10 Sequels That Were Cancelled Due To Box Office Flops

When Hollywood overplays its hand...

Dredd 2.jpg
Lionsgate

Hollywood likes to get way, way ahead of itself, so it's never surprising when studios set about commissioning sequels to movies that aren't even out yet.

Some of the time, this occurs in relation to films that end up doing great business at the box office, and so the foresight in putting a sequel into development as quickly as possible actually pays off in a big way.

It doesn't always work out like that however: studios can bet on the wrong horse to be a major hit and put a sequel into development, only for said horse to plummet over the first fence at the box office and be taken out the back and shot.

Occasionally the studio will bite the bullet and plough forwards, hoping that things change when the sequel swings around, but in most cases they're forced to concede embarrassing defeat and cancel.

Here are 10 sequels that were either shelved or found themselves shunted into development hell (forever) after their initial movies failed to entice the punters to the theatre. 

Learn your lesson, Hollywood: slow down.

10. The Lone Ranger 2

Johnny Depp The Lone Ranger
Disney

"Hi-Yo, Silver!"

Or, uh, not. After the success of Pirates of the Caribbean, a film franchise based on a shoddy ride from the '60s, Disney asked themselves: "Hey, which other redundant artefact with minor cultural relevance can we update and sell to the masses?" Their gaze fell on The Lone Ranger, a western TV series from the '40s, known for its iconic theme tune and light-hearted antics.

Get Gore Verbinski to direct, and Johnny Depp to star... what could go wrong?

Well lots. The studio's first mistake was believing that casting Depp as Tonto would ensure the film as a box office smash. Disney also failed to realise that, in 2013, the western - as a genre - was done for and that lead actor Armie Hammer lacked draw.

And so the film, made for $225 million, grossed just $260 million (despite not being anywhere near as bad as the critics made it out to be).

Planned out as a major franchise with Hammer and Depp both signed on for multiple sequels, the disappointing returns meant that The Lone Ranger 2 had to take a bullet; Disney quickly halted development on the sequel, and then - to Depp's well-publicized chagrin - swiftly wiped it from existence.


9. Fantastic Four 2

Fantastic Four 2015
20th Century Fox

When Tim Story's embarrassingly broad and cartoonish film is still considered to be the best Fantastic Four movie to date, something has gone terribly wrong.

The nightmarish production on Josh Trank's recent reboot has entered the stuff of Hollywood legend; intended to be a darker and more cerebral take on the iconic superhero team, the most shocking thing about the film is in how little it resembles a film at all. Half-assed acting and dodgy special effects aside, Fantastic Four plays out like a feature-length prologue. Just when it gets going, it's over.

The turbulent relationship shared between Trank and 20th Century Fox during the making of this superhero screw-up dominated the conversation in the weeks leading up to the film's release, and the controversy got Trank thrown off a Star Wars spin-off he was supposed to be mounting over at Disney.

After Chronicle, everyone was expecting a masterpiece, but what we got was a flop, torn apart by the critics; it made just $168 million on a budget of $120 million. Somewhat unexpectedly, Fox announced that - despite the poor gross - they still intended to mount the sequel. And then they quietly took it back when, two months later, Fantastic Four 2 mysteriously vanished from the release slate.

Flame on? Flame off.


8. The Mortal Instruments: City Of Ashes

The Mortal Instruments City of Bones
Screen Gems

You have to kind of feel sorry for people who backed The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones. It came out at a time when Harry Potter and The Hunger Games were all the rage, and must've seemed like a real safe bet.

The only problem was that the market was already saturated with Young Adult novel adaptations, and this was the franchise that people kind of deemed to be a step too far, as if to say: "I accepted Percy Jackson, but please, God, no more."

Without any notable stars or anything to separate it from the pack, it was doomed.

So, The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones, based on the series of the same name by Cassandra Clare, arrived feeling like the cinematic equivalent of the guy who arrives at the party when everyone has gone home and there are three people left drunkly cleaning up. Not only was it met with terrible reviews, it made only $90 million on a budget of $30 million; not the worst box office result ever, but nowhere near enough to keep the franchise alive.

