10 Unmade Guillermo Del Toro Projects That Look Awesome

How about a del Toro comic book film that's not Hellboy, huh?

One of the downsides of Hollywood filmmaking is that it can take years, even decades, for a project to be fully realised. When you get to Guillermo del Toro that's especially troubling, since the dude has about a dozen great ideas a minute, and all of them are worth making. It's just the way of the world that he's doomed never to bring all of them to fruition. The Mexican director is one of those rare people where most of his ideas are genuinely fascinating. Flicking through his book Cabinet Of Curiosities: My Notebooks, Collections, And Other Obsessions reveals dozens of well-thought-out, unique ideas that the slow grind of film production will never see realised. No wonder he dabbles in books, games and TV shows as well. As if his movies didn't make it clear enough, Del Toro is a singularly weird dude. He started his career with a vampire film that basically dumped every famous cliché about vampires from the off. His Hollywood debut involved giant, semi-humanoid mutant cockroaches eating people. His comic book movie is about the son of the devil. So, naturally, a lot of the time, his great ideas don't get made because they're just too bizarre. All of which ultimately means that we, his adoring public, don't get to see some of his most original, strange, and brilliant work. He's had films that simply disappeared into production schedules, games that were cancelled because they were simply not going to be money-makers, and more.

10. Frankenstein

How could you not want a Guillermo del Toro Frankenstein film? Especially given that the director was reportedly courting Benedict Cumberbatch to play the eponymous doctor (as he had on stage to great effect for Danny Boyle), and regular collaborator Doug Jones (who was both the Faun and creepy no-eye guy in Pan's Labyrinth) for the monster. Just as Cronos threw out most of the established vampire mythology, you could rely on del Toro not to rest on the laurels of past Frankenstein adaptations, of which there have been... let's say a few. But when he signed up with Universal to make his version he was adamant it would be a period piece, not unlike their classic, iconic Boris Karloff-starring version. In fact, del Toro had signed a contract with Universal that included enough films to last him until 2017. To date, none of them have been made, which means we may never see this perfect-sounding Frankenstein: even on a conceptual level it boasts a great cast, a director famously sympathetic to monsters as well as humans, and undoubtedly some top-notch physical effects for the monster. And it might have spared us all from I, Frankenstein...

9. The Adventures Of Pinocchio

disney Like Frankenstein, The Adventures Of Pinocchio have been adapted seemingly countless times since their original publication. And like Frankenstein with the Karloff iteration, saying the name Pinocchio will bring forth one image in most people's heads: the animated Disney version from 1940. Guillermo del Toro's Adventures Of Pinocchio would probably have been a bit less whimsical to say the least. When he started developing his own adaptation, del Toro was still intending for the puppet-come-to-life to be animated. In fact, he was angling for a stop-motion film in the style of A Nightmare Before Christmas and - most exciting of all - was collaborating with the Jim Henson Company, who hadn't done that sort of thing since their eighties heyday with The Dark Crystal. First look images (above and also HERE) were created and at one point it looked like it was going to happen. Unfortunately, it looks like it's not to be. Stop-motion is a painstakingly long process, and costly; apparently the failure of similar projects like ParaNorman at the box office nixed the funding of del Toro's Pinocchio. Don't worry (or do) - we'll be getting a new version of the lying puppet from Disney themselves, with Robert Downey, Jr. playing Geppetto.

8. Insane

He may be best known for his movies, but Guillermo del Toro is a man who recognises when he has an interesting new way to tell a story; no doubt buoyed by his interest in video games, the filmmaker recently began working on his own. That game was Insane, developed in collaboration with Volition. Planned as a trilogy of titles, del Toro said upon announcement "I want to take players to a place they have never seen before, where every single action makes them question their own senses of morality and reality," whatever that means. Given the sort of thought he puts into every project - and how scary they often are - Insane would likely have been a high-end horror title. Sadly, "likely" is as far as it goes, because nothing ever came of the game, thanks to the collapse of publisher THQ. Besides some cryptic comments by del Toro and the news that Hellboy comic artist Guy Davis was working on designs, not much was known about Insane; only that those titbits are enough, coupled with the idea of a del Toro horror game, for fans to be disappointed when it was canned.

7. The Haunted Mansion

The first attempt to adapt The Haunted Mansion to film sucked. Guillermo del Toro apparently took his kids to see the Eddie Murphy vehicle (which hoped to capitalise on Disney's success at adapting their Pirates Of The Caribbean theme park attraction to film) and, all in all, he found it failed in both being funny and being scary. So he decided to pitch his own version. Amazingly, Disney said yes, and he set to developing his own version of The Haunted Mansion, delving into the mythology of the Disneyland attraction itself which has all manner of spooky, real-life stories haunting it. The cornerstone of del Toro's version was the Hatbox Ghost, a part of the ride which was never implemented and has an eerie standing in Disneyland lore. Announced at Comic-Con in 2010, del Toro promised €œwe are not making it a comedy. We are making it scary and fun at the same time, but the scary will be scary.€ And anybody who has seen basically any del Toro film knows he can do scary. Perhaps too scary, which is why little has been heard since about the project, except that Ryan Gosling might be interested in starring.

