10 Stupid Decisions Made By Saw Characters

Some questionable decisions spelled "Game Over" for these unfortunate characters.

Saw V Strahm
Lionsgate

James Wan's 2004 low budget thriller Saw wasn't only an unexpected hit, it spun off an unstoppable franchise and changed the horror landscape of the period. In a market that was dwindling commercially, slashers seemed tired and remakes were abound. Saw offered that element that had been missing, plenty of blood and gore, incredibly intelligent writing and genuinely shocking character moments.

As the film branched off into a franchise, it seemed each movie upped the stakes with more elaborate traps and twist after twist that left audiences breathless. It's fair to say that the Saw franchise features some of the most intelligent and genuinely surprising writing and character decisions of the genre in recent years.

Unfortunately, as a franchise goes on, screenwriters become pressed to find fresh takes on situations that have been played out countless times before. Inevitably, despite their best efforts, the Saw movies fell into this "trap" in their haste for more content.

So, I want to play a game - with eight films to choose from, let's see if we can find the 10 stupidest decisions made by characters in this seminal horror franchise. A warning of major spoilers ahead!

10. John Rescues Logan - Jigsaw

Jigsaw Bucket
Lionsgate

2017's Jigsaw is perhaps the most divisive entry in the Saw franchise. Why, I hear you ask? Well, to put it simply, Jigsaw acts as a large and very convenient retcon and presents John Kramer in a very different way, which feels out of character.

With the reveal that our new "Jigsaw" is mild-mannered medical examiner Logan Nelson, as an audience we are eager to discover his backstory and ties to the infamous killer.

But the explanation leaves a lot to be desired, as we learn Logan once mixed up John Kramer's X-rays which led to Kramer's cancer being missed and becoming terminal. Consequently, Logan found himself in a Jigsaw trap for his carelessness.

But in a truly baffling turn, the usually cold and merciless John Kramer has an attack of conscience and rescues Logan before he can succumb. Subsequently John takes Logan under his wing and mentors him to be his eventual successor.

If there's one thing John Kramer can do, it's hold a grudge. So to say that this decision is out of character is an understatement. Why would he suddenly forgive an "honest mistake" that ended his own life?

It all seems very convenient and somewhat clumsy, and one can't help but think it may have been for the best if Logan was left in the trap.


9. Hoffman Frames Jigsaw - Saw V

Saw IV
Lionsgate Films

Here's some useful advice, readers. Don't frame a legendary serial killer for your own crime!

2007's Saw IV ended with the fabulous revelation that Detective Mark Hoffman is in fact the mastermind behind his own trap, and will be taking John Kramer's place as Jigsaw.

Unfortunately, 2008's Saw V expands on this development just a little bit too much. The beginning of the film shows us a gruesome pendulum trap orchestrated by "Jigsaw" cutting a man in half. Later we learn that this victim was responsible for the death of Detective Hoffman's sister.

Further backstory reveals that Hoffman orchestrated the trap to avenge his sister's death, framing it as another Jigsaw murder. In hindsight, this may not have been the best decision for the police officer.

Sensing an ingenious way to outsmart the cops, John Kramer seeks out Hoffman, threatening to expose his crime unless he helps him in his murderous endeavors.

So, we learn that Hoffman was a man torn by grief who chose a rather unwise way to cover his tracks. Not the strongest decision, as he's now bound to commit more crimes against his will or face punishment. One can't help but think his life would've been much simpler had he chosen not to frame an infamous and active serial killer.

Hoffman's decision ultimately leads to insanity and his eventual presumed death, which all could've been avoided.


8. Not Working Together - Saw V

saw 5 blood death
Lionsgate

2008's Saw V became one of the most derided entries by both critics and audience members - the consensus being that the series was beginning to become repetitive and the trademark "twist" revelations were notably weaker.

Given that Saw V already had an uphill battle it didn't help the movie when after an initial viewing, most audiences branded the characters... rather stupid.

Saw V's big reveal is that all 5 "players" are connected to a fire years before. Some have lost loved ones, some are considered responsible. The twist lets us know that every game played was survivable with 5 participants - no one had to die as all the opposing characters had to do was work together.

This reason for their failure was found to be groan inducing by many. Critics pointed out that by this point Jigsaw's "games" are legendary. Victims had told of their survival via wits and remaining calm. So, why didn't this group of protagonists take just a moment to compose themselves and brainstorm once realizing their situation?

