10 Superhero Films If They Were Made By Legendary Directors

Scorsese's Punisher?... With De Niro?... Somebody build a time machine and bankroll this sucker!

Columbia PicturesColumbia PicturesIn 2003 a rumour proliferated online that back in 1946 Orson Welles had planned to direct a Batman film. The information €œuncovered€ included a wealth of detail on Welles€™ intentions for his film €œThe Bat-Man€ and painted a compelling picture of what might have been. The word was that Welles wanted to portray Batman himself but the studio instead forced through the casting of hot property Gregory Peck. Peck was to be supported by a dream cast that included Marlene Dietrich as Catwoman, George Raft as Two-Face, James Cagney as The Riddler and Basil Rathbone as The Joker. The Bat-Man would have been a hard-nosed noir take on the material - faithful to the original incarnation of the character. It would be enough to make you weep for what we were denied if it hadn€™t all been revealed as an almighty hoax orchestrated by comics scribe Mark Millar on the CBR message boards. Millar€™s hoax caught the imagination of comic fans and inspired a wealth of mocked up fan-art posters and even a fairly impressive fan-made trailer. Using Millar€™s retrofitting of superhero cinema history as a jump-off point this article re-imagines ten major superhero properties as if they had been placed in the hands of some of the greatest directors ever. Some of the ideas that emerge fall squarely on the insane side of crazy but others will make you wish the golden age of superhero cinema had started a good few decades earlier.

10. Martin Scorsese's The Punisher

Sorcha EdwardFrank Castle is arguably a product of post-Vietnam America as much as John Rambo and more pertinently Travis Bickle, so who better to tackle the character in the decade he was created than Marty himself? If it was made today with Scorsese at the helm we'd no doubt have Leo with a skull-shaped lapel-badge on his Armani suit, but seeing as this is the 70's it would take none other than Robert De Niro to administer a campaign of one-man vengeance in Skull T-shirt and flak jacket. Set in New York, this would have been far more than just taking Taxi Driver and superimposing a skull logo onto Travis Bickle, De Niro would have brought the perfect balance of mournful pain and vengeance-induced insanity that has been so lacking in other depictions of Castle. In a nod to his debut in Amazing Spider-Man #129 the film would open with Castle in rooftop pursuit of Your Friendly Neighbourhood Spider-Man. Spidey would be portrayed in cameo by the teen idol of the age: David Cassidy, a casting reminiscent of the off-kilter choice of Jerry Lewis in The King of Comedy. Once the Webslinger learns of Castle's tragic background (depicted in flashback) the story would then follow The Punisher's journey from villain to anti-hero as he sets about taking down the criminals that murdered his family. There would be a final parallel to Taxi Driver with Scorsese's other regular Harvey Keitel appearing as a puzzle-scarred pimp version of Jigsaw. If time-travel is ever invented then it would be greatly appreciated if any would-be chrono-tourists could consider going back to bankroll this project.

9. John Carpenter's Spawn

http://sorchaedward.tumblr.comSorcha EdwardJohn Carpenter was already on his downward trajectory when Spawn #1 first appeared in 1992. Nevertheless if he could have squeezed out one more decent film before mediocrity started to seep in with 1997€™s Escape From LA Spawn would have been a fitting property to stop the rot. The Carpenter making this version of Spawn would be the same director who gave us The Thing, They Live, Big Trouble In Little China and Prince of Darkness, as such this film would arrive at the end of that run and reflect elements of each. Keith David would be the only choice for Carpenter€™s Al Simmons with Kurt Russell playing his best friend Terry, this would be a nice subversion of their roles in The Thing (and David's in They Live) with David taking the lead. Lee van Cleef would have made a perfect Jason Wynn but seeing as he wasn€™t around at this point the role could go to James Brolin. Another Carpenter fave Donald Pleasance would complete the cast as The Clown in one of his final film roles. Proving himself the master of three genres in Action, Science-Fiction and Horror, often by combining all three, Carpenter in his prime would have been the ideal director for Todd McFarlane's creation, bringing with him the visceral horror of Robb Botin's effects team to bring the damned Al Simmons' charred corpse to life.

8. David Lynch's X-Men

http://sorchaedward.tumblr.comSorcha EdwardHe did Dune (and has previously played with mutant chickens and babies) so there's no reason to think Lynch couldn't have put his hand to an equally recognisable property such as X-Men. David Lynch's mutants would no doubt include: Kyle McLachlan as Cyclops, Dean Stockwell as Nightcrawler, Laura Dern as Phoenix and considering their work together on Dune, Patrick Stewart could retain his role of Professor X in this alternative universe. Wolverine would be trickier to cast, from Lynch alumni there are only really Jack Nance and Bill Pullman who could come close to pulling off the role so instead it would be worth plucking an actor like Michael Biehn. Biehn is commonly associated with another legendary director James Cameron but would work as Logan in a Lynchian take on Marvel€™s Mutants. The mind boggles as to what surrealism Lynch would apply were he to have tackled the X-Men post-Dune, it is unlikely he would make something that would fall into any ongoing continuity, and would probably even hint at the X-Men personas being dreamlike projections of the character€™s inner beings. This is difficult to imagine in some respects but as well as having dealt with sweeping fantastical themes in Dune, Lynch also directed one of the definitive portraits of a societal outcast in The Elephant Man, so imagining the two preceding works feeding into his version of X-Men makes it slightly easier to imagine what form it would have taken.