Still, the sequel, City of Ashes, didn't die straight away; Screen Gems committed to it, and claimed production would begin in 2014. It didn't, but the studio insisted it was definitely happening. Now, it's three years later and everybody has forgotten that this franchise ever existed.


7. His Dark Materials: The Subtle Knife

The Golden Compass battle Lyra
New Line Cinema

In the wake of Peter Jackson's phenomenally successful Lord of the Rings trilogy, New Line envisioned The Golden Compass to be their next money-making behemoth; the plan was to take Phillip Pullman's fantastic fantasy series, His Dark Materials, and produce three box office hits, one by one, thus cornering the market for magical creatures and strange lands for years to come.

Hey, it worked for The Lord of the Rings, right?

Yeah, except the only different was that The Lord of the Rings movies were brilliant, and The Golden Compass was... well, the very opposite of that. It was met with lukewarm to poor critical notices, and pulled in $372 million on a budget of $190 million. Not horrific, but hardly the stuff of New Line's fantasy dreams.

Without word of mouth to ignite the fire, nobody bothered to go out and see "that film with the armoured polar bear," because absolutely nobody was recommending it. There was also the little matter of the Church; given the anti-Christian themes in The Golden Compass, the studio were pressured into losing an entire segment of the film: the ending.

The Subtle Knife already had a script and a release date, but instead of making it into a film, the studio took the blade and used it to commit seppuku.


6. I Am Number Four 2

I AM NUMBER FOUR
Disney

"John Smith is an alien from the planet Lorien."

That right there is pretty much the reason why I Am Number Four floundered at the box office, pulling in - to the studio's disappointment - $150 million on a budget of $50 million. Based on a somewhat better novel of the same name, the idea didn't translate to the cinematic medium and audiences were left with was a sub-par flick filled with naff performances and a plot that made zero sense.

For some reason, the studio were so convinced that I Am Number Four was destined for box office glory that it put plans for a sequel film into development long before the first film was even out. Think about that for a second: in the minds of the head honchos over at Disney, there was a point where they considered Alex Pettyfer and Timothy Olyphant to be a team worthy of box office grandeur.

2011 was a crazy time.

Anyhow, the sequel was very quickly cancelled when the film failed to make the franchise-starting gross of around $500 million. Sad news for the eight people who were desperate to find out what happened to John Smith, that alien from the planet Lorien, and the twenty or so plot threads this movie left dangling.


5. John Carter 2

John Carter Taylor Kitsch
Disney

In yet another ill-judged attempt to take something semi-beloved and make a ton of money out of it, John Carter was intended to be a franchise of epic, space-sized proportions for Disney; Star Wars for a new generation, helmed by Andrew Stanton, the guy who brought Pixar's Wall-E to the big screen.

In a curious case of counting their chickens before they'd hatched, however, it turned out that Disney had no idea whatsoever as how to market John Carter and proceeded to murder their film before it ever got a chance to shine. One crucial mistake came about when the studio decided to drop "Of Mars" from the title, leaving the film to sound as bland and uninviting as a tinned food brand.

Worse than that, though? John Carter is yawn-worthy. For such a huge movie, set across multiple planets, featuring aliens and a hero capable of jumping fifty feet into the air, it's plainly boring to sit through. It also isn't funny, none of the characters are even the least bit memorable, and the action is "blah."

At a cost of $263 million, the film grossed just $286 million, which meant the planned trilogy was put "on hold" - a polite way of saying that it was never gonna happen. A script for a sequel was reportedly written, but in 2014 Disney relinquished the rights, signalling a sad, sudden end for John Carter. Of Mars.


4. Dredd 2

Dredd 20012 Karl Urban
DNA Films

Written by Alex Garland, the novelist turned screenwriter responsible for films such as 28 Days Later and Ex Machina, Dredd was yet another attempt to make the character relevant for a modern audience; after the campy failure that was 1995's Judge Dredd, which felt like it was directed by somebody who had never read the original comic series, Garland's own script was dark, tight and very violent.

The resulting film stands as something of an unsung triumph; whilst Karl Urban was lauded for his turn as the titular law enforcement officer and critics praised the film for its bloody simplicity, nobody bothered to go and see it. It grossed a depressing $41.5 million on a budget of $45 million, which meant that Garland's plan to pen two further sequels were instantly compromised.

