10 Terrifying Horror Films You’ve Probably Never Seen

The best horrors outside of the mainstream flicks to make you scared of the dark...

Would You Rather
IFC Films

Say what you will about 2020, but at least we've all had more of a chance to binge-watch. Whether you're finally getting around to watching that final series of Game of Thrones or demolishing your long list of movies on Netflix that have been begging for your love for months, many of us now feel like we’ve seen it all!

This goes especially for horror lovers. For those that consider wetting their pants at every creak and sprinting to bed when they finally pick up the courage to turn off the lights a thrilling pastime, there are only a finite amount of horror classics to sink your teeth into (pun intended).

However, once you look past the Halloweens, Conjurings and Paranormal Activities, there are so many horror films that just wait to scare audiences silly. Having spent hours sitting through jump scares, evil children and things that go bump in the night, here are a ten of the best horror films you've probably haven’t seen before.

Quick warning, expect minor plot spoilers ahead…

10. Better Watch Out (2016)

Better Watch Out
Well Go USA

Starting the list is Better Watch Out, which is what would happen if Home Alone and Halloween had a surprisingly charming child. The cast is refreshingly young, starring Levi Miller, who swaps his role as the magical Peter Pan to the mature – and boy does he let us know about it – adolescent, pining for his teenage babysitter whilst his friend mocks him, both played by The Visit alumni Olivia DeJonge and Ed Oxenbould.

The film does an excellent job making these characters real and relatable with contemporary and natural dialogue, meaning when things begin to go bump in the night and intruders threaten them and our squeaky voiced hero must defend his beloved. It makes for a really interesting flip on the stereotypical slasher, which expects the babysitter to be the final girl who protects the youngsters.

However, by the second half, the film outrageously turns things completely on its head yet again. By the finale, there have been so many twists and turns, you’ll be lucky not to be feeling a little bit of motion sickness. However, each turn which seems to get darker and darker by the minute turns a decent reversal of the slasher genre into an unforgettable psychological horror.


9. Bad Match (2017)

Bad Match
Boulderlight Pictures

Bad Match is one of those typical under-the-radar horrors which can be found buried within the menus of Netflix or NOW TV, which would leave most to believe it would be average at best. However, when watched, Bad Match reveals a strong, well-acted slow burner of a horror movie, which feels all too real in the modern world of dating and technology. The film stars Jack Cutmore-Scott as a Hugh Heffner wannabe who uses girls for sex and ghosts them.

At the start, ol’ Heff Junior comes across as purposefully unlikeable. However, with the introduction of a supposed femme fatale played my Lili Simmons, Heff quickly finds his life tipped upside down and his world (and mind) crumble around him.

Bad Match is a patient picture which appears to start with harmless coincidences and slowly cascades into unsettling real territory, with the protagonist being tormented in very real ways, such as being hacked in very shocking and disturbing ways. By the end, the film does such a good job in flipping the entire premise on its head and leaving those watching gasping at the well-earned finale.


8. Terrifier (2016)

Terrifier Art
Dread Central Presents

Now this film must come with a warning as well as a recommendation. This WILL give most viewers nightmares. Everything about Terrifier is just so unsettling and can be compared to watching a man repeatedly getting hit in the unmentionables: no matter how hard you wince, you simply can’t look away.

A slasher through and through, Terrifier follows the vile escapades of Art the Clown, who may earn the title of the harlequin of horror (apologies to the Joker and Pennywise), as he single-handedly murders an apartment building on Halloween.

David Howard Thornton brings an unprecedented amount of energy to this film as he gleefully hacks and slashes his way through a variety of characters. This film pulls no punches and makes the violence of the likes of Saw look like an episode of Treehouse of Horror, as well as making killer clowns like American Horror Story’s Twisty look a little more like Krusty.

For those who want to leave behind the artsy, symbolic horror films that are growing in popularity, Terrifier takes that idea and stabs it until it is nothing but bloody viscera. A real throwback to slashers that paved the way, this ferocious film is sure to leave viewers sick to the stomach with an acute fear of clowns like never before.


