10 Upcoming Comic Book Films (And Who Should Direct Them)

Brad Bird on Superman simply has to happen!

IT BPRD
Warner Bros./Dark Horse

Over the years, comic book films haven't managed to really shirk behind the scenes drama. Patty Jenkins famously departed Thor: The Dark World a few years back, Edgar Wright dropped out of Marvel's Ant-Man, and the path to Matt Reeves' Batman reboot has been anything but smooth.

While these examples illustrate that both Marvel and DC are no strangers to behind-the-scenes controversy or critically poor releases, it's also true that both companies have produced some truly inspired directorial choices in recent years. Patty Jenkins' Wonder Woman shone, and the MCU continues to reach new critical heights under the stewardship of Joe and Anthony Russo.

They exemplify how directors can really elevate a project for the better, and with Creed's Ryan Coogler inevitably guiding Black Panther to critical and commercial stardom, both companies have an eye for what does and doesn't fit their universes. David Ayer aside.

It’s not just the big two either: Neil Marshall’s involvement in the upcoming Hellboy reboot makes perfect sense, given his horror credentials.

But what of those up and coming features? Who would best suit them?


10. Batman: Jennifer Kent

By Photo by Camille Griner Cropped by RanZag (original version) (Flickr) [CC BY-SA 2.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0)], via Wikimedia Commons

The Babadook - apart from being one of the best horror films of the decade - introduced audiences to Jennifer Kent who, at the time of writing, is currently working on The Nightingale, set to be released later this year.

While her involvement in both Nightingale and the upcoming adaptation of Alice + Freda Forever might destroy any chance of the director getting involved in DC anytime soon, Kent was in talks to direct Wonder Woman originally. With that in mind, there's every chance that the director could get involved with the DCEU at some point, especially if there's a project out there more befitting of the skills she showed in the Babadook.

One such hero that is begging for a unique and altogether more different kind of feature is Batman, who'll receive a solo flick in 2019 courtesy of Apes alum, Matt Reeves. While Reeves is a stellar pick for the project, and will no doubt produce a brilliant Bat-flick with Bat-fleck, one can't help but wonder what a Kent-directed Dark Knight would look like.

Certainly, if there are any sequels in mind (and there will be, let's face it) she has to be considered. A horror-themed romp through Arkham Asylum would be amazing to see on the big screen, and with some key Baba-esque visuals deployed, it would be a terrifying one too.


9. Untitled Man Of Steel Sequel: Brad Bird

Tomorrowland Brad Bird
Disney

You'd think that the director behind The Incredibles would be attached to big franchises more often, but that isn't the case for Brad Bird, who only got given the keys to an established franchise in 2011's Mission Impossible: Ghost Protocol.

The director's name has, however, been thrown into discussions surrounding just who, exactly, will replace Colin Trevorrow for Episode IX. And yes, while he'd make a great fit for that franchise, having already flexed his sci-fi credentials on Tomorrowland and Iron Giant, we'd love to see Bird take a stab at the comic book genre again - away from the animated realm.

Although Man of Steel gave Superman fans the action that had been sorely lacking in most of the character's previous live action endeavours, it felt particularly soulless, and even cruel in parts. Doubts do, of course, also remain regarding Henry Cavill's performance as the character, but perhaps what's missing is a director to really eek out the big blue scout's more heartfelt qualities.

Brad Bird gets the kind of warmth that needs to reverberate from a comic book feature - particularly one as iconic and uplifting as Superman - and it's because of that he should get the nod to direct a Man of Steel sequel. It's a warmth that's been found wanting in most DC tales, but when it is there - as Wonder Woman so eloquently displayed - it can really elevate a given project. Bird is the man that can make it happen.


8. Black Widow: Susanne Bier

Susanne Bier
By Les Kaner [CC BY 3.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0)], via Wikimedia Commons

Anyone who watched last year's Night Manager will be quick to praise Susanne Bier, who directed the entirety of the mini-series.

The show - which starred Tom Hiddleston, Hugh Laurie and Olivia Colman - was a flawless adaptation of the le Carré classic, and was also just about the best espionage related thing of the past two years. Bier was instrumental in its success, and with an Academy Award to her name too, it's clear that the filmmaker is ideally suited for a big blockbuster outing.

