10 Most Ridiculous Rom-Com Premises In Cinema History

Boy meets girl is so dated that it's only natural to stick in magic, time-travel, curses, brain damage and semen-swapping. Right? ...Right?

The rom-com has to be the least fussy genre in term of plot and quality, a little way ahead of the horror genre (as much as I love it). It relies on audience sentimentality €“ that if you make a lightly amusing trailer, it'll get the audiences in the cinema. Also, given that most of a rom-com's audience is accounted for by dates they may not have their attention completely focused on the screen anyway, if you catch my drift. Though this normally results in the familiar "meet cute" trope we're all sick to death of €“ sometimes filmmakers have, for both better and for worse €“ tried to slip more outlandish romantic premises by us. This has on occasion resulted in a genius romance the likes of which we could never have imagined, though most absurd rom-coms are simply too crazy for their own good. They might deviate pleasantly from formula, but they're not backed up by enough intelligent, chemistry and genuine heart. Still, as this list makes clear, occasionally a crazy premise can work if the cast believe in it enough. As usual, let me know about any more ridiculous rom-coms in the comments!

10. Heartbreaker €“ Professional Seducer Falls In Love With Mark

I'll ease you in with a rom-com that's actually remotely plausible and that's the cult French gem Heartbreaker, which revolves around suave, extremely handsome Alex (Romain Duris), who is the head of a business where they are paid by a third party (often a friend or relative) to break a woman up from her partner. Their one moral imperative is that the woman must be unhappy, but simply not know it. From here, Alex and his crack team of co-ordinators will make the woman fall for Alex's easy charm, at which point Alex will break it off with the woman and allow them to seek out a man who makes them feel much the same way. It's a hilarious film, and one that thankfully draws attention to its lunacy rather than working in spite of it. Still, it doesn't make a lot of sense. Firstly, isn't there the possibility that these women will spend the rest of their lives searching for a man like Alex, but find no comparison, given how he is essentially a one in a million-type catch? Furthermore, Alex ends up falling for the woman he has been "working" the entire film, Juliette (Vanessa Paradis), as we sit back and have to apparently applaud these two while Juliette's husband (Andrew Lincoln), a perfectly nice yet quite boring guy, is left jilted at the altar (though does rebound in the credits with Juliette's friend Sophie). Great fun perhaps, but it also requires a pretty firm suspension of disbelief. Thankfully the film is so free-wheeling it's easy enough to do that.

9. Harold And Maude €“ Spring-Winter Romance, Sudden Death

A far less accessible and unconventional rom com is Hal Ashby's dark comedic masterpiece Harold and Maude, which depicts the growing pains of young Harold (Bud Cort), as he eventually comes to fall for a 79-year-old woman named Maude (Ruth Gordon), resulting in one of the most ickily bizarre rom-coms in cinema history. The two meet at a funeral (they both enjoy attending them), and his bleak outlook on life contrasts with her more carefree one, to the point that they eventually decide to get married, much to the disgust of Harold's mother and pretty much everyone else he knows. However, things take another turn when Maude turns 80, and decides that she is at the right age to die, swallowing down an overdose of sleeping pills and passing soon thereafter, despite Harold's attempts to save her. Harold is a dejected mess, and aims to commit suicide by driving his car off a cliff, but gets out at the last minute. It is a romance in the most obtuse sense, a romance for life which was taught to Harold by Maude's fiery spirit. It might sound depressing, but rest assured that Ashby's film is a demented treat for fans of dark humour.

8. What Happens In Vegas €“ Justice System Forces Couple To Live Together, Probably Illegal

What Happens In Vegas might not be supernatural in origin (like many of the films to come on this list), but it relies on an enormous amount of contrivance to get going. Joy (Cameron Diaz) and Jack (Ashton Kutcher) are both drowning their sorrows in Law Vegas and end up hanging out after a room mix-up. They get drunk and get married, yet before they can get a quickie divorce, Jack uses a coin given to him by Joy on a slot machine and wins $3 million. Jack is jubilant until he realises that Joy is entitled to half the winnings, and the two go to court back home to get a divorce where a judge says that he will only unlock the money if the two try to co-exist as a couple for 6 months. Until that point, the money will be essentially held hostage by the courts. Joy and Jack happened to come across the biggest asshat of a judge walking in the entire United States, the one who couldn't go with the conventional 50/50 settlement, but instead decided to have a little fun with the two first. It's ridiculous because it would never happen in real life, even with the relatively animated nature of American judges. You'd appeal that ruling, and probably be cruising around in a Ferrari before lunchtime. And of course, this is without even mentioning that the two end up staying together at the end and getting "properly" married.

7. Leap Year €“ Amy Adams Forces Proposal, Everyone's Terrible

One of the most boneheaded, arguably sexist premises in recent rom-com history is in Leap Year, where Anna (a slumming Amy Adams) has grown frustrated with her boyfriend, Jeremy (Adam Scott) not proposing to her. As a result, she learns of an Irish tradition that on February 29th (aka "leap day"), if a woman proposes to a man, the man must say yes. The film traces her attempts to get to Ireland to propose, and the friendship she strikes up with a kindly Irish innkeeper, Declan (Matthew Goode), which as you can guess, soon enough causes her to question who she really has feelings for. It's ridiculous because there's the impression the filmmakers thought they were being progressive by saying that a woman can propose to a man, but how about not following dumb superstition and just doing it when you feel ready? Instead Anna comes across as an idiot, making the real romance with Declan harder to root for. Also, they pull the big rom-rom no-no of cheaply turning the jilted man, Jeremy, into a douchebag in the final moments of the film, so that the actions of the protagonists seem morally "right". Pretty much everyone in this film is intensely unlikeable, making the frothy nature of the story all that more unbelievable.