Fans of the movie have spent the three years following Dredd's release rallying for said sequels to be made, but Garland has insisted they'll never happen due to the first flick's low box office takings.

Interestingly, there have been recent discussions regarding a Netflix TV series, but nothing has been confirmed as of yet.


3. Terminator Genisys 2

Terminator Genysis
Paramount Pictures

Emilia Clarke recently announced that she has decided to jump ship from the Terminator: Genisys sequel... but that's assuming that there was a ship to jump from in the first place. After all, the semi-failure of the first installment in this remake/reboot/sequel didn't make anywhere near as much as the studio hoped it would - $440 million isn't terrible, but it's not Terminator money, is it?

The poor reviews didn't help matters, not to mention the fact that the film was unable to work out what it was and tried to be several things at once - the results were confusing, and Clarke - ship-jumper that she is - made for an unbelievable Sarah Connor when compared to Linda Hamilton's badass incarnation.

In response to the overtly lacklustre response to Genisys, Paramount wiped the 2017 sequel from its release slate, throwing the future of the franchise into contention. Arnold Schwarzenegger is still insisting that another film will happen, but as of right now nothing seems set in stone.

On the bright side, Genisys - more than any other recent blockbuster, perhaps - gave Hollywood a reason to be scared. It essentially proved that movie-goers are less respondent to arbitrary sequels than they initially thought, even those from popular and established franchises. Time to terminate this one for good.


2. Green Lantern 2

Green Lantern Ryan Reynolds
Warner Bros.

Ryan Reynolds might be hot stuff now, but prior to his recent success with Deadpool ($761 million in global takings, in case you're wondering) he was considered to be "box office poison." As in, you put the guy in a movie, and you're almost definitely going to lose a bunch of money.

No Ryan Reynolds venture proved this as much as Green Lantern did; intended as the first installment in a huge, Marvel Cinematic Universe-sized mega-franchise, it turned out that nobody was interested in actually seeing it; it didn't help that the movie in question was terrible, which was kind of unexpected given that it had been helmed by Casino Royale's Martin Campbell, a usually reliable director.

Made on a budget of $200 million, Green Lantern was expected to pull in somewhere in the region of $600-700 million. It didn't. Poor reviews and negative word of mouth resulted in the film taking a measly $220 million, which means that - marketing budget considered - Warner Bros. lost a hell of a lot of money.

You can guess what happened next: the proposed sequel flick, set to be penned by Michael Goldenberg (who co-wrote the first one and the fifth Harry Potter film), was cancelled and the whole cinematic universe idea was put on the scrap heap.


1. The Girl Who Played With Fire

The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo Rooney Mara
Sony Pictures

Of all the movies on this list, this is the one that really should've happened. The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo turned out great, after all, thanks to David Fincher's peerless direction and Rooney Mara's performance at its centre; on that basis alone, it seemed inevitable that Sony would commit to making all three movies.

The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo under-performed at the box office, though; it brought just $232 million on a budget of $90 million, and Sony had expected at least double that. The two sequel films, which Fincher originally planned to shoot back-to-back, were suddenly on extended hiatus... and then nothing.

During the Sony Leaks (remember those?), it later emerged that Mara had contacted studio boss Amy Pascal via email in an attempt to find out what was happening with The Girl Who Played with Fire. "I'm writing because I wanted to ask you about the Dragon Tattoo sequels," she wrote. "Logic tells me they are not ever happening, as it's been almost 3 years since it came out."

Pascal responded to Mara and arranged a meeting to discuss the sequel, but later cancelled. In the wake of the leaks, Pascal was removed from her position as studio head, and with that any chance of these sequels died with her departure.

There has been recent talk of a reboot, which could amount to something, but as far as the Fincher/Mara side of the franchise is concerned, it's certainly over.

Which other canned sequels belong on this list? Share your finds below in the comments thread.


Contributor

Sam Hill is an ardent cinephile and has been writing about film professionally since 2008. He harbours a particular fondness for western and sci-fi movies.