10 Remakes That Totally Outshone The Original

Newer actually can be better.

The Wizard Of Oz
MGM

A common opinion is that remakes, much like sequels, never live up to the standard set by their predecessors. But it's the exceptions that prove the rule and obviously, there have been several pertinent points to the contrary over the years. And there are some remakes that have been so good, many people seem to not even realize that there had been another version to begin with.

That's even the case when the originals are perfectly fine or bette, which is one of Hollywood's greatest ironies, really. Finished products that are awful tend to be left behind and left to be forgotten, even if another attempt could result in something special, but if something was done well the first time, studios wants to do it all over again in a few years.

Inevitably - and cynically - the reason for this is the likely big profits new versions can bring in, but there can be other genuine reasons behind remakes. Among them is the curiosity to find out how a story turns out with newer technology or simply what the vision for the story is from the point of view of a new group of talent. This can be especially true if it involves an adaptation from another medium. Of course, this can all magnificently backfire if a new vision is not to the liking of a long-established fanbase.

Whatever the justifications behind so many remakes, cynical or not, the fact is no matter how well the first go round went, there genuinely can be room for improvement...

10. Freaky Friday (2003)

Freaky Friday Jamie Lee Curtis Lindsay Lohan
Buena Vista Pictures

Based on the 1972 novel by Mary Rodgers, the first Freaky Friday movie was released in 1976 and starred Barbara Harris and Jodie Foster as a mother-daughter pair who, after having frequently been at odds with each other, switch bodies for a day and learn to appreciate the difficulties in each other's lives.

A big hit, it snagged both Harris and Foster Golden Globe nominations to go along with a third for Best Original Song.

A little-known made-for-TV movie version was released in 1995 starring Shelley Long and Gabby Hoffmann, but it's the 2003 version that really made its mark.

The update starred Jamie Lee Curtis and Lindsay Lohan back before her name became synonymous with 'cautionary tale'. Despite the praise for Harris and Foster, the remake's cast is generally viewed to have done better. Curtis also received a Golden Globe nod and her being left out of the Oscar nominations has widely been considered a snub. The supporting cast includes Mark Harmon and Chad Michael Murray.

In 2017, it was announced that a fourth movie would go into production. This one is intended to be a musical version to air on the Disney Channel.


9. The Thing

Kurt Russell The Thing
Universal Pictures

A short story entitled Who Goes There? by John W. Campbell was the basis for 1951's The Thing from Another World. Its central premise follows a group of scientists in the arctic trying to stop a vicious alien from reaching civilization. This movie did very well indeed and has been considered among the best science fiction films of the 1950s.

That was a very tough act to try to follow, but John Carpenter did just that in 1982.

Originally a commercial and critical flop, the film is significantly more graphic and definitely not for everyone. But, despite its humble opening, in the years since it has been reevaluated as a masterpiece of both the science fiction and horror genres.

With a cast led by Kurt Russell, The Thing has been particularly hailed for its suspenseful and paranoid atmosphere along with its visuals.


8. Homeward Bound: The Incredible Journey

Hoemeward Bound
Buena Vista Pictures

Sheila Burnford's 1961 novel The Incredible Journey has been tugging at the heartstrings of readers for decades. The story of three dedicated pets - two dogs and a cat - going on a treacherous adventure to be reunited with their family is an emotional roller coaster. Disney's 1963 film adaptation has also been loved by many for almost as long.

Even with that established, the remake released 30 years later entitled Homeward Bound: The Incredible Journey has often been regarded as the better of the two. While other points of emphasis have included its pacing, for many what really sets the remake apart from the original was the decision in voice casting.

Whereas in the first movie the journey of the three beloved animals was narrated by Rex Allen, the 1993 take featured Don Ameche, Michael J. Fox and Sally Field giving voice to the animal characters. Changing the movie's point of view from third person to first person, so to speak, seems so simple yet so massive at the same time.

A sequel, Homeward Bound II: Lost in San Francisco, was also received relatively well, if not as much so as its predecessors.


7. Buffy The Vampire Slayer (TV)

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Season 1
Mutant Enemy

Released in 1992, the film Buffy the Vampire Slayer received lackluster reviews and likewise box office returns. The campy flick that had been swamped with turmoil behind the scenes starred Kristy Swanson in the title role alongside Luke Perry and Donald Sutherland. It has also been noted for featuring Hilary Swank in her movie debut in a small role and Ben Affleck in an even smaller one.

The film likely wouldn't be remembered by very many if the television version hadn't premiered in 1997 with Sarah Michelle Gellar headlining the cast. Its tone would be very different from the previous product. While comedy would be an essential element, the tv series also balanced it with possibly equal parts drama and horror.

Though it went somewhat under the radar during its run, it has since been regarded as one of the finest television shows ever created. It has also been viewed as a landmark for its treatment of a lead female character.

It would produce a successful spin-off, Angel, beginning in 1999. Both series would be chosen to continue in comic book form, helping to start a new trend in the television community.


6. Teen Wolf (TV)

Teen Wolf
MTV

Though the 1985 movie Teen Wolf is not a critical darling by really any stretch of the imagination, it has still managed to garner a following. It featured Michael J. Fox as high school student who finds out he is a werewolf.

