10 War Movie Plot Twists That Nobody Saw Coming
Pick that jaw up off the floor, soldier!
The unpredictable backdrop of war movies provides the perfect setting for that most classic of movie tropes: the plot twist.
Dozens of offerings from the war movie genre have managed to do the unthinkable by producing a curveball that still lands with a seismic impact, despite the unforseeable and erratic nature of their wider environment. It's a testament to the skill involved in crafting a narrative U-turn in the midst of such chaos that these twists are still so shocking.
On paper, the notion of being shocked at an unexpected development in a war film is like being surprised at getting mildly burned after sticking one's head into a furnace. However, the following names underline the ineffable qualities of this brand of cinematic twist. Above all else, these offerings highlight that even in the midst of such volatile and turbulent surroundings, expecting the unexpected isn't always enough.
Warning: this article contains MAJOR spoilers!
10. Irina Is Shot By Her Fellow Russians - Stalingrad
The quintessential anti-war film, 1993's Stalingrad is unashamedly desolating. Following a platoon of German soldiers on the Eastern Front, Joseph Vilsmaier's picture captures the notion of war as hell in unflinching clarity. It's an exemplary movie, but it's an emotionally exhausting experience.
True to form, Stalingrad saves its most unexpectedly devastating gut punch for last. The soldiers form a tentative bond with Irina - a female Russian soldier - across the course of the film. This bond progresses to the point where Thomas Kretschmann's Hans von Witzland has literally sworn to protect her by the film's ending.
Stalingrad's conclusion sees the disillusioned pair along with Dominique Horwitz's Fritz Reiser silently trudging through the snow attempting to escape their hellish environs. They are finally alerted to a sign of human life as a Russian flare illuminates the winter sky. All initially appears to be well as Irina rushes towards the signal, shouting to her people in her mother tongue.
That is of course, until the young woman is gunned down and instantly killed by a volley of Soviet gunfire - there isn't even time to blink in shock. Even in the midst of Stalingrad's inescapably morbid aura, Irina's sudden and brutal death is more than worthy of inclusion on this list.
9. Juba's Revenge - The Wall (2017)
War thriller The Wall may have divided critical opinion on the film's release in 2017, but Doug Liman's picture features one of the more deviously nasty twist endings in recent memory.
Set during the final stages of the Iraq War, the film centres on an American sniper and his spotter, played by John Cena and Aaron Taylor-Johnson respectively. The pair soon find themselves lured into a deadly game of cat-and-mouse with an Iraqi marksman named "Juba". Pinned down and unable to move, the duo's only source of cover from the sniper's aim takes the form of the film's crumbling eponymous wall.
Cena's Staff Sergeant duly bites the dust at Juba's hands but the movie's conclusion sees his spotter apparently triumph over their tormentor. Taylor-Johnson's Sergeant Isaac seemingly guns down the sniper with his final round after a prolonged shooting match between the pair. He then tests the waters by standing up in plain view of his assailant. Juba's shot never comes, indicating that Isaac has indeed dispatched his foe.
Of course, that's before Liman whips the rug out from under his audience with the revelation that the sharpshooter is simply lying in wait for more targets. As backup arrives, the Iraqi proceeds to dispose of Isaac and his rescuers in one fell swoop, using his rifle to down the escape helicopter and concluding the film with the wickedest of gut punches.
8. Meet Private Ryan - Saving Private Ryan
"James...earn this. Earn it."
Saving Private Ryan is one of the greatest cinematic productions of all time and contentiously the finest war film ever conceived. Steven Spielberg's epic WWII offering follows a group of soldiers on a mission to locate the eponymous Private and bring him home safely after his three brothers are killed in combat.
Spielberg's picture is bookended by scenes featuring an old man attending a WWII cemetery with his family. The film's beginning immediately segues into the first scenes set during the war, depicting the hellish arrival of Tom Hanks' Captain Miller and Co. on Omaha Beach. Accordingly, the initial assumption is that the old man is an elderly version of Miller himself, a supposition reinforced by his resemblance to Hanks.
In a narrative bombshell as heart-rending as it is uplifting, the veteran is later revealed to be none other than Private Ryan himself, with his facial features in the aftermath of the movie's climactic engagement morphing into that of his older self. Ryan is in fact visiting the grave of his fallen comrade, the aforementioned Miller, who died in battle attempting to carry out his mission.
