10 Sci-Fi Fan Theories That Make The Films Better

Is Agent Smith the One? Is the Indominus Rex part person? Whatever became of the Raptor Kid?

The One The Matrix
Warner Bros.

Some fan theories have the power to totally ruin a movie—particularly the edgy but annoyingly effective “your childhood favourite is actually about something disturbing” brand of trollish fandom speculation. We’ll never watch the Home Alone franchise the same way again—nor the Saw films, for that matter.

But conversely some fan theories actually manage to deepen and further colour the universe of whatever films they spring from and can not only fill in pesky plot holes but even make the flick itself more entertaining upon a re-watch. These are the rare fan theories which seem less based in random speculation and more culled from minor details hidden, intentionally or otherwise, in the films they come from.

That said, whilst some of these are deeply impressive for the obvious attention to detail which went into uncovering them, some are just great fun even if the supposed “evidence” supporting them is shaky at best. Whether wildly implausible but great fun or surprisingly solid and well-supported, here are ten sci-fi fan theories which actually made the films they’re from better.

10. Agent Smith Is The One - The Matrix

The Matrix Revolutions Hugo Weaving
Warner Bros.

Okay, so hear us out here.

Yes, we know, Neo is the One, it’s right there in the terribly obvious anagram of his name, we get it (it’s hard to miss, Wachowski sisters). But what if he, you know, weren’t?

Just consider the evidence outlined by this fan theory, which we can’t really shake from our regular re-watches of the trilogy since hearing it. See, according to the movies the One doesn’t need to be a willing part of their destiny, so we’ve no reason to expect that Agent Smith would know this was his fate or predestined for him. The One, we’re told, was born in the Matrix—which is undeniably the case for Agent Smith, given that he’s literally part of the code. Neo, on the other hand, was born in the normal human way—you know, gestating in an energy-harvesting pod for later use as a living battery (weird series).

Both Neo and Agent Smith are able to manipulate the code, but Smith proves able to do so after he has already been unplugged by Neo—which is an ability we’d expect from the One, and not from his nemesis Neo.

Trippy, isn’t it?


9. The Na'vi Aren't Native To Pandora - Avatar

Sam Worthington in Avatar
20th Century Studios

Now this one may simply be an attempt by dastardly humans to absolve ourselves of our fictional guilt over colonizing Pandora, but it’s worth digging into this popular fan theory about Titanic helmer James Cameron’s 2009 epic eco-action Avatar anyway—mainly because literally anything would make re-watching this overrated dud more bearable.

So in the film as we saw it, earth’s nefarious inhabitants attempt to mine the planet Pandora and its innocent inhabitants, the humble Na’vi, of their resources, fuelling our green marble’s excesses via their precious and limited assets.

But what if—get this—they’re not even locals? As one Reddit fan theory notes, the Na’vi aren’t all that similar to the native animals we see on their planet, and they’re surprisingly similar to us humans—a coincidence which this theory chalks up to the fact that Pandora isn’t their planet at all. Instead, they’re just earlier colonizers of the same place, and the film’s conflict is between a pair of warring tribes rather than an indigenous people and their oppressor.

Hey, at least it’s a lot less cliché this way.


8. Cobb's Totem Is His Wedding Ring - Inception

Inception Cobb
Warner Bros. Pictures

Now this one is legitimate enough in terms of onscreen evidence that we’re sort of surprised Dark Knight helmer Christopher Nolan never added in an explicit mention of it onscreen, but then, this infamous flick wouldn’t be the same mindf*** if he did, would it?

Throughout the film we follow Leonard DiCaprio’s tortured inception expert, haunted by the death of his wife as he assembles a crack team to infiltrate the dreams of an energy magnate’s son unbeknownst to said offspring. When our hero uses a spinning top as an example of a “totem”, he’s explaining that each member of his team needs to bring such an item in order to check whether they’re in reality or a dream at any given time. So naturally we presume the top is his totem, and when he sets it spinning at the end of the film, we have no way of knowing whether he is in reality or not as we never see it fall.

