10 Things You Learn Rewatching Halloween II (2009)
Does Rob Zombie fare any better the second time around?
After the immense financial success of Rob Zombie's Halloween remake, Dimension and the Akkads were hungry for more. With a newly rebooted timeline in place, they recruited Zombie to the franchise once more and deliver a follow-up.
Zombie spent the lead-up to his sequel's release singing its praises, referring to it as "my Road Warrior" on several occasions. He teased that in making a second Halloween film, he was able to make the film he had always wanted to, saying;
"I felt like the last movie was 50% me, 50% John Carpenter... Now, it’s 100% me."
Audiences, however, did not share Zombie's enthusiasm.
When the film was released, it was roundly trounced by fans and critics alike. It didn't even recoup half of the grosses that the previous film made and it wound up putting the franchise on ice for nine years, the longest period of time the franchise ever went without releasing a film.
Now that the draught is nearly over, with Blumhouse's new film coming out in less than a week, it's time to look back and see; is Halloween 2 as bad as its reputation suggests? Let's find out...
10. The Prologue
After Zombie's first Halloween film suffered from a case of compromised vision, Zombie comes out of the gate swinging in this sequel.
Picking up immediately after the events of the remake, Sheriff Brackett finds Laurie wandering the streets of Haddonfield, still clinging to the gun she shot Michael with. He takes her to the hospital, as the coroners grab Michael's body from the Myers house. Of course, nothing goes according to plan. Michael wakes up, kills the coroners, and makes his way to the hospital to tack down Laurie.
What follows is a genuinely riveting sequence which showcases the film's love of gore, the brutality of Tyler Mane's Michael, and the fact that this thing is 100% Rob Zombie. It's got gonzo visuals like Laurie falling into a trash compactor full of bodies, Michael using an ax to kill a guard ala Jack Torrence killing Dick Hallorann in The Shining, and a relentlessly in-your-face pace that hardly ever holds long enough for the audience to even catch its breath.
Hell, it even sees Zombie successfully utilizing suspense more so than the entirety of the previous film did. It is everything one could possibly expect from a Halloween movie by Rob Zombie... and then the movie throws it all away.
In reality, it was all just a nightmare that Laurie was having. This is a cheap excuse for a killer intro because it means that literally none of it mattered, it was all just for show. The movie then proceeds to become infinitely less interesting from here.
9. The Music... Or Lack Thereof
In Zombie's first Halloween film, the music was surprisingly stellar. Rather than opting for he and Tyler Bates' own updated versions of the classic John Carpenter themes, the film regularly just used the original's instead. At the time, there were rumors that Zombie wasn't thrilled with this decision and would have preferred to do without the music altogether.
Judging from Halloween II, it appears those rumors were very true.
Despite the fact that it appears on Tyler Bates' soundtrack for the film and in the theatrical cut, the director's cut of Halloween II never once features the iconic Halloween theme. Similarly, no versions of Carpenter's other iconic themes are utilized either.
The Halloween music is definitely iconic and a defining part of the franchise, so to completely throw it all out is a strange choice but not necessarily a bad one. When you're making the tenth film in a franchise, change isn't a bad thing. But if you're going all in on that, then at least replace them with brand new themes.
Instead, Bates' score is almost entirely comprised of feedback, sustained tones, murmuring voices, and the occasional loud blaring sound effects to accompany a jump scare. Which leaves the film sounding like every other horror film made in the late 2000s.
Instead of taking the opportunity to distinguish themselves, Zombie and Bates just conform to the most boring and bland standards of the genre.
8. The Strange And Delightful Cameos
Generally speaking, Rob Zombie films are populated with the same character actors over and over again. Zombie has said publically before that he enjoys working with actors numerous times because he loves the way they "develop a shorthand" and the fact that repeat actors "always give you more".
But for the first time in the history of Zombie's filmography, this film does not feature his regular crew of character actors like Sid Haig, Bill Moseley, and Tom Towles. Instead, Zombie populates the peripheries of this film with well-established actors and celebrities he admires and the results are surprisingly fun.
Years before her breakout role in The Help would cement her status as an Academy darling, Octavia Spencer appeared as a nurse in this film and got the prestigious honor of being the only character in the film that Michael kills with his classic 'hero' butcher knife. Sons of Anarchy regulars, Dayton Callie and Mark Boone Junior both make brief appearances as characters who meet grisly ends. Even Weird Al Yankovic gets in on the fun, appearing as himself on a talk show, ribbing Dr. Loomis, and making a Michael Myers/Austin Powers joke years before Edgar Wright made it cool in Baby Driver.
There are others, (we're not touching that painful Chris Hardwicke appearance with a thirty-nine-and-a-half-foot-pole) but the most profound of the bunch is resident badass, Lois Lane herself, Margot Kidder playing Barbara Collier, Laurie's therapist. Her appearances are brief and she basically just gets yelled at by Laurie, but it is undeniably great to see her on-screen again.
