10 Ways Batman & Robin Changed Batman Movie History

It wasn't all bad...

Batman & Robin
Warner Bros.

It feels like a lifetime since Joel Schumacher's Batman & Robin threatened to kill Batman completely, so it's almost a surprise that the film has only just reached its 20th anniversary. Considered not only one of 1997's worst films, but also one of the worst of the decade, the film remains the go-to whipping boy when fans talk about the low-points in comic book movie history.

It's hard to really argue against the tide of criticism: it is not in any way a good film, and even the cultish kitsch appreciation of it that seems to have risen up in more recent years mostly ignores the specifics in favour of a comedic reading of it. But Batman & Robin does still have a hugely important position in wider Batman lore.

Without Batman & Robin - and mostly its disastrous performance - we would have an entirely different Batman cinematic universe right now, which might still be based on the pillars built during Joel Schumacher's time in charge of the Dark Knight. In other words, you should probably be thankful that it all imploded so catastrophically.


10. It Cancelled Schumacher's Batman "Triumphant"

Batman Triumphant New Logo 2
WC

As has been widely reported for years now, Warner Bros were so happy with the rushes for Batman & Robin that they immediately green-lit Schumacher's planned sequel. It would have been called Batman Unchained - though it was wrongly called Batman Triumphant until very recently - with a compelling story-line featuring the return of The Joker (at least as an hallucination) and the debuts of Harley Quinn and the Scarecrow.

Over the years, little bits of information related to the film have sneaked out - with Madonna and Courtney Love apparently sought for Harley Quinn and Nic Cage in the running for The Scarecrow - and though it all sounds pretty goofy in retrospect, there's a lot to be said for the film. It could actually have been Schumacher's best.

Unfortunately, the negative reception of Batman & Robin killed the project dead - and while elements of the plot can be seen in Batman Begins and the Arkham Knight game, that's as close as we'll ever get to seeing Schumacher's original vision. It's a shame, but who's to say where we'd be now if Unchained had come out...

Had it been a roaring success, we'd probably still be in that same timeline (or a variation), and if it had failed, we might have had to wait even longer for the redemptive reboot.


9. It Ended The Possibility Of Schumacher's Arkham Asylum (And Others)

Darknight Batman.jpg
WC

In the wake of Batman & Robin's failure - and though he later said he left the project out of fear that he'd lose his passion for film-making - Joel Schumacher actually had another sequel plan. Batman: DarKnight would have seen Batman face off with Man-Bat and The Scarecrow, and that project got as far as having a script written before it too was pushed aside.

Batman & Robin itself actually replaced Schumacher's original plan to make an Arkham Asylum-set movie - which was set up by the end of Batman Forever - and we could well have seen that idea reborn later in the series had the sequel not tanked.

More importantly, in place of Batman & Robin, Schumacher actually wanted to make The Dark Knight as his second Batman movie, but his desires were quashed by his paymasters:

"I wanted to do a whole other thing, because we had kind of re-invented franchise with Val as Batman and it was a very young, sexy, and much less expensive movie. We brought in Robin and I wanted to make The Dark Knight desperately, but the studio didn't want that and it's their money and they're my bosses."

It's very clear that Schumacher actually had some great ideas for Batman - knowing whether he was ever given full creative licence to turn them into films is what's up for debate. And just imagine how different the Batman universe would have been if we'd got Schumacher's Dark Knight - a sexier, cooler sequel in place of the camp pantomime of Batman & Robin. That would have caused waves.


8. Robin's Spin-Off Died

Warner Bros.

The plot of Batman Unchained would have apparently featured a clash of ideologies between Batman and young upstart Robin (which was already seeded in Batman & Robin), which would have eventually led to a spin-off for Chris O'Donnell's Boy Wonder.

He admitted that the spin-off had been on the table when Batman & Robin was wrongly assumed to be a home run, and while there were scant details offered when he announced what could have been in 2012, it's reasonable to assume we would have got a Nightwing movie with Robin striking out on his own.

Sadly - like the Michelle Pfeiffer-starring Catwoman spin-off - it was killed by the performance of Schumacher's work. While Catwoman died because Batman Forever ushered in a new era of non-gritty Batman movies, Batman & Robin's performance simply stopped spin-offs being a possibility. It was the ultimate franchise killer, and Robin was consigned to the scrap heap - where he still remains aside from a holy costume glimpsed in Batman v Superman.


7. It Killed The Era Of Camp

uma thurman poison ivy
Warner Bros.

As previously alluded, it was the huge success of Batman Forever that really shaped the way Warner Bros framed their plan for the future of Batman movies after 1995. The neon-tinged super spectacle was exactly to brief, with a fun spirit that would appeal to a family audience and sell toys starkly in contrast to Tim Burton's take on the character. It was also enough to kill that planned Catwoman spin-off that would have followed more closely to Burton's vision, but was deemed too contradictory to the new spirit of the Batman movies.

Unfortunately, the decision was made with Batman & Robin to dial up the campy sense of fun even more. The villains wouldn't have felt out of place on the 1960s Batman TV show, Gotham was increasingly turned into a living fun fair exhibit and the script was just mind-numbingly silly.

You would have thought that Warner Bros would have taken heed from the fact that camp had almost killed Batman comics for good back at the tail end of the 1960s, but they mercifully realised their error with Batman & Robin and ended the second era of camp. In its place, they sought to instead make Batman Beyond and Year One, which would have been a stark removal from the cartoonish tone set by Schumacher.


6. It Led To Years Of Creative Turbulence

Joss Whedon Year One.jpg
WC

Even after Batman Unchained was deemed dead in the water, Warner Bros had no plans to put Batman on ice. They ultimately decided to consider both Batman Beyond and an adaptation of Year One. Unfortunately - and somewhat bafflingly - neither ever really got beyond scripting, and it took until 2003 to get anything concrete into production when Chris Nolan was hired.

Reflecting the period of years before Batman 1989 came out - in which it looked like Batman would never get to the big screen due to general studio apathy - the years between Batman & Robin and Batman Begins were studded with multiple near misses. We almost got a couple of Year One adaptations, a Justice League from George Miller, Batman v Superman, Schumacher's DarKnight and a new origin from Joss Wehdon to name but a few.

Looking back now, it's stunning to think that Warner Bros would have struggled to make a Batman film in the wake of Batman & Robin. Its overseas performance suggested there was still an audience for the character, and given the greater commitment these days to continue with DCEU movies even despite critical performance, it's odd on reflection to think of Batman as so precarious a brand.


5. It Killed Warner Bros' Toy Fetish

Batman Robin Toy
Kenner

As toy collectors will attest - 1997 was a wonderful time for buying Batman toy, because Warner Bros doubled down on their merchandise deals in the wake of Batman Forever's success, and the resulting toy line was huge and mostly great. A lot of it had absolutely nothing to do with the film, but that was by the by.

The influx of toys was a by-product of Warner Bros' desire to market Batman more at kids to capture a healthier slice of the merchandise pot. They had been frustrated by Tim Burton's grown-up, creepier vision that wasn't going to sell toys to anyone but the most broken of children, and it was apparently that that led to them leaning on Schumacher to lighten up his films.

In other words, it was Warner Bros' desire to sell more toys that gave us the unwanted gift of Batman & Robin's neon awfulness. Mercifully