10 Stephen King Adaptations The Author HATES

Safe to say the Master of Horror wasn't a fan of The Shining...

The Shining
Warner Bros.

He's the master of horror and his books have inspired countless screen hits. From his 70s breakthrough with Carrie to the pair of recent IT movies breaking box office records, Stephen King has been a consistent source of page-to-screen success.

Himself a big movie fan, King has been vociferous in his praise for the filmmakers who have adapted his work and really nailed what he was going for. The likes of Rob Reiner (Stand By Me, Misery) and Frank Darabont (The Shawshank Redemption, The Green Mile, The Mist) are very much in the writer's good books.

But the author reserves a poison pen for those film directors who don't quite measure up to his exacting standards.

Sometimes these are movies that are widely agreed to be horrific in all the wrong ways, sometimes they are critical darlings that King just thinks missed his point. Either way, though, the man whose job it is to find creative ways to make people suffer isn't shy about pointing out when someone has failed to get his work right.

These are just the ten adaptations of his books of which Stephen King is the most vocal in his hatred.

10. The Running Man

Running Man
TriStar Pictures

In the late 70s and early 80s King enjoyed a prolific second career as pulp action writer Richard Bachman. Under the Bachman pseudonym, King knocked out this futuristic gameshow chase story in less than a week.

By the time of the 1987 movie adaptation, King had been "outed" as Bachman. But he still insisted that his own name be kept off the film and the fictional Bachman receive all of the credit.

Perhaps King didn't want to be associated with the finished product because, while the movie remains a dystopian cult favourite, it also has very little in common with its source material.

In The Importance Of Being Bachman, King's introduction to the collected edition of his "Bachman Books", the writer complained that his scrawny, sickly protagonist Ben Richards was "as far away from the Arnold Schwarzenegger character in the movie as you can get."

For his part, Arnie wasn't exactly thrilled with the completed movie either. The Austrian Oak had signed on for director Andrew Davis's vision of the film and was disappointed with the work of Paul Michael Glaser who stepped in after the Under Siege helmer was fired.

Glaser "shot the movie like it was a television show, losing all the deeper themes", Schwarzenegger wrote in his autobiography, Total Recall, proving himself King's surprising ally in not liking a film that most audiences think has aged pretty well.


9. Children Of The Corn

Children Of The Corn Runaway
Lionsgate

In terms of sheer output, Children Of The Corn is the most successful Stephen King brand of them all: a single 1970s short story spun into ten movies over thirty-five years.

The original 1984 film was not particularly popular with critics at the time, but over time has become increasingly well-liked for its narrow focus and taut, tense atmosphere.

It especially started to look pretty great once the franchise started churning out sequels with increasingly little connection either to King's original concept or anything resembling actual shocks and scares.

King himself seems to share the typical consensus on the long-running series his writing has inspired, telling Deadline: "I could do without all of the Children Of The Corn sequels", but adding that "I actually like the original pretty well. I thought they did a pretty good job on that."

Unfortunately for his creator, though, He Who Walks Behind The Rows remains virtually unkillable. This is, after all, a franchise that made five direct sequels to a movie titled "The Final Sacrifice".

A remake from Equilibrium director Kurt Wimmer continued to shoot in Australia this spring, undeterred by the country's Coronavirus lockdown rules. So expect to see even more Children Of The Corn soon, whether King can do without them or not.


8. Dreamcatcher

Dreamcatcher film
Warner Bros.

Dreamcatcher came to our screens with a pedigree that seemed to promise an instant classic.

Producers Castle Rock Entertainment (named for the fictional Maine town that is a favourite King setting) had shepherded a number of successful King adaptations, most notably The Shawshank Redemption, and the film was directed by Star Wars and Indiana Jones veteran Lawrence Kasdan who had co-written the screenplay with multiple Oscar winner William Goldman (himself responsible for a past King hit with the script for Misery). But, then, it is also the one with the "sh*t-weasels".

"When you put together a script, a director, and all the other variables, you never really know what's going to come out," King told Time Magazine back in 2007, "And so you start with the idea that it's like a baseball game — you put the best team you can on the field, and you know that, more times than not, you're gonna win... That doesn't mean you're not going to have the occasional thing that's just a train wreck like Dreamcatcher."

