10 Things You Need To Know About Tim Burton's Superman Lives
You would have believed Nic Cage could fly. Tim Allen, less so.
If it seemed like the Dark Knight was a poisoned chalice for a good decade or so after Joel Schumacher drove him into the ground with the camp-tastic Batman & Robin, spare a thought for the Man Of Tomorrow. There were eight years separating that monstrosity and Christopher Nolan's rebooted Batman Begins and there are nearly twenty years between Superman IV: The (inexplicably low-budget) Quest For Peace and Bryan Singer's Superman Returns.
Not that there weren't attempts to get Clark Kent back off the ground in the meantime. In fact, once Burton had been shunted off of Batman in favour of Schumacher (abandoning plans for an end to his own trilogy), Warner Bros placated him with a pay-or-play deal on a Superman movie. Which meant even if it didn't get made, he'd still be paid.
Superman Lives, or Superman Reborn, or whatever you want to call it, was obviously never made. Which is a great shame, because it sounded absolutely insane. You want to see the Man Of Steel wrestling with polar bears for no real reason? You got it. The most bonkers casting of Superman ever? Sure thing? A gay R2-D2? Apparently that was in the mix.
Of all the late, great unmade superhero films, this one has to be up there if not as the most missed opportunity, then at least the most straight-up bonkers.
Here are ten things you need to know about Tim Burton's Superman...
10. Nicolas Cage Was Going To Star
So right up top, that's a pretty crazy idea to get your head around, right? Cage is known for a style of acting which he calls "Nouveau Shamanic" and everyone else calls chewing every single piece of scenery in sight, crapping it out, then eating it again, all whilst with eyes open wide and manic grin plastered over his face.
Sounds like the guy to play the heroic, clean-cut Superman, no? Well, apparently Cage is quite the Superman fan. No, really: his house is covered in memorabilia related to the Man Of Steel, and he even went so far as to call one of his sons Kal-El, after Superman's Kryptonian birth name, and was grief-stricken to part with his copy of Action Comics #1, the character's first appearance, when a few years ago he needed a cash-injection.
Reportedly Cage impressed with his costume tests, which had him styled after the mid-nineties mulleted Superman. He wasn't the weirdest name in the hat, mind: one producer's first pick for the role? Sean Penn. Another classically heroic-looking figure.
9. Batman Might Have Made A Cameo
Believe it or not, Warner Bros. had the earliest glimmerings of a Shared Cinematic Universe a good twenty years before Marvel had even begun to consider such a thing.
Joel Schumacher's aborted third Batman film would've connected to Burton's first two, totally different takes on the Dark Knight by attempting to coax Jack Nicholson back for a cameo as The Joker.
Superman Lives would've taken it a step further, with Burton allegedly eager to bring his old mucker Michael Keaton in for a brief appearance, either in his civvies as Bruce Wayne or else as Batman himself.
Could even the largest multiplex have been able to hold the twin titanic personalities (and broad acting styles) of Keaton as Batman and Cage as Superman?
8. It Was The Death And Return Of Superman
From the looks of things the Man Of Steel could've used all the help he could get in Burton's film, with the majority of the draft scripts (of which there were numerous) mainly drawing upon the recent Death Of Superman storyline. Yep, in a cynical attempt to boost sales...erm, to tell an interesting, bold new story, DC killed off their biggest character for a few months in the nineties.
Obviously he came back eventually, with more readers than ever jumping on board with the resurrected Superman. The media circus surrounding the event was unprecedented, and Warner Bros obviously wanted to ride that wave of interest into making Superman Lives an even bigger deal than a Superman movie already would be.
So, Burton's film would almost certainly have involved Doomsday, the alien killing machine designed specifically to murder Superman with his bare hands. i.e. - exactly what happened in Batman vs Superman: Dawn Of Justice.
7. Some Versions Involved Superman's Baby
You can see the embryonic beginnings of Bryan Singer's Superman Returns even as early as the very first Superman V: Reborn script, again based loosely on The Death Of Superman, which opened with an insecure Clark Kent unable to admit his feelings for the tragically human Lois Lane.
Just when he's about to proclaim his love for her (and reveal his secret identity), Doomsday shows up and kills him. In this version of the film, Superman's soul would've entered Lois's body after his death, giving birth to his child just a few days later, with the kid growing into the body of a 21-year-old man within the space of three weeks to take the part of the reborn Superman. And then Lois dies. Yeah.
The final draft, by Dan Gilroy, again involved Lois Lane pregnant by Superman, albeit in a much more traditional, less insane manner. Which is about where Superman Returns picked up, a good decade or so later. Not that the pair could conceivably have unprotected sex, as this scene from Mallrats explains.
6. Kevin Smith Wrote A Draft Of The Script
The Mallrats scene is what Kevin Smith believes got him not only in the room to discuss the Superman Lives script, but a crack at writing his own.
The director of nerd comedies like Clerks and Mallrats doesn't seem like the most natural fit for a multi-million dollar superhero blockbuster and he's since admitted as such. He's also admitted that his script was mostly an attempt to return Superman to some of his more classic comic book storylines and characteristics, despite the best attempts of producer Jon Peters to derail it.
