10 Terrible Mistakes That Almost Ruined Batman For Everyone
Just how close did we come to Batman being forgotten?

Over the years, Batman has been trapped in some pretty abusive relationships: the 1966 TV show turned him into a camp clown, writers throughout his history have turned him into a joke, and Joel Schumacher slapped on some nipples and put him in the middle of a garish, nightmarish pantomime.
And yet, the Bat endures. He has the kind of enduring longevity that most characters can only dream of, and while that is undoubtedly a positive thing for the lasting legacy of the character (meaning he can bounce back from even the worst creative crimes,) that also represents a safety net for writers and directors with crazy ideas, and means they feel safer messing with the winning formula.
If some of the mistakes made in Batman's name on this list had been allowed to fully play out, without remedy or logical intervention, the unthinkably might have happened. Batman might have been ruined as a property, or worse, killed entirely. So take these mistakes as a warning, and make sure you look after your Batman.
Honourable Mention
Joe Chill

A controversial place to start no doubt, but retrospectively, the decision to give the killer of Bruce Wayne's parents a name, a story and in one memorable case, a death was a mistake - not a ruining one by any means, but a mistake all the same.
Yes, it was an established storyline that ran for many years, and shaped a lot of things in the character's make-up, but events that came later proved exactly how good the alternative could have been. Chill only really became a mistake when he was retconned out of existence briefly with the events of Zero Hour, when Hal Jordan effectively gave DC an opportunity to rewrite any origins they wanted to play about with, that weren't changed in Crisis On Infinite Earths.
After Zero Hour, it became canon that the killer of Wayne's parents was never identified, and the anonymity helped make him an even more enduring symbol to Batman's cause. That decision robbed Batman of a specific focus for his grief or his bubbling rage, which added far more poignancy to Batman's endless torture, until the retcon was retconned again, and Chill got his name back.
10. Batman Was Nearly Cancelled In The 1960s

Given the enduring popularity of the character, and the many spin-offs today, the revelation that Batman was almost no more after a poor run of sales in the early 1960s might come as something of a shock, but Bob Kane confirmed that by 1964 DC was indeed planning on killing the character off altogether.
Common debate questions this, suggesting that the "killing" would probably have been impermanent, or Batman would simply have been relegated to a supporting character in the JLA series, but without the subsequent appointment of editor Julius Schwartz, it's likely nonetheless that we wouldn't have seen Batman's over-riding success for the next almost sixty years.
Schwartz came in in '64 and completely reinvented the character, cutting away dead wood and tightening the focus with a new look Batman who debuted in Detective Comics #327 (May 1964) and was targeted as a more contemporary iteration of the character (in a similar vein to what Nolan did fifty years later.)
Under Schwartz, the detective elements of the character were brought back to prominence, and so crucially, was the character's darker aspects, under the stewardship of writer Dennis O'Neil and artist Neal Adams. Basically, without Schwartz and the complete reinvention of the Batman property, we would never have had the modern Batman.
9. The Ridiculous Bat-Companions

Back before Julie saved Batman from apparent cancellation, the comic book property was bloated by superfluous additional characters who were adding an unwanted sillier edge to the property. Specifically, the worst offenders were the awful Bat-Mite and the almost comical Ace The Bathound, both of whom were thankfully dropped when Schwartz came on board to save the character from the ignominy of cancellation.
Batgirl was similarly cast aside by the New Look revolution, but she was by far the least offender, considering the sins committed especially by Bat-Mite. Ace was less of a crime, since he was clearly inspired by the success of Krypto (another regrettable decision) in a time when heroic dogs were all the rage, but that doesn't distract from the fact that he was a hyper-intelligent dog in a mask helping out the world's supposedly Greatest Detective.
And as for Bat-Mite, the forgiveness or understanding come a lot harder: he was an annoying abomination, clearly inspired by the same school of thought that added Scrappy Doo to Scooby Doo and The Great Gazoo to The Flintstones. All three focus groups who said yes to those tone-ruining clowns should have been stripped of their responsibilities entirely.
Imagine if Bat-Mite had been allowed to continue - he would have been just as culpable for the inevitable death of Batman - or the property's reduction to a laughing stock - as those other two annoying sidekicks were to their respective shows.
8. Ludicrous Storylines