A poignant twist of the highest order, with a notable sense of heartwarming relief that Ryan made it home, juxtaposed against a sense of poignant loss at the notion that Miller and much of his squad weren't so lucky.
7. Smith, Schaffer And Turner's True Identities Are Revealed - Where Eagles Dare
Based on an original screenplay from legendary novelist Alistair MacLean, 1968's Where Eagles Dare is renowned as one of the greatest war films ever conceived. Led by Richard Burton and Clint Eastwood as Major John Smith and Lieutenant Morris Schaffer respectively, Brian G. Hutton's picture is as renowned for its immortal twist ending as it is for its exemplary overall quality.
Where Eagles Dare is initially touted as a joint British-American operation to rescue a US general from a remote castle in the German Alps. As the movie progresses, the rescue mission is unmasked as a ruse - the operation is actually an ingenious cover story to mask the real goal of obtaining vital enemy intelligence.
After eventually making a thrilling escape, Smith reveals the movie's final mindblowing bombshell as he is debriefed by Patrick Wymark's Colonel Turner aboard a transport plane. Burton's soldier reveals that he and Schaffer actually joined the mission on behalf of MI6 to root out the top German undercover agent operating in Britain - an individual that the intelligence gathered on the mission revealed to be none other than Turner himself.
Unsurprisingly, the duplicitous Colonel wisely elects to avoid a trial by jumping out of the aircraft to his death. The shock factor of this twist was clearly too much for him to handle.
6. John Wayne Actually Dies - Sands Of Iwo Jima
Across a diverse range of genres and roles, John Wayne's party trick was to triumphantly ride off into the sunset after saving the day. The American film icon garnered such a reputation for doing precisely that in one form or another that it usually came as a legitimate shock whenever one of Wayne's characters actually bit the dust onscreen.
There is perhaps no better example of this status quo than 1949's Sands of Iwo Jima. Allan Dwan's offering is one of the most lauded war films of all time, starring Wayne in the leading role of Sergeant John Stryker. One of the American's most iconic characters, Stryker is a hard-as-nails disciplinarian - initially despised by his men, the members of his squad soon come to appreciate his methods amidst the heat of battle.
Even if Wayne's cinematic charges had made dying more of a habit, Stryker's formidable aura of toughness means that it still comes as an almighty surprise when he is shown to be just as mortal as anybody else. As the squad enjoy a brief lull in the fighting, John is suddenly shot and killed by a Japanese soldier in a stupefying twist for the ages.
The fact it's the seemingly indestructible John Wayne is just the icing on the cake.
5. Gibson Is Unveiled As A Frenchman - Dunkirk
The chaotic backdrop provided by Christopher Nolan's 2017 take on the Dunkirk evacuation provided the perfect camouflage for one of the director's most cunning narrative curveballs. Nolan has built himself a reputation as a master of the twist and the legendary film-maker does not disappoint here.
One of his key characters this time around is the subject of the director's latest mind-bending efforts - Aneurin Bernard's initially unassuming "Gibson". Fionn Whitehead's Tommy first encounters Gibson burying a dead body but the curious nature of this visual is lost amidst the turmoil of their surroundings - a dead soldier in this fraught environment is hardly the most surprising sight in the world.
However, Gibson's relentless silence becomes increasingly suspicious, prompting Harry Style's Alex to accuse him of being a German spy and precipitating the movie's most shocking development. Gibson is revealed to be a Frenchman, a soldier who attempted to adopt the identity of a British soldier - the man he was seen burying earlier - in a ploy to escape Dunkirk before the German vanguard broke through.
However, Nolan wasn't quite done there. Gibson meets a shocking demise almost immediately after he is unmasked. Attempting to escape the sinking boat that his group were hiding in, the unfortunate young man drowns after becoming tangled in a chain.
4. Steiner's Demise And Churchill's Body Double - The Eagle Has Landed
Based on Jack Higgins' novel of the same name, the WWII thriller The Eagle Has Landed depicts a fictional German plot to kidnap Winston Churchill at the height of the conflict. The 1976 film stars Michael Caine in the leading role of the brooding and highly decorated Colonel Kurt Steiner, the man charged with carrying out this daring plot.
