10 Sequels That Were Nothing Like The First Movie
For better or worse, at least these movies weren't carbon copies of the first one.
Despite churning them out at an alarmingly high rate on an annual basis, Hollywood is incredibly hit-or-miss when it comes to delivering genuinely good sequels. Some of the best ever made learn from the mistakes of their predecessors, improving upon the first movie's weaknesses to craft something familiar, yet entirely different and ultimately much better. Think The Dark Knight, Dawn of the Planet of the Apes, The Bourne Supremacy and Weekend at Bernie's 2.
Other times, the studios are content to simply hit 'Ctrl C + Ctrl V' on the script for a hit movie, change a few locations or lines of dialogue here and there, and simply do the same old thing again because if it worked once, the chances are it'll work again. And it does, frequently, forcing audiences to sit through the likes of The Hangover Part II, Taken 2 and Ocean's Twelve wondering where that creeping sense of deja vu is coming from.
Reinventing the wheel is key to franchise filmmaking, as it manages to extend the shelf-life of a popular brand without veering too far away from what made the brand popular in the first place. However, there have been plenty of sequels that are completely unrecognizable from the movies that launched their respective franchises, and the results can quite often be incredibly hit or miss.
10. Thor: Ragnarok
The Original:
Kenneth Branagh's Thor was a superhero origin story wrapped in Shakespearean clothing, full of grandiose production design and canted camera angles. The theme of warring brothers dueling for their father's affection only reinforced the notion, with Chris Hemsworth playing the title character as a noble and stoic yet flawed hero.
The Sequel:
The Dark World is rightfully regarded as one of, if not the, weakest entries in the entire Marvel Cinematic Universe. The franchise was in dire need of a fresh perspective, and Taika Waititi turned out to be an unlikely-yet-perfect fit for the material.
About as far away from Branagh's classic sensibilities as you could hope to get, Waititi re-energized the tiring God of Thunder by moving away from the opulence and borderline-pomposity of the previous two movies and into sheer batsh*t craziness.
In the space of just two movies, the Thor franchise had transformed from faux-Shakespearean drama into a wacky intergalactic buddy comedy packed full of witty one-liners and Jeff Goldblum going full Goldblum as an immortal alien. The biggest beneficiary of the drastic tonal change may have been Hemsworth himself, with Thor's reinvention into a cosmic frat-bro a much better fit for the actor than that of the troubled and reluctant hero.
9. Logan
The Original:
X-Men Origins: Wolverine was a colossal misstep. There's very little that the movie managed to get right; it humanized Logan in entirely the wrong way by giving him a sappy backstory, suffered from terrible CGI, sewed Deadpool's mouth shut and most heinously of all, gave will.i.am a major role in a Hollywood blockbuster.
The Sequel:
Things improved dramatically once James Mangold took over the solo franchise. The Wolverine was a huge step in the right direction but still suffered from ticking off the required number of comic book movie cliches. In giving the iconic character the sendoff he deserved, Mangold and Hugh Jackman delivered one of the greatest comic book movies ever made.
Its still definitely a superhero movie, but Logan turned its back on the tropes of the genre and instead positioned the title character's last stand as a brutal, stripped-back modern Western with more than a hint of film noir.
Gritty, violent, thoughtful, emotional and many other superlatives in between; Jackman finally got the chance to make the Wolverine movie he had always wanted to make and retired his career-defining character in spectacular fashion.
8. Jason X
The Original:
Capitalizing on the breakout success of Halloween two years earlier, 1980's Friday the 13th sent the slasher boom into overdrive, with the low-budget horror set at an abandoned summer camp earning over a hundred times its budget at the box office.
The Sequel:
The first follow-up introduced the soon-to-be-iconic Jason Voorhees, who repeatedly returned in a series of sequels of wildly inconsistent quality over the course of the next decade. After an eight-year absence from screens, a genius executive must have blurted out 'what if it was the same as all of the other movies... but in space?' and thus, we ended up with Jason X.
We're a far cry from Mrs. Voorhees terrorizing promiscuous teenagers around some log cabins, as her son finds himself trapped on a spaceship in the year 2455. Yes, its just as stupid and ridiculous as it sounds and miles away from the original premise but hey, at least he's keeping the family business alive and well by murdering one-dimensional characters in absurd fashion.
7. Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home
The Original:
Star Trek: The Motion Picture boldly went... pretty much where everyone expected it to, picking up where the original series had left off a decade earlier by sending Captain Kirk and his crew on his mission to stop a deadly intergalactic threat.
The Sequel:
The second and third installments largely followed the tried-and-tested narrative path on which Star Trek made its name, albeit to the tune of diminishing box office returns. Sensing something fresh was needed, director and co-writer Leonard Nimoy fashioned a sequel that was completely bonkers, even by Trek standards.
Time-traveling back to Earth by slingshotting around the sun in order to round up a couple of humpback whales to answer an alien distress call (no, seriously), The Voyage Home moves firmly into fish-out-of-water comedy territory as the team gets up to all sorts of shenanigans in 1986 San Francisco.
Tongue-in-cheek without descending into full-blown parody, Star Trek IV's premise had the potential to sink the franchise entirely given how wildly different it was to the previous entries, but the end product is still regarded as a fan-favorite to this day.