Throughout the illustrious history of Batman comics, even beyond the influence of Julius Schwartz, there have been some mind-numbingly stupid storylines dedicated to the caped crusader.
In the interest of adding some colour and diversity to the Batman universe (a quest for variety that now seems ridiculously misplaced,) some writers charged with looking after the character whored him out in the interest of entertainment. At various times throughout his history, Batman has been an undercover fortune teller, a caveman and a medieval bandit (sort of) and has been the subject of romantic storylines (involving a furious spurned Vicki Vale) that would have no place in the modern, darker Batman world.
There have been some monumentally odd storylines - like the strip-offer shown above, and the time Batman and Robin were turned into 2D characters by a rainbow monster. Or when he became Bat-Baby and continued to foil crimes. And these aren't even drops in the ocean of idiocy.
Every time a story like that emerged, a strip of credibility was ripped away from the property, and it's no surprise that the most enduring periods of stupidity coincide quite obviously with the lowest sales points in Batman comics history. Hopefully the writers now know we don't respond well to Batman goofing off.
7. Alfred Pennyworth: Bungling Detective

Alfred wasn't always the pinnacle of virtue and the grounding influence that he currently is on Batman (particularly in the film series,) he was originally conceived as a comic foil for Batman and Robin, and his early appearances reinforced that agenda.
Rather than the near-regal companion he would later become, Alfred's early duties saw him attempting to be a detective in his own right, bungling his way through cases, including in his own four-page feature, which somehow lasted for thirteen issues up to Batman #36.
In those stories, Alfred would invariably foil a criminal plot entirely by accident. It's difficult not to imagine Alfred as similar to Inspector Clouseau, and the long-term consequences of that could have cast massive ripples on the universe
Thankfully, the comedic aspects of his character were downplayed and dropped, reinventing the character for the better and establishing the model for the character that would continue up to the modern day. And even worse than his short-lived exploits as a clown detective, he almost didn't last at all...
6. Alfred Was Killed Off

Without Alfred, who for some reason was presented as Batman's mother, father and sort-of spurned lover ("it's me or the job, Bats,") Chris Nolan's franchise would have lacked emotional heart. The same could perhaps be said of Batman & Robin, since Alfred's illness is what drives part of the narrative, but then that film should mostly just be struck from the Bat-records entirely.
But life without Alfred was actually a reality for a while back in the 60s. After Julius Schwartz reinvented the property and sales picked up in 1964, writers combined to give Alfred the heroic death many thought Nolan would give him - specifically saving Batman and Robin from a falling boulder that killed him in Detective #328 (June 1964.) And not only that, he was pulling a sweet skid on a motorbike at the time. Hero.

The retcon came some two years later, when it was revealed that Alfred has been revived (in Detective #356) by Brandon Crawford, which turned him into an unlikely member of Batman's rogue's gallery. His attempt at regeneration resulted in a dramatic change: Alfred awoke from his apparent death with pasty white skin with circular markings, superhuman powers, including telekinesis, and a desire to destroy Batman and Robin.
Calling himself The Outsider, he indirectly battled the Dynamic Duo on a number of occasions, using others as his puppets the Grasshopper Gang in Detective #334, Zatanna in Detective #336, and even the Batmobile itself in Detective #340 and generally only appeared as a mocking voice over the radio.
He did not physically appear in the comics until Detective #356, when he is bathed again in the rays of the regeneration machine during a struggle with Batman, and returns to normal, with no memory of his time as a supervillain. His time as the Outsider is collected in Showcase Presents: Batman Volumes 1 and 2.
5. Bill Murray Almost Played Batman

The many actors who have almost played Batman have been much-discussed, especially recently with the news that Jay & Silent Bob's Ben Affleck will star as the next big screen Bat, but none would have been as terrible a decision as the near casting of Bill Murray for the 1989 Tim Burton production.
While Michael Keaton's comic side probably helped the character, he was quirky and edgy enough to add depth to both the Caped Crusader and Bruce Wayne, and he had enough charisma and poise to pull off both sides of the character. Murray on the other hand would have ruined both.
He might have been an arresting Bruce Wayne, but much of his career has been spent playing consciously immature (though intelligent) characters - self-consciously developmentally different might be the best way to put it - and his own brand of arrogant neurosis wouldn't have fit.
That failure would likely have stopped Burton's Bat-films before they got going, and we would never have had Batman Returns, or the lesser sequels, and no studio would ever have seen potential enough to hand the reigns to Chris Nolan for his iteration of the property. Thus Batman would probably have been consigned to the same scrap-heap as The Spirit, The Shadow, Spawn, Daredevil and Howard The Duck.
And he wasn't the only terrible choice to play Batman, as revealed in this list of actors who would have been even worse choices than Ben Affleck...
4. Aronofsky's Batman Year One

