10 Signs The Batman Could Be A Crushing Disappointment

The Batman may have all the makings of a hit, but you probably shouldn't get your hopes up...

The Batman
Twitter (@Bosslogic)

The Batman was originally going to be directed by Ben Affleck, and the filmmaker was set to reprise the role of the Caped Crusader after playing Bruce Wayne in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, Suicide Squad, and Justice League. However, after handing the movie over to Matt Reeves, Affleck ultimately decided to leave the DC Extended Universe for good, and a new Dark Knight was found in British actor Robert Pattinson.

With shooting taking place on the movie, more details are quickly starting to be revealed, and even the Batsuit has been shown off in its entirety thanks to recent set photos. However, while it's still early days for the project, evidence does appear to be mounting that it could prove to be a complete and utter disappointment.

That may sound like a bold proclamation, and The Batman could potentially surprise comic book fans. Unfortunately, there are signs there that this DC Comics adaptation will fall short of the high expectations that surround it.

Now, we're taking a look at why Reeves' movie may fail to deliver the epic Batman adventure fans are hoping for by looking at everything from what we know about the plot to some suspect casting decisions and, well, an undeniably disappointing take on the Batsuit. June 2021 is still a while off, but you may want to adjust your expectations accordingly...

10. The Chances Of It Being Another Origin Story Seem High

Batman Parents
DC Comics

It's been said that The Batman takes place in "Year Two" of the Dark Knight's crime fighting career, but make no mistake about it, this has all the makings of another origin story. While it's too soon to say whether we'll have to once again watch Thomas and Martha Wayne get gunned down, Reeves' movie is going to explore how Batman became...Batman!

Zack Snyder gave us a world-weary Batman who had spent decades in Gotham City, but Reeves had the chance to find a comfortable middle-ground with his movie. Instead, we're going to be forced to spend time with a rookie Batman, and while there's a lot of storytelling potential with that concept, the film might as well still include the murder of his parents.

Don't believe us? Well, look no further than the Batsuit for proof that what happened to them will factor into The Batman in a big way. This Bruce Wayne wears the gun used to kill them on his chest as a twisted reminder of what happened, and there's no way this is just an Easter Egg rather than something Reeves plans to devote a lot of screentime to.

We've seen this too many times before, and it really isn't something we need more of!


9. Robert Pattinson Just Doesn't Seem To Get The Character

Robert Pattinson The Batman
Warner Bros.

Not every actor who plays a superhero needs to have an expert knowledge of comic books, but it certainly helps if they at least have some understanding of who they're playing. In the case of Robert Pattinson, he certainly has some pretty controversial opinions about Batman, most of which point to a complete lack of understanding of the Dark Knight.

While the actor admits that he's been delving into the "classic" comics to prepare for the movie, he's also adamant that Batman isn't a superhero...because he doesn't have powers.

Pattinson would later take that even further by proclaiming that the character shouldn't be considered a hero because "his morality is a little bit off." Unless he's been studying Ben Affleck's killer Batman, that's simply not a statement we're able to get on board with.

While the actor was correct in saying that "there is a simplicity to [Batman's] worldview," he has a moral compass and is a good man who simply wants to eradicate crime (all while sticking to a code that separates Bruce Wayne from the criminals he pursues). If this is what Pattinson truly believes, it's hard not to worry about what he plans to bring to the role.


8. Honestly, The Batsuit Kind Of Sucks

Batman robert pattinson logo
Warner Bros.

We've now seen both costume test footage and set photos of The Batman's Batsuit, and that's honestly enough to declare it a disappointment. While there are a number of elements which have been lifted from the comic books that it's easy enough to appreciate, the overall package is one that doesn't really work for the most part.

It's a busy, somewhat cumbersome suit that looks like a "prototype" costume rather than the finished version. Previous reports have claimed that this Batsuit will be created by Bruce Wayne and Alfred Pennyworth rather than one expertly made by Lucius Fox and Wayne Enterprises, but there's nothing overly special about it.

An underwhelming costume (which is once again a boring shade of grey) alone isn't going to ruin an entire movie, but it's a massively important part of any adventure starring a character as iconic as Batman. If this is what the Batsuit looks like, it's obviously hard to get excited about the appearance of villains like The Penguin and The Riddler.


7. It Won't Tie Into What We've Seen Before

Ben Affleck Batman
Warner Bros.

Initially, it was rumoured that The Batman would be set in the 1990s and serve as a loose prequel - of sorts - to Ben Affleck's time as the iconic DC Comics superhero. That opened the door to us seeing everything from Robin's murder at the hands of The Joker to what led to Batman becoming someone who was willing to kill Superman in Dawn of Justice.

Since then, it's become clear that this is a total reboot with a new Batman set in a world that has little to nothing to do with the one Affleck's version of Bruce Wayne called home.

That's massively disappointing, and yet another sign the DC Extended Universe is becoming more standalone in nature moving forward. While it's understandable that Warner Bros. wishes to take things down that route after their failed attempts to create their own version of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, is anyone desperate for yet another reboot?

Like it or not, that's what we're getting, but Warner Bros. has missed a trick to further build on the foundations of the DCEU and explore Batman's fall and eventual rise in the present.


6. It Looks Like Another Batman Movie Grounded In Reality

Penguin DC Comics
DC Comics

Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight Trilogy was superb, but it was also grounded firmly in reality. That led to many beloved elements from the comic books being abandoned, and that's something a lot of fans struggled with. Bane, for example, was just a big guy with a breathing mask rather than someone who enhances their strength with "Venom."