Right?

Sure—unless he was just using the top as an example, and the protagonist’s actual totem is his wedding ring, which only ever appears when he’s in a dream world and vanishes back in reality.


7. Jar Jar Binks Is A Secret Sith Lord - Star Wars

Star Wars The Force Awakens Jar Jar
Lucasfilm

Now this one may be too ludicrous to consider on the face of it, but there’s some pretty convincing evidence that it’s only crazy because the nigh-on unstoppable Jar Jar has managed to convince you so. Everything is broken down at length in the Reddit post outlining this theory, but a basic rundown is that, rather than being the oafish goof we know and despise from the prequels, Jar Jar is a villain on par with or possibly above Palpatine himself on the Sith chain of command.

How? Well, his goofiness never stops him from constantly succeeding effortlessly in battle, lending credence to the theory that it’s a façade. His affable demeanour gives him constant access to Anakin, and his influence sees him roast Qui-Gon to the impressionable child, ensuring he’ll grow up to dismiss the authority of Jedis. Then there’s the fact that, years after silly Jar Jar was “tricked” into electing Palpatine, the pair still share the screen in Revenge of the Sith. What business would the Emperor have with such an idiotic figure—unless he was conferring with, or even taking orders from, him?

Look, maybe this one is way off, but there are too many “wacky idiots” in real politics who have transpired to be competent double agents for us to dismiss this much mounting evidence.


6. Mad Max Is Road Warrior's Feral Kid All Grown Up - Fury Road

The Feral Kid Boomerang
Warner Bros.

Fury Road may have breathed new life into George Miller’s franchise with a pulse pounding and socially resonant slice of intense sci-fi action, but the thrill-ride didn’t manage to revive one pivotal figure from earlier instalments—the eponymous Max Rockatansky.

Okay so the titular vigilante road warrior does feature in the film, but his face is looking pretty different, having transformed from the Mel Gibson of the first three films into British Bronson star Tom Hardy at some point. Maybe it’s age and Gibson’s directorial career—or maybe it’s that the film’s Max is actually the Feral Kid from the second instalment of the series, Road Warrior.

Where’s the evidence? Well, Max left the kid a music box, one of few things which Fury Road’s Max has in his possession. Max barely talks in Fury Road, communicating mostly in grunts and assorted noises much like the Feral Kid, and Max sounds unsure of his name when he finally identifies himself near the film’s close—because he’s borrowing it from his former mentor. It’s a rare theory which managed to impress even the film’s director, who admitted he hadn’t planned it but couldn’t argue with the logic.


5. Owen Grady Is Jurassic Park's Raptor Kid All Grown Up - Jurassic World

Jurassic Park Raptor Claw
Universal

This one has little evidence, but the bit of back up on offer is tantalizing enough that Jurassic World director Colin Trevorrow couldn’t bring himself to confirm or deny the speculation since fans were having so much fun with the idea. Early in 1993’s classic Spielberg blockbuster Jurassic Park, Sam Neill’s irritable palaeontologist tells an unimpressed kid visiting the dig site (that seems like a safe and sensible place to bring children) that he ought to respect the raptor’s awesome prowess as a biologically flawless predator.

It’s a weird comment coming from him, since the species are pretty long gone and probably unavailable for in-person respecting for the foreseeable—but then, lo and behold, it seems pretty striking when Chris Pratt’s gruffly heroic Owen Grady, a raptor trainer, tells a crowd of colleagues that his success with the beasts is based on a “relationship of respect” during an early equivalent scene in Jurassic World some twenty two years later.

It seems too close to be a coincidence, though whatever about Trevorrow’s input, according to Raptor Kid himself, actor Whit Herford, “Chris Pratt is not playing a grown up version of my character. That role is mine, dammit!”


4. Skynet Needs Humans - The Terminator

Skynet wallpaper
Orion Pictures

The Terminator series is rife with potential for fan theories since each film in the inconsistent franchise attempts to deepen the lore of the universe shared by the series. But whilst the flicks themselves may vary in quality, one fan theory explains the underlying conflict of the series with a surprisingly believable and consistent internal logic which beats the actual explanations offered in the films.