Perhaps King is right. Maybe Dreamcatcher is the exception that proves the rule that bringing a bunch of talented people together likely means a positive result. But, then, maybe he's also right that in this particular case the result was a steaming pile of sh*t-weasels.


7. The Lawnmower Man

Lawnmower man
New Line Cinema

King has acknowledged that there have been masterful adaptations of his work and disastrous adaptations. There is one "Stephen King" film, however, that the author simply refuses to accept as an adaptation at all.

Thirty years ago studio New Line went into production on an early-CGI-fuelled virtual reality-themed sci-fi horror from an original script titled Cyber God. At the same time New Line also owned the rights to The Lawnmower Man, King's 1970s story combining pagan folklore and yard work.

Rather than bother trying to turn that oddity into a movie of its own, New Line simply slapped the Lawnmower Man name (and, more importantly, the highly profitable name of "Stephen King") onto Cyber God instead.

King responded with a lawsuit in which he declared, quite accurately, that the film "bore no meaningful resemblance" to his work.

The legal case allowed King to force New Line to change the movie's title from Stephen King's The Lawnmower Man to simply The Lawnmower Man and to remove "based on a story by Stephen King" from the credits and marketing material.

By the time that King's lawsuit had succeeded, though, New Line had already established the link between King and the film in the minds of movie-going audiences.

If people remember anything about The Lawnmower Man these days, it's that it is another bad Stephen King movie. Which undoubtedly continues to annoy the author to this day.


6. Pet Sematary

Gage Pet Sematary
Paramount Pictures

King was actually pretty heavily involved with Mary Lambert's disturbing 1989 adaptation of his toddler death-and-resurrection tale, handling all the screenwriting duties and appearing on screen in a cameo as a preacher.

The writer didn't get unusually involved in this film adaptation above most others because the novel had a special place in his heart, though. No, quite the opposite.

For King, Pet Sematary may be the point at which he crossed the line, a book too dark, too full of grief to be appealing, and one that he only ever published in the first place to get out of his contract with publisher Doubleday.

King told Entertainment Weekly on the release of the movie's 2019 remake, that his attitude to the original Pet Sematary novel remained "this is awful, this is really f**king terrible". In the interview he explained that he wrote the film's screenplay not because he liked the book but because "maybe I can take this and make it a little bit better".

Although he speaks well of Lambert's ideas and efforts with the film, then, this was never going to be one of his favourites.

"Nobody ever went broke underestimating the taste of the American people," is the old adage that King used to explain how something he created that he hates nevertheless remains one of his more popular works.


5. Graveyard Shift

Graveyard Shift
Paramount Pictures

King's 1970 short story about a rat-infested textile mill is largely notable as one of his first published works rather than one that has particularly stood the test of time. Nevertheless, two decades later the King name was enough of a popular brand for Paramount to throw together a big screen version directed by Pet Sematary producer Ralph Singleton.

The Graveyard Shift movie is the kind of derivative, low effort affair that can't even be bothered with the bare bones anti-big business subtext of King's story.

"Just kind of a quick exploitation picture," was King's apt description of the movie in an interview with Deadline.

He's not wrong, but the only question is why single out Graveyard Shift as a rushed cash-in and not, say, The Night Flier or Dolan's Cadillac? It's not like this one movie is unique in the canon of King adaptations for being a quick exploitation picture.

Admittedly, King did nod toward Graveyard Shift not being the only adaptation of his work made with no love and little effort when he said of it "I guess there are a number of pictures that I feel like, a little bit like, yuck."


4. The Dark Tower

Dark Tower Matthew McConaughey
Warner Bros.

For years it was the project on the top of any King fan's adaptation wish list: an epic fantasy western spread across eight novels and with a web of connections to many of the writer's most beloved other works. But nevertheless The Dark Tower movie came and went in 2017 with barely a flicker of audience or critical interest.

At the time, King had nothing but praise for the efforts of director Nikolaj Arcel and writer Akiva Goldsman, suggesting that its only flaw was that perhaps the series was just too complex to condense into a movie.

By the time of an interview with Entertainment Weekly at the end of that year, however, he had some less positive things to say about the whole experience.

