10 Things Hollywood Can Learn From The Lone Ranger Flop

the lone ranger poster

Proof that there is some justice in Hollywood, Johnny Depp's latest big-budget star vehicle, The Lone Ranger, is set to become one of the biggest box office bombs in recent years, joining last year's likes of Battleship and John Carter as a testament to the fact that sometimes there are consequences to scarcely-veiled creative bankruptcy. Scoring negatively with critics as well as audiences - scraping 25% on Rotten Tomatoes - there has been much discussion this week regarding what this says about audience trends, Johnny Depp's career, and big-budget filmmaking in general. What's clear above all else is that Hollywood can evidently learn something from the colossal failure of The Lone Ranger. Whether they will or not is another question altogether, but here's a few points to nudge them in the right direction...

10. Johnny Depp In Make-Up Is Not Automatic Box Office Dynamite

lone-ranger-funny Johnny Depp is reported to have made in excess of $300 million from the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise, and given that he's made Jerry Bruckheimer and Disney several billion dollars playing the mega-popular pirate Jack Sparrow - and let's face it, he is almost the sole source of that income - that seems like a pretty sound and fair investment. While Depp took a reported 20% pay-cut to star in The Lone Ranger - as the film's budget was a major point of contention before it was green-lit - it's safe to bet that he was still paid an exorbitant amount to star, and Pirates of the Caribbean is a large part of the reason why. Disney executives no doubt got complacent and assumed that slathering Johnny Depp in make-up and errantly lobbing him into any nascent franchise was enough to guarantee box office dynamite, which has clearly just been proven false. Hell, we need only look at the disappointing returns of Tim Burton's Dark Shadows - which also featured Depp in strange make-up - to see that this is true.

9. Studios Need To Stop Adapting Things Just Because They Exist

It will be of no surprise to anyone but Disney and Bruckheimer that a movie based on a 1930s radio serial and 1950s television show wasn't a huge hit with the youngsters, even with Mr. Depp at the helm. This highlights a wider problem facing studios, that they're run by executives who think that every possible property they can get their mits on needs to be formed into a tentpole summer blockbuster, regardless of whether it suits the summer blockbuster audience or not. For instance, last year's Battleship took a freaking board game and turned it into a movie; audiences clearly realised the crass, desperate cynicism of the project, and swore it off in droves. The point is that studios need to think harder about what they adapt, both whether it's worth doing, and whether it's worth doing with such a massive budget.

8. Nail Down A Good Story Before Green-Lighting A Movie

lone-ranger-feature-horse-ride It should be common sense, but going by the reviews for The Lone Ranger so far, that isn't the case here at all. I can only imagine Jerry Bruckheimer pitching the movie to Disney executives with a few storyboard portraits of Johnny Depp made up as Tonto, and a blank face as the masked Lone Ranger (because screw him, right?), declaring, "It's Depp, what can possibly go wrong, right?" Executives likely ate it up, seeing the truckloads of money Pirates had made them, and wanting to see more of that Depp moolah. Greed likely ended up trumping their desire for a good story, because a) money will make you blind and b) more cynically, executives might have assumed that they didn't need a good story to make tonnes of cash. It's this sort of probable contempt for audiences that makes the film's failure more satisfying to observe; The Lone Ranger flopping is audiences saying to studios, "Try to force-feed us s***, and we're not just going to swallow it and say 'Thanks' anymore".

7. Don't Spend Sequel Money On The First Movie

lone-ranger-action If estimates from the Hollywood press are correct, then The Lone Ranger cost around $375 million to both produce and then market, and more scarily, they suggest that it would need to make around $800 million at the box office just to break even. Allow that figure to sink in for a moment, and then think about how broken that makes the Hollywood studio system seem. More to the point, if the film has cost close to $400 million in total, then there is clearly far too much money being spent on it; in fact, that's the sort of money you should only spend if you're making a sequel to a film that was box office gangbusters, say, a Pirates of the Caribbean sequel. Take comparable blockbuster movies; Transformers cost $150 million to make, and only when it was a tremendous success did Michael Bay get $200 million for the sequel. Similarly, the Pirates sequels were given greater injections of cash when Disney were sure that they had a sound investment on their hands, but with The Lone Ranger, they have essentially budgeted it as another Pirates sequel and been quite poetically stung for their complacency.

6. Forcing Young, New Actors On Us Does Not Work

The Lone Ranger Though Armie Hammer hasn't starred in a whole lot, he proved in David Fincher's sublime The Social Network that he's a very talented young actor, one capable of many great things if he puts his mind to it, something not so much made clear in The Lone Ranger. While the film is marketed almost solely on Depp's appeal, with Hammer spending the movie underneath a mask, would it not have made sense to cast someone a little better known in the role? Instead, it seems like they just selected an interchangeable young actor who isn't too recognised they could pay a low salary to just to fill the gap, while affording Depp's considerably larger pay-day. This isn't to say that casting a better-known young actor in a more strongly-written role would have resulted in a more successful box office yield, but Hell, it surely couldn't have hurt, no? Instead, taking a talented young actor on the rise, dumping him in a crap role and expecting him to flourish is just a fail waiting to happen.

