10 Star Wars Theories That Make Appalling Sense
Alternative theories that suggest a secret, and often much darker, history of the Star Wars galaxy.
For all its fans love it, Star Wars doesn't always make the most sense. It’s the tales of starfaring derring-do and the grimy, real and colourful universe that keep them coming back, not the finely-tuned plotlines.
For the most part they’re happy to be carried away by the flow of sassy droids, laser swords, and exploding spaceships. Star Wars isn't ‘hard’ science fiction where spacecraft and blaster pistols need realistic physics, and its fantasy-in-space voice means fans can always say ‘it was the Force’ whenever something doesn't make sense.
Perhaps if someone look a little too close, though, things make little enough sense that they are forced out of the cosy world of salty smugglers and gutsy princesses, and remember Star Wars is a work of often flawed fiction.
Of course, geeks being the creative weirdos they are, there are plenty of theories that help paper over the logical gaps in the Star Wars series. Some of them make a frightening level of sense given how much explain perplexing plot holes and inconsistencies. And some of them force us to rethink everything audiences thought they knew about Star Wars.
10. The Force Awakened To Try Again
The similarity of The Force Awakens to A New Hope are numerous and at times glaring, from the desert planet origins of the hero to the masked Dark Jedi villain, planet-nuking plot device and cute trundling droid. This theory explains the similarities not just as a deliberate attempt by the filmmakers to capture the appeal of the original movie, but as the Force restarting its plan to set the galaxy to rights.
The original trilogy saw Luke, ordained by the Force, rising to become a Jedi and destroy the evil galactic Empire. But for some reason, he failed. Either he didn't do the job properly, or the Force had something entirely different in mind for him.
So The Force Awakens sees the Force trying again with the same ingredients - isolated young hero, dashing pilot ally, elderly faded Jedi mentor and the same cocktail of Light Side, Dark Side, conflict and destiny. The Force isn't just an invisible power source for space wizards - it is an intelligence moulding the events of the galaxy towards it own desired conclusion.
In this theory the Force is cyclical, and will go through the same loop as many times as it needs to get it right. Who know how many times it has created the saga before, or even if this will be the last one?
9. Qui-Gon Jinn Left A Killswitch In Anakin
During the adventures of Qui-Gon Jinn on Tatooine, he meets the unassuming blonde tot who will grow up to be Anakin Skywalker. Young Anakin is a slave, which as he explains to Qui-Gon over tea involves having an explosive device implanted that his owner can detonate to dissuade escape attempts. When Qui-Gon acquires the child from his owner Watto, the implant is presumably deactivated, but there is never mention made of it being removed.
This theory holds that Qui-Gon realised how powerful Anakin could be, but also how dangerous. He deliberately left the explosive implant in Anakin so if the ‘Chosen One’ ever fell to the Dark Side, Qui-Gon could end the threat my reactivating the implant and detonating the pre-Darth Jedi.
So why was it never done? Qui-Gon didn't trust his padawan Obi-Wan Kenobi with this knowledge, because Kenobi was still too inexperienced a Jedi to have such responsibility. Qui-Gon would have passed on the knowledge to the Jedi Council once he reached Coruscant with Anakin.
But he never arrived, having been impaled by Darth Maul during their duel on Naboo. So the killswitch stayed unused and undiscovered, even as Anakin spearheaded the destruction of the Jedi Order.
8. Yoda Saw Order 66 Coming
Master Yoda, it seems, dropped the ball when it came to watching the Jedi Order’s back in Attack Of The Clones. In spite of his ability to detect subtle emotions and determine major galactic events, he entirely fails to notice the whole Grand Army of the Republic has been given orders to kill him and the rest of the Order.
One explanation is that Yoda was fully aware of Order 66, and chose to let it happen. This particular conspiracy theory has its roots in the idea the Jedi Order and the Galactic Republic were decaying, corrupt and ineffectual institutions, as demonstrated by Palpatine’s ability to manipulate it towards its own destruction.
Yoda, seeing this and knowing it had to change, decided to let Palpatine and Vader destroy the Jedi Order and bring down the Republic. Yoda had already foreseen the Empire would be brought down in turn, and that both the Republic and Jedi could be remade from scratch into what Yoda thought they should be.
