became one of the greatest unintentional comedies ever made. The "Oh God, not the bees!" scene in particular has gone down in history as one of Cage's greatest moments of overacting.
7. Arthur (2011)
Drunk people are funny, aren't they? They stagger around, confused, falling over, almost baby-like in their new perspective on the world. If there aren't any drunk people nearby to laugh at, you can go find videos online! Isn't the internet an amazing thing? But you know what isn't funny? Alcoholism.
Arthur tells the story of an alcoholic man-child who is soon to be married off in the hopes that it will make him grow up. In the 1981 version, Arthur, played by Dudley Moore, is funny and loveable, in spite of his horrendous drinking habit - not because of it.
It was clear to see how Arthur had ended up friendless and lonely, and the film doesn't skim over this fact. When his valet Hobson dies, Arthur goes on a massive drinking binge, as his only friend in the world had left him. It's a sad and incredibly touching moment, and something that the remake failed to do justice to.
Russell Brand's incarnation of Arthur attempts to make the playboy's rampant alcoholism the butt of the joke, but it never works because this wasn't how it was intended to be portrayed. The original used Arthur's alcoholism as the backdrop of jokes, constantly contrasting the humour with the darker aspects of addiction.
Another point the remake failed to pick up on was the character of Hobson. Helen Mirren does a passable job (this is Helen Mirren after all), but misses out on the multitude of sarcastic comments criticising Arthur and his lifestyle, which hide Hobson's enduring loyalty to Arthur.
6. Ben-Hur (2016)
It takes a great deal of skill, effort, and talent to produce a film capable of winning eleven Academy Awards. It also takes a great deal of skill, effort, and talent to produce the one of the biggest flops in history and simultaneously ruin the name of a great movie.
The original Ben-Hur was a triumph of cinema, telling an intelligent and very human story of a slave that became a champion charioteer, but never forgot the family he left behind. It produced the iconic chariot race sequence, which required three months and an entire second production unit to film, and an actual injury to a stuntman was even worked into the final cut of the film.
All for a few minutes of screen time.
Ben-Hur was a critical and commercial success, becoming the second-highest grossing film in history, and as said before, scooping eleven of the twelve Academy Awards it was nominated for.
The other Ben-Hur was certainly not a critical and commercial success, and it couldn't get anywhere near the Academy Awards even if it tried to bribe the doorman. Despite a $100 million budget, the 2016 incarnation attracted little in the way of serious star power, Morgan Freeman being a notable exception.
But worst of all, with almost sixty years of technological advancement, and seven times as much money as the original, the remake failed to do justice to the chariot scene. Over-edited and using far too much CGI, it lacked the grandeur and sheer scale of the 1959 version.
5. Planet Of The Apes (2001)
Tim Burton is a strange man, and most studios know that. He likes making weird films about weird things, like a singing serial killer working part-time as a barber, or a man with scissors for hands.
When he was given a chance to remake the Planet Of The Apes, Burton got straight on the phone with a man that could provide him with several viking longboats, a pickaxe, and some purple paint. He didn't really, but this is Tim Burton.
Remembering that they had just employed the man who almost made Nicholas Cage Superman, 20th Century Fox actively prevented Burton from adding anything really weird into the remake. In fact, they just handed him a hacked-up script of the 1968 film and told him to stick to it, making the reboot both unimaginative and poorly scripted.
The original Planet Of The Apes boasted a compelling story and characters, dark humour, and Charlton Heston shouting at an unclean monkey. It was also technically impressive, winning an Academy Award for its make-up work, but Heston steals the show, screaming those immortal words on the beach when he realises the apes had destroyed humanity.
Like its predecessor, the make-up teamed earned praise, but this was overshadowed by Tim Burton blowing a hole in the end of the film and confusing everyone in the process, presumably because he couldn't have his purple paint. Even the cast couldn't work out ending, with Tim Roth stating: "I cannot explain that ending. I have seen it twice and I don't understand anything."
4. Psycho (1998)
It takes balls to remake any Alfred Hitchcock film. They're cinematic masterpieces, intense thrillers that earned Hitchcock the title of "Master of Suspense." Gus Van Sant balls must be a pair made from solid steel, because he took on the task of remaking Hitchcock's most famous production, Psycho.
Mixing one of the most recognisable film scores in history with Hitchcock's incredible capabilities as a director and editor, Psycho became an instant classic. The way it framed graphic violence and sexual imagery contributed towards the erosion of the conservative production code, permitting the growth of modern cinema.