6. Drood

Historical drama is something that del Toro has at least some experience with. Both Pan's Labyrnith and The Devil's Backbone use the very real atrocities committed during the Spanish Civil War as the backdrop to supernatural horror, and (despite the fairy tale trappings) for the most part he manages to be true to facts of those events. But he's never done a full-blown period film starring actual historical figures. Which might be what drew him to Drood, an adaptation of the Dan Simmons novel about the final years of Charles Dickens' life. The Simmons book took some notable liberties with the fact, taking in all manner of other famous Victorian characters and adding a thriller plot, but, hey, it's still based on true events. It sounds a bit like The Raven, basically, where a fictionalised Edgar Allen Poe got caught up in a spooky conspiracy. Maybe those similarities stalled the project. Which is a shame, because del Toro would surely have delighted in recreating an idealised version of gothic, smog-filled Victorian England, and of playing with Dickens as a troubled hero.

5. Monster

Television is one of the few mediums that Guillermo del Toro hasn't dipped his toes in fully. He's an executive producer on The Strain, the FX adaptation of the vampire novels he writes with Chuck Hogan, but he's not all that involved. Maybe he's just waiting for the right project to come along; or maybe he's been burned because he had the ideal project, and then he lost it. As far back as the mid-2000s del Toro was attached to Monster, an adaptation of Naoki Urasaw's manga that he would have produced on HBO. The channel that routinely features the sort of brutal violence of Game Of Thrones was perfectly suited to del Toro and his source material, which involved a series of murders across pre-unification Germany. Monster also deals with issues of morality, if there's such thing as true evil, and political corruption - all of which are del Toro hallmarks. Seeing him work on his first long-form visual story would have been a treat, as would just getting weekly instalments of gorgeous del Toro direction. Except nothing has been heard since 2013, so it's possible Monster is dead in the water.

4. Slaughterhouse-Five

Kurt Vonnegut's Slaughterhouse-Five is a classic for a reason. The novel blends autobiography, historical and science fiction in the story of Billy Pilgrim, who becomes "unstuck in time". Throughout the narrative he slips back to the World War II Dresden bombings he was party to, then to his recovery post-war, and then to an alien planet where he was kept in a zoo and "mated". It's a powerful, odd, funny and dark story, and it's already been adapted to film perfectly well in the seventies. But when Guillermo del Toro approaches a project, you know he has something new to say. And when he's got Charlie Kaufman (of Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind fame) on board as a screenwriter, you know you want to hear it. Along with del Toro being able to sensitively handle the war-torn drama, his take on the five-dimensional Tralfamadorians that abduct Billy would not doubt be more impressive than the seventies version. Kaufman's perfect for the script, too, with his experience of fractured, traumatic plots making him an oh-so obvious choice. Unfortunately there's been no word on Slaughterhouse-Five since 2011.

3. Silent Hills

The most recent of del Toro's abandoned projects might also be the most high-profile. The news that horror master Guillermo del Toro was teaming with weirdo video maverick Hideo Kojima, creator of the Metal Gear series, to make a new Silent Hill title was obviously met with rapturous delight by fans, followed by a sense of dread. Because the finished game would surely be terrifying. In fact, the duo gave players a sneak-preview of what was to come in PT, the game's playable teaser which remains the only piece of Silent Hills left in existence. And it remains absolutely nightmarish, in a typically del Toro way, with an impending sense of dread sometimes broken by a good old fashioned, haunted house-style jump scare. Factor in The Walking Dead heartthrob Norman Reedus providing a motion capture performance, making him the "star" of the game, and Silent Hills looked like a done deal. Except then Kojima fell out with Konami, and the developer began to fall apart, and del Toro was forced to admit his second foray into video games had been consigned to the scrap heap as well.

2. Justice League Dark

The DC Cinematic Universe could do with a dose of the weird. As it stand, Warner Bros. look to be trying to beat their competitors at Marvel at their own game, building up a shared fictional world that centres on big, Avengers-style Justice League films punctuated by solo films. But just pretend, for a moment, that they didn't do that. Imagine that they tried something different. Like, for instance, getting Guillermo del Toro to work on an alternate Justice League film which wouldn't have been a bright, colourful superhero team-up. Instead, del Toro's Dark Universe - later Justice League Dark - would involve the comic publisher's strange, scary and supernatural characters teaming up, possibly to deal with a similarly dark, occult threat. Not so much a summer blockbuster, more a continuation of what he'd done with Hellboy, with pulp thrills and chills side-by-side. Del Toro worked on a treatment for years, including iconic characters like Swamp Thing and John Constantine. While it's still allegedly on the cards, only now a part of the DC Extended Universe, del Toro is no longer attached, meaning any version we do ultimately get won't have quite the same allure.

1. At The Mountains Of Madness

Pacific Rim should never have been made. Oh, that it was a success, and enough so to inspire a sequel, is a merciful miracle, but to get del Toro's love letter to giant robots and old kaiju movies we had to essentially bid farewell to At The Mountains Of Madness. Guillermo del Toro's attempt to adapt HP Lovecraft's classic novella about an ancient civilisation hidden beneath the ice of Antarctica had a lot going for it: James Cameron had promised his pioneering 3D special effects technology from Avatar, and signed on as a producer; Tom Cruise was also in as the star, despite it being an uncharacteristically non-blockbuster project. It was that which ultimately sunk the film. It's a dark, scary exploration of humanity and ancient evil. Del Toro wanted it to be R-rated, full of gore and unpleasantness, but the scale of the story required a huge budget, which likely couldn't be recouped by such a weird film. Lovecraft has inspired parts of every del Toro film, so to see him finally tackle that influence head on - and with some amazing special effects and actors - would have been incredible. But it looks like it is never to be. What other Guillermo del Toro projects remain unmade? Share any more we missed down in the comments.

Contributor
Contributor

Articles published under the WhatCulture name denote collective efforts of a number of our writers, both past and present.