In the theory's defence, note how Yoda is able to ensure his own safety when Order 66 goes down, so he can help direct the next regeneration in taking down Palpatine and re-founding the Jedi. Yoda might die of old age during the original trilogy, but only after he has set the stage for the destiny he envisages - and safe in the knowledge he can continue to tweak the course of history in Force Ghost form.
7. Anakin Skywalker Was Created By Palpatine
Anakin Skywalker's supposedly immaculate conception is the starting point for this theory, which states that it was something far more malign than the will of the Force that planted the embryonic Anakin in Shmi Skywalker's womb. Shmi interprets her unexplained pregnancy as a blessing, since it would be traumatising to imagine it was caused by something terrible. But tragically for her and everyone else, it was.
The culprit is Palpatine instead, in full Sith evil puppet master ode as Darth Sidious. Palpatine needed an apprentice, presumably deciding Count Dooku and Darth Maul weren't up to the task of destroying the Republic and avenging themselves on the Jedi.
So using the technique of creating life he hints at in Revenge of the Sith, he created a spawn of the dark side to be birthed by Shmi. Of all the bonkers Star Wars theories this might be the most plausible one, as it explains one of The Phantom Menace's biggest misfires (the whole virgin birth thing) and and elevates Palpatine's Machiavellian malevolence to even greater heights.
6. Princess Leia Led The Empire To Yavin IV
Princess Leia’s mission at the very start of the original trilogy is to deliver the Death Star plans, with its details on the fatal thermal exhaust port flaw, to the Rebel Alliance. The battle station's blueprints made it possible for the Rebel Alliance to destroy the Death Star, and this theory suggests that Leia went further than anyone realised to make that happen.
For the Rebel Alliance to destroy the Death Star, it needed more than just the plans. It needed to get the Death Star to a time and place where the Rebel fleet could attack it. Leia knew the only such place was Yavin IV, the location of the hidden Rebel base.
Not only would the Rebels have ships available to attack the thermal exhaust vent, but the Rebel command would be forced to do so because their entire command structure was threatened by the superweapon. According to this theory, Leia engineered the Empire’s discovery of Yavin IV, using the rebel base and all its leaders as bait for the Death Star.
Leia did not tell Vader the base’s location, knowing he would be suspicious if she gave up the information too easily. Instead, she made sure the Empire has attached a tracker to the Millennium Falcon (perhaps even placing it herself). When she asked Han if the Falcon could be tracked it was not to stop the Empire from doing so, but to make sure Han doesn’t think it’s possible.
Then she led the Empire straight to Yavin IV, because as a daughter of Alderaan she would risk anything to see the Death Star destroyed - even the survival of the Rebellion itself.
5. Luke Never Left Dagobah
During Luke's training in The Empire Strikes Back, Yoda sends Luke into a cave infused with the power of the Dark Side to face his sternest test. There Luke is confronted with a vision of Darth Vader and, inflamed by anger, attacks it with his lightsaber. The vision is revealed to have Luke's own face and upon emerging, Luke is told by Yoda that he has failed. He gave into his hatred, and the Dark Side is too strong within him.
This theory suggests Luke never left the cave. Either he died there, or is comatose in the cave having been stripped of his power by the Force before he turned completely to the Dark Side. The rest of the series after Luke's failure in the cave is what Luke sees in his mind after his failure and possibly death.
This theory helps explain how Luke becomes a Jedi even after Yoda is explicit about Luke's inability to master the Force. Luke lives out a power fantasy that first sees him create a dark surrogate father figure in Darth Vader, and then kill that figure to vanquish Luke's anguish at never knowing his true father.
Luke's fantasy world also helps explain his absence from the galaxy at the start of The Force Awakens - he is trying to escape the galaxy he has made for himself and return to reality. He is trying to wake up.
4. Yoda Is A Sith
A deeper cut on Yoda is that the diminutive Jedi guru was a Sith all along. Yoda is the thread that ties the whole Star Wars saga together. He's present from the beginning of the prequels to his shuffling off the mortal coil in Return of the Jedi. Only The Force Awakens and Rogue One are lacking his pointy-eared presence, and his influence is felt throughout the whole series.
This theory posits that as a Sith, Yoda has been manipulating events to first destroy the Republic and Jedi Order by allowing Palpatine to seize power as the Emperor (note how Yoda made sure he survived the Jedi purge after Order 66), and then trained Luke Skywalker to destroy Palpatine and his apprentice, Vader.