The famous shower scene was a showcase of directorial talent, utilising innovative techniques to capture Hitchcock's vision, such as creating the sound of the attack by stabbing a watermelon. Almost eighty different camera angles were used, and fifty cuts were made in post-production to create four minutes of cinematic gold.
In 1998, Gus Van Sant, and his balls of steel, decided to remake Psycho. Unlike other directors, who use new techniques, or add some of their own flair to a film in order to make their mark on the project, Gus Van Sant reshot the film from every single angle that Hitchcock used. The only difference between the two versions, aside from the new cast, is that Van Sant filmed his in colour.
This unimaginative attempt to cash in on Hitchcock's success gained Van Sant nothing but two Golden Raspberry Awards for Worst Remake and Worst Director.
3. Oldboy (2013)
Foreign films are often a target for English-language remakes, and some come out of the transition successfully. The production of films like The Ring can attest to the fact that giving an American spin and Hollywood-level budgets often do result in excellent re-imaginings of these films, doing justice to their foreign counterparts.
Not so with Oldboy.
The Korean original by Park Chan-wook was a well-crafted revenge film, telling the story of a kidnapped man relentlessly pursuing the truth, at the cost of a lot of blood, and a large chunk of his own tongue.
Mixing ruthless ultra-violence, beautiful editing, and a score that seems to mourn the action it surrounds. The corridor fight is one of the most incredible pieces of choreography to watch. Oh, and there's a bit where the guy eats a live octopus, it's Jeff Goldblum's Fly levels of horrible. And there's some incest.
Clearly, fun for the whole family.
The 2013 remake by Spike Lee attempted to bring the same level of shock and awe to worldwide cinemas, but failed miserably. It didn't contain the same musical score, and the trademark action is toned down and boring in comparison. The incest is removed. It was sort of the whole plot of the original film, but it wouldn't have gone down so well with American audiences.
But without the extreme violence and outlandish plot of the Korean film, Oldboy just seems repackaged in an attempt to bring in a wider audience. Everything that made it intense and horrifying was stripped out, creating a pale imitation of the original.
2. RoboCop (2014)
Like many films on this list, the RoboCop remake fell into the mistake of believing that slapping a shiny new veneer onto an old film would result in the same success. But when the 2014 RoboCop remake was released, it failed to recognise what had made the original so popular.
Released amidst the action-heavy films of the 1980s, ridden with one-liners and large men that couldn't act properly, RoboCop was startlingly intelligent. The plot is pulled straight out of a comic book, but the writing makes it work as an exaggeration of America, heavy with cynicism and humour.
That the protagonist is a literal machine, impenetrable to both bullets and emotion, is a clever twist on the typical shots of Schwarzenegger or Stallone mercilessly gunning down men by the hundreds in their films.
With such obvious social commentary on the surface of the film, it shouldn't have been difficult to bring RoboCop into the modern era, where society is still plagued with controversial issues of police brutality and privatisation. The 2014 film attempted this, but it had no real conviction behind it. The demand for darker, more realistic films in recent years resulted in the screenwriters stripping all the satire and clever wit from the original film.
Without the humour of the original film, the remake of RoboCop seems to simply go through the motions of providing a commentary on modern day America, and measures up poorly to the satirical and humour-laden predecessor.
1. Godzilla (1998)
The original Godzilla was a masterpiece. Based on director IshirÅ Honda's thoughts on hydrogen bomb testing, it never shied away from displaying the destruction wrought by the beast, often drawing comparisons to the bombing of Nagasaki and Hiroshima at the end of the second world war. The script portrays Godzilla as something akin to a god, consistently present without always physically being there.
Godzilla represented a sobering commentary on nuclear weapons in postwar Japan, even making some in the film question if they deserved to be in their situation due to the nuclear tests that had caused Godzilla's appearance. The emotional and moral undertones of the film certainly go a long way towards explaining its 93% fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes.
The 1998 remake of Godzilla was a $120 million ripoff that removed everything in Godzilla that symbolised the core issue of nuclear weapons, and made only passing attempts to adhere to Godzilla's nature as something of a tragic character, not completely understanding what he's doing. It relied on its visuals to shield the terrible plot, shoddy scripting, and implausible science.
Despite being a commercial success, the Godzilla remake was a critical bomb, and even writers of the script have admitted that it was poorly executed. The film also found criticism from Kenpachiro Satsuma, the man who played Godzilla in most of the Japanese sequels, who walked out of a screening of the film, stating that "it's not Godzilla, it doesn't have his spirit."