7. Upgrade (2018)

Upgrade Logan Marshall Green
BH Tilt

What happens when you combine steampunk action with creeping undertones of the dangers of overreliance of technology? Upgrade happens. Incredibly underrated actor and potential Tom Hardy twin Logan Marshall-Green stars as a technophobic paraplegic, given the chance to walk and take revenge on his cripplers by advanced technology: awesome!

Whilst many would call this a sci-fi revenge flick, the idea of being trapped with your biggest fear, whilst that fear slowly overwhelms you and controls you is enough for it to make its way onto this list. Marshall-Green makes this film worthwhile with a largely unwilling and helpless shell of a man being manipulated by everyone around him, whilst a worried but thrilled audience are forced to watch just as helplessly.

Add in a shady gang and a LOT of violent gore and this film presents itself as a hybrid love letter to the action, sci-fi, horror and steampunk genres, leaving you with 100 minutes of heart-pounding, thrilling film which will leave its fans re-evaluating whether they really need all of those Apple products by the end.


6. Would You Rather (2015)

Would You Rather
Periscope Entertainment

This is another one for all the gore hounds out there. For the fans of Hostel, Saw and Texas Chainsaw Massacre who are searching for another teeth-gritting, cringe-inducing ride on the torture train, Would You Rather has arrived at the station. Brittany Snow trades in her catty ways from Hairspray for a compelling and sympathetic final girl who seeks to win fortune in a twisted game to help her dying brother.

Horror veteran Jeffrey Combs also stars in the “rich psychopathic sadist” role which will have audiences both cringing in disgust and snickering with chuckles through witty dialogue and a scenery-chewing delivery that will really divide viewers between pure hatred and fascinating fixation.

The film builds climactically through different scenarios of the parlour game ‘would you rather’, with a deadly twist. Contestants are forced to stab, shock and beat each other until there is only one. Would You Rather increases the stakes every time you think they are out, destroying the characters they spend the movie developing well one by one, whilst people watching gleefully watch with a hand over their mouths.


5. The Witch (2015)

The Witch
A24

The Witch feels like debuting feature film director Robert Eggers wanted to combine the terrifying setting of The Blair Witch Project, the paranoia of The Thing and the unsettling presence of evil from The Omen. Throw in some creepy kids and you’ve got yourself a cult classic for years to come.

Anya Taylor-Joy, who audiences may know as Michael’s deceitful wife Gina in Peaky Blinders, wonderfully plays the black sheep of the family who becomes ensnared in a slow-burning plot of evil and derangement. Meanwhile, Game of Thrones alumni and gravelly voice enthusiast Ralph Ineson knocks it out of the park as the strapping patriarch trying to keep his family together as petrifying events unfold.

Whilst on its own, the film’s Puritan setting makes it a disquieting period piece, the choice to have the actors speak in archaic English makes the experience more alien for contemporary audiences and thus, builds a far creepier atmopshere. For those patient enough to do a little translation, The Witch gives a bounty of rewards with a refreshed take that breathes maleficent life into the Witch genre.


4. Brightburn (2019)

Brightburn movie
Sony

What if Superman became evil before he hit puberty? Well last year the Gunn family gave grateful horror fanatics a terrifying answer to this nightmarish scenario with the release of Brightburn. Brightburn stars Elisabeth Banks and David Denman in the Ma and Pa Kent roles as conflicted parents raising an alien baby with supernatural abilities (we’ve all been there right?). Meanwhile, Jackson A. Dunn puts the “AAAAA!” in alien with an eerier performance that falls further and further from humanity in every scene.

Brightburn offers its audience a smorgasbord of themes and genres. Whilst primarily being a rare superhero horror akin to the likes of Chronicle, the film is also a slow burning supernatural thriller, as well as partially a coming-of-age drama, where the sinister superboy tries to handle growing up and puberty.