Talk of a Black Widow solo movie has stalled this past year, but fans are by no means less excited by the prospect of one nearing production. Scarlett Johansson's character has long been an MCU favourite, and although there's little chance of movement happening before 2020, one can only hope that Bier's name is on the shortlist for when it does, eventually, get going.


7. Joker Origin Movie: Ben Wheatley

Ben Wheatley A Field In England
Drafthouse Films

Ben Wheatley isn't a name that gets thrown around a lot when it comes to big budget blockbusters, but his most recent directorial effort - Free Fire - must surely have people talking.

Although divisive upon its release, Free Fire was a fun, slapstick action comedy with real grit, a great cast, and an even greater premise. Its own sense of humour is equally noteworthy, and Wheatley's other projects - Sightseers and High-Rise particularly - display the same kind of quality. The writer/director has plenty of range too, with A Field in England fitting the description of a psychological horror more so than the black comedy of his other works.

If it's true that Martin Scorsese is behind this upcoming, self-contained Joker story, then there's a chance that Wheatley could actually be in contention. Free Fire was, after all, produced by Scorsese, and while a Joker story would be a massive leap from the director's other projects, it's hard not to envision that he'd be a good pick for the job, particularly if it's looking to portray the clown prince's early, pre-acid bath years.


6. Batgirl: Lexi Alexander

Punisher War Zone Lexi Alexander
Lionsgate

Lexi Alexander is perhaps best known for her work on the criminally underrated Punisher: War Zone - a film that, until Netflix came a knocking, offered just about the most authentic onscreen Punisher to date.

Alexander has also played a vocal role in highlighting sexism throughout the entertainment industry, and has spoken at length regarding the various directorial opportunities that have been denied to her because of her gender. She's an immensely talented filmmaker too, and, coming off the back of two gigs on Arrow and Supergirl respectively, is more than ready to helm another big screen feature.

Much has ben discussed in regards to Joss Whedon's involvement in Batgirl, and while yes, the director does have the kind of experience to make it work, one can't help but feel that DC are missing a trick in not making it another women-led project. Certainly so, given the emphatic reaction to this summer's Wonder Woman.

Alexander would be a brilliant candidate for the job in any case, and would bring an edge to the flick that few directors would be able to match. Let's make it happen DC!


5. Gotham City Sirens: Nicole Holofcener

Fox Searchlight

Despite the fairly disastrous reception Suicide Squad had to deal with when it released, Warner Bros. are, supposedly, ready to give David Ayer another directing gig, on another DC property no less.

Said gig will purportedly involve a Suicide Squad spin-off, operating under the title of the criminally overlooked Paul Dini/Guillem March series, Gotham City Sirens. Margot Robbie is due to reprise her role as Harley Quinn for the film, although her co-leads - Poison Ivy and Catwoman - are yet to be cast.

Casting aside, having Ayer in the director's chair again is a massive mistake on WB's behalf. While Suicide Squad was indeed financially successful, production issues marred its release and it was a critical disaster in every sense of the word. We know that Ayer can perform when necessary (both End of Watch and Fury are great films), but he's just not fit for the DCEU, nor for Gotham City Sirens in particular.

Nicole Holofcener, however, would do wonders with the right material. Having lent her talents to Parks and Recreation and Gilmore Girls, the writer/director is a clear fit for the production. Her 2013 film, Enough Said, also debuted to critical acclaim, and picked up a plethora of nominations during the 2014 awards season, which intimates her skill behind the camera well enough, really.

Any Sirens film simply has to feel fun, and Holofcener - with her experience on shows like Parks and Rec - is the right person to convey that feel on the big screen.


4. Untitled B.P.R.D. Movie - Andrés Muschietti

Andres Muschietti IT behind the scenes
Warner Bros.

IT may have only released last week, but it's already proving to be this year's finest horror movie, and indeed, possibly one of the best films of the year all around. A lot of that success must be attributed to the film's director, Andrés Muschietti, who will no doubt be coveted by a plethora of studios going forward.

Muschietti had previously worked on Mama with Guillmero Del Toro, and his roots are firmly in the horror genre. Considering how Lionsgate have already tapped Neil Marshall - another horror movie director - for Hellboy, it would make sense to keep the theme going for the rest of their burgeoning cinematic universe.