7. Don Siegel's Daredevil

http://sorchaedward.tumblr.comSorcha EdwardIf Dirty Harry director Don Siegel could've filmed Daredevil in the 70s then who better than the "Man With No Name" to play his "Man Without Fear"? It is often suggested that Clint would have made a great Batman, usually in relation to Frank Miller€™s The Dark Knight Returns but 70s Clint of Dirty Harry and Play Misty For Me would have been phenomenal as both Matt Murdoch and his alter-ego Daredevil in a hard-boiled Don Siegel adaptation. In homage to Millar€™s The Bat-Man Orson Welles would have had the stature and presence at that point to play Kingpin Wilson Fisk but perhaps not the martial capabilities. Jill St John could have channelled her Bond Girl Tiffany Case from Diamonds Are Forever into playing Elektra, and in a Heat level pairing of key 70s actors, Charles Bronson could face-off against Clint as a grizzled hitman version of Bullseye. Daredevil was created in the 1960s but Frank Miller's seminal run on the character was brought to life by having the backdrop of a crime-ridden New York (specifically Hell's Kitchen) of the 70s and 80s. It is a New York that no longer truly exists, so it is easy to see how Joe Carnahan arrived at his pitch of a 1970's set Daredevil, later rejected in favour of a contemporary TV take on the character.

6. Elia Kazan's Fantastic Four

Sorcha EdwardTaking the kind of subjects that Elia Kazan was famed for broaching such as family and the working class struggle and then applying it to something like The Fantastic Four would have been a fascinating prospect. In Kazan€™s Four it is easy to imagine Marlon Brando as a cocksure Johnny Storm clashing with Ernest Borgnine as The Thing, their conflict playing out the generational clash of two sides of American blue collar-dom. Montgomery Clift would have also been an inspired choice to play Mr Fantastic against and equally perfect Kim Novak as Sue Storm. Never one to broach the fantastical it is somewhat difficult to imagine Kazan handling the Sci-Fi elements of the story but this is where bringing in the creative trailblazers of the time such as A. Arnold Gillespie, Irving G. Ries, and Wesley C. Miller who were the Oscar nominated team behind the special effects in Forbidden Planet. A young Ray Harryhausen could work on the stop-motion animation of Galactus, the Silver Surfer and long-shots of the Thing. Rounding out the stellar cast (and providing the greatest special effect of all) would be Vincent Price as the nefarious and theatrical voice of Victor Von Doom.

5. John Ford€™s Captain America

http://sorchaedward.tumblr.comSorcha EdwardIf Western auteur John Ford had of made a version of Captain America contemporary to the war then the most obvious choice for Steve Rogers would no doubt have been Ford regular John Wayne. Instead though the role would go to real-life actor come war hero Audie Murphy and Wayne would appear in cameo as Sergeant Fury (later appearing in spin-off team-up film: The Invaders), Mickey Rooney would play Bucky Barnes (foreshadowing a later role as Fall-Out Boy) with the most famous Hollywood based German speaking actor of the time: Peter Lorre making for a decidedly creepy Red Skull. Anybody who knows Audie Murphy's story knows that he more or less was the "real" Captain America. Murphy was one of the most decorated American soldiers in the War, he was involved in the Invasion of Sicily and Anzio, the Liberation of Rome and the Invasion of Southern France, as well as famously holding off a company of German soldiers single handedly for over an hour. It was his appearance on the cover of Life magazine celebrating this fact which brought him to the attention of James Cagney. Murphy's incredible war record was immortalised in the 1955 film Hell and Back, where he played himself. If 1940's Hollywood had seen the potential of the fledgling superhero genre then Murphy could have been a definitive Captain America over sixty years before Chris Evans made the role his own.

4. Cecil B DeMille's Superman

Sorcha EdwardGiven the overt parallels between Moses and the Last Son of Krypton - brought to the story by Jewish creators Siegel and Shuster - then it would be fitting that the creative team behind the most famous cultural depiction (outside The Old Testament) of Moses's story: The Ten Commandments would also be responsible for bringing Kal-El's tale to the big screen. Cecil B. DeMille would bring a sweeping epic quality to Superman wrought large in Cinemascope, drawing upon the art-deco beauty of the Fleischer cartoons and the glorious matte backgrounds of his biblical masterpieces. Only Charlton Heston could portray DeMille's Superman, with a flighty Vivian Leigh as Lois Lane, and in perhaps the greatest missed character casting opportunity of all: Yul Brynner as a dark and intense Lex Luthor. Impossibly detailed mattes would serve as Krypton€™s doomed landscapes. This Superman would move mountains with the ease of Moses parting the Red Sea, creating the perfect Technicolor backdrop for Charlton Heston€™s lantern-jawed all-American Superman to face off against Yul Brynner's megalomaniacal Luthor.