6. The Proposal €“ Sandra Bullock Forces Underling Into Marriage

The Proposal is lucky to be blessed with two sizzling lead actors, because it's another bureaucratically ridiculous rom-com in the same vein as What Happens in Vegas. High-flying publishing agent Margaret (Sandra Bullock) is notified that her visa has expired (she's Canadian), and that she's likely going to be deported. To save her hide, she convinces her assistant Andrew (Ryan Reynolds) to marry her, the catch being that they will have to pose convincingly as a couple while U.S. immigration investigates them, or Margaret will be deported and Andrew may go to jail. And so the ruse begins, where the pair meet Andrew's family €“ who are bemused that the boss he's spent years moaning about is now his partner €“ and then later on that they're engaged. It's awkward and pretty hilarious to say the least, largely thanks to Reynolds and Bullock's totally game attitudes to what is a very cartoonish romance. We all know how it's going to end, with the two realising they actually do have feelings for each other, but thankfully it's largely all about the car-crash embarrassment of the lie, which eventually is no longer a lie.

5. The Switch €“ Jason Bateman Sneak-Impregnates Jennifer Aniston, Hilarity Ensues

Not anywhere near as heart-warming is the absurd premise for The Switch, in which Kassie (Jennifer Aniston) decides she wants to have a baby despite being single, using a sperm sample from dreamboat specimen Roland (Patrick Wilson). Kassie's friend Wally (Jason Bateman) is madly infatuated with her and doesn't like the idea, so gets wasted and spills Roland's semen sample (by "accident"), replacing it with his own. Kassie leaves New York, but 7 years later, she returns and reconnects with Wally, who bonds quickly with his biological son, Sebastian. There's a kicker though, that Kassie is dating Roland, who she presumes is the father of Sebastian. In the end, Wally confesses the truth, at which point Kassie is mad as hell (quite rightly). She backs down eventually, dumping Roland and getting with Wally, who proposes to her, and the three of them live happily ever after. It's a horrible film because it's so damn creepy, and not once did I actually want Wally to get with Kassie at the end. Roland seemed like a much better pick every step of the way. Misguided, ridiculous, and tonally jarring, The Switch sucks.

4. Groundhog Day €“ Bill Murray As A Time-Travelling God

One of the best romantic comedies ever made, Groundhog Day forms a totally OTT premise and then just runs with it. Phil Connors (Bill Murray) is a self-centered, douchey TV weatherman who finds himself caught in a time loop, repeating the same day seemingly forever more while retaining his memory each time. He ultimately attempts to use this to his advantage to woo his co-worker, news producer Rita (Andie MacDowell), though finds himself constantly failing, until he realises that short-cuts aren't going to win her over. It's totally absurd in that it has zero plausibility on this physical plane, but it's such a brilliantly original concept that it doesn't matter. It has a great fantasy appeal for the audience, to think of the ways they could take advantage of such a time loop, both romantically and otherwise, and has been an enduring romantic hit for both genders ever since its release.

3. Good Luck Chuck €“ Dane Cook's Penis Makes Marriage Happen

Not so lucky is Good Luck Chuck, which conversely is rated among the worst romantic comedies ever made. It boasts a similarly magical premise, yet with none of the heart or wit of a film like Groundhog Day. Anyway, the premise €“ Chuck (Dane Cook) has been cursed since childhood due to him refusing to have sex with a goth girl, who placed said curse on him, meaning that every girl he has sex with will break up with him immediately after and marry the next man she meets. It's not a terrible premise by any means, but it's so lacking in charm and intelligence that Cook and Alba were destined to earn Razzie nominations from the second the script was greenlit. So much more could have been done with an idea like this, but instead it settles for lowest-common denominator jokes and, well, Dane Cook.

2. 50 First Dates €“ Severe Neurological Trauma Made Worse By Adam Sandler

50 First Dates revolves around a man, Henry Roth (Adam Sandler), a player who has no designs on settling down until he meets Lucy (Drew Barrymore), and the two hit it off. The next day however, he finds out she has Goldfield Syndrome, a form of amnesia which means that she cannot retain information beyond hitting her head a year prior on her father's birthday, and so thinks it's that very day every time she wakes up in the morning. To spare the agony of having to explain to her what's happened every day, her family just go along with it, and Henry finds himself irresistibly drawn into her life. The only thing more ridiculous than the premise is how it ends. Lucy wakes up every day and has to watch a tape called "Good morning Lucy", which reveals the nature of her condition and the fact that she is in fact now married to Henry. We then see that they also have a daughter, making everyone in the audience wonder quite what Lucy's reaction must have been when she woke up 8 months, 3 weeks pregnant. Despite requiring possibly a higher level of disbelief than any other film on the list, it just about works because of the sweet tone and Sandler and Barrymore's chemistry. In lesser hands, it could've been horrifically disturbing.

1. Mannequin €“ Man Falls In Love With Cursed Inanimate Object

Taking the #1 spot is the ludicrous 80s cult hit Mannequin, which revolves around Jonathan Switcher (Andrew McCarthy), a young man who starts working at a department store. He falls in love with one of the mannequins there, Emmy (Kim Cattrall), who actually comes to life by way of an Ancient Egyptian prayer to the gods centuries earlier. I'm honestly not kidding. However, she is only alive for Jonathan, and to others is simply a mannequin, albeit a very fetching one who helps Jonathan climb the career ladder at his firm. In the end, Jonathan triumphs over their business competitors who want to "kidnap" Emmy, and ends up marrying her in the very shop window they so nicely decorated together. It's sappy, it's cornball, but most of all, it's totally frigging ridiculous. Still, we got a pretty awesome Starship song out of it, right? Are there any more crazy rom coms I missed? Let me know!

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.