The operation appears doomed to fail from the get-go, with high-ranking German officials realistically viewing the endeavour as little more than a meaningless exercise to placate their demented leader's whims. As such, the fact that the mission actually appears to succeed constitutes an almighty twist in itself, with Steiner apparently managing to successfully assassinate the British Prime Minister before being gunned down himself.
Remarkably, the shocking nature of the proceedings doesn't let up one bit from there. The dead "Churchill" is soon revealed to have been an unnervingly similar-looking body double - the real man is safe and sound on his way to the Tehran Conference. It's a seismic level curveball and the perfect conclusion to one of the most underrated war films from the 1970s.
3. The Alternate Timeline - Inglourious Basterds
The initial goings in the chaotic universe depicted by Quentin Tarantino's Inglourious Basterds indicated that the director was always willing to play it somewhat fast and loose with WWII's actual canon.
However, the extent to which Tarantino was willing to venture away from the realms of reality wasn't fully established until the confirmation that his film depicted an alternate - and decidedly embellished - historical timeline.
How does the inimitable filmmaker confirm this state of affairs, you ask? A few minor liberties with the real version of events here and there - namely, the Basterds massacring the entirety of Nazi High Command as they attend a premiere of the propaganda film, "Nation's Pride".
The delightful visual of Adolf Hitler's face being torn to shreds by a hail of machine gun bullets even comes around as the result of a slick twist within a twist. Christoph Waltz's Hans Landa merrily sells out his superiors to save his own skin in light of the Axis' impending defeat, despite his reputation as a fanatically loyal and ruthless Nazi.
The mind-bending revelation that Tarantino's film depicts alternate history makes his 2009 endeavour a worthy addition to this list, even before the shocking manner in which the subsequent bloody mayhem unfolds is revealed.
2. Blake's Death - 1917
If one had to pick a main character between the pair of George Mackay's Will Schofield and Dean Charles-Chapman's Tom Blake in the early goings of 1917, it is fair to say that the latter seems the more likely of the duo.
Not only was Blake the more outwardly personable of the two soldiers, but he also possessed an emotional connection to the film's central mission. He and Schofield are charged with carrying a message calling off a scheduled attack that would jeopardise the lives of nearly 2,000 men - amongst them, Blake's elder brother, Joseph.
In any case, there was somewhat of an intrinsic expectation that the film's two lead comrades in arms would at least make it to the end of Sam Mendes' epic, amplified by the prominence of the pair in promotional material for 1917. As such, watching said expectation suddenly and unexpectedly go up in flames around the film's halfway mark likely comes as an almighty surprise.
In a desolating development, Blake is mortally wounded by a German pilot after he and Will pull him from the wreckage of his own burning plane. Mackay's private dispatches the wounded aviator but it's too late - Tom bleeds out soon after, eliciting heartbreaking promises from Schofield that he will write to his mother and complete the mission.
1. Briony's Revelation - Atonement
Based on Ian McEwan's novel of the same name, Joe Wright's Atonement received a tidal wave of positive critical reception. The 2007 offering chronicles a purported crime and its devastating consequences over the course of nearly 60 years, set against the backdrop of WWII.
This evocative meditation on remorse and loss centres on Saoirse Ronan's Briony, who mistakenly accuses her older sister Cecilia's boyfriend Robbie - played by Keira Knightley and James McAvoy respectively - of a sexual assault. The innocent Robbie is incarcerated until he is eventually released to fight when war breaks out.
Atonement's twist isn't so much a twist as it is an emotional trainwreck. Robbie eventually makes it home - via the beaches of Dunkirk no less - to be reunited with Cecilia, eventually culminating in a tearful apology to the pair from Briony for her harrowing mistake. All's well that ends well, right?
Wrong. This happy ending is revealed to be a complete fabrication of the guilt-stricken Briony's mind, adapted into the chapters of an autobiographical novel to atone for her seismic levels of regret. In reality, Robbie died from an infected wound while waiting to be evacuated and Cecilia met her own demise soon after in the Balham tube station bombing.
Simply put, it's the most gutting twist to conclude a movie imaginable.