King complained about the "studio edict" from Warner Bros. that The Dark Tower be a PG-13 blockbuster tentpole. "When they did that I think that they lost a lot of the toughness of it ," he said, "and it became something where people went to it and said: Well yeah, but it’s really not anything that we haven’t seen before."

King went on to highlight how he had advised the team behind the movie against starting in the middle of the story, but that trying to prevent this potentially confusing storytelling choice was "a little bit like hitting your fist against hard rubber, you know? It doesn’t really hurt, but you don’t get anywhere. It just sort of bounces back."

The Dark Tower, however, shows no sign of bouncing back itself, as Amazon recently canned the proposed TV adaptation.


3. Firestarter

Stephen King Firestarter
Universal

King's novel of pre-teen pyrokinesis was turned into a vehicle for a post-ET Drew Barrymore in 1984. But, after original director John Carpenter was dropped after his version of The Thing flopped, the finished version of Firestarter from Commando's Mark L Lester failed to come alight.

Narratively, the Firestarter movie hews pretty close to King's novel, but tonally it feels bland and lifeless. And that was what most infuriated the author.

"There must have been literally no direction," King complained to American Film magazine way back in 1986, calling the adaptation "one of the worst of the bunch".

As far as he was concerned, the movie's special effects "make no sense whatsoever", producer Dino De Laurentiis ignored all of his input, and lead actor David Keith delivered a particularly unengaging performance. ("My wife said he has stupid eyes," he added, really driving the knife into poor Keith).

Proving that a bestselling author always has a knack for a good turn of phrase and an apt analogy, King would conclude that Firestarter's greatest flaw was that it was "flavourless, like cafeteria mashed potatoes".


2. The Shining

Jack Nicholson The Shining
Warner Bros.

Widely seen today as the finest Stephen King adaptation of them all, if not perhaps the greatest of all horror films, The Shining is also notorious for quite how much the author loathes the movie. So much so, in fact, that he endorsed the drab 1990s miniseries version instead.

King, who once had a character in The Outsider remark that they wanted to watch Stanley Kubrick's Paths Of Glory because "it's better than The Shining", admires Kubrick's work and craft, just not what he did with this particular film.

He once told The Paris Review that the Kubrick film was "a Cadillac with no engine in it", beautiful to look at but lacking in substance.

King has complained that, rather than his story of a man struggling to keep a grip on his sanity, Jack Nicholson's take on Jack Torrance "has no arc at all ... all he does is get crazier". Meanwhile, he called Shelly Duvall's version of Wendy "one of the most misogynistic characters ever put on film. She's basically just there to scream and be stupid".

At least there's a sort of happy ending to this one, though. After trying to bridge the gap between King and Kubrick's vision for The Shining with his sequel Doctor Sleep, director Mike Flanagan told Entertainment Weekly that Doctor Sleep had managed to "warm" King's feelings toward the Kubrick film. It's just a shame that the new film didn't really connect with wider audiences in the same way.


1. Maximum Overdrive

Maximum Overdrive
De Laurentiis Entertainment Group

For all that it may now be seen as a classic, at the time The Shining earned Kubrick a Razzie nomination for Worst Director. Six years later there was a second Razzie nod for a director of a Stephen King adaptation and this time the director was, well, Stephen King.

He may be one of the most successful writers of all time, but in his one time behind the camera (adapting his own 1973 short story Trucks) King proved an utter disaster. Maximum Overdrive is clunky, ham-fisted and stiffly acted. He would himself describe his own work as "a moron movie".

In Hollywood's Stephen King, the writer-turned-director explained the absolute car crash of a movie by saying that he was "coked out of my mind all through production and didn't know what I was doing".

He noted that "I didn't get the job because I went to film school. I got the job because I'm Stephen King," which probably explains why the movie doesn't feel even remotely professionally competent.

Maximum Overdrive remains something of an old shame for a writer who has otherwise proved pretty successful at all he has turned his hand to. He has declined to return to the director's chair since.

Still, the film does at least prove that if you really need someone to royally screw up a Stephen King adaptation, you can do no better than calling the man himself!


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Loves ghost stories, mysteries and giant ape movies