10 Things You Need To Know About Sam Raimi's Spider-Man 4
Starring John Malkovich as Vulture! And Anne Hathaway as...Vulturess?
Spider-Man may now be safe at home with Marvel (who have shared custody of the franchise with Sony), but things haven't been as bright for the webslinger recently.
According to leaked internal emails, before grovelling to Disney Sony were considered everything from an animated Spider-Man film from LEGO Movie director Phil Lord and Chris Miller to an Aunt May spinoff. Perhaps the most surprising plan they had, though, involved Sam Raimi.
Which is surprising, because Raimi leaving the series after his disastrous third Spider-Man is what kick-started the Amazing reboot, which in turn led to such drastic measures. Then again, Spider-Man 2 remains the most prosperous in terms of returns and reviews.
Would a fourth Raimi film have worked, however? Maybe not, since he was working on a fourth film when he got the boot from the franchise. Or did he quit? And how close would it have been to the reboot? It's a strange, mysterious project, and here's ten things you need to know about Sam Raimi's Spider-Man 4.
10. Dylan Baker Would've Been The Lizard
Raimi had been seeding a bunch of future plans in his Spider-Man movies. It may not have looked it at times, as in the spectacularly messy third film, but even that was supposed to lead into a Venom spin-off at some point. Something Sony are also still considering!
Anyway, one of the other, more subtle bits of foreshadowing he had been working in was Dylan Baker's appearance in the third film as Dr Curt Connors, the one-armed geneticist that everybody knows better as the reptilian supervillain The Lizard.
According the reports, he would've been the main villain of Spider-Man 4. Unfortunately Baker never got to make good on whatever contract he had at Sony and the hours he'd put into a bit part that would eventually bloom into a lead once they rebooted the franchise and Rhys Ifans snatched the role from under his nose. Harsh.
9. John Malkovich Would Play The Vulture
The Lizard was definitely in the mix, anyway, and apparently Raimi didn't learn his too many villains spoil the broth lesson on Spider-Man 3 - which included The Sandman, Venom, and Harry Osborn as a New Goblin, all causing headaches for the wall crawler - because he wanted The Vulture in there too.
And considering that John Malkovich is a significantly bigger name than Dylan Baker, it's possible that he would've been the actual central protagonist, with Lizard more in the Sandman position of supporting bad guy.
Malkovich would actually be quite the get, too. He was apparently all signed on to play Adrian Toomes, who is kind of a weird villain: he's an elderly criminal who builds a suit that lets him fly. But like, with wings. And a little neck ruff. Like an actual vulture. Presumably he would've gotten a Defoe-as-Goblin redesign...
8. Anne Hathaway Gets Her Claws Out Earlier...
Right, so apparently even that wasn't quite enough, because not content with The Vulture and The Lizard on the scene, Peter Parker was also going to be introduced to the innumerable charms of Felicia Hardy. If that name seems familiar, it's because Felicity Jones played the same character in The Amazing Spider-Man 2.
To be honest, it's probably better they pinched that from the aborted Spider-Man 4 script than The Vulture. They were a little too late to capture the rising star that Raimi had in line to play Felicia, however. Apparently Anne Hathaway was all but confirmed to play the character, in whatever capacity she'd appear.
So presumably Sony wasn't the only one picking over the remains of Spider-Man 4, since in the comics Felicia Hardy becomes the feline-themed burglar Black Cat - basically the Marvel Universe's equivalent of Catwoman, whom she played in The Dark Knight Rises...
7. ...Or Not
Although from the looks of it, Sam Raimi planned to take Felicia Hardy in a very different direction to how she was in the comics. Like, to the degree that you wonder why she was even going to be called Felicia Hardy, unless it was solely to troll comic books fans by not giving them what they wanted (ie Anne Hathaway in a skin-tight black catsuit).
No, instead of becoming the anti-hero cat burglar who has a flirtatious relationship with Spider-Man - because more of that was needed after the damp squib of the Peter-Mary Jane-Gwen Stacy love triangle of the last film - she was going to be the Vulture's sidekick. And she was going to be called The Vulturess, obviously, because if there was one thing screenwriter James Vanderbilt is lacking, it's understanding of cool names, ironically.
Tobey Maguire fighting a high-flying Anne Hathaway and John Malkovich would've been...interesting.
6. Carnage Might Also Have Been On Board
Don't count your chickens before they hatch, however, because there were contemporary rumours that The Vulture, his Vulturess and The Lizard weren't enough. Supposedly Raimi figured the amount of bad guys in a film had to correlate to the title, because the bloated Spider-Man 4 script featured four villains.