More than 20 years later and largely inspired by what had been done with Buffy the Vampire Slayer, work began on a television adaptation. Like its inspiration, the Teen Wolf television series turned away from the campy tone of the preceding film, instead featuring a blend of drama, comedy and horror.

Premiering in 2011, the series and its cast were met with much praise from critics. This is something to be noted, seeing as finding a critically acclaimed MTV series is just about the equivalent to finding a unicorn in a forest.

The Teen Wolf series concluded in 2017, though questions were deliberately left unanswered in anticipation of a possible continuation.


5. Chicago (2002)

Chicago 2002
Miramax

The play written by Maurine Dallas Watkins, a former reporter for the Chicago Tribune, debuted in 1926. Inspired by a pair of murder cases she had covered, Chicago satirized the media and its sensationalizing of terrible crimes.

It quickly spawned a silent movie adaptation sharing the same title. Another version entitled Roxie Hart starring Ginger Rogers in the title role was released in 1942.

A new vision of the story hit the public in 1975 with a musical stage version. It was this version that director Rob Marshall adapted into the 2002 film. Featuring a cast including Renee Zellweger, Catherine Zeta-Jones, Richard Gere, Queen Latifah and John C. Reilly, 2002's Chicago is one of the most successful movie musicals of all-time.

To go along with claiming more than $300 million at the box office and cleaning up at the Golden Globes, it won six Oscars including Best Picture and Best Supporting Actress for Zeta-Jones.


4. Battlestar Galactica (2000s)

Battlestar Galactica
Sci-Fi

The original Battlestar Galactica began as a television movie in 1978. Its ensuing television series became a phenomenon at the time, though its run was ultimately cut short due to its high budget. For many looking back, the story about the apparently last surviving humans travelling through space after a robot rebellion is rather corny, but still endearing.

Corny was decidedly not the goal in 2003 when what was then the Sci-Fi Channel aired a two-part update. Much of the early attention surrounded changes in gender when it came to Starbuck, ethnicity when it came to Tigh or both when it came to Boomer. There was also a lot of skepticism about the darker tone.

Then it actually aired. So popular was it that it turned into a regular series that spun off three tv movies and a prequel series. The new version included stories on politics, faith, morality and just how desolate life would probably be for survivors of an apocalyptic event stranded in the dark, cold vastness of space.

It has often been cited as the greatest science fiction series ever and one of the greatest of any genre period.


3. The Man Who Knew Too Much (1956)

The Man Who Knew Too Much
Paramount

Director Alfred Hitchcock's initial take on parents trying to retrieve their kidnapped child was released in 1934 and entitled The Man Who Knew Too Much. Its cast included Peter Lorre. The British film is considered one of Hitchcock's finest before his going to America.

But even so Hitchcock was apparently not satisfied with the results. And so 22 years later the remake with the same title was released starring James Stewart and Doris Day.

While the most immediately noticeable difference is likely the change from black and white to color, Hitchcock also went with several others, including changing the kidnapped child from a girl to a boy. The 1956 version has typically been considered the superior of the two. More polished and stylized, the famed director would later express that he felt the original was the product of an amateur, whereas the remake was a product of a professional.

1956's movie is also noted for bringing the world the song Que Sera, Sera. This song would win the Oscar for Best Original Song and would become a signature of Doris Day's.


2. The Maltese Falcon (1941)

Bogart The Maltese Falcon
Warner Bros.

Original serialized in the pulp magazine Black Mask, The Maltese Falcon is arguably author Dashiell Hammett's best known work. It is centered on a private detective who finds himself caught up in a dangerous search for a highly valuable statue.

The first film adaptation was released in 1931 and later became unavailable to the public for three decades because it featured content deemed 'lewd'. A comedic version starring Bette Davis came out five years later under the title Satan Met a Lady.

It wasn't until 1941 that most well-regarded version came out. Featuring a revered performance by Humphrey Bogart, the film received Oscar nominations for its screenplay, Sydney Greenstreet's turn as the villain and for Best Picture. It also has the distinction of featuring one of the most quoted movie lines ever near its conclusion.

If you've ever wondered what the 'stuff' is that dreams are supposedly made of, 1941's The Maltese Falcon in the movie for you.


1. The Wizard Of Oz (1939)

Wizard of Oz Judy Garland
MGM

There were many early adaptions of L. Frank Baum's The Wonderful Wizard of Oz, the most infamous probably being 1925's silent flick The Wizard of Oz. Featuring a young Oliver Hardy, the film was a critical and commercial disaster.

Several years later, MGM opted to give it another go and turn it into a musical, largely in color. Early prospects were not good. Though only one is credited, the project actually went through four different directors. Buddy Ebsen, who had been cast as the Tin Man, had to drop out because of an allergic reaction to the aluminum dust in the makeup used for his character.

Controversies still rage about the treatment of the cast, in particular those playing the Munchkins, and whether or not something horrifying can be seen in the background of one of the shots. It can't, but that's never stopped the conspiracy theories.

But after its world premiere in Oconomowoc, Wisconsin in August of 1939, it became a sensation. The film would win an Oscar for its score and be nominated for four more, including Best Picture. It is now an icon, with characters, quotes, songs and more that are among the most recognizable in the world.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I like to think I'm a clever person, but apparently I'm not clever enough to come up with a witty biography.