10 Times Comedic Actors Went Against Type (And Totally Pulled It Off)
Trading laughs for drama.
There is something oddly moving about seeing an actor go against their usual on-screen persona and wowing fans with an amazing piece of acting. Never has this been more true or effective than when talking about funny people turning on their jokes and often silly on-screen personalities.
The following actors are all best remembered for their roles in comedy - from sit-coms, noughties stoner flicks, stand-up specials and classic comedy movies that often helped shape a generation.
Each actor on this list was stereotyped by audiences long before they showed up with a new look and maturity, and in casting aside their jokes proved to be more than just someone there to make you laugh.
This isn't to say their comedic performances were bad - in many cases, they were very far from it. But it is fair to say that all of these actors have been typecast with previous roles, and the films featured on this list helped shake-up people's perception of them. And, in some cases, even completely changed their careers.
Whether it's a sit-com darling, an SNL superstar, or a comedy legend who redefined our views on them, here are ten actors who went against type and totally nailed it.
10. Sarah Silverman - I Smile Back
One of the most controversial, successful and care-free comediennes of all time, Sarah Silverman's tackling of topics such as sex, sexism, racism, and politics has often led to a mix of controversy and accolades.
Though very much a unique performer on stage, her film roles have also often leaned into her persona of dead-pan delivery and discussions about taboo topics. Her roles in There's Something About Mary, Say It Isn't So and A Million Ways to Die in the West are just some examples of her leaning into her on stage persona.
Despite having a very successful comedy career, in 2015 she defied all the odds with her role in the drama film I Smile Back. Gone is her usual brand of comedy, her taboo discussions and her care-free references to sex, gender and race.
Playing seemingly happy suburbanite Laney Brooks, a woman whose supposedly perfect life is being threatened by a deep depression and unresolved family trauma, Silverman shines with every scene, playing Laney with compassion and understanding.
You can't help but think it's a very personal role for Silverman, who has been open about her own mental health in the past, and her commitment resonates from start to finish.
The film around her suffers from a weak script and some loose plotting, but for Silverman's award-worthy and completely out-of-the-blue performance alone it deserved to be admired.
9. Jason Segel - The End Of The Tour
Launching into the spotlight thanks to his role in the cult classic sit-com Freaks and Geeks, Jason Segel found himself entertaining an entire generation with supporting roles in comedies such as Knocked Up, Forgetting Sarah Marshall, I Love You Man, Bad Teacher, and This Is 40.
He is perhaps best known for his role as Marshall Erikson in the sit-com How I Met Your Mother, in which he starred from 2005 to 2014.
When How I Met Your Mother came to end, it seemed as though Segel could do no wrong and was destined to go from strength-to-strength. The first role he took after the show came to an end was far removed from what people were expecting. Starring alongside Jesse Eisenberg in the film The End of the Tour, Segel portrayed acclaimed author David Foster Wallace.
The drama depicts a journalist (Eisenberg), who after hearing about Wallace's suicide recalls the twelve days they spent together for an interview. The film itself is a solid and serious drama, but Segel stands head and shoulders above the finished picture with a performance that proves to be respectful, passionate and constantly engaging.
Generating Oscar buzz, it's a performance that stands out on Segel's CV like a diamond, and although he still tends to stick to his comedic roots, he most recently played the lead in the sci-fi drama The Discovery, in which he gives another top-notch performance.
If he wants to pursue more ventures like that, then it definitely wouldn't be a problem.
8. Bill Murray - Lost In Translation
Could it even be a comedian-turns-to-drama list without mentioning the great Bill Murray and his Academy Award nominated turn in Sofia Coppola's Lost in Translation? In short, no it wouldn't.
Known for his energetic, ad-libbing and completely hysterical roles in films such as Caddyshack, Tootsie, Ghostbusters, Scrooged and What About Bob?, Murray rose to fame on Saturday Night Live and proved early in his career to be a one-of-a-kind performer and a natural talent in the realm of comedy.
Fast forward to 2003, and Murray found himself cast in the drama Lost in Translation, portraying fading movie star Bob Harris, who's having a mid-life crisis and travels to Tokyo to promote a brand of whiskey. On his travels, Bob strikes up a connection with a young woman and the pair help each other confront their lives.
It's an intelligent and moving piece of cinema, anchored from start to finish by Murray at his career best. Quiet, restrained and effortless, he plays Bob with wit, dry humour and maturity and holds the screen with every scene, without ever reverting to his typical brand of eccentric and odd-ball humour.
And it pays off endlessly.
7. Kristen Wiig And Bill Hader - The Skeleton Twins
A film which produced two staggering performances for the price of one, The Skeleton Twins came out in 2014, and followed two depressed twins played by Bill Hader and Kristen Wiig.
After Milo attempts suicide, he is reconnected with his estranged sister, Maggie, and the pair reminiscence about their lives and their family, coming to terms with their relationship and their mistakes.
A striking and compelling drama, Hader and Wiig are equally brilliant in their respected roles. Before the film's release, both actors were known for their stints on Saturday Night Live. Hader had had roles in Superbad, Paul, Tropic Thunder and Forgetting Sarah Marshall, and Wiig had starred in Knocked Up, Ghost Town, Date Night and Bridesmaids.
Their comedic credentials speaking for themselves thanks to SNL alone, both Hader and Wiig were surprise additions to the drama but managed to defy all expectations, playing their characters with wry humour and heartbreaking authenticity.
The Skeleton Twins makes for a stellar drama for plot alone, but Hader and Wiig elevate it to new heights.
6. Jonah Hill - Moneyball
Jonah Hill's filmography speaks for itself - he's a comedy staple. Funny, endearing and always somehow likeable, his roles in Superbad, Funny People, Get Him to the Greek and Megamind helped set him on the way to being a big name for comedy.