That puts Yoda as the halfway point of his plan to rebuild the whole Republic and the Jedi from scratch. Now he pursues his plan as a Force Ghost (and possibly in holographic form as Supreme Leader Snoke) to both bring the new Republic to its knees, and destroy everything Luke Skywalker loves.
Yoda's ultimate end game is for a desperate, broken Luke to fall to the Dark Side and become the Republic's new dictator, utterly in Yoda's thrall as Palpatine never was.
3. Obi-Wan Killed Owen And Beru
At the beginning of Star Wars, Obi-Wan knows that Luke Skywalker is the son of the galaxy’s most powerful Jedi and has the potential to bring down Darth Vader and the Galactic Empire. But Luke has spent his whole life on a moisture farm on the backwater planet of Tatooine. There is no way the teenage Luke would join the mad old hermit Ben Kenobi on a jaunt into space, especially with Uncle Owen and Aunt Beru denying him permission to even speak to Kenobi.
According to this theory, Owen and Beru are the biggest obstacles to getting Luke to leave Tatooine and take his place as the forger of the galaxy’s destiny. After all, Owen has been specifically tasked with keeping Luke safe from Darth Vader, which means keeping him from leaving the planet. When the arrival of Leia’s droids provide a reason to take Luke on his adventure, Obi-Wan first needs to remove those obstacles.
Kenobi uses a stormtrooper blaster rifle (which must be common on the Mos Eisley black market), assassinates Beru and Owen, and burns the corpses. As a soldier in the Clone Wars he’s easily a good enough marksman to produce the accurate shot grouping he later uses as evidence that stormtroopers committed the murders.
Now Luke has nothing to keep him on Tatooine, he eagerly joins Obi-Wan on his journey to Alderaan. Owen and Beru were just collateral damage, a worthwhile sacrifice for the greater good of the galaxy. And so it is that the New Republic is born as the old one fell, in deceit and bloodshed.
2. Luke Skywalker Is Supreme Leader Snoke
The character of Supreme Leader Snoke, peculiarly deformed commander of the ex-Imperial First Order, is a character seemingly created specifically to spark debate over who he actually is. Theories abound over who Snoke might be: The Emperor's clone son, the Emperor's clone brother, Luke's clone brother, Mace Windu, Zombie Vader, Anakin's real father, Jar Jar Binks. Luke Skywalker makes as much sense as any of these, and according to this theory, he makes a lot more.
Luke's motivation as Snoke is to control the remnants of the Galactic Empire. Knowing he cannot destroy First Order, he instead commands them, and pits them against his old friends in the Resistance to keep them from interfering in the rest of the galaxy. His reasons for Starkiller Base's attack on the Republic is to encourage the Republic to finish off the First Order since the Resistance can't manage it.
Luke also has the First Order try to prevent the Resistance from recovering BB-8 and its information on his location to keep the Resistance from finding him, and potentially discovering the Last Jedi is also the Resistance's worst enemy. Finally Luke is seeking an apprentice, and is positioning both Kylo Ren and Rey for training.
1. The First Order Are The New Republic's Black Ops Division
The Force Awakens leaves the origins of the First Order frustratingly elusive. Presumably they are the remnants of the Galactic Empire, fighting for a vaguely-stated vengeance against the New Republic. Nowhere are their real workings or motivations spelled out, leaving room for plenty of speculation about who they actually are.
This theory holds that the First Order are a part of the New Republic, controlled in secret by those who rose to fill the power vacuum after the fall of the Galactic Empire. The First Order military are former Imperial officers, soldiers and pilots secretly offered immunity from retribution for the Empire's crimes and put to work doing the Republic's dirty work. The 'Imperial Remnant' idea is just a cover so they can commit ruthless acts without tarnishing the reputation of the New Republic.
As the Republic's secret army, the First Order's main mission is to wipe out the parts of the Galactic Empire that did not accept the Republic's offer. Another use for them is to fight the Resistance, which is a volatile embarrassment to the New Republic and must be kept busy fighting Hux and his men to keep them from interfering in the Republic's business.
And Starkiller Base's attack on the Republic? A classic false flag operation, intended to force public opinion to accept a more militarised, tightly-controlled regime.