10 Simple Fixes That Would Have Made Star Wars: The Force Awakens Perfect

This is how the Force should work.

Star Wars The Force Awakens Captain Phasma
Lucasfilm

Wow. They actually, really did it. They didn’t just make Star Wars Episode VII, a movie people had been waiting for since 1983, but they made it good. Like, really good.

In many ways it achieved the impossible; it was respectful enough to the construction of the originals to not anger fans with major canon changes, but in its new cast still offered up something fresh and exciting. Even now, over half a year on from the media blitz that brought us BB-8 oranges, rude spoilers and TR-8R (more on that guy later) it still feels like a major event, just the start of something bigger.

But, and this is coming from a lifelong Star Wars fan who went giddy the moment that opening crawl came up, cried when Han Solo fell victim to the First Order’s lack of handrails and put it in his best films of the year, it wasn’t perfect. Oh, it was as good as we could have hoped by any stretch of the imagination, but it's not without room for improvement.

Taking a look at filmmaking flubs and strange unexplained moments (but, importantly, not messing with the broader scope of the saga), here's ten simple fixes that could have made The Force Awakens even more amazing.

10. Make Lor San Tekka Someone We Know Or Less Mysterious

Star Wars The Force Awakens Poe Dameron Lor San Tekka
Lucasfilm

The Force Awakens opens very strongly with a sequence that introduces four of our key characters and establishes the basic story motivations. But then you have all the confusion over who the fluff Lor San Tekka is.

Yes, I know there’s a detailed backstory in the extra material that explains it, but that’s not in the movie and makes the whole thing more confusing.

There’s two options here. The first is to make him someone we already know, which he’s almost treated like. That’d also make his abrupt death sting a bit more. Who is a bit hard to decide on - you can’t use a prequel character because fans would have lynched JJ, but perhaps he’s a Rebel, hence the royalty line: Dodonna, Madine, that guy whose official title is Star Wars Commander?

Those are all a bit tricky though, so why not just have him be less mysterious. Make his dialogue less allusion-heavy and explain succinctly how he fits into the bigger picture. All the winking talking about Leia and balance in the Force adds little to the story and is really only there to get you to pick up the books.


9. Explain Poe’s Survival (And Use It To Power The Resistance Plot)

Star Wars The Force Awakens Crashed TIE Finn
Lucasfilm

When Oscar Isaac was first offered the role of Poe Dameron the pilot so cool he makes Han Solo look like a bit of a dweeb was going to die in the Jakku crash. Isaac took the role anyway, because who wouldn’t be in Star Wars, only to be told “I figured it out. You’re in the whole movie now.”

By “figured it out”, though, Abrams meant “I’m just going to bring you back later on, with a single line of explanation”. It’s not impossible that Poe jumped out and was saved by some random Resistance help, it’s just very lazy screenwriting and means that when he does come back, he feels like a less important main character. He doesn’t even speak to Rey.

A smarter trick would be to show him being rescued and use that as an in to a Resistance sub-plot, something that would in turn introduce us to Leia earlier and make us care about the Galactic war ahead of time. Hopefully Rian Johnson doesn't give Poe the same short shrift in Episode VIII.


8. Use Starkiller Base To Better Set Up Hux And Kylo

Star Wars The Force Awakens Starkiller Base
Lucasfilm

There’s nothing wrong with having a new Death Star in The Force Awakens. It’s like poetry, it rhymes and all that. And Starkiller base - an actual planet that harvests the power of a star - is a great expansion of that idea. It’s also really cool to see the political capital be destroyed (although why they didn’t make it Coruscant is beyond me).

The problem is that it comes too late in the film to be a sustained threat. The Death Stars are the driving force of their respective films, but here there’s something almost lackadaisical about Starkiller - Han even dismisses it as a nothing threat. It in an way feels like it was mainly there out of obligation to formula.

If you’re going to have it in, double-down on it. Make that what Hux is going for, but Kylo is obsessed with Skywalker, furthering their bickering and competition. That'd develop the villains a little bit and set up their ultimate goal - wipe of the Resistance - earlier.


7. Fix The Pacing At The End Of The Second Act

Star Wars The Force Awakens Rey Daisy Ridley
Lucasfilm

OK, this is my biggest problem with the film and where, for about ten minutes it begins to really mess up.

Here’s the situation: at Maz’s castle, Finn suddenly decides he wants to run away. Rey calls him a coward, then gets a vision and decides to run away herself. Then all of a sudden the First Order has a Death Star and Finn’s back, then Kylo Ren turns up and then they’re at the Resistance base and then they’re being targeted by Starkiller Base and... there's just no coherence. Things get back to normal for the final act, but there’s some very obvious rushed editing in how Finn acts and how Maz just disappears.

Fixing this without bloating the film would be hard, but shifting some of the events earlier/later - which having Poe back and Starkiller established sooner would make easier - would make things a bit more cohesive. A few calm, non-plot essential character beats interspersed within there would be nice too, keeping the pace from being so breakneck and all too convenient.


6. Explain Where The Lightsaber Came From

Star Wars The Force Awakens Maz Kanata Lightsaber
Lucasfilm
“A good question for another time”

Urgh, really? I said it at the time and I’ll say it again, that’s not good enough. They clearly wanted to have the Skywalker’s saber appear in this trilogy, but couldn’t be bothered to explain how it wound up not on Bespin. An alt opening was even going to have Luke’s hand flying through space and have it replace the map as the film's MacGuffin, which makes so little sense even George Lucas would think twice.