The plot is portrayed as a lit fuse of dynamite, with Dunn going from anger to rage in seconds as he devolves from adorable pre-teen to monstrous pre-teen (although I suppose all teenagers are monstrous). A particularly bleak ending will leave those who hate the hero overcoming the odds in horror feeling satisfied, whilst a well-acted, menacing ninety minutes will leave the rest on the edge of their seat with the covers over their eyes.


3. The Prodigy (2019)

Jackson Robert Scott THE PRODIGY
Orion Pictures

Who doesn’t love a classic killer kid movie every now and then? Well it's likely that a host of new parents might be planning on fleeing the country after this one! The Prodigy stars the adorable Jackson Robert Scott as the titular tyke with a remarkable IQ and a little bit of temper troubles. Fresh off his performance as Georgie in IT (poor little Georgie), Scott once again proves he has the pintsized chops for horror, managing to play a character you want to both cuddle and strangle.

Also,for audiences wanting to see how Piper Chapman would cope dealing with a demon child (no judgement here), then The Prodigy is just the film! Taylor Schilling puts in a great performance as the doting mother, as she pushes the plot forward whilst expertly mixing terror and love towards her evil offspring.

Whilst perhaps not as subtle and artsy as other films on this list, The Prodigy is a great addition to the “my child might be a wrong’un” genre of horror. Seeing the horror slowly unravel into a dark, gory mess whilst more and more is revealed about why this prodigy is becoming such a monster will be sure to keep those watching glued to seats and will have parents bolting bedroom doors shut and fearing children for days.


2. The Invitation (2015)

The Invitation
Drafthouse Films

Whilst it can be found on Netflix, The Invitation isn’t a typical low-budget horror romp to stick on for a cheap scare or to ogle at some gore. The premise of a man and his new girlfriend attending a dinner party at his ex’s house sounds either like my own personal nightmare, a cheesy and depressing new Meet the Parents sequel, or a paint-by-numbers formula to a torture porn palooza. But this unsettling, artistic movie is so much more.

The stellar acting once again from Logan Marshall-Green, who now closely resembles Tom Hardy’s hobo-looking cousin, really helps this film. Through his eyes, The Invitation explores themes of paranoia, guilt, grief and so much more. Meanwhile, a contrasting, upbeat cast creates genuine tension as the slow burn of the movie moves closer and closer and closer towards an assumed and feared marvelous explosion.

Also, for those of a weak disposition who like to hide behind their partners during any suspected jump scares (totally not speaking from experience), then good news! The Invitation has very little if any jump scares, choosing instead to craft unbearable tension through the crescendo of music and eerie silences. Once again, a twist befitting of Shyamalan in his prime leaves a lasting feeling of uneasiness as the credits roll, as only the best horror movies can.


1. Ghost Stories (2017)

Ghost Stories
Warp Films

Finally, the top ten ends with a gem that's probably the best-known horror on this list, at least to UK audiences. Yet despite enjoying a modest box office, Ghost Stories remains unfairly out of the public eye, despite being one of the finest British horror films this century. Based on an equally terrifying play, co-creator Andy Nyman plays a snarky, pessimistic professor who sets out to solve three unsolvable supernatural cases, which play out as three equally spine-chilling short films, before coming together in a jaw-dropping finale.

Interested? Well the film also features the expert and darkly comic performances from Martin Freeman, AKA Bilbo Baggins, and Alex Lawther of End of the F**king World fame. Both Freeman and Lawther excellently chew the scenery in their stories and are part of a wonderful ensemble cast that keep the scares (and laughs) coming a mile a minute.

The flick is a love letter to classic horror, and it shows as the film displays silly humour proudly alongside a chilling atmosphere and a dark, gut-wrenching twist that will left all in its wake gasping and clambering for countless rewatches. However, as with the play, the secrets of Ghost Stories must not be retold, so only those that are brave enough to watch shall truly experience such a masterful horror.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Writer. Quizmaster. Nerd.