Probably a controversial choice, but there is logic in this probably perceived madness. Before Chris Nolan was offered the chance to reinvent Batman with a darker, more realistic edge, another rising star director was approached to see whether there was still some life in theproperty.
Step forward Darren Aronofsky, who teamed up with Frank Miller to develop an adaptation of Batman: Year One, arguably the most loved single Batman comic ever released. At this stage it all sounds good - as does the decision to possibly cast Christian Bale - but the problem with Aronofsky's vision was that he didn't actually want to make a Batman film. At least not one that would advance the mythology or brand of the character, and that was clearly an important thing for a studio looking to make money, and fans looking for some service to their favourite character.
In Miller's script, Bruce Wayne wasn't a billionaire heir, he was a street urchin, with borderline psychosis, who tackles crime by taking violent revenge on thugs and criminals. He would be a recession superhero, ignoring Batman's usual gadgets and using whatever he could get his hands on, and disguising himself without the aid of the iconic suit. Every recognisable element was stripped away - no suit, no Batmobile, and even Alfred was re-imagined as a paternal mechanic called Big Al who dies before the film opens, and his gigantic son Little Al.
The Batcave was going to be a subway station (like in the Turtles II movie) and Aronofsky's agenda to move away from the comics was confirmed finally in the hero's name-change from Batman to The Bat-Man (like The Final Destination.) With Aronofsky we wouldn't have got Batman, we would have had something entirely different, and something that would have split the fans massively.
Thankfully, the director realised he wasn't actually making a Batman film, and walked away, citing too many similarities to Rocky - as if he somehow wasn't entirely responsible.
3. Camp

Sometimes it feels like people never learn, and that counts doubly for people in charge of beloved products. Rather than recognising what works and what is beloved by fans, the perpetual quest for innovation inevitably brings change, and petty often, those changes spell disaster.
DC are particularly guilty of this: even after Julius Schwartz saved Batman, be bringing darkness and focus, the initial success of the 1966 TV adaptation starring Adam West meant DC leant on him to change the tone of the comics to fit the show. That inevitably meant more camp.
But the TV show didn't last, and the camp wore thin quite quickly before the show was cancelled in 1968, leaving the comics with a tone that wasn't popular, and which was some distance from the successful model brought in by Schwartz. Thankfully, Dennis O'Neil and Neal Adams swooped back in to distance Batman from the camp, and to return the character to the darker origins that Bob Kane had built.
But if it wasn't for that redemption, it's hard to see a camp Batman enduring for much longer than the Adam West show, even with the nostalgic revival of kitsch and camp more recently.
2. Batman Triumphant

There have been any number of Batman films that never made it to screen, but easily the worst, outstripping even Aronofsky's Not-Batman: Year One, is the bloated, hyperactive joke that would have been Joel Schumacher's third take on the property.
With a cast that would have included Nic Cage as The Scarecrow, and Madonna as Harley Quinn (reimagined as The Joker's vengeful daughter,) the film was optioned when Warner Bros were somehow impressed with the dailies for Batman & Robin.
But thankfully, when the film tanked, the studio saw sense and cut Joel Schumacher away from the project, letting Batman have a rest from the relentless numb-skullery of Schumacher's luminous world until Nolan came in to save the day.
While Batman & Robin wasn't quite enough to kill the potential of the product altogether, the prospect of another catastrophic, camp failure from Schumacher, with the added kickers of Cage and Madonna, would probably have spelled disaster for Batman as a viable option, and we would have had to wait longer to see him back on screen, and probably not with Chris Nolan at the helm.
Considering the impact the director had, you have to wonder what the trajectory of the films might then have been.
1. The Joker Died In His First Appearance

How would Batman have survived without his greatest nemesis? As superhero mythology is careful to reinforce, a hero is nothing without his counter-point, just as without darkness, there can be no light. But that's exactly the type of future we would have faced if the original writers of Batman had had their way.
In the interest of preserving the moral integrity of the comics, and letting Batman triumph without compromise, the Joker's first appearance was designed to be his final one, as he was stabbed in the heart, and kicked the bucket. Bill Finger had been concerned that allowing villains to return would simply make Batman look inept, but he was over-ruled by editor Whitney Ellsworth, who told him to add another panel to the ending above.

Without The Joker, there can't have been an enduring Batman, and even more importantly, without returning villains, we would have been stuck with DC imagining new villains every issue, and we all know what their imagination was like thanks to the appearance of abominable villains like the rainbow monster, Calendar Man and Kite Man.
Did we miss any moments that almost spelled the end for Batman as we know and love him? Share your own picks below.