10 Terrible Films By Game Of Thrones Directors

They shouldn't have left Westeros.

Alan Taylor Game Of Thrones Terminator Genisys
HBO/Paramount Pictures

HBO's Game of Thrones has gone from strength to strength since the first season took primetime television by storm back in 2011, with the finale of the show's latest run bringing in a series-record 8.9 million viewers. It's already deeply ingrained in pop culture and will undoubtedly define the current generation of television, and this is testament not only to a talented author in George R. R. Martin, but to those who adapted his work for the screen.

David Benioff and D. B. Weiss have come in for some criticism from certain sections of the A Song Of Ice And Fire crowd, though their commitment to realising Martin's epic has not gone unnoticed at the Emmys. The showrunning duo are the current holders of the award for Outstanding Drama Series, and they weren't the only Game Of Thrones winners at the last ceremony.

Another reigning Emmy champion is director David Nutter, who triumphed in the Outstanding Direction for a Drama Series category with his season 5 finale Mother's Mercy. Two of his fellow Game Of Thrones directors are in contention to take the winged statue away from him this year - Jack Bender for his tear-jerking episode The Door, and Miguel Sapochnik for the epic Battle Of The Bastards.

It stands to reason that a show of Game of Thrones' magnitude should employ the best in the industry, and when it comes to directors that is clearly the case. The small-screen credentials of the show's many helmers speak for themselves, though a good television director doesn't always make a good feature film director, as the following examples prove beyond doubt.

10. Repo Men (2004)

42555

Director: Miguel Sapochnik

Miguel Sapochnik has directed some of the most memorable Game Of Thrones episodes to date, making his debut during the show's fifth season with The Gift and then the critically acclaimed Hardhome. The English director returned for Season 6 and was entrusted with the final two episodes - the highly anticipated and well-received Battle Of The Bastards and The Winds Of Winter.

Sapochnik has also worked on House and True Detective in the past, earning a name for himself as a talent in the world of direction. In TV at least; his one and only attempt at a feature film thus far wasn't met with the same level of approval. Far from it in fact - Repo Men scored a measly 22% on Rotten Tomatoes.

Based on the novel The Repossession Mambo by Eric Garcia, this sci-fi action-thriller stars Jude Law and Forest Whitaker and takes place in a near future where diseased organs can be replaced with bio-mechanical ones. If patients fall behind on payments, however, the Repo Men are called in to reclaim the replacement organs in ruthless and violent fashion.

It's a gory premise, and Sapochnik certainly can't be accused of shying away from the job at hand, though the amount of blood and guts simply becomes mind numbing after a while and completely loses impact by the end. An excess of homages and a twist right out of the left field are just failed attempts at saving a movie that manages to be ultra-violent and ultra-dull at the same time.


9. What's Your Number? (2011)

Whats Your Number Anna Faris Chris Evans
20th Century Fox

Director: Mark Mylod

British director Mark Mylod began his career with the BBC, making his move into American television when HBO hired him to work on Entourage. He impressed the network enough to earn a shot at directing on Game Of Thrones, and in 2014 he took charge of episodes three and four of Season 5. He was welcomed back for season 6, directing episode seven The Broken Man, and episode eight No One, in which Arya finally got to kill that pesky Waif.

There are no fights to the death in Mylod's 2011 film What's Your Number? however, with the only battle being the one the audience face to stay awake. Rated a gone-off splat by both Rotten Tomatoes users and critics (who scored it as 44% and 23% respectively) this flat rom-com stars Anna Faris as Ally Darling, a woman who goes looking for the best ex of her life after a magazine article convinces her she's going to die alone.

Anyone who has seen a few Anna Faris movies knows that she has the potential to be a comedy star. Her crack timing and scatterbrained enthusiasm could be channelled into something genuinely hilarious, though What's Your Number? is just another in a string of movies that fails to capitalise on her obvious talents.

Mylod oversees a painfully predictable mash-up of long since played out rom-com cliches thrown together carelessly in the editing room, and even Captain America himself Chris Evans (Faris' best ex) can't save this one from sucking hard.


8. Doomsday (2008)

Doomsday Cannibals
Universal Pictures

Director: Neil Marshall

British director Neil Marshall has been a mixed bag when it comes to feature films, though the two episodes of Game Of Thrones he has directed have both been met with critical acclaim. The penultimate episode is usually seen as the season's best, and Marshall has helmed two thus far - the memorable Blackwater in season 2 and The Watcher on the Wall in season 4.

Long before HBO greenlit Game of Thrones, Marshall was making a name for himself in horror circles with his critically acclaimed debut Dog Soldiers (2002) and the claustrophobic chiller The Descent (2005), films that earned him the right to play with a bigger budget for 2008's Doomsday.

This near-future sci-fi takes place in Scotland after the country has been quarantined for three decades because of the outbreak of the deadly Reaper virus. When Reaper is discovered in London, politicians in the UK's secure capital send a team north to cross the border and search for a possible cure.