7. The White Horse Sequences
The film's first frame is a title card stating the definition of a white horse and its role in psychology. It reads;
"(They're) linked to instinct, purity, and the drive of the physical body to release powerful and emotional forces, like rage with ensuing chaos and destruction."
The fact that this is all made-up gibberish aside, this leads to Zombie linking Michael's desires to kill with him seeing visions of his mother and a white horse, asking him to create a "river of blood" for them so they can be reunited.
These visions grow increasingly strange throughout the film, especially once Laurie begins to have them as well. While there is something to be said for Zombie having the sheer chutzpah to try something this out-of-the-box as having a black-and-white dinner sequence with several pumpkin-headed demons eating Laurie alive as a crucified Michael Myers skeleton watches from above, it never quite works.
Zombie is swinging for something more avant-garde in these sequences, with some visuals clearly cribbed from the likes of Tobe Hooper's The Texas Chain Saw Massacre and the work of German Expressionism filmmakers like Robert Wiene, but he never commits to it enough to make a lasting impression. These gonzo visions only take up a few sparse minutes of the film's runtime. They are rushed through and edited to cut to ribbons, making it feel less like a bold statement and more like a surface-level aesthetic choice with cues taken from Zombie's music videos.
A film that devoted more time and consideration to these gonzo moments could have wound up being an arthouse horror film for the ages. Instead, Zombie just kind of brushes them aside, making it all feel less like an artistic excursion and more like a cheap excuse to keep his wife, Sheri Moon Zombie as Mother Myers, in the film.
6. The Gore Is Intense
Whether this actually counts as a pro or a con for you is going to be determined almost solely by the strength of your stomach, but Halloween II 2009 features the most intense violence and gore of any of the Halloween films-to-date.
Zombie goes above and beyond here to make what he calls;
"The darkest, nastiest, grittiest film ever featuring Michael Myers."
And he absolutely succeeds in this. From the film's very first kill, a clear precedent is set. The coroners driving Michael's body in the prologue accidentally crash into a cow (as unintentionally hysterical as it sounds) which results in the cow exploding everywhere and the driver's face getting caved in by the steering wheel. Michael then emerges from the back of the van, picks up a piece of broken glass, and proceeds to cut the other coroner's head clean off.
Other gory highlights (or lowlights, depending on your point of view) feature Michael brutally smashing a man's face to a pulp with his boot and yet another dog meeting an unfortunate end in the grizzliest way imaginable.
It's not just the actions committed or the prosthetics and copious amounts of fake blood used in sequences like this that make it so affecting, a huge part of it is the sound design. Even when Michael's just doing his general stabbing later on in the film, it has never sounded grosser than it does in this film.
What Zombie creates here isn't a far cry at all from the torture porn films that ruled the horror genre at this time. But I'll give Zombie credit, even those films were unable to capture the kind of gleeful lunacy and visceral madness that these sequences have.
5. The Visuals Are Piss-Poor
Once again, Zombie's greatest hindrance is himself and his complete and total lack of restraint or subtlety.
Eschewing the more cinematic aspect ratio of 2.39:1 that he used on his Halloween remake, Zombie switches to a 1.85:1 frame on this film and it is immediately noticeable. This results in a more narrow frame, which only serves to further emphasize Zombie's other bad tendencies.
Nearly half of the shots in this film are close-ups, and viewers can practically count the number of actual wide shots between two hands. This gives the film a claustrophobic style that Zombie is pretty obviously not aiming for, he just can't help himself. Every character who is delivering a line is constantly framed in extreme close-ups and to quote David Fincher;
"Every time you go to a close-up, the audience knows 'look at this, this is important'. You have to be very, very cautious and careful about when you choose to do it."
Zombie is decidedly not careful about he chooses close-ups here, instead just seemingly defaulting to them in nearly every instance.
To further worsen things, in the editing of the film, Zombie opted to desaturate the visuals so much that the film is practically in black-and-white at times. Between the desaturated visuals, the narrow frame, Zombie's aversion to wide shots, and the truly atrocious editing, there are entire minutes of screen time in this film where viewers will have no idea what is going on.
Most notably, the majority of the sequence of Michael in The Rabbit In Red Lounge is just quick cuts of indistinguishable shaky footage. You literally can't tell what is supposed to be happening, at all.
4. Laurie's Arc Is Underdeveloped
After a lackluster debut in Zombie's previous Halloween film, Scout Taylor-Compton returns to the role of Laurie Strode in this film. To her credit, it is a slight improvement.
Part of this comes is thanks to the fact that Taylor-Compton is allowed to take the character in a completely different direction than Jamie Lee Curtis ever did, so she is finally able to escape her shadow and any unwanted comparisons. The other huge factor that plays into the improvement is the fact that she simply gets more screentime here to develop her character. Where Zombie's remake didn't even introduce her until just before the third act, Laurie is the protagonist of this film from the get-go.