6. Army of Darkness
The Original:
Made for a minuscule budget, Sam Raimi's breakout feature quickly transcended its status as a cult classic to become a bona fide box office smash, grossing almost $30m against a budget of $350,000 and earning a reputation as one of the most terrifying horror movies of all time, deftly balancing the gore with pitch-black humor.
The Sequel:
Evil Dead II may have introduced more humor to the series, but it was 1992's Army of Darkness that went full-blown screwball comedy, about as far a departure from the original as anyone could imagine. Transporting Ash to the Middle Ages sees Raimi let his imagination run wild, with the threequel more indebted to Ray Harryhausen than John Carpenter.
Army of Darkness' reviews weren't quite as enthusiastic as those that greeted the first two installments, as many seemed to be taken aback that the movie was more of a swords-and-sorcery adventure than the stripped-back horror of the first two entries in the franchise. It was still groovy, just in an entirely different way.
5. Book Of Shadows: Blair Witch 2
The Original:
An absolute game-changer that both popularized the found footage sub-genre and made use of the internet's potential as a marketing tool, The Blair Witch Project is still one of the most successful independent movies ever made, earning almost $250m on a budget of just $60,000.
The Sequel:
The Blair Witch Project was hardly a movie crying out for a follow-up but it got one anyway, purely for financial reasons you would expect. Discarding everything that made the first movie so memorable, Book of Shadows ended up as just another forgettable low-budget genre flick.
The connections to the original were tenuous at best, and the entirely-scripted psychological horror offered little in the way of new ideas, instead deciding to piggyback off the success of its groundbreaking predecessor. Despite featuring trained actors the performances were somehow even worse, and by casually slapping the 'Blair Witch' moniker on the title it couldn't have been more obvious that Book of Shadows was nothing more than a cynical cash-grab.
4. Fast Five
The Original:
Basically Point Break with wheels, The Fast and the Furious was an unashamed B-move based around the Los Angeles street racing scene, one that embraced its pulp roots and delivered an entertaining enough actioner.
The Sequel:
While it may have been the fourth movie that reunited the original cast, Fast Five was when the franchise really embraced its new identity. Upgrading itself as gravity-defying, balls-to-the wall escapism, the fifth installment threw logic out of the window and was all the better for it.
The casting of Dwayne Johnson cemented this shift into the realms of blockbuster territory, with the franchise's street-racing roots all-but-forgotten following a series of city-destroying, bone-breaking and utterly gonzo action sequences that transformed the Fast and Furious series into one of Hollywood's elite franchises, a position that it has embraced with increasingly-ridiculous results with each sequel since.
3. Die Hard 4.0
The Original:
Perhaps the greatest action movie ever made, Die Hard signaled a shift away from the musclebound action heroes of the 1980's towards characters that audiences could actually relate to, as John McClane overcame the odds to save the day at Nakatomi Plaza.
The Sequel:
Die Hard 4.0 isn't awful, but it does forget everything that made Die Hard such a success. John McClane was an ordinary guy trapped in extraordinary circumstances, who used his wits and a sh*tload of luck to save the day, picking up more than a few injuries along the way.
In Len Wiseman's fourth installment, he's basically the Terminator. No longer the everyman hero that we used to root for, McClane is now an indestructible killing machine that can take down a fighter jet with his bare hands and casually guns down reams of faceless henchmen, and is now capable of surviving enough gunfights and explosions that Chuck Norris himself would be jealous.
Which is the polar opposite of what the character is supposed to be, but that didn't really seem to matter to the filmmakers. Its a blockbuster sequel; bigger is always better.
2. Rambo: First Blood Part II
The Original:
First Blood is absolutely nothing like the rest of the Rambo franchise. Sylvester Stallone gives one of the best performances of his career as the troubled Vietnam veteran forced to rely on his primal instincts as crooked law enforcement officials hunt him down in the woods of Washington.
The Sequel:
Whereas First Blood actually boasted some depth, proper characterization and even a little political subtext, Part II (co-written by Stallone and James Cameron) is the typical 1980's shoot-em-up. Gone are the subtleties found in the original, replaced by a shirtless Stallone gunning down faceless bad guys with a gun almost as big as his biceps.
Instead of the questions raised in the first installment of what happens when veterans return from war, First Blood Part II is more than content to rest on its laurels and present the all-American John Rambo as an unstoppable and deadly force of nature, turning the character as a poster boy for the cut-and-paste nature of the decade's action cinema in the process.
1. Batman & Robin
The Original:
Completely wiping away the memory of Adam West's take on the character, Tim Burton's dark and brooding Batman dragged the Dark Knight into the modern era, revolutionizing the way blockbuster movies were marketed and merchandised forever and reinventing the Caped Crusader for a new generation of fans.
The Sequel:
It seems unbelievable that Batman & Robin even exists in the same continuity as Burton's original, given how incredibly different they are. Gone are the Gothic cityscapes, tortured characters and sense of foreboding that permeated Batman and Batman Returns, replaced by a neon and nipples extravaganza designed exclusively to sell toys to kids.
The Dark Knight certainly wasn't dark anymore, replaced by a series of fluorescent costumes and crap dialogue that reached a head with Arnold Schwarzenegger's painful series of Mr. Freeze-related puns. George Clooney still apologizes for it to this day, and no wonder; Batman had come full circle and returned to the high-camp of the 1960's TV show, which was about as far away from the 1989 original as you could possibly get.