What makes all the confusion so irritating is that this wouldn’t even be that hard to explain. Put in a little bit in Rey’s vision where we see it get stuck at the bottom of the chute and picked up by an ugnaught or when Maz says fobs Han off just have her explain it; that case doesn't need to be a mystery box.

This may get addressed in Episode VIII, but, unlike the rest of the vision or an explanation to what Luke was up to, it’s something that should be definitely the movie.


5. Give Maz Force Powers

Star Wars The Force Awakens Maz Kanata
caps.pictures

Here’s one thing that was almost meant to be in the movie, but was cut for time and wound up weakening an entire character.

Now, there was a lot changed with Maz Kanata. The original trailers had her in the Resistance base and she talking very different to how she was in the finished film, which suggested she was going to be a more mystical, straight up Yoda character, although that’s nothing on this biggie: she was going to have the Force.

Now that would have been a great twist in the middle of the film, taking the Force outside of the Jedi/Sith confines and giving a taste of the post-Jedi galaxy's multicultural make-up. Maybe it was deemed too Yoda-y and things were changed, but there’s no avoiding her character feels a little half-baked because it's not there.

Although if this was fixed, you definitely don't want it done in the same method as the script suggested, with a scene of Han joking with Stormtroopers about Snoke's name ("Smoke? What makes him Surpreme?") intended to end with the sudden reveal a real groaner.


4. Make Phasma TR-8R

Star Wars The Force Awakens Finn Traitor
Lucasfilm

Captain Phasma was all over the marketing for The Force Awakens. Heck, she was in more toys than Rey (although that’s not saying as much as it perhaps should). Such an intriguing character, everyone was pretty amped to see her in action.

That she’s played by Gwendoline Christie, who has done precisely nothing in any of her non-Brienne roles should have been a real clue, but Phasma’s kinda useless. She kills the villagers on Kylo Ren’s command, chastises Finn, stands around as Hux commits mass genocide and then gives up the entire First Order with minimal pressure. Maybe it’s a meta joke. Boba Fett was another character who stood around looking awesome only to be offed in an equally humiliating way, but if so it failed completely.

She didn’t need to have a massive role, just a bit more substance. How to do that? Make her TR-8R - the actual break-out character from the film. He was super cool and having her fight Finn in the middle act would give her an actual arc that's paid of by her own later betrayal.


3. Have R2 Steal The Map

Star Wars The Force Awakens Map
Lucasfilm

R2-D2 was really wasted in The Force Awakens, spending most of the film in an completely unexplained comatose state. Maybe it's because they couldn't think of a way for the trash can to play a major part in the plot otherwise. Although if that's true then Abrams and Kasdan really weren't trying.

What they should have done is have him awake throughout the film at the Resistance, eventually tagging along with Han and Finn to Starkiller Base, wherein he steals the rest of the map that the First Order recovered from the Empire’s remains. Simple, but also incredibly effective; it wouldn't just make Artoo important, but it'd explain what the map is (it's definitely a map to the first Jedi Temple0 and how both sides have all but the final piece, a major unexplained point from the movie.

Crucially, it reintroduces him late enough to not distract from BB-8, yet still allows to opportunity for a bit of droid bickering. Easy.


2. “The Force” Line

Star Wars The Force Awakens Rey Lightsaber
Lucasfilm

I have very little bad to say about the movie’s finale - the convergence of characters in Starkiller fits, Han’s death is well handled, the space fight thrilling and the lightsaber duel at the end is perfect, a scrappy mesh of the kineticism of the prequels and the emotional weight of the originals. The one thing that does irk me about all this is the manner with which Rey gets the upper-hand - using the Force only after Kylo Ren reminds her.

I think Rey’s character works fine within how she’s set up - no Mary Sue whining here - and for her to beat a mopey manchild who views Hayden Christensen the peak of menace isn’t as much a stretch as some would have you believe, but this moment doesn’t lock with the character and if anything makes her too dumb.

To fix it, simply have her gain the upper hand without pointing it out; audiences will be able to get it's the Force. Or (and this is a massive canon switch that could go against where the series is going), how about her hearing Luke in her head? Chills!


1. Don’t Make Rey’s Parentage A Big Deal

Star Wars The Force Awakens Rey
Lucasfilm

The big question everyone had after The Force Awakens, fuelling an obscene amount of thought pieces was "Who are Rey’s parents?" Luke and some random woman? Han and Leia? Jyn Erso? Obi-Wan’s granddaughter (OK, that one’s dumb).

It’s got everyone guessing, but Rian Johnson’s in a bit of a Catch-22 situation here - make Rey related to an original cast member and, well, we’ve already guessed it, but make her unrelated and the mystery feels flat. There’s no way the resolution won’t disappoint.

It may not even work as a scene, either. If they are saving it for an “I am your father” style reveal at the of Episode VIII, the hype is only going to hurt it - the Vader twist is all the more shocking because it comes completely out of nowhere. There’s no teasing or real mystery around Anakin, it just happens.

So don’t make it a thing. Have it referenced by all means, but you don’t need to have her waiting for her family or having such alluding visions. Less is more.

What would you change about Star Wars: The Force Awakens? Share any more simple fixes down in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.