It seems like quite an obvious step, and had been demonstrated in previous movies, yet here, characters opt to scream, yell and curse until there's no time left. It definitely feels like a step backward for character development.


7. "No Exit" - Jigsaw

Jigsaw Ryan
Lionsgate

This questionable decision comes courtesy of Ryan, one of three surviving characters ready to take on Jigsaw's next test.

Something that has become evident throughout the Saw franchise is that Jigsaw is actually quite a helpful antagonist. Although wits are required to escape his games alive, the considerate maniac leaves a series of hints around the scene.

Unfortunately it is a frustrating and rather convenient trait that many characters in the series share when they choose to ignore the handy hints scattered here and there.

After becoming a little overwhelmed by the situation, poor Ryan chooses to disregard a door marked "NO EXIT," and decides to make a dive for freedom. Before you can say "duh" his foot crashes through the floor and is ensnared in razor sharp wire.

This sets off yet another "game," wherein Ryan must amputate his ankle in order to save his fellow captives from a rapidly filling grain silo. But one can't help roll their eyes at this perilous plot development as it was so easily avoidable.

If Ryan had only heeded his captor's warning, the deadly game would never have been triggered. Which leaves us wondering, what would've happened had this character actually been smart? Would he have lived to fight another day?


6. Perez & Billy - Saw IV

Jigsaw Doll
Lionsgate Films

The trait of Saw characters making ridiculous choices for the plot's sake takes centre stage once again in this head-scratchingly inept scene from 2007's Saw IV.

In a suitably creepy tableau, FBI agents Strahm and Perez enter a room laden with candles to find Billy the Puppet seated and cackling maniacally. Attached to the creepy doll is one of Jigsaw's trademark cassette tapes labelled "PLAY ME."

As an audience, we are willing these characters to know better - they are familiar with their suspect and his games, why on earth would they play right into one?

However, that is exactly what the naive Agent Perez does as she snatches the tape and is warned "Your next move is critical!" And what exactly is her next move? She steps closer to the creepy puppet as its eyes begin to glint and roll back in its head.

It's hardly a surprise when the doll's face explodes outward and sends debris into the face and neck of the young woman. One can only scream "Why? Why?" Why would someone get so close to something so sinister, why didn't either of them read the room and air more caution?

Perez's injury seems almost justified given just how careless she was. If one listens closely, the cassette can be heard whispering "Step back, you're going to die." Meaning once again one of Jigsaw's helpful survival tips was missed.


5. Dina Pleads - Saw 3D

Saw Puppet 2004
Lionsgate

Saw 3D was released as the franchise's final chapter in 2010 after disappointing box-office returns from Saw VI. The quick turnaround and the condensing of 2 pitched films into one left the movie with a number of plot holes and a myriad of questionable character decisions.

These questionable character choices are evident from the film's very first "game." One public display via a store front, we meet Ryan and Brad, both taped to a workbench with nasty built in circular saws. Suspended above them is Dina, and one man must kill the other in order to save the helpless girl.

This unique entry stands as both a great character decision and also an achingly stupid one. It soon becomes obvious that Dina has been seeing both men romantically, and she quickly begins to profess her love for whichever she believes will save her faster.

The young woman's choice to flit between who she "loves" more and expose her charade and shady character is absolutely laughable. We can't help but cheer when her scorned lovers decide to work together and opt to let Dina fall onto the saw blades.

It is a quick and incredibly just end to a terribly stupid and unlikable character.


4. Magnum Eyehole - Saw II

Saw II Gus
Lionsgate

This sequel was inevitable. Sensing a sure thing, the budget was upped, the traps were more perilous and the victims multiplied.

Saw II is almost flawlessly written and features a double whammy twist ending that will leave you speechless with shock.

Yes, I said "almost flawlessly written." Despite an incredibly strong script, Saw II features the first instances of characters making very questionable decisions.

We follow a group of strangers finding themselves trapped in a house. Jigsaw informs them the rooms are filling with a deadly nerve gas and antidotes are placed throughout the building. They will survive if they can successfully obtain one.

Remember Jigsaw's helpful hints? Saw II sees this begin with the very first game. Trapped members of the group peer through a peephole only to see a gun staring back. Attached to the key is a note; "Do not attempt to use this key on the door to this room!"

Sounds pretty simple, right? As an audience we're quite sure what will happen if this rule is disobeyed. Most of the group are too, but Gus and Xavier decide they don't play by rules. Whilst Gus keeps an eye on the peephole, Xavier turns the key...

