10 Romantic Film Relationships That Definitely Wouldn't Last

You'd Better Shape Up, Cause This Will Be Short...

Romance in movies is all about chemistry, the sexual tension between two unfairly attractive humans. It usually isn't, however, about the realism. Screenwriters sometimes seem like they have a connect the dots mentally when it comes to on-screen relationships, where they need to get from point A to point B to point C, but it doesn't really matter how it happens. Or if it is even remotely believable. In the movies, the couple always manages to find their way back to one another in the third act, where they€™ll live happily ever after. But most of the time, you know it€™s not going to last. Are they compatible at all, or were they just haphazardly thrown together to pander to the audiences? There's a sense that if the characters can make it to the very end of the film still together, that's all that matters. But we can't help but wonder what happens to them after the credits role. Inevitably, the issues that are casually swept under the rug for the movie's run time are going to rear their ugly heads again, and that wonderful sexy romantic couple is going to self-destruct in spectacular fashion. Six months down the line, they€™re just going to be a pair of bitter exes, and we all know it.

10. Baby And Johnny - Dirty Dancing

Baby and Johnny have a lot of sexual chemistry, that's for sure. But really, that, a love of dance, and a mutual admiration for each other is all they really have in common. One of the first things we learn about Baby is that she's very politically minded, and wants to join the Peace Corps after graduating from college. Johnny's a nice guy, but he works as a dancer at a resort. Not that there's anything wrong with that, but how exactly are these two going to make things work? Will Baby spend her summer and Christmas break at the lodge with Johnny, grasping for the connection that seems to be slipping away? Or will Johnny give up dancing and get a job in a factory or busing tables to be closer to her? All we can picture is them sitting down to dinner together, both of them facing the crushing realisation that they have nothing to say that will interest the other, and resenting each other for it. However you cut it, the relationship between Baby and Johnny is sweet, but it has summer fling written all over it.

9. Preston And Amanda - Can't Hardly Wait

There's something a little bit weird about the relationship between Preston and Amanda in Can't Hardly Wait. The entire film is built around them getting together, but not because we the audience have any indication that they will be a good couple, but rather because Preston seems like a nice guy and we'd like to see him get what he wants. That's pretty much it. At no point in the film do we see anything that leads us to believe that Amanda has any feelings about him whatsoever (or even knows who he is) until the last five minutes of the film, when she finds his letter and decides that she'd like to be with him. Even though up until that point she seemed pretty confident in her decision to be single for a while, having defined herself in the past by her relationships, and wanting to head off to college without any romantic entanglements. Which is just so smart it honestly has no place in a romantic comedy. And Preston? Well... he has good intentions, but he's just straight up creepy. Newsflash, guy: eating the same brand of Pop-Tarts does not mean that you and some random girl you don't even know are cosmically bound or something. But it's a romantic comedy, so there has to be a "happy ending". So they hook up before Preston heads away to a writing workshop at his college. And honestly? Their relationship probably didn't last much longer than the few hours they spent feverishly making out at the train station.

8. Ferris And Sloane - Ferris Bueller's Day Off

This has really nothing to do with the relationship shown on screen. Ferris and Sloane seem to really care about each other, they have the same kind of devil-may-care attitude, and it's clear that Sloane is envisioning a future for the two of them. But let's be real. Ferris is a total flake. If he thinks high school is too much of a commitment to handle attending on a regular basis, imagine how he's going to treat a long-term relationship. It's cute when you're 18 and skipping school, less so when you're in your early 20s and hijacking parades to get out of dinner with your girlfriend's parents. Ferris has a certain amount of affection for Sloane, but he sort of seems like the human version of a sprite: none of his emotions run particularly deep or last for very long. Will his relationship with Sloane be able to survive him being out in the real world while she still has one more year left of high school? Even Ferris acknowledges the writing on the wall with that one. And for the record, the relationship between Sloane and Cameron always seemed to be a bit more emotionally fulfilling.

7. Jack And Rose - Titanic

Alright, so considering the fact that Jack died a horrible icy death, this argument is entirely academic. But had both Jack and Rose survived, had they been on the Carpathia instead of the Titanic, their relationship still would have been doomed. Everything you see between the two characters on the ship is a classic example of the beginning of a relationship between two very young people. Rose may think that Jack's nomadic lifestyle is exciting and romantic, but at the end of the day, she's a rich girl. She's gotten accustomed to a certain way of life, and while she might not enjoy the hypocrisy and snobbishness of her fellow one percenters, she's probably going to be singing a different tune the first time she's asked to sleep on the street. And Jack's aimlessness will start to get a lot less charming. As for Jack, if he's the kind of guy who wants to be able to pick up and leave at a moments notice, a long term relationship has to feel pretty inhibiting.