5. Westerns Are Not Popular Anymore

Cowboys and Aliens The Western genre is that one that everyone's dad loves, but it's never exactly been solid gold at the box office, largely because youngsters dismiss them as "boring", as a result of seeing their dads watching them on TV every Sunday afternoon. However, even when hip young actors like Will Smith take on the genre, it's still proven to be a disaster; who can forget the execrable critical and commercial failure that was 1999's Wild Wild West? More recent examples fare no better; Casa de Mi Padre, Cowboys & Aliens and Jonah Hex were all victims of the critical and box office chopping blocks, and the only Western movies that seem to succeed are those coming from auteurs like the Coen Brothers (True Grit) and Quentin Tarantino (Django Unchained). The clear message is this; unless you've got a very distinct, singular vision with a top-notch cast, it's best not to bother.

4. Johnny Depp Is A Talented Actor, But He Is Also Extremely Lazy

Dark Shadows By Johnny Depp's own recent admission, the guy keeps taking blockbuster roles simply because they're there, and he's doing it for the money, to ensure that his kids are well looked after. While one can't blame the guy taking care of the homestead first, with $300 million to his name just from the Pirates films, is he surely not there by now? That isn't to say Depp should stop making movies, but Jesus, could he not put a little more thought into the projects he accepts? As was made painfully apparent in Dark Shadows, Depp has essentially become a tired comedian performing a rote routine that people are sick of watching, and he himself seems to have lost a lot of enthusiasm for. To say that this feeling is replicated in The Lone Ranger is an absolute understatement. The guy is a fantastic actor when he wants to be; it just seems that he hasn't been keen to stretch himself in quite some time.

3. Don't Insult The Source Material You're Adapting

When adapting classic source material, one of the foremost tenets is to ensure that you're sufficiently respectful of the source material; otherwise, what on Earth is the point? This is clearly not a message The Lone Ranger has taken on board, because as several prominent critics have noted, it is a film that is sorely embarrassed of its heritage, seeking to admonish and excuse its own goofiness at every opportunity possible. For example, at the end of the film, Tonto calls The Lone Ranger out for sayng "Hi, ho Silver, away!", requesting that he never say it again. Though Tonto's retort is supposed to be funny, it just indicates that rather than update the story for a new generation, this movie is just keen to poke fun at the very thing it's trying to make money off. The way to do this is to be reverent to the material while making fun of it; take last year's The Muppets, which thoroughly noted how dated the puppets were, but managed to update them to a contemporary audience without actively mocking the spirit of Jim Henson's creations.

2. Animation Will Always Trounce Live-Action At The Box Office

despicable me 2_edited-1 Despicable Me 2 had already opened internationally prior to its US bow on July 3rd, but that didn't prevent it from posting the third-highest opening day ever for an animated film in the US, opening to #1 its first weekend, and in five days pulling in a stunning $143.1 million, the highest-ever five-day start for an animated movie. By comparison, The Lone Ranger, opening on the very same day, grossed merely $48.9 million, around a third of that figure, despite having roughly three-times the budget. The lesson? Don't put your expensive tentpole movie up against animated fare, because animated films very, very rarely result in box office disaster, even when they underwhelm. A property such as Despicable Me was guaranteed to make huge bank, and while Disney were certainly limited as to where they could place the film - they had competition from World War Z behind them and Pacific Rim ahead of them - it might have been smarter to just push the film forward or back drastically until a slot opened up.

1. A Long Runtime Does Not Indicate Quality

Hobbit Of course, length should never in of itself be an indicator of a movie's quality, though The Lone Ranger is a movie that is both excruciating to watch and extremely distended as it unfolds. While the majority of the summer's blockbusters will cruise over the 2-hour mark, did The Lone Ranger really feel itself so full of prize material that it couldn't possibly be a minute under 149 minutes? Did the film really need to be just a few minutes short of Zero Dark Thirty? I doubt many audience members feel like they need an excessively long film just to justify their buying a cinema ticket; after all, do we not all prefer quality rather than quantity? Further still, I can guarantee that the movie's critical reception would have been more forgiving with a lean 100 minute runtime, and of course, this would have allowed cinemas to show a few more screenings of the film per day, likely increasing its gross also. Have you seen The Lone Ranger yet? Let us know what you think in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Frequently sleep-deprived film addict and video game obsessive who spends more time than is healthy in darkened London screening rooms. Follow his twitter on @ShaunMunroFilm or e-mail him at shaneo632 [at] gmail.com.