Amongst other things, he introduced the idea of Superman flying not as a dude on wires against back-projection, but as a lightning-fast "red blur", like in Frank Miller's The Dark Knight Returns. At times Smith's treatment was a little too faithful to the source material, but it still did a pretty good job at covering all the bases.
The origin story was revisited, it introduced some major villains, Lois and Clark were together and she knew his secret identity, the death was still in there but handled better, and there were cameos for both Batman and Deadshot.
5. Braniac Was The Main Villain...
In both Smith's take on it and the eventual film that Tim Burton was developing, Braniac was the principal antagonist. The villain has blighted Superman in various forms in the comics over the years, but has yet to appear in a live-action movie, possibly because it's hard to pare down exactly which of the hyper-intelligent extraterrestrial android supervillain they want to go with.
Most versions of Superman Lives involved Braniac not only blotting out the sun over Metropolis (which, besides being a plot of Mr Burns's from The Simpsons, would've robbed Superman of his source of power), but then releasing Doomsday himself to kill the Man Of Steel whilst he was week. Which is pretty hardcore!
And, obviously, the freak-sympathetic Burton wanted to play up the similarities between the alien hero and villain. Some versions also had Braniac responsible for the destruction of Krypton, kinda like how Burton's Batman had the pre-disfiguring Joker as the one who shot Bruce Wayne's parents.
Weirdest of all is the casting choice for Braniac, reportedly the wholesome Tim Allen. As in, the voice of Buzz Lightyear. As in, The Santa Clause. As in, Home Improvement. What?!
4. ...Alongside Lex Luthor
Thankfully, it didn't look like Tim Allen was going to be left with all the heavy lifting, villainy-wise. In fact there's more similarities between this aborted project and the eventual Superman Returns, with Kevin Spacey in line as the favourite to play Lex Luthor as early as Tim Burton's take on the Man Of Steel.
Considering he killed it in Returns (he was the best thing about it), this was the one inspired bit of casting the film had. Having Luthor playing second fiddle to Braniac was an interesting move.
In most of the Christopher Reeve Superman films Gene Hackman's antagonist was similarly behind the scenes, manipulating other, more powerful enemies to do his bidding i.e, to eradicate the Man Of Tomorrow. So again, in most versions of the Superman Lives script it's Luthor whose space probe invites Braniac down to Earth, on the basis that the supervillain wants some Kryptonian battery or another for some reason, and Superman's his best shot.
Eventually they double cross each other...except in Burton's script, where they eventually merge into a single entity dubbed "Luthiac". Which would have been awful.
3. Also, Braniac Had A Gay Robot Sidekick
Oh yeah, Braniac doesn't get let off that easily. Not only would he have been played by Tim Allen, but apparently Jon Peters...yep, that weirdo producer again, who got his start in the movie business because he was Barbara Streisand's hairdresser and allegedly, was also insistent that the main villain of Superman Lives needed a comedy sidekick. And that he would be like a gay R2-D2.
This was right around the time Kevin Smith had been brought on to write a treatment for the film, which involved numerous meetings with Peters. To hear Smith tell it, Peters is a crazy person...
After seeing Smith's film Chasing Amy, the producer took a shine to Dwight Ewell's character - a militant, black, gay, comic book creator. Peters decided they needed something like that in Superman Lives, and asked Smith to write in such a sidekick to Braniac, with Ewell in line to voice the robotic L-Ron.
Oh and after seeing the re-released Star Wars, Peters also insisted on a Chewbacca-style shaggy dog for the pair, too, which could make a great toy.
2. The Producer Insisted On A Giant Spider
Peters was far from done with his list of demands. Whilst Burton's and Gilroy's eventual drafts threw out a lot of what Kevin Smith had put in his script at the behest of the producer, they were still there for a little while, expected to be integral parts of Superman Lives. He said there needed to be an action beat every ten pages, and some of his ideas were...interesting.
For one, Peters decided that a visit to Superman's Arctic base the Fortress Of Solitude needed a fight scene. His HQ wouldn't be totally undefended, would it? So when Braniac and L-Ron show up to find the supposedly deceased Superman, they have to fight a couple of polar bears who, in Peters' opinion, were the fiercest killers in the animal kingdom.
Also, there needed to be a bit where Superman fought a giant spider because, in Peters' opinion, they were the fiercest killers in the insect kingdom.
Smith wrote the scene with the monster in question, apparently meant to recall King Kong as a a "Thanagarian Snare Beast".
Fun note: Jon Peters later produced Wild Wild West. Whose climactic scene involves...a giant spider.
1. There's A Documentary About The Whole Thing
The whole saga of Jon Peters' involvement in the project is weird enough as it is (he also insisted audiences don't see Superman fly, and he never wears a costume either, since both apparently looked faggy). But that's just a small part of Superman Lives, one of the strangest unproduced blockbusters in the history of Hollywood. Which is what made The Death Of Superman Lives such an exciting release.
Funded through Kickstarter a couple of years ago, this documentary interviews basically everyone involved in the project Tim Burton, Nicolas Cage, Kevin Smith, even comic book writer Grant Morrison to try and figure out what the hell happened.
There's also a whole cache of previously unseen preproduction art and costume tests. Seriously, there is nothing weirder than Superman Lives.