6. Danny And Sandy - Grease

Because what relationship isn't going to succeed when both people are constantly trying to change themselves for each other? Don't be fooled by the magical car flying off into the sunset -- Sandy and Danny have some serious problems. But you can't judge them too harshly. After all, who hasn't met someone on vacation that was a totally different person when you see them in the real world? The difference is, most people would chalk that up to a summer fling and move on from it, not try and force a relationship that clearly isn't meant to be. First of all, Danny is a total jerk to her. Come on, if you're lucky enough to get with Olivia Newton-John, you do not throw shade at her in front of your friends to try and look cool. He's torn between wanting to act like a genuine human being, which Sandy likes, and acting the way a teenage boy thinks will get him laid. And Sandy, well... the girl is just a mess. You are a bright, beautiful, wonderful (if ridiculously naive) person, don't bust out the black leather just for someone who wasn't treating you right in the first place. In summation, Sandy and Danny are just a train wreck, but will probably stick together and pop out a couple of kids before they realise it.

5. Kate And Leopold

On the surface, this seems perfect. Leopold is a gorgeous, courteous (not to mention rich and intelligent) man who pretty much worships the ground that Kate walks on. What's not to love? It makes perfect sense that Kate would follow him back to the 1800s, where she can live a life of privilege as the Duchess of Albany and be with the man she loves. But then you think about what she's really just committed to. This is 1876. How is Kate, a driven career woman, going to react when she fully grasps the implications of the fact that women will not be allowed to vote in New York for another 41 years? To say nothing of the logistical issues of living in a less advanced society after you have, you know, sort of gotten used to antiseptics, cars, and pasteurised milk. Imagine the horror of the realisation that you will never have a hot shower or Starbucks ever again. Inevitably, Kate will grow to resent Leo, for having to give up everything she has ever known to be with him, and their relationship will disintegrate. You really put all your eggs in one basket, didn't you, Kate?

4. Andie And Blane - Pretty In Pink

No matter how classic this film is, it's hard to shake the feeling that Andie and Blane are dating an idea of a person rather than the actual person. Blane's bored of his yuppie rich boy life, so naturally he goes for the eccentric girl from the wrong side of the tracks. And it has to be immensely flattering for Andie when someone from the group that had always picked on her is actually kind and interested in her as a person. But is there a real, solid connection between these two characters? Not really. It doesn't help that Blane is probably one of the most bland characters in the history of cinema, and that Jon Cryer immensely overshadows him in the doting best friend role. But it just seems like they're in this relationship for all of the wrong reasons. They come off as people who are dating because, as generally good people, they're nice to each other, not because there's any attraction going on between them. It speaks volumes that a tremendous portion of the audience wanted Andie and Duckie to end up at the prom together.

3. Sugar And Joe - Some Like It Hot

Frankly, we'd be really surprised if the relationship between Sugar and Joe lasted for the length of their getaway boat ride. Sugar is the girl who is always dating the wrong guy, and Joe is the wrong guy. He's a saxophone player who seduces all the girls and then breaks their hearts, and while a lot of films have characters like that who change over the course of the movie because of the influence of the girl they love, Joe at the end is more or less the same as the Joe at the beginning. He's still lying, still coming up with ridiculous schemes that hurt people just so that he can get what he wants. While they're in the boat, he's even self-aware enough to beg Sugar not to go with him, because she deserves better. At the end of the day, he just isn't a good boyfriend, and he knows that. Inevitably, once the glow of the honeymoon period is over, he's going to get tired of her and move on to the next pretty girl with a ukulele, and she's going to start drinking again. This is how it ends.

2. Andrew And Allison - The Breakfast Club

The relationship between Bender and Claire is one thing. It's fine, it makes sense, the bad boy and the princess, we can all wrap our heads around that. But what was with the slapdash union of Emilio Estevez and Ally Sheedy? Why was it necessary? One can only assume it was borne out of a desire to pair everyone off (except for the nerd, of course -- he will be forever alone). But there is little to no build up between the characters, which is puzzling. It essentially begins with Sheedy being so weird that it forced Emilio's character to think about something other than himself for a change, and it culminates with the totally random makeover which undermined everything that her character had been for the entirety of the film. That's it. Hardly a love story for the ages. There's no hint as to why either of these characters are interested in each other at all, except for the fact that they're both attractive humans. Not to be a killjoy, but this relationship will end as quickly and bizarrely as it began.

1. Ben And Elaine - The Graduate

The Graduate features one of the most open-ended, bittersweet conclusions in all of film. It's the triumphant ending, where Ben has convinced Elaine to ditch her own wedding and run away with him. They're sitting together on the bus, elated by their boldness. But the camera lingers a few seconds too long, and their excited grins start to fade from their faces, as they realise the enormity of what they've done. In the world of The Graduate, there are brief moments of happiness, but sooner or later The Sound of Silence starts playing again and you remember that you're going to die alone. But aside from the ending, their entire relationship sets off warning bells. First of all, there's the not so minor problem of Ben sleeping with Elaine's mother, which really can't be overstated. And even after that relationship is over, he doesn't so much make Elaine fall in love with him as he does wear her down. His idea of wooing her is asking over and over again if she'll marry him. They're just... not great together, and the church is barely out of the rear view mirror before you can see both of them realise that they've made a terrible mistake.

Contributor
Contributor

Audrey Fox is an ex-film student, which means that she prefers to spend her days in the dark, watching movies and pondering the director's use of diegetic sound. She currently works as an entertainment writer, joyfully rambling about all things film and television related. Add her on Twitter at @audonamission and check out her film blog at 1001moviesandbeyond.com.