10 Things You Learn Rewatching Halloween (2007)
Rob Zombie's attempt to re-imagine John Carpenter's original vision.
Following the fallout of the atrocity that was Halloween: Resurrection, it looked as though Michael Myers may have finally truly met his end. In the early 2000s, the franchise was practically dead with no clear future in sight for it.
This lead to Dimension feeling that the best thing for the franchise was a completely clean slate, a new start. And thus, in 2007, a remake of the original Halloween was released. Directed by shock-horror auteur Rob Zombie, the film opened to big box office success (and a fairly positive reception from the general public) but to little acclaim from fans or critics.
They despised it, claiming that Zombie's film took the hallowed original and turned into a straight-to-DVD slasher flick that was entirely unremarkable. Since then, Zombie released a director's cut and has made it pretty much impossible for anyone to get their hands on the theatrical cut ever again (which is why this rewatch centers around said director's cut).
With Blumhouse's new film growing closer by the day, Zombie's remake is set to become a relic of a long-lost era, forgotten sooner rather than later. But does it deserve this fate? Is it the harmful rehash that many say it is or is it an underappreciated gem? Let's find out...
10. Wants To Have Its Cake And Eat It Too
When Rob Zombie initially went into meetings with Dimension and the Weinsteins about writing and directing a new Halloween film, he had two separate pitches in mind. One was a prequel to Halloween, exploring Michael's childhood and his years spent at Smith's Grove Sanitarium, and the other was a straight remake of the original film.
Ultimately, the studio chose the more bankable idea of just remaking the original. However, during the writing process, Zombie began to experiment with incorporating elements from his prequel pitch into the remake's narrative and resulted in the finished film being a combination of the two. This juxtaposition between the new and the old is a conflict that the film can never really resolve.
Halloween 2007 simultaneously wants to be a completely different beast from the original and a worthy remake. Once it gets to the second half of the film where Michael is an adult, lines, moments, and even entire setpieces from the John Carpenter classic are copied verbatim.
At the very least, Zombie seems to be on cloud nine during the early sequences of young Michael. It is blindingly obvious that that is the film he would have rather made, and he practically said as much on several different occasions during interviews.
Thus, when the film segues into the remake portion of its runtime, it just feels like Zombie is trudging through it because it's what the studio is actually paying him to do. It's a film that wants viewers to be in awe of Michael's radical new origin story while simultaneously expecting them to go nuts over some of the most blatant and in-your-face 'here's a line you know!' fan service ever put to screen.
9. The Music Is Hit-and-Miss
With Rob Zombie at the helm of this film, there was plenty of reason to be a bit fearful of what exactly would happen to the score. Zombie infamously first rose to fame as the lead singer of the heavy metal band White Zombie. Once he became a filmmaker, he kept a similarly heavy and grimy musical aesthetic for his films. On his first film, House of 1000 Corpses, Zombie handled the music himself. Even when he handed the duties over to Tyler Bates on his next film, The Devil's Rejects, he remained heavily involved in the recording process.
When he was hired for the Halloween remake, Dimension confirmed that he would "write, direct, produce, and serve as music supervisor" alongside now-frequent collaborator Tyler Bates, which made it sound all-but-certain that Carpenter's iconic Halloween themes would be getting some very drastic make-overs once again.
And they did.
But miraculously, the film frequently opts to keep things simple. Several times throughout, such as the first uses of the Halloween Theme or Laurie's Theme, it is Carpenter's original recordings instead of Tyler Bates' new ones. Once the film gets into the second and third act, viewers can hear more of Bates' score, which essentially just takes Carpenter's themes and layers on tons of ambiance and feedback noise.
So when the film busts out the original score, it is surprisingly effective. However, the longer the film drags on, the more frequent and grating Bates and Zombie's attempts at re-inventing the score become.
8. Zombie's Heavy Hand
Let's be frank; a man who calls himself Rob Zombie is never exactly going to be one for subtlety. From the very opening of this film, Zombie's heavy-handed tendencies get the best of him and nearly strangle his creation to death in its infancy.
In an effort to make Michael "scary again", Zombie spends the first act exploring Michael's troubled childhood. And in an attempt to make it "more real" (Zombie's words), he gives Micahel a broken home that helps inspire his acts of madness.
The problem is Zombie goes so overboard with this broken home that it practically turns into self-parody. His family's house is in shambles, his mother is a stripper, his sister is the school whore, and his mother's live-in boyfriend is overtly abusive.
A regular day at the Myers house begins with cursing profusely at and throwing dishes at each other, apparently.
This and the subsequent explorations of Michael's murderous exploits in this first act (read: killing animals and beating Juni Cortez to death with a tree branch) come off as dime-store psychology at best. Zombie is never content to let implications or subtext do any of the work for him, instead opting to bash the audience's brains in with how on-the-nose all of this is and it is to his own film's detriment.