Indeed, if a B.P.R.D. spin-off is planned (and we surely hope it is) then Muschietti would be a brilliant pick for the role. Mike Mignola's original Hellboy series and the B.P.R.D. comics that followed all took place in a certain point in history, and IT's feel for the late eighties zeitgeist is undoubtedly one of the reasons why it's resonated in the way it has.

If Muschietti could capture the same historic feel for a more horrific comic book tale, then it could just make Dark Horse a force to be reckoned with on the big screen. Granted, it's possible we could just be getting ahead of ourselves, but still, IT's great, and Hellboy sounds even better. Make it happen Lionsgate!


3. Justice League Dark: Guillmero Del Toro

Legendary

Look, we know that del Toro dropped out of the project a few years back, but considering how it's been stuck in development hell since, surely it's time to admit he's the only man for the job?

Since its announcement in 2012, Justice League Dark has seen plenty of rewrites, hirings, firings and resignations - so much so that, if it were any other project, it would probably have been considered a lost cause. WB are all too aware of the potential for a supernatural comic book feature to bang at the box office however, and so it makes sense that they're persevering in spite of the many developmental issues that have plagued the project for the last five or so years.

However, maybe - just maybe - it's time to concede that the film simply needs del Toro to succeed. The director lives and breathes horror both in front and behind the camera, and regardless of the fact that it could take literally years more for it to see the light of day, he's still the ideal candidate to guide the project to completion.

We hear that the script is currently undergoing rewrites, which implies that WB are still pressing ahead with the film as a del Toro-less one, but - in the slim chance that the director could return - we have to hope that they have an older draft lying around somewhere.


2. Green Lantern Corps: Justin Lin

star trek beyond chris pine justin lin
Paramount

JJ Abrams' 2009 Star Trek reboot was divisive amongst hardcore Trekkies, but there's no denying that it galvanised the franchise, and provided the base necessary for Star Trek: Discovery to move ahead this year.

Funnily enough, the best film of the rebooted trilogy didn't actually feature Abrams, but rather Justin Lin instead. Lin, more famous for helming the Fast and the Furious franchise than anything else, took to Star Trek: Beyond and illustrated - in no small way - that he just plain gets sci-fi. The director's involvement in several episodes of Dan Harmon's Community probably did much to show that too.

Anyway, with Green Lantern needing something pretty dramatic to remind audiences he's infinitely more compelling than a tacky CGI suit would suggest, it needs to hit the ground running. Lin, having worked on Star Trek and the Fast and the Furious, could easily ensure that speedy start, especially if the feature will revolve around more than one member of DC's famous emerald corps.

There are certainly other directors out there with the sci-fi pedigree to make Green Lantern work, but Lin straight up knows how to make a compelling blockbuster. Given the freedom necessary to make it work, it could just make for the best DC feature yet.


1. Doctor Doom: Sam Mendes

Spectre Sam Mendes
MGM/Columbia

One of the more interesting pieces of news to emerge from the halls of SDCC 2017 was that Noah Hawley - of Fargo and Legion fame - had been working on a Doctor Doom solo movie for Fox.

Admittedly, it is a tad frustrating to see Fox cling onto the rights for the Fantastic Four, especially since the MCU is crying out for key characters in the FF mythos. But hey, Hawley's involvement is cause for excitement, or - at the very least - tempered optimism.

Fox are yet to announce a director for the project, what with the film being in the earliest stages of pre-production, but certain names must be floating around. With Hawley's involvement, it's clear that there's at least an air of quality surrounding the film, and - unlikely as it may be - one would hope that Fox would be targeting some equally formidable talent, like Sam Mendes.

Mendes will, of course, be known for helming both Skyfall and Spectre, and while Doom would look like something of a demotion for the director, adding a layer of political intrigue and personal drama to the character's story is something he'd be able to convey with ease. It would have to be atmospheric too, and with his previous work on Road to Perdition having satisfied in that department, it becomes increasingly clear that he'd do Victor well, especially if it took place in the fictional setting of Latveria.

In any case, one can only hope that the film will offer a more authentic depiction of the green-clad dictator than what has previously been the case. Mendes, while an unlikely pick, would bring that authenticity and make it work.

-

What directors would you like to see direct a comic book feature? Let us know in the comments below!


Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.