3. Alfred Hitchcock's Catwoman

http://sorchaedward.tumblr.comSorcha EdwardWho better to handle the ultimate comic book femme fatale than The Master himself? The twist on Hitchcock€™s Catwoman would be having Bruce Wayne (here played by Cary Grant) blurring the lines between stalker and vigilante as he observes and investigates social climber Selina Kyle (Grace Kelly). Wayne first encounters Selina at a charity fundraiser ball held for the young dilettantes of Gotham. He is beguiled by the social mobility of the class defying Kyle, but on further investigation discovers her to be an expert jewel thief going by the name Catwoman. His pursuit of the feline thief soon leads to him discover she has links to a greater crime organisation. It perhaps sounds like Hitchcock€™s Batman rather than Catwoman, with Wayne being the protagonist, but the focal point of the film is all Selina, the duality of her contrasting identities drawing upon the great Hitchcock blondes from Kim Novak in Vertigo to Kelly herself in Marnie. Grant would make for an inquisitive and slightly paranoid Bruce Wayne/Batman, torn by his burgeoning feelings for Selina and his duty to bring down Catwoman. Rounding out the cast would be David Niven as Alfred (who almost played the part in Tom Mankiwiecz's unmade early-eighties version) and British actor Roger Livesey (A Matter of Life and Death) as Commissioner Gordon. Hitchcock could even make his signature cameo appearance in a newspaper clipping as the mugshot of captured criminal Oswald Cobblepot AKA The Penguin.

2. Mike Nichols' Spider-Man

http://sorchaedward.tumblr.comSorcha EdwardSpider-man is the definitive Marvel superhero creation of the 1960s and had he appeared cinematically in that decade then the director and star of The Graduate Mike Nichols and Dustin Hoffman would have been the perfect team to bring the webslinger to life. Despite being from vastly different social standings there are a great many parallels between The Graduate's Benjamin Braddock and Peter Parker beyond the alliterative names. They are both negotiating the awkward period between adolescence and adulthood, they both engage in clandestine night time activity that they keep a secret from their loved ones and both found themselves caught in a love-triangle. In a further act of Spidey-fying The Graduate Mr Robinson Murray Hamilton could slot into the role of Norman Osbourne with Hoffman's All The President's Men co-star Robert Redford as Harry Osbourne. One of the most exciting prospects when casting a 1960s Spider-Man movie is the opportunity to bring in Spencer Tracy and Katherine Hepburn as Uncle Ben and Aunt May, both of whom are so similar in appearance to their print counterparts that its possible Steve Ditko used their likenesses as the basis for Peter's guardians.

1. Stanley Kubrick's Watchmen

http://sorchaedward.tumblr.comSorcha EdwardWe€™ve all imagined what Terry Gilliam and Paul Greengrass€™ Watchmen might have been like given that they almost came to pass but what if Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons€™ masterpiece had fallen on Stanley€™s desk instead of Eyes Wide Shut? Watchmen is perhaps the only superhero property it is possible to imagine Kubrick making, he had previously delved into popular fiction to great success with The Shining so there is no reason a property as complex and acclaimed as Watchmen would be any lesser a prospect for a talent such as his. If we place the idea of Kubrick directing Watchmen in the fourteen year gap between Full Metal Jacket and Eyes Wide Shut we can form a cast of the kind of actors who would have interested Kubrick and even ones gleaned from both of those productions. Tom Cruise was linked to the role of Ozymandis at various stages anyway and given the fame of the character in the Watchmen universe he would have made for a fitting Adrian Veidt, especially in the hands of Kubrick who would no doubt have coaxed one of his finest performances. Rorschach could be played by James Woods, he never appeared in a Kubrick film but he would work perfectly in this alternative scenario. Rounding out the cast would be Tim Robbins as Nite-Owl, Rebecca De Mornay as the Silk Spectre II and William Hurt as Dr Manhattan. Kubrick€™s Watchmen would have been a fascinating proposition and like The Shining would have been filtered through his unique lens to make a for an altered but no less brilliant version of the story. (The images for this article were kindly created by Sorcha Edward) Any other superhero properties that evaded their perfect director? Tell us below:

Contributor
Contributor

As well as the odd article, I apply my "special mind" to scriptwriting for Comics, Films and Games... Oh and I cut down trees, I skip and jump, I like to press wild flow'rs, I put on women's clothing, and hang around in bars. Follow me on Twitter @DrRobertOtnik