Having introduced the idea of the alien symbiote with Venom in the third film, the follow-up was going to adapt the next stage in that storyline: the creation of a separate symbiote, born from Venom, which attaches itself to serial killer Cletus Kassady and becomes the villain Carnage! Which, presumably, was mostly more set-up for the mooted Venom movie - where they hoped to pit the two symbiote-clad loonies against each other - but would've almost certainly also tipped Spider-Man 4 into an even bigger mess than 3. A chilling thought.
5. It Could've Been 3D
A lot of that is conjecture, however. The nature of big budget Hollywood productions - especially ones that don't wind up getting made - is that they go through countless different permutations before you reach the finished product. The Vanderbilt script could've been totally bloated and involved all of the above rumoured antagonists; they could also have all existed separately, in different drafts of scripts and pitches.
Regardless of that, what is known for sure of the entire debacle surrounding Spider-Man 4's collapse, cancellation, and abandonment by everyone involved - necessitating a total franchise reboot - suggests that the production was a bit of a mess. Too much going on. A lot of pressure.
So the decision that they would shoot in 3D couldn't have helped matters. It's unclear if they actually knew for sure that's the road they were going down, but Sony wanted to get on that Avatar gravy train, even if it would add six months to the already strained schedule.
4. Bruce Campbell Might've Got A Lead Part
All of which is mostly bad news, and is probably making everyone feeling pretty blessed that Sam Raimi's Spider-Man 4 never happened. It was also a missed opportunity, however: the director wanted to make his long-time collaborator and victim Bruce Campbell into a proper star with the movie. Campbell was the star of Raimi's first film, the low-budget horror film The Evil Dead, and was the breakout star of its sequels too. Since then, the director has tried to get him into every big-budget production he makes, which lead to a series of small cameo roles in each Spider-Man film. He was a ring announcer in the first film, snooty usher in the second, and a maître d who actually played a significant role in the third's plot (such as it was). Apparently the fourth film would've had him playing an actual character. Spider-Man Vs Ash?
3. They Were Also Planning 5 And 6
If making another Spider-Man film after the total disaster of the third entry seemed like a significant act of hubris, you don't know the half of it. Not only did the cancellation of Raimi's Spider-Man 4 mean that film was kaput, but pre-production work also halted on a projected fifth and sixth film, presumably with the same director and cast.
Not only that, but it was planned that he fifth film would be shot concurrently with the fourth, in the manner of The Lord Of The Rings trilogy or the first two Pirates Of The Caribbean sequels. Which was a pretty monumental workload, and a big commitment by everyone involved.
How exactly would that have worked? It's hard to say. It would probably have meant Spider-Man films coming out one year after another, instead of a gap of a couple of years. It might also have meant that the villains got a little more spread out. It might also have been awful.
2. The Release Date Was The Same Week As Thor
One of the penultimate nails in the coffin of Spider-Man 4 is that Sony had set a release date of May 6, 2011, and refused to budge from it. Now studios have learned that shifting a release date isn't quite such a big deal as it used to be, not a sign that a production is in trouble or whatever it used to signify.
In 2010, though, they were not going to change for nobody. Part of that was because Marvel had already made a significant dent in the superhero movie market with the surprise smash hit of their first independent production, Iron Man. The Incredible Hulk didn't quite do enough to capitalise on that, but Sony were clearly worried about the Kenneth Branagh-directed Thor.
In the end Spider-Man 4 was cancelled, and Thor got pushed back from May 20th so it instead came out on... May 6th. So for a hot minute there, it looked like Thor and Spider-Man 4 would've gone toe-to-toe.
1. They Didn't Make It Because Raimi Hated It
The pressure being put on Raimi to rush Spider-Man 4 out so it could compete with the burgeoning Marvel Cinematic Universe isn't the Sony reason that he walked away from the film, but it definitely seems to be the straw that broke the camel's back.
The truncated production schedule was going to involve some sacrificing of quality, in his eyes. What's weird is that Spider-Man 4 seemed to be all set. Maguire was on board through six films, after striking a deal which would allow him evenings off to spend with his young daughter. Dunst was onboard, Malkovich and Hathaway seemed as good as locked, scripts were being written. Scripts which, in Raimi's words, hated.
He reportedly went through four revisions of the script, with different writers, and not a one of them could nail it. Raimi doubted they would have the issues ironed out in time, and generally though that release date was optimistic. Sony cancelled the film in January 2010.
Ultimately, Sony thanked Raimi for not wasting the studio's money and Vanderbilt wrote 2012's The Amazing Spider-Man, which became the highest-grossing reboot of all time.
Would you have liked to see Sam Raimi's Spider-Man 4? Or are you glad we got The Amazing Spider-Man and the eventual move to Marvel? Have your say down in the comments.