And loses half of his head to a bullet... We all saw it coming a mile away. This beginning trait of hasty characters would remain a contentious issue throughout the series.


3. Jill Runs - Saw 3D

Betsy Russell Saw 3D
Lionsgate

Jill Tuck is John Kramer's ex-wife and the police pursue her doggedly, believing she must know something of future Jigsaw plans.

Saw VI reveals to us that Jill is an ice queen. Aware of her ex-husband's activities, she has agreed to carry out his posthumous last wish and assume the mantle of Jigsaw.

In an ice-cold performance, Betsy Russell delights in taking the power-mad Detective Hoffman captive and ending his Jigsaw reign. With the iconic reverse bear trap in place, Jill leaves Hoffman to his bloody fate.

Although the least successful entry in the franchise, fans and critics agreed that Russell's turn as Jigsaw wrapped up the series nicely and would've been a fitting end. Unfortunately, it wasn't.

In a move that still irks fans to this day, Saw 3D sees Hoffman effortlessly escape Jill's trap. Jill goes from badass final boss to standard frightened horror movie victim.

In an even stranger move, she chooses to seek out police protection, which seems to be a painfully obvious decision to sideline her for most of the film. When she is finally hunted down and trapped by Hoffman, we see all her character's strength and icy villainy explode in a useless plume of blood and guts.

It's a crying shame this character was robbed of her strength and reduced to a quivering victim.


2. Doctor Gordon's Loyalty - Saw 3D

Saw 3D Cary Elwes
Lionsgate

Although interest in the series had cooled considerably, the announcement of Cary Elwes' return to the Saw fold as Doctor Lawrence Gordon sparked renewed curiosity.

The undeniably brave man had not been seen or heard of since he cut off his own foot to escape six years before. Many wondered in the intervening years if he was even alive. Fans hoped Elwes' return would signal the ultimate re-teaming of survivors to take down Jigsaw apprentices and devotees for good.

Unfortunately what we got is... questionable to say the least. Saw 3D presents Gordon as an oddly sinister figure, now walking on a prosthetic foot. The movie plays out largely as a vehicle for Detective Mark Hoffman's madness as he continues to commit his own Jigsaw style murders.

Elwes is largely forgotten until the film's final reveal: Doctor Gordon has been on Jigsaw's side since his escape and delivers the final blow, locking Hoffman in the bathroom where it all began.

Confused? Don't worry... Many franchise fans were too. This character turn just seems... so odd for the good Doctor. Why is he so loyal to the serial killer that not only tried to kill him, but his family as well? Why devote his life to continuing that legacy?

It's a head-scratching choice... A choice that disappointed many and seemed a rather weak grab for one final "shocking" ending.


1. Razor Box - Saw II

Saw II
Lionsgate Films

The otherwise wonderful Saw II makes its second appearance with a scene so ridiculous it hurts.

After witnessing several of her fellow hostages fall victim to Jigsaw's traps, call girl Addison decides it would be a great idea to separate herself from the remaining survivors. Weak from the nerve gas, she comes across a suspended glass box with two arm holes and a mini-cassette.

Inside this rather harmless looking box is the antidote she needs... However, after all she has witnessed, one would assume she'd air some caution, right? Nothing is ever as simple as it seems when Jigsaw is involved.

Well... She doesn't. In a truly stupid moment, the young woman chooses to disregard the cassette with Jigsaw's instructions and nonchalantly insert her hands into the box. It comes as no surprise when she finds herself trapped as razor blades seize her wrists and she slowly begins to bleed out.

This was a shock to no one but Addison it seems, who is absolutely perplexed and begs for assistance. Has she not been paying attention whilst people have been dropping like flies? A further sting reveals, had she listened to the tape, she would've been able to simply smash the glass box and obtain the antidote.

The character's lack of common sense is truly baffling and leaves the viewer shaking their head in amazement.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Saw
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Hi! The first thing you should know about me is that I'm a HUGE horror movie nut. A confirmed addict to the WhatCulture Horror YouTube channel I thought I'd try my luck on their writing team. I'm a wannabe author with one completed manuscript submitted to a few agents. Please cross your fingers for me! I am currently working on my second book. If you wanna talk horror or need any movie recommendations, I'm your man! Give me a follow on Instagram... since there doesn't seem to be a section for that in the "socials" tab @that_horror_nerd