10 Things MCU Phase 3 Must Avoid (And Why)

Will Captain America come out?

Captain America Gay Shield
Marvel Studios

The release of Captain America: Civil War of course signaled the beginning of the Marvel Cinematic Universe's Phase 3, which will include movies featuring Doctor Strange, the Guardians of the Galaxy, Spider-Man, Thor, Black Panther, Ant-Man and Captain Marvel, before culminating in the 2019 Infinity War finale.

As successful as the MCU is, it's certainly not without its share of problems, from compromises made to appeal to a wide audience to nagging technical issues and flat-out lazy screenwriting.

With Phase 3 being by far the most ambitious and crucial stage of the franchise yet, Marvel Studios would do well to ensure that they don't repeat their past mistakes and make this the most robust, laser-focused era of the mammoth series to date. 

If they pull it off, they'll continue their streak of critical acclaim and insane box office grosses, not to mention have fans salivating for the inevitable Phase 4.

Here are 10 things MCU Phase 3 must avoid...

10. Too Much Humour

Captain America Avengers Age of Ultron language
Marvel Studios

One thing that last year's Age of Ultron made clear is that quipping in the Marvel Cinematic Universe had reached its breaking point, to the extent that numerous characters basically ended up sounding like the same Joss Whedon archetype.

The jokes were delivered in a rushed, perfunctory manner in-between action beats that felt massively forced and detracted from audience involvement in the set-pieces themselves.

Thankfully the Russo brothers have proven with the latter two Captain America movies that they can deliver entertaining, successful movies without so much comedy, so it seems that the Infinity War saga at least shouldn't suffer from these issues.

The comic tone suits films like Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 and Spider-Man: Homecoming much better and those two should really be the comedic backbone of Phase 3.

Doctor Strange and Black Panther in particular will hopefully play things a little more straight, while Thor: Ragnarok can find a comfortable middle ground, considering it's a buddy movie starring Thor and The Hulk.


9. Giving Away Spoilers In The Trailer

Captain America Civil War Bucky shoots Tony Stark
Marvel

The last two Captain America movies sadly both gave away crucial plot points in their trailers: a shot of Nick Fury from late in the movie made it pretty clear that he wasn't dead, and Civil War sneaked in a glimpse of Bucky's severed arm.

If Phase 3 could tone down the heavy spoilers in its marketing campaigns, that'd be great. It takes away the thrill of realising these things for ourselves, and spoiling them in the trailers did absolutely nothing for the movie's PR anyway. These shots could've been removed and their box office success would be exactly the same.

Infinity War in particular needs to play it cool, considering how crucial it'll be for the future of the MCU, though it's much more likely that Doctor Strange and Black Panther will give too much away considering how "risky" they are as solo projects.


8. More Mediocre Villains

Ronan The Accuser
Marvel Studios

The MCU has had a villain problem for quite some time now, with Phase 2's Malekith, Ronan and Yellowjacket proving especially underwhelming.

The primary issue is that these villains are so easily outclassed and out-charmed by the hero that they're just not very entertaining to watch: the better MCU baddies, such as Loki and Red Skull, have larger-than-life personalities that make them tremendously entertaining to watch.

At least Phase 3 is off to a good start with its first villain, Civil War's Helmut Zemo. Flying in the face of rogue AIs and aliens, he's a mere human being with a simple (if slightly convoluted) plan, one that he pulls off no less.

While we'll hopefully see more of Zemo sometime down the line, Phase 3 does at least have some promising baddies waiting in the wings: Mads Mikkelsen's sorcerer villain in Doctor Strange, Guardians 2 is rumoured to have Ayesha, Spider-Man: Homecoming may have The Vulture, Thor: Ragnarok has Cate Blanchett's Hela, Black Panther may have Andy Serkis' Ulysses Klaue, and of course, Infinity War has the main event himself, Thanos.

In short, Phase 3 would have to make so many catastrophic mistakes to repeat Phase 2's villain problem.


7. Bad Cinematography & Editing

Black Widow Fight
Marvel

Pretty much ever since the MCU first kicked off, it's had a bit of an issue with visuals: Marvel Studios insist on a "house style" for most of their movies which prevents the directors from placing much of an individual stamp or personality on their movies.

The worst offenders by far are The Avengers and Ant-Man, which boast flat cinematography and basically look like high-budget TV episodes.

Then there's Civil War, which looks decent enough in terms of cinematography but suffers from horrifically poor editing, such that the opening fight scene in Lagos is at times near-incomprehensible, especially during Black Widow's action.

The camera's high shutter speed is an attempt by the Russos to eliminate motion blur, but it unfortunately causes frames to "bleed" into one another and can be irritating or headache-inducing to many viewers.

While Civil War's iconic airport sequence thankfully didn't suffer from the same issues, it's still a tad concerning moving forward, especially in terms of Infinity War, which the Russos will of course direct.


6. Reducing The Stakes Of Death

Agent Coulson Avengers Death
Marvel Studios

Much has been written about the controversial decision to bring S.H.I.E.L.D. agent Phil Coulson back from the dead after Loki killed him in The Avengers, resurrected in the TV series Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.