But in 2011, after a slew of hits and a successful run of instant classic comedies, Hill took a career detour to play Peter Brand in the drama Moneyball alongside Brad Pitt.
Though a risky move on paper, Hill made it work with ease. Playing Brand with a subtle intensity and maturity, he proved to be a match for seasoned dramatic actors such as Pitt, Philip Seymour Hoffman and Robin Wright.
Beside being nominated for his first Oscar, Hill also found his career taking a new and exciting path. He continued his dramatic success with roles in The Wolf of Wall Street, War Dogs and True Story, and though he remains a frequent comedic performer, his dramatic chops have opened up a whole new chapter in his career, promising big things.
And maybe an Oscar, if he keeps it up.
5. Mo'Nique - Precious
Mo'Nique's role in the 2009 drama film Precious can simply be referred to as a revelation. Out of the blue and completely immersive, her performance as abusive mother Mary Johnston earned her an Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress and a spot on every "best against type role" list in existence.
Previously known as a successful stand-up comedienne, performing at such venues as The Apollo, Mo'Nique made a name for herself as a member of the film The Queens of Comedy. To solidify her fame and popularity, she also played a major role in the sit-com The Parkers from 1999 to 2004.
A veteran in stand-up comedy, her casting in Precious proved to a risky move on paper. But on screen, it was phenomenal.
Playing the mother of titular character Precious Jones, Mo'Nique was terrifying, cruel, violent and tear-inducing. Constantly, effortlessly convincing, her performance was truly extraordinary, and one of the best examples of just how effective at drama comedians can be when given the right material.
4. Steve Carell - Foxcatcher
One of the most surprising dramatic turns in recent years, Steve Carell's performance in Foxcatcher was nothing short of mesmerising. Sinister, cold, and tragic, everything you ever associated with the accomplished funny man was forgotten and tossed aside.
Starring opposite Mark Ruffalo, Channing Tatum and Sienna Miller, Carrel portrays John du Pont, a man whose love for wrestling began a chain of events which ended in tragedy.
Based on a true story, the film was lauded for its story, direction, and the performance of Ruffalo, but it was Carell's transformative turn as du Pont which stood out amongst the crowd.
Known previously for his roles in Anchorman, The 40-Year-Old Virgin, Get Smart and Date Night, Carell's career defining role came as Michael Scott in the fan favourite sit-com The Office.
Since his role in Foxcatcher, which saw him nominated for an Oscar, Carell has leaned more and more into dramatic roles, and thanks to recent turns in Beautiful Boy, Vice and Battle of the Sexes he's well on his way to be one of Hollywood's most successful dramatic actors.
And who doesn't love to see that?
3. Jennifer Aniston - Cake
Jennifer Aniston made a name for herself thanks to her era-defining role as Rachel Greene in the sit-com Friends, a role she played for ten years. Though she's never fully been able to remove herself from the popularity of Friends or her role in it, she has had some big hits since the show came to an end.
Mostly sticking to the rom-com genre, Aniston best shined in films like Along Came Polly, The Break-Up, The Bounty Hunter and Just Go With It, before steering massively clear of her comedy roots with her starring role in the drama film Cake.
Portraying Claire Bennett, a severely depressed woman suffering from chronic pain following the death of her son, Aniston anchors the high-stakes emotion of the film and its deep and effective tackling of themes such as depression, family, death and suicide.
The film itself received mixed reviews, but Aniston received only praise, and it's easy to see why. A complete performance, moving and heartbreaking from start to finish, she received a number of big accolades and proved without a shadow of a doubt to be more than just a cast member of Friends and a rom-com staple.
2. Adam Sandler - Punch-Drunk Love
As with Bill Murray before him, it wouldn't be a complete against-type list without giving a due shout-out to Adam Sandler and his performance in Paul Thomas Anderson's 2002 romantic drama Punch-Drunk Love.
Playing Barry Egan, a man with social anxiety who falls in love with a friend of his sister's, Sandler defined all expectations with his moving and subtle performance.
Previously known for his own brand of silly and over-the-top humour, best seen in films such as Happy Gilmore, The Wedding Singer, The Waterboy and Big Daddy, his role in Punch-Drunk Love completely dialled back his usual level of weirdness and instead offered audiences a clever, subtle and endearing performance.
Though Sandler's comedy roles have arguably increased over the years, Punch-Drunk Love easily proved he could do more than yell and make stupid jokes. Proving it wasn't a fluke, his recent turn in the crime drama Uncut Gems has been his most recent foray into drama, and may be his best performance to date.
Perhaps, it may also be a turning point in his career.
1. Jim Carrey - Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind
Jim Carrey is without question one of cinema's most beloved comedic presences. With his defining roles in The Grinch, Ace Ventura, The Mask, Liar Liar and Dumb and Dumber, Carrey made his career out if being the most energetic and hilarious actors on screen.
He briefly moved into drama territory with his role in 1998's The Truman Show and 1999's Man on the Moon, but it wasn't until 2004's Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind that he fully immersed himself into a role of pure drama.
Whilst Truman and Man on the Moon allowed him to occasionally lean into his comedic chops, Carrey's role as Joel Barish, a man who sets out to have his ex-girlfriend erased from his memory, allows for no such situation.
Rather, the film forces Carrey to embrace his calmer and more measured side, and what he creates is a beautiful and even tragic portrayal of a man confused and tormented by his feelings.
With a career spanning decades, Carrey has still got a long way to go, and if he focuses on bringing roles like this to the screen he can only keep going up and up.
Watch Next
Can You Name These Jonah Hill Films From Just One Image?