It’s an age-old question—if Skynet killed off half of humanity the moment it became self-aware via nuclear Armageddon, why didn’t they just wipe out the entire human world at once? Why send Arnie back in time to off John Connor?

Well, because it needs humans in order to have a purpose—that purpose being, destroy them. Therefore the not-that-bright computer brain behind the antagonists of the series is essentially treating John Connor and by extension humanity the way a cat does a mouse—letting them escape long enough to chase them again, and repeating this loop ad nauseaum.

Boy, when you put it like that it makes the end of Terminator 3 sound positively uplifting.


3. The Indominus Rex Is Part Human - Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom

Jurassic World Indominus Rex attack
Universal

Another Jurassic World theory, because this one is too good to leave unshared.

We’re informed early on in 2015’s blockbuster reboot of the “theme park gone wrong” dinosaur adventure series that the Indominus Rex is a perfect predator, engineered from the DNA of various other animals in order to optimize its intelligence, aggression, and ruthlessness.

But what animal is more cruel than… MAN?!

Forgive our hammy delivery there, but you know the old chestnut. Yes, man is amongst the most ruthless and cunning of creatures, which explains why rabbits aren’t razing the Amazon for resources, and John Sayles’ early script for this reboot featured a human-raptor hybrid designed as a weapon for sale to arms manufacturers—which is exactly what Indominus Rex ends up becoming in the next instalment, when he’s auctioned off to the highest bidder at a shady and improbable high stakes arms auction.

Oh, did we mention said auction takes place on an estate which also houses a human clone? Maybe it’s merely coincidence, but this underutilized plot strand and the absurd intelligence of the dinosaur tell us this one was featured in an earlier, more coherent draft of the script.


2. Caleb Is A Robot Too - Ex Machina

Domhnall Gleeson Ex Machina
Universal Pictures

Much has been written about Alex Garland’s Ex Machina, with the mind behind The Beach and Annihilation having his film picked apart by debate and conversation as much as his film’s antagonist Nathan picks apart his own creations through the same interminable tests. Of course, it’s just the android Ava who is being tested in this flick—or is it?

According to one Reddit user, our protagonist and audience insertion persona Caleb, ably played by The Little Stranger’s Domhnall Gleeson, is also an android unbeknownst to himself—a reality hinted at in the film. There are tons of little details hinting at this possibility, chief amongst them the fact that Caleb fails to describe tastes when pressed by Nathan, is confined to a box during his interviews with Ava, and is simply informed “you” when he asks Nathan the purpose of his tests.

Most interesting, however, is the unsettling note that Nathan claims Ava can’t process empathy, something his much more impressive follow-up model can manage. According to this theory, that’s why she sees no issue with trapping him when freeing herself, and why he helps her escape in the first place.


1. They're Not Aliens, They're Demons - Signs

Signs M. Night Shyamalan
Touchstone Pictures

M Night Shyamalan’s 2002 alien invasion thriller is better than you remember, as committed to slow burn psychological dread and tense atmospheric family drama as actual monster attacks. Yes, okay, so the eventual revelation that the farm’s shadowy threat are subdued and killed with water is cartoonish-ly implausible when they’re landing on a planet almost entirely covered in the stuff. But what if it’s not the water that kills them, but the fact that it’s holy water?

Okay hear us out here—Mel Gibson’s troubled patriarch is a lapsed Catholic who lost his faith after the death of his wife, and his little brother Merrill is a once promising baseball player who lost it all by not believing in his ability. In the film’s denouement, it’s the father regaining his faith in God and Merrill believing in himself which empowers them rather than any water—because they’re not besieged by extra-terrestrials, but rather just your average common or garden demons instead.

Given the fact that the characters confront their metaphorical demons at the same time they face down these scaly fiends, this theory feels far more believable than the “aliens are allergic to water” alternative.


Watch Next


Contributor

Cathal Gunning hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.