Marvel Studios were at least smart enough to appreciate the issues it would cause in the movies, and so have ensured to keep him in the TV show and not even remotely reference him in the movies. As such, those who only watch the films can happily create their own "head-canon" where Coulson is still dead.

However, in a broader sense, this does reduce the stakes and emotional impact of death, which is already something of a problem when you're dealing with supernatural characters like Thor, who can die but also be returned to life.

Sure, Quicksilver appeared to die for real in Age of Ultron, but shockingly not a single Avenger died in Civil War, and after a point it's necessary in order to sell the stakes of all this fighting.

Still, Phase 3 has a ton of opportunities to remedy this, especially with Thanos wreaking havoc in Infinity War and almost certainly killing at least a few Avengers when he gets the fully-loaded Infinity Gauntlet.

If Cap dies, as many suspect, hopefully he'll stay dead and allow Bucky to take up the Cap mantle, but don't be surprised if Cap is resurrected with one of the Infinity Stones...because magic!


5. Shoehorned Romantic Subplots

hulk black widow
Marvel Studios

Yes, these movies are Hollywood blockbusters so of course the studio executives believe that women won't see them without a romantic subplot, but when these films are cranking out an easy billion dollars a pop, aren't we kinda past that?

The most risible romances to date are unquestionably Thor and Jane Foster and The Hulk and Black Widow, while the few that really worked were Tony Stark and Pepper Potts, and Cap and Peggy Carter.

In fairness, Phase 3 has a lot of potential for more gooey romance we don't want: Doctor Strange and Rachel McAdams' surgeon character, Thor and Valkyrie, and Black Panther and Lupita Nyong'o's character.

Hopefully Marvel will learn their lesson, but it's really, really not necessary for these movies to have any romance whatsoever. They just waste screen time and feel cynically forced into the whole.


4. Endless Collateral Damage Debates

Captain America Civil War Iron Man Tony Stark Chris Evans
Marvel

Civil War did an admittedly fantastic job debating the nature of heroism in the "real world", where no matter how careful superheroes are, human collateral damage is an inevitability.

That said, with both Batman v Superman and Civil War broaching the subject this summer, aren't we as viewers just feeling a little bit fed up of it?

There's a point where the debate just feels tacked-on for its own sake in order to imply "depth", but it's been done well, and now would be a time to move on from it.

If Infinity War in particular is accompanied by extensive debates about Thanos' destruction and The Avengers role in "provoking" it, then it's going to feel pretty damn tired and played out.

It's been done, now let's move on and keep things fun and interesting.


3. Killing Off Loki

Thor: The Dark World Loki death
Disney

Considering that Thor: Ragnarok is widely expected to be Loki's final appearance in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, many suspect that he will be killed off in the film, most likely sacrificing himself to save Thor and/or The Hulk (the latter of which would be an amusingly ironic turn of events).

Likely though this is, it'd be a major mistake to kill off easily the most entertaining villain in the MCU to date, not to mention a character who is decidedly more compelling than most of The Avengers themselves.

He brings so much wit and delicious villainy to the table, and it feels Loki really should be one of those characters who is never killed, but merely re-appears every so often to cause mayhem.

Even if he doesn't die, though, should he in fact end up cast as the next James Bond, that'll likely signal the end of the character anyway...short of a re-casting (which would be even worse).


2. Turning Captain America Gay

Captain America Gay
Marvel Studos

There has been a significant campaign in recent weeks for Captain America to come out as gay in a future movie, with the hashtag #givecaptainamericaaboyfriend picking up significant traction online.

The call for pop-culture as a whole to feature more LGBT characters is certainly noble and reasonable, but to transform a pre-existing character's sexual identity? It would seem forced and even token to do so.

This stems from a general recent phenomena where, thanks to the likes of Twitter and Instagram, audiences feel more closely connected to the creators of their preferred art. This gives them a certain sense of entitlement, that they are free to request changes to the material rather than merely accept the art as it is or simply not pour money into it.

It's just a matter of time before we get a major gay superhero on-screen, as we should, but giving Captain America a boyfriend would feel majorly shoehorned. Plus, most of the hetero romances in the MCU are already pretty terrible, and we really don't need more of this fantasy shipper nonsense.


1. Making Infinity War Overcrowded

Avengers Infinity War
Marvel Studios

The biggest challenge above all else will be ensuring that the Infinity War saga isn't a crowded mess of characters, plot-lines and set-pieces.

Considering that the film will reportedly deal with almost 70 characters, the Russos have a lot to cram on the screen, and making the various dialogues and set-pieces work without it seeming slapdash will take an incredible amount of effort and patience.

It's most likely that the various subsets of heroes will be compartmentalised into smaller battles, such that we probably won't get to see much of the Guardians of the Galaxy hanging out with the mainline Avengers team. Plus, if Civil War is anything to go by, the Avengers themselves are already conveniently already split into two teams, ready to go for Infinity War.

It's certainly not impossible, but the odds are definitely for it feeling at least a little cluttered. As ever, we'll have to wait and see.

What must MCU Phase 3 avoid? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.