There's an argument to be made for whether or not telling the story of Michael's youth is even a worthwhile exploit but in Zombie's hands, all of this never even gets a chance to get off the ground before becoming obnoxiously hamfisted.
7. Danny Trejo Continues To Be An International Treasure
If there's one actor who serves as the bright spot of this entire film, it's Danny Trejo. An international treasure for decades now, Trejo has remained a remarkable character actor who does the best he can with bit roles, often elevating entire films in the process. This film is no different.
Trejo's role as Ismael Cruz, one of the head guards at Smith's Grove, is easily Zombie's best addition to the entire narrative. In a film bursting at the seems with absurdly unlikable characters, Trejo's Ismael is sympathetic and endearing as he becomes Michael's only friend in the sanitarium.
Sure, in theory, Ismael is just a one-dimensional stereotype whose kindness is just a cheap ploy on Zombie's part to strengthen the gut-punch impact of when Michael later murders him (as Zombie literally has him repeatedly say "I was good to you", again displaying all the subtlety of a hormonal teenager).
But in execution, Trejo makes it so much more. His screentime may be brief but he sells every second of this performance and quickly becomes the most compelling character of the entire film. Even the aforementioned death scene carries a certain heft to it specifically because of how endearing Trejo makes Ismael.
Timelines be damned; Trejo's Ismael should absolutely make an appearance in one of Blumhouse's future Halloween films because he deserves better than this.
6. Malcolm McDowell's Dr. Loomis Is A Dick
Straight-up: recasting Dr. Loomis and Laurie Strode was always going to be this movie's biggest obstacle.
In the case of Dr. Loomis, it was always going to be especially hard to find someone who could embody the role without just coming off as an imitation of Donald Pleasence's iconic work. And honestly, Zombie could have done a lot worse than Malcolm McDowell.
McDowell brings the energy and vigor to Loomis that has been a staple of his career ever since his breakout role in Kubrick's A Clockwork Orange. Approaching it from a completely different angle than Pleasence, McDowell's take on the character would be worthwhile, if he only had a half-decent scene in the entire script.
When it's just McDowell spinning his wheels he's fascinating but when he's doing anything central to the narrative, it's a slog. Zombie's script turns Loomis from heroic monster-hunter to fame-hungry dick looking to make a quick buck off of the Myers family's tragedy. Even when other characters in the film like Sherriff Brackett attempt to call him out on it, Zombie's script always comes down in favor of Loomis treating him as if he's still some hero.
But he isn't.
Whereas Pleasence's Loomis spent the night Michael escaped attempting to hunt him down all throughout Haddonfield, McDowell's Loomis just sits around in the police station. The end result is an infinitely more passive version of the character whose final stand against Michael rings completely hollow and leaves McDowell's performance with a whole lot of gas but nowhere to go.
5. Prioritizes Surprise Over Suspense
If you've been following these Halloween retrospectives for any amount of time, you know that we often return to the godfather of horror cinema himself, Alfred Hitchcock, and his explanation of surprise versus suspense. In short, Hitchcock surmised that a shock gave the audience "fifteen seconds of surprise" while a sequence of suspense that built upon the audience's knowledge of the situation provided "fifteen minutes of suspense".
John Carpenter learned a lot from Hitchcock and his original Halloween is one of the most iconic horror films precisely because of how it weaponizes suspense. The way in which Carpenter crafted these sequences of suspense was flat-out masterful and revolutionized horror cinema for decades to come.
Rob Zombie, on the other hand, did not learn these lessons from Hitchcock. He is a filmmaker infatuated with shock, who salivates over surprise and this becomes frustrating. In every single instance, Zombie chooses to go for the easiest possible shock rather than building anything of greater substance.
Take, for instance, Bob's death scene. In Carpenter's film, the sequence was prolonged and charged with tension, using subtle sound design and Dean Cundey's long-takes to put the audience in the moment, feeling the suspense build. Thus, when Michael finally shows up, it's a pay-off that capitalizes on several minutes of build-up.
In Zombie's film, the suspense is gone. The film cuts back-and-forth between Bob's beer run and several other scenes, consistently taking the audience out of the moment. It then just abruptly cuts to a shot of Bob walking down the hallway and Michael jumping out to stab him. There's no build-up, no suspense, just a baseless shock that leaves little-to-no-impact.
When a film consistently returns to surprise and shock as its only method of generating tension or a reaction, it wears thin incredibly quickly. Yet, Zombie continuously returns to the same tricks over and over again.
4. A Poor Man's Laurie Strode
Jamie Lee Curtis' performance as Laurie Strode in the original Halloween isn't just great, it is iconic. In her debut role, Curtis was able to capture both the innocence and strength of the character, simultaneously, and it made her a movie star in the process.