Zack Snyder's love of the source material admittedly proved to be a detriment at times, but his Batman was one who stepped directly out of the pages of The Dark Knight Returns.

Reeves, on the other hand, seems to be following Nolan's movie with a grounded approach that essentially explores what it would be like for Batman to exist in our world. That explains why Colin Farrell's Penguin (spotted in set photos) looks like just a regular man, and we've obviously already addressed how normal the Batsuit is in terms of appearance.

The Batman sounded like a true comic book adventure. Reeves' plan for what looks like a gritty crime story has some potential, but based on how Marvel embraces the comic books and finds such huge success, that might have been the better route to take this one down.


5. The Same Old Faces

Catwoman 0
DC Comics

Batman has a massive rogues gallery, but there's something awfully familiar about this movie. It seems Reeves must be a fan of those early big screen adventures starring the Dark Knight because he's using Batman Returns' characters The Penguin and Catwoman, while also borrowing The Riddler from Batman Forever.

A modern interpretation on that trio is no bad thing, but it also feels like we're retreading old ground. Could Batman not face Clayface, Hush, or Hugo Strange? What about bad guys who are arguably a lot more original like Poison Ivy and Two-Face? We've seen them before, yes, but there's an awful lot more that can be done with them on screen.

Fans do expect mainstays like Commissioner Gordon and Alfred Pennyworth in a Batman movie, but could we not have mixed things up a little by bringing the likes of Dick Grayson (Nightwing) or Barbara Gordon (Batgirl) into the mix? That could follow down the line, but getting excited about seeing Batman battle the same old faces isn't easy.


4. The Batman Sounded Like The Better Movie

Deathstroke Justice League
Warner Bros.

Ben Affleck wrote The Batman's screenplay alongside comic book writer Geoff Johns, and while specific details have never really been revealed, we do know that the premise would have been Lex Luthor sending the assassin Deathstroke to Gotham City to kill Batman.

That would have been revenge for sending him to Arkham Asylum, of course, and rumours swirled that the movie was going to also see the Caped Crusader coming face to face with some of his greatest foes after being trapped inside that iconic comic book location.

We may know very little about Reeves' version of The Batman beyond it being a noir-driven detective story, but Affleck's version just sounds like the better of the two. As a result, there's no way fans won't be thinking about what might have been, and that alone could lead to the movie being a somewhat disappointing experience for those who were anxious to see an action-packed slugfest with the Dark Knight going to war with Deathstroke!


3. This Movie Leaves The DCEU Without A Batman

Justice League Final Battle
Warner Bros.

The plan is reportedly for The Batman to launch a new trilogy, and that's an exciting prospect. However, with it standing apart from the rest of the DC Extended Universe, it's something that also means the part of this world that's still shared by characters like Wonder Woman, Aquaman, Shazam, and the Flash, won't have a Batman.

With any luck, there will be some sort of explanation (Flashpoint seems like the most logical place to explain why Batman is suddenly M.I.A. after fighting alongside the Justice League), but it feels like we're trapped back in the days when superhero movie crossovers were a fantasy. Will Robert Pattinson's Dark Knight reunite the Justice League? Don't count on it.

That's a great shame because Batman's interactions with his fellow heroes have always been a lot of fun. Based on past interviews, Reeves doesn't sound overly interested in connecting to other stories, and while a story like Flashpoint could bring Pattinson into the wider DCEU, that honestly feels more like fan-fiction than a real possibility.


2. Is It Actually Bringing Anything New To The Table?

Batman The Animated Series Comic
DC Comics

There are some reasons to be excited for The Batman, but as we've now pointed out quite a few times, the movie feels familiar and not overly different to what we've seen before from this iconic hero on the big screen. You might think that it's hard to do anything new with Bruce Wayne at this point, but if you're familiar with the comics, you'll know otherwise.

It's definitely a good start that Reeves wants to delve into what makes Batman the "World's Greatest Detective," but as enjoyable as that and the Dark Knight matching wits with The Riddler might be, it isn't something that's going to shake up this franchise in a major way.

Imagine a Batman movie with Dick Grayson donning the Cape and Cowl after the death of his father figure? How about an elderly Bruce Wayne attempting to train a new generation in an adaptation of Batman Beyond? This is a character who needs to be reimagined, and making him a rookie who is honing his detective skills is fine, but...well, it's not amazing!


1. Warner Bros. Has A Spotty Track Record

Birds Of Prey Margot Robbie
Warner Bros.

This isn't about Marvel vs. DC, but whereas Marvel Studios has managed to successfully create a shared comic book world, Warner Bros. has struggled from the star. Much of that boils down to poor decision-making, and while things are starting to look up for the DCEU, the recent commercial failure of Birds of Prey proves that they're still struggling.

That should never have been R-Rated, while some recently leaked Wonder Woman 1984 plot details haven't exactly got fans excited. On the surface, Matt Reeves being trusted to take charge of The Batman seems like a smart move, but is he the right man for the job?

It's obviously too soon to say, but seeing as Warner Bros. once announced an entire slate of Justice League spinoffs despite Zack Snyder having a very finite trilogy in mind, their vision for The Batman may not line up with what fans are hoping for. Aquaman was fun, Shazam! was mostly forgettable, and Birds of Prey was too quirky to connect with moviegoers, so while things have started improving for the DCEU, maybe don't get your hopes up yet!


In this post: 
The Batman
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Josh Wilding hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.