Some reviews accused Doomsday of lifting far too heavily from existing films (Aliens and The Road Warrior being the most blatant) though the real problem here isn't the director's many influences, it's how haphazardly they are thrown together. The film goes out of its way to blend genres and in doing so loses the rhythm that made Marshall's earlier work play so well, resulting in a slog of set-pieces that just aren't enough to keep you interested in what happens next.


7. Kill The Poor (2006)

Kill The Poor
IFC Films

Director: Alan Taylor

Despite having helmed huge feature films such as Marvel's Thor: The Dark World (2013), Alan Taylor is still better known for his work as a television director. He has plied his trade behind the camera on a number of biggest shows in recent TV history including Lost, The West Wing, The Sopranos, Boardwalk Empire, Man Men and, of course, Game of Thrones.

The Brooklyn-born director was behind two Season 1 and four Season 2 episodes, and while it seems like a lifetime ago in Westeros, there's no avoiding that Taylor's work on episodes nine and ten of Season 1 has defined the series - Baelor, in which Ned tragically lost his head, and Fire and Blood, in which Daenerys' dragons are born in the flames of Drogo's funeral pyre.

There was nothing memorable about Taylor's Kill The Poor, unfortunately, as his adaptation of Joel Rose's novel ended up coming across as barely preferable to beheading. It takes place in pre-gentrification Manhattan and focuses on the residents of an Alphabet City apartment building, whom have to come together to determine which of them tried to burn the place down.

Kill The Poor is nowhere near as provocative as the title suggests, setting itself up as more of a character study. The problem is, these characters - a flamboyant gay man named Delilah, a presumptuous graduate student named Butch, the tenement's resident floozy Scarlet - have all been studied before, and in most cases to much greater effect. The 25% rating this film received on Rotten Tomatoes is actually flattering.


6. The Glass House (2001)

The Glass House
Columbia Pictures

Director: Daniel Sackheim

Daniel Sackheim was involved in a string of feature-length projects in the late 1990s, helming four movies between '94 and '96 and working as a producer on The X-Files in '98 (a show on which Sackheim had worked as a director prior to life on Game Of Thrones).

Last season Sackheim directed both episodes three (Oathbreaker, which featured the first Tower Of Joy flashback) and four (Book of the Stranger, in which a captured Daenerys burns the remaining khals to death at Vaes Dothrak). Both episodes were well received, though the same cannot be said of the director's 2001 mystery drama The Glass House.

The film follows a problematic teen named Ruby (an incredibly hammy Leelee Sobieski), a girl who takes her parents for granted until they tragically meet their end in a car accident. Ruby and her brother then come under the guardianship of their seemingly perfect neighbours the Glasses, and it becomes obvious pretty quickly (too quickly, in fact) that they are not what they seem.

The film opens with a cheap-trick sequence as the protagonist and her friends turn out to be watching a movie-within-a-movie, and ten minutes in you are willing them to put that film back on. It soon becomes painfully obvious where things are heading, with a plot so thin and contrived that you can't help but wonder if the screenplay was scribbled on a napkin during Wesley Strick's lunch break.


5. Save The Last Dance 2: Stepping Up (2006)

Save the Last Dance 2
Paramount Home Entertainment

Director: David Petrarca

Rhode Island native David Petrarca worked as a director at Chicago's Goodman Theatre from 1998 until 2005, and from there forged a path into television. This well respected TV helmer has worked on a number of big shows, from Netflix's Jessica Jones and Marco Pollo to HBO's Boardwalk Empire, but most prominently episode's four and five of Game of Thrones Season 2.

Petrarca's one and only foray into feature film directing was a strange one for someone of his background and pedigree - Save The Last Dance 2: Stepping Up. Maybe he relished the challenge of bringing some credibility to the idea, but if he did he failed that challenge resoundingly, sending this awful sequel straight to video.

This is the story of a ballerina student that gets seduced away from her chosen discipline by a new tutor who preaches the raw honesty of hip-hop dance, pretty much imitating the steps of the first movie. Julia Stiles is replaced by Izabella Miko in the lead role of Sara, and the new actress makes little effort to mimic her predecessor, inexplicably giving the character a bunch of new traits.

It's a horribly edited mess with a number of random story threads that seem to either go nowhere or disappear entirely; a dancer named Candy displays unprovoked hostility toward Sara and is hardly seen again, Sara's teacher discovers she is taking pills to help with her performance and just forgets about it, her roommate harps on about a play that we never get to see. Petrarca's film amounts to little more than half-boiled sub-plots and generic dance scenes.


4. The Big White (2005)

The Big White Robin Williams
Momentum Pictures

Director: Mark Mylod

Back to Mark Mylod, as essential Throne director set to return for Season 7. The Brit is one of the few Game Of Thrones directors to have a run of past feature efforts on his CV, though here's another one that falls into the same category as his awful rom-com What's Your Number?.

A nigh-on unwatchable effort, The Big White follows travel agent Paul Barnell (Robin Williams) after he finds a body in a dumpster and decides to use it to his advantage. Heavily in debt and desperate to find a cure for his wife's Tourettes Syndrome, Paul recovers the frozen corpse and uses it to trigger his missing brother's life-insurance policy.

It didn't sound like a bad premise at the time, and the additions of Woody Harrelson and Tim Blake Nelson to the cast only spelled good things for this dark comedy, but in the end the film was worthy of its 30% Rotten Tomatoes rating. The trouble for Mylod was that he was trying so hard to channel Fargo that his film gets snowed under with indie sentiment and becomes more pretentious (and less funny) with every passing scene.

The film was so misguided that producers could not strike a deal for studio release and were forced to settle for the VOD dumping ground.


3. Centurion (2010)

Centurion
Warner Bros.

Director: Neil Marshall

In 2014 Neil Marshall was nominated for a Primetime Emmy for his directorial work on Game Of Thrones season 4's penultimate episode The Watchers On The Wall, but four years earlier his latest (and still most recent) major feature film wasted a talented cast and an interesting premise, much like the disappointing Doomsday did two years before that.

Like most of his film work, Centurion is set in Britain, this time during the Roman conquest of the 2nd Century. It stars Michael Fassbender as Quintus Dias, a Roman centurion who leads a group of soldiers in a rescue raid on a Pict camp. While the Roman invaders manage to secure their captured general, they find themselves hunted by a group of the Pict's most vicious and skilled warriors.

Like Fassbender's debut film 300, Centurion takes its ancient context and uses it as little more than a vague guideline, being far more interested in setting up scenes of mass bloodshed than in maintaining historical accuracy. Heads roll with such regularity that the film becomes nothing more than a series of violent skirmishes broken up with hackneyed speeches about duty and honour that, while intended to inspire, only evoke memories of better movies in the historical action genre.

The jarring modern vernacular and misjudged use of comical voice-overs prove to be the final nails in the coffin here, and no matter how many shots of breathtaking Scottish landscapes Marshall includes, he can't hide the fact that the story is sub-standard and fails to capitalise on a fantastic setting.


2. Ali G Indahouse (2004)

Ali G Indahouse
Universal Pictures

Director: Mark Mylod

Ali G Indahouse is the third of Mark Mylod's films to make this list, making it a full house for the man that introduced us to new fanboy favourite Lyanna Mormont in last season's The Broken Man; this low-brow comedy was not only the first big-screen appearance for one of Sacha Baron Cohen's many characters, but also Mylod's feature film debut.

Ali G became a much-loved cult character through his appearances on British TV in the early to mid naughties, though his one-note gags get repetitive pretty quickly over a relatively short 88-minute run-time in Ali G Indahouse. A tired and tedious script certainly doesn't help Mylod here, but the main reason that the film is so terrible is the change in style from TV.

Despite Da Ali G Show having him conducting absurd interviews with real-life politicians, but this spin-off film revolves around a manufactured story; Ali gets used by an underhanded politician to discredit the British Prime Minister only to impress and start ascending the political ladder himself.

Watching Ali G Indahouse back today, you can't help but imagine how much funnier it would have been had it been done in the style of the original show, with real-life politicians reacting to Ali's seemingly genuine proposals - ensuring the immigration of attractive women into the UK, for example. As it is, Mylod takes about fifteen minutes of passable gags and stretches them well past breaking point.


1. Terminator Genisys (2015)

Terminator Genisys Fight
Paramount Pictures

Director: Alan Taylor

The most recent and the most disappointing film on this list given the significance of the franchise in pop culture, Alan Taylor's Terminator Genisys was frustrating from the word go. Unnecessary and misguided, the spoilerific advertising in particular left a sour taste in the mouth before anyone had even sat down to watch it.

Taylor's Thor: The Dark World made just shy of $650 million at the box office in 2013 and was given a just-about-respectable approval rating of 66% on Rotten Tomatoes, though by Marvel standards it was an average effort. Genisys was next, and while MCU fans gave him a relatively easy ride, Terminator fans were not so forgiving.

This is the fifth film in a much-loved and once-revered franchise, and by now even the staunchest of Terminator fans are starting to doubt the muddled mythology, with Taylor's instalment only serving to muddy the waters with more questionable logic. In fact, a good chunk of dialogue is taken up by the cast reiterating exactly what is going on for the benefit of the audience (and most likely themselves).

While it obviously boasts a better quality of CGI than the early entries in the series, Genisys amounts to nothing more than a substandard rehash of those beloved movies, lacking the thematic depth and intelligence that made Terminator such a phenomenon at the time.

What other films from Game Of Thrones directors could have made this list? What are the rare hits? Share your thoughts down on the comments.


Contributor

Phil still hasn't got round to writing a profile yet, as he has an unhealthy amount of box sets on the go.