This film replaces Curtis, with Scout Taylor-Compton taking over the Laurie Strode role, and the results are not good. To be fair, Taylor-Compton is at an immediate disadvantage in a number of ways. For starters, she's attempting to follow-up Curtis' stellar work and that's a tall order. More importantly, whereas Carpenter's original film introduced Laurie in the first act and allowed Curtis the time to grow and develop her character across the film, Zombie's film doesn't even introduce audiences to Laurie until midway through the film.
To top it all off, Zombie's writing of the character is atrocious. He doesn't understand what made Laurie an iconic character in the first place. Whereas Carpenter had the assistance of the eternally badass Debra Hill on the original film, to write convincing and naturalistic dialogue for Laurie and her friends, Zombie does not. His dialogue in these sequences is strained at best.
At the time of this film's release, Zombie was asked if he intentionally cut out Laurie's closet scene from the original film's climax and what role its exclusion played into the character's reading via feminist theory in this film, to which Zombie responded;
"Yeah, no. I never even thought about that."
This film's version of Laurie Strode isn't Laurie Strode. Scout Taylor-Compton could be playing any nameless final girl and it wouldn't have made a difference. But the blame cannot fall solely on Taylor-Compton's limp performance, as Zombie's writing never gave her much of a chance in the first place.
3. It Over-Explains Everything
In the lead up to the theatrical release of this film, Zombie infamously stated that one of the biggest changes he'd made to the core story was that Michael Myers wouldn't know how to drive in this film. As he would go on to state;
"That always bothered me. They would always play that off like someone must have given him lessons, but you know no one gave him lessons! He's in a maximum-security prison! So, no, he doesn't drive."
So instead of hijacking a car and driving to Haddonfield from Smith's Grove, Michael walks the full hundred miles between the two points over the course of fewer than twenty-four hours. See the issue here? In attempting to 'fix' something about the original, Zombie over-explained it and only dug himself deeper.
This happens a lot throughout the film because, again, Zombie is not one for subtlety. Everything from where Loomis bought his gun, how Michael chose that mask and knife, how Michael got the jumpsuit, how Michael learned to 'look past the walls' and become silent is given a backstory. All of it plays out in excruciating detail that harm the film rather than helping it.
These over explanations don't add anything of note, they're just awkwardly jammed into the narrative and frequently bring the entire film's momentum screeching to a halt. All in the name of indulging Zombie's fan fiction fixes.
2. A Nothing Of A Finale
The film's final sequence is one of the worst in the franchise's history.
Eschewing the original ending of Laurie and Michael's showdown at the Doyle house, this film sees Michael kidnapping Laurie and taking her back to the Myers house. It's clearly Zombie attempting to go the extra mile for the film but it simply doesn't work.
The ensuing chase sequence is nonsensical and feels as if it's taking place in a constantly in-flux location. Despite all the time the film spends at the Myers house, the geography is never clearly established thanks to Zombie's aversion to wide shots. This, along with the hand-held camera aesthetic and a choppy edit, results in a finale that is nigh impossible to follow and is severely lacking clarity.
The audience is left to guess where Laurie is in relation to Michael a lot of the time. On top of this, the sequence consistently falls back on jump scares and camera angles that only serve to further disorientate and confuse.
It all just becomes noise and neuters what should have been an emotionally-charged finale. But instead of focusing on character dynamics or offering some sort of completion to his narrative, Zombie just goes for cheap shocks once again and leaves audiences dangling on one of the most incoherent "cliff-hangers" in horror movie history.
1. In Summary
Rob Zombie's Halloween is a misfire of a film. It has the heavy burden of being the first Halloween film since the original sequel that actively invites comparisons to Carpenter's original and it can never even begin to stand on its own because of it.
There are some solid ideas and intriguing creative choices sprinkled throughout that offer glimpses of the better film this could have been, but they are few and far between. The end result is a shockingly joyless affair that takes itself far too seriously and feels like a compromise on all fronts. It isn't Rob Zombie-enough to satiate his die-hards, yet it also isn't classically Halloween-enough to please fans of the original film.
Haddonfield High Superlatives:
Best Kill: Michael turning Paul into a hanging jack-o-lantern.
Funniest Scene: Joe Grizzly's entire death scene.
Biggest Dick of a Character: Ronnie
How Awful of a Town is Haddonfield?: 4 out of 10 (it looks like a dump during the first act but by the time it catches up to modern day with the Strodes, it seems positively quaint)
Scream Queen Award: Danielle Harris as Annie Brackett. Not because she's particularly great but because she's easily the best of the bunch and it's nice to see Jamie Lloyd back in action.
Ranking of the Films Revisited Thus Far From Best to Worst: Halloween (1978), Halloween III: Season of the Witch (1982), Halloween II (1981), Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers (1989), Halloween H20: 20 Years Later (1998), Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers (1988), Halloween (2007), Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers (1995), Halloween: Resurrection (2002)
Check out our previous Halloween Retrospectives below:
Halloween III: Season of the Witch
Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers
Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers
Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers
Halloween: Resurrection