Having said all of that, Zombie still doesn't seem to really know what to do with Laurie. The 'good girl' aspects of the character clearly never appealed to Zombie, so here he turns into a deeply troubled character who also happens to bear a striking resemblance to Rob Zombie himself, dreds and all. But this doesn't make her character any more compelling. In fact, it just generalizes her and makes her even less interesting because now she fits squarely into Zombie's aesthetic wheelhouse, alongside everything else in the film.
Where Laurie's arc really falls apart is anytime Taylor-Compton is tasked with responding to the heavier material. Rather than giving her anything of substance to actually work with, Zombie's script just has her say "f*ck" over and over again, sometimes for full minutes of screentime at a time. Notably, this results in laughable responses to key moments of narrative heft, like when Laurie finds out she's actually Angel Myers.
The result of all of this is a performance and protagonist that is severely undercooked and desperately underserved.
3. Loomis Is Absolutely Worthless
In Zombie's first Halloween film, Malcolm McDowell's performance as Dr. Loomis was hit-and-miss. He committed to the role but the script left him with little to do, seeming strangely fixated on turning the character into a money-hungry jackass.
For some reason, Zombie doubles down on this in the sequel and it is very much to the character's detriment. Loomis is now exclusively a dick, with McDowell hamming it up to the point of turning the role into self-parody. Not only is this kind of insulting to the core of the character; it's just not interesting.
The film frequently cuts back to Loomis on his book tour, further exploiting the tragedy of Michael Myers and his victims, but its almost entirely superfluous. He doesn't interact with any of the characters in the narrative proper until the last few minutes of the film's runtime and the tone and style of his sequences are completely different from anything else in the film, making it feel like this was a different film entirely that just spliced into the edit.
It's obvious that McDowell and Zombie are having fun filming these sequences, but that doesn't make them fun to watch. They're dull and boring. There were several directions Zombie could have taken this incarnation of Loomis after nearly dying at the hands of Michael in the prior film's climax, and literally anything else would have been more compelling than this.
2. Hobo Michael
Rob Zombie's Halloween II is nothing if not filled with burgeoning bold ideas. But by far the biggest risk Zombie takes is in depicting Michael as a savage homeless man with a big bushy beard who spends entire chunks of the film walking around in broad daylight with his mask off.
While this is definitely different, it doesn't really work. Not only does this not feel like the Michael Myers of the original films; it doesn't even feel like the Michael Myers of the previous film. He spent his entire time in the sanitarium forging masks out of paper mache to hide his face, and then once he's free he just suddenly doesn't want to wear one anymore?
It's a strange character choice that also impacts the narrative of the film as a whole. Because he's just this wanderer, Zombie's script has to practically break its own back bending over backward attempting to explain why he's coming back for Laurie this Halloween and in giving him things to do until he finds her in the third act.
The result is a messy narrative structure that just kind of violently zip-zags back and forth between Michael's random killings, Laurie's PTSD, and Loomis' book tour.
But by far the worst thing this movie does to Michael is in the finale. In the finale of the director's cut, adult Michael Myers speaks for the first time in the entirety of the series and it's such a profoundly idiotic and pointless line, it'll leave you wishing they had sewn his mouth shut instead.
It's ferociously idiotic and just puts the cherry on top of the truly terrible final few minutes of this film's runtime.
1. In Summary
Rob Zombie's Halloween II is one of the strangest films in the franchise, and for this franchise, that's really saying something. On the one hand, it's far more enjoyable than its predecessor simply because it's something entirely original and Zombie takes some big risks, even if they don't always pan out. On the other hand, this thing is edited to sh*t, increasingly grotesque, further wastes some great characters, and is borderline unwatchable in parts. It tries to trade in the grounded realism of Zombie's prior film for a more surreal approach but winds up kind of tripping over its own feet in the process. While Zombie's ambitions here are something to be admired, and it's easy to recommend as a watch just for what a strange ride it is, this is still far from the franchise's upper echelon.
Haddonfield High Superlatives:
Best Kill: Michael stomping a man's face in with his boot.
Funniest Scene: Zombie's heavy-handedness earns more than a few laughs in the sequence that cuts back-and-forth between Laurie eating a vegetarian pizza and Michael eating a dog.
Biggest Dick of a Character: Loomis. It's not even a contest.
How Awful of a Town is Haddonfield?: 6 out of 10 (lets Loomis run ads all over town for his book that openly exploits them, all of Laurie's friends seem like terrible people who would be awful neighbors)
Scream Queen Award: Brad Dourif as Sheriff Brackett. He goes all in here and delivers what is probably his best on-screen performance, really selling Brackett as a worn-down and troubled sheriff who's just trying to protect his family.
Ranking of the Films Revisited Thus Far From Best to Worst: Halloween (1978), Halloween III: Season of the Witch (1982), Halloween II (1981), Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers (1989), Halloween H20: 20 Years Later (1998), Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers (1988), Halloween II (2009), Halloween (2007), Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers (1995), Halloween: Resurrection (2002)
Check out our previous Halloween Retrospectives below:
Halloween III: Season of the Witch
Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers
Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers
Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers