10 Underrated Films By Amazing Directors
The films you never watched, by the directors you adore!
Not every film a director releases will be a hit, in fact, many directors have one and spend the rest of their careers chasing the second, sacrificing quality, artistic-control and even their own sanity trying to find it.
Meanwhile, for some directors, the hits just keep on coming, as Tom Cruise tells us in A Few Good Men, no matter what they do, the film makes more and more money worldwide and the praise gets more and more thunderous, the idea of them having a flop or ghosting under the radar in some way is absurd!
But many directors will have a true masterpiece or gem just tucked away in the back of their filmography, just waiting for someone to find it while the others take the centre-stage.
10. The Coen Brothers - Inside Llewyn Davis
Inside Llewyn Davis follows the titular musician (played by Oscar Isaac), who is loosely based on the '60s folk singer Dave van Ronk, in a week of his life as he navigates the burgeoning New York folk scene.
It boasts an array of superstars such as Carey Mulligan, Adam Driver, Justin Timberlake, John Goodman and even F. Murray Abraham, and it’s hard to see why the film isn’t more well-known, especially given how highly rated the film is by critics.
The film followed a similar production technique to Les Misérables, in that the musicians in the film performed their songs live, in front of the camera. While a soundtrack of the film is available, the soundtrack is more or less a chance for the actors to perform their songs in a dialogue-free environment, it also serves as the first and most likely last time that you will ever see Marcus Mumford, T-Bone Burnett, The Punch Brothers and Justin Timberlake all on the same album, outside of a Spotify playlist.
It’s worth it if only to see Oscar Isaac, Justin Timberlake and Adam Driver perform the hilarious novelty track “Please Mr. Kennedy” for a record executive at Columbia Records.
While the praise it has from critics perhaps places it more in the “Highly-Rated” section of their filmography, it’s division among fans is why it’s here.
9. Edgar Wright - Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World
Whether he's turning his hand to classic homages to zombie horror films or buddy-cop films or heists, Edgar Wright is one of the most talented directors currently working.
As a direct adaptation of Bryan Lee O’Malley’s superb Scott Pilgrim graphic novels, Scott Pilgrim vs. the World is a wonderful blend of romance, comedy, action and comic book. Here we can see everything that we love about Edgar Wright on show in dazzling form, from the inventive scene transitions (that really make you feel like you’re in an actual comic book) to the pitch-perfect dialogue, it’s hard to see why a film as genius as this didn’t do better at the box office.
The story follows the love-life of the titular Scott Pilgrim (played to perfection by Michael Cera, who rivals his own performances in both Superbad and Arrested Development) as he has to battle the seven evil exes of his love-interest, Ramona Flowers (played by Mary Elizabeth Winstead).
Honestly, it’s baffling how a film that brags a cast of Kieran Culkin, Anna Kendrick, Chris Evans, Jason Schwartzman, Brandon Routh, Mae Whitman and Brie Larson isn’t more well-known, but here it is.
8. Christopher Nolan - Insomnia
A 1997 Norwegian film of the same name, Insomnia is the only film to date that Christopher Nolan has not had some part in the writing of, even if he did mastermind a final draft of the screenplay.
Insomnia follows the story of two LA detectives investigating a murder in Alaska, where the sun-cycle is as unforgiving as the Football Gods are to Arsenal. In a Twin Peaks-esque set-up of an out-of-towner cop investigating the murder of a young woman while seemingly unable to satisfy his lust for slumber due to the aforementioned perishing sun cycle, Insomnia really lives up to its name. Here we see Al Pacino, Hilary Swank and the late Robin Williams starring in this somewhat bizarre game of cat and mouse.
While the non-linear setting that is so prevalent in Nolan’s later films isn’t present here, Nolan’s incredible use of natural vistas and on-set shooting are used to devastating effect. As Al Pacino’s character begins to succumb more and more to the titular ailment, we see the torture of the world around him play out as he slowly begins to lose his mind, though unlike Dale Cooper in Twin Peaks, Pacino’s Will Dormer can’t for the life of him go-with-the-flow as the paranoia sets in, the film becomes more and more claustrophobic and sets up a show-stopping finale, that will leave you on the edge of your seat.
Christopher Nolan may be known for is unrivalled Dark Knight trilogy or his mind-bending Inception or even the truly bizarre Interstellar, but Insomnia is as worthy an entry in his filmography as any other.
7. Quentin Tarantino - Death Proof
Released as part of the Grindhouse double-bill with friend Robert Rodríguez, it’s not too hard to see why Death Proof has flown under the radar for so long. While Rodríguez’s Planet Terror was the other movie playing alongside it, Death Proof eventually was given its own release.
Starring Kurt Russell as Stuntman Mike, Death Proof follows the story of a crazed stuntman who kills unsuspecting groups of women in his death-proof (get it?) stunt car. The film is seen as a homage to the classic exploitation, slasher and car-based films of the ’70s, basically, think Faster, Pussycat! Kill! Kill!, Halloween and Vanishing Point all rolled into one, with a hint of Jackie Brown.
The first half of the film is shown with missing film cells, jump-cuts and even scratched film to replicate the classic look of the films of the time, although the look is somewhat abandoned in the second half of the film, which is a shame, as the jumpy, scratched look from the first half had a certain charm to it that really pulled you in.
While Death Proof may not be as engaging as other Tarantino films, the car chase at the end is probably one of the greatest car chases ever put to film…seriously! With a chase that carries over deserted country roads, highways and even across an interstate, it’s truly breathtaking to behold.
While the film isn’t as well-known or even as well-liked as say...Pulp Fiction, Django Unchained or Kill Bill, Death Proof is still a solid entry into the infamous director’s impressive filmography.
6. Alfred Hitchcock - Rope
When he isn’t scaring the living daylights out of you with Psycho or having you descend into paranoia with The 39 Steps or even making you think twice before you enter a cornfield again with North by Northwest, Alfred Hitchcock was innovating and changing the face of film as we know it.
His techniques in the world of cinema are as used today as they were in the swinging '60s and his ability to create tension and suspense are still as unrivalled as they were at the time. But here, we see the culmination of all his classic techniques roll into one with 1948’s Rope. Adapted from the 1929 play of the same name by Patrick Hamilton, Rope stands as a long-dormant classic.
Now, while Alfred Hitchcock directed over fifty full-length features, it’s difficult to pick any one film as underrated, so we’ve chosen Rope as it’s possibly the best example of what Hitchcock was and what he remains today, an auteur.
What makes Rope so unique, isn’t just the filming style, but more the set-up. Shot in one continuously long-take (but for only ten cuts), the film takes place in one place, the apartment of two young men who have just killed their friend David and proceed to have a dinner party on a trunk in which their late friend’s corpse lies. Lovely.
While Rope was later described by Hitchcock as being “a stunt”, it still holds up today as a masterpiece of not only suspense, but in turn for its technical accomplishments, without Rope, we wouldn’t have films such as Birdman or: The Unexpected Virtue of Ignorance or Russian Ark, which have since prevailed with the techniques shown in Rope, we also wouldn’t have the hilarious Charlie Work episode of It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia either, but that’s a different discussion.
5. Steven Spielberg — Duel
While it’s gained something of a cult following over the last few years, there was a time when Duel was comparatively unknown. But this really is one of Spielberg’s best films, which is saying something, because he very rarely releases a bad one, but there is an undeniable charm to Duel that has gone unnoticed for many years.
Dennis Weaver as David Mann, a salesman on a business trip, who is stalked on a remote highway in the Californian desert in a truck, Duel is the first full-length feature film that Spielberg ever did, and while it may not be the film that put him on the map, it certainly afforded him more license with films such as Jaws in later years.
While Duel takes the idea of the unknown and enforces it in a way that not only intrigues the audience but also scares the bejesus out of them, Duel also showcases Spielberg’s visual flair, his use of cutting and his attention to detail.
Duel may not be Spielberg’s most well-known film, but it’s definitely the film that started it all and it’s worthy of anyone’s filmography, especially someone as incredible as Steven Spielberg.
4. Orson Welles - Touch Of Evil
While this too has started to receive a bit more praise in recent years, owing to its rather impeccable restoration courtesy of Eureka!, Touch of Evil remains one of Orson Welles’ masterpieces.
Released in 1958, the story of the production of Touch of Evil is one that has forever lived in the Orson Welles’ mythology. The film’s plot tells the story of Miguel Vargas (Charlton Heston) and his wife Susie (Janet Leigh) on honeymoon at the Mexican-American border, when a bomb is exploded on American soil, killing a government official; what follows next, is a story of corruption, intrigue and deception.
Touch of Evil was originally not supposed to feature Orson Welles as the director, he was originally only hired to play the role of Police Captain Hank Quinlan (an early caricature of Gene Hunt), though there are conflicting stories as to how he wound up in the director’s chair.
Either way, the hugely talented Welles ended up taking the director’s seat and producing one of the great masterpieces of his career. While there have been nearly three separate versions of the release (something that Blade Runner stares at and asks how it didn’t get as few as three different versions), the film has since gained a restored print, based off a fifty-eight page memo that Welles sent to Universal, begging them not to change the film too much.
Easily one of the best film-noirs ever released, and still today one of the best releases from Orson Welles as well (which is pretty impressive, if Citizen Kane is your first film) and boasting one of the most gorgeous long-takes ever put to film.
3. Sidney Lumet — The Offence
While 12 Angry Men, Network and to a lesser extent The Hill, will probably be remembered as Sidney Lumet's true masterpieces, it’s easy to see how something like The Offence has managed to remain out of the equation.
After agreeing to return as everyone’s favourite little sex pest James Bond in Diamonds are Forever, United Artists agreed to back two films under $2,000,000 that Sean Connery wanted to make. What came out of that was The Offence. Having worked together on both The Anderson Tapes and the aforementioned The Hill, Sidney Lumet was chosen as the director.
The film follows the story of Sean Connery’s Johnson (there is probably a better way that I could have chosen to word that) who “accidentally” kills a suspected child molester Kenneth Baxter (played by Ian Bannen) during a police interview. The film explores Johnson’s own deeply flawed logic in the murder of Baxter, his own hypocritical take on the crimes that he has put people away for and his ever-chipping away psyche as he deals with flashbacks and regular violent outbursts.
Though it’s by no means a fun-filled flick for all the family, it’s certainly a daring entry into the filmography of director and actor alike. It was a chance for Connery to shed himself of the weighty James Bond mantra that he had taken up and was also a chance for Sidney Lumet to really let the characters take shape before our very eyes.
The film’s impact cannot be underestimated, indeed, the iconic Joker interrogation scene from Christopher Nolan’s magnum opus The Dark Knight owes a huge amount to this film and countless other films that have drawn inspiration from it too.
2. Martin Scorsese - The King Of Comedy
While his partnership with Robert De Niro goes together like butter on bread or milk in tea, Martin Scorsese and Robert De Niro don’t always hit the big time as is evident with The King of Comedy.
The film follows the story of Rupert Pupkin an aspiring comedian and performer, trying to hit the big time, as he begins to stalk his hero Jerry Langford. What proceeds, is a story of madness, comedy and tragedy as Pupkin’s delusion is played out in full.
After the runaway success of Raging Bull, Scorsese had considered retiring from films altogether to focus on making documentaries instead, but at the behest of Robert De Niro and his own interest in developing The Last Temptation of Christ, Scorsese returned with The King of Comedy.
While it wasn’t the sort of success that he would later find, The King of Comedy is a true dive into the world of celebrity worship, with its final scene, standing up as a truly tragic, yet beautiful scene.
The story itself has inspired countless films since, not least the upcoming DC film Joker, which De Niro will also be appearing and that Scorsese was at one point producing.
It may not be his most well-known (otherwise it wouldn’t be in this list), but The King of Comedy is worth the price of admission on its own and should be a must-watch for any Scorsese or De Niro fan.
1. Stanley Kubrick — The Killing
He may not have been prolific on the same scale as some other great directors, but Stanley Kubrick will always go down as one of cinema’s greatest ever contributors. Divisive upon their release, only to be critically lauded years after, his films have always been divisive, outrageous and downright awesome.
But while he will always be remembered for films such as The Shining, A Clockwork Orange, Full Metal Jacket and 2001: A Space Odyssey, it’s a surprise that a film as good as The Killing isn’t as well thought of as it should be.
Hot off the heels of Killer’s Kiss, Stanley Kubrick was finally allowed to make his first de-facto studio film. After he and production partner James B. Harris beat United Artists to the rights for Lionel White’s novel Clean Break, United Artists sought to fund Kubrick’s film as long as he could find a star to appear in the project, which led to the casting of Sterling Hayden.
While Hayden himself was not really a big enough star for United Artists to cough up the dough to make the film entirely, they still provided enough of the finance for the project to sort of go ahead.
What followed is a film about a criminal, Johnny Clay (Hayden) planning that fabled last big heist before skipping town for good. Clay gets a rag-tag bunch of criminals together and gets them to aid him in his heist as they aim to steal $2,000,000 (the equivalent of just shy of $20,000,000 today) from a racetrack.
While it may not be the most technically advanced film out there and something of a safe bet from a director who would later go on to be known for his bold choice of film, The Killing is a truly mesmeric film, that manages to keep the audience captivated and on the edge of their seats. The Killing has since inspired numerous heist films and started to get Kubrick’s name out there to the studio brass.
While it’s fair to say that it isn’t the best Kubrick film out there today and perhaps isn’t the best example of what he would later be known for, The Killing is still a worthy entry in any filmmaker’s filmography and it is perhaps a testament to how strong Kubrick’s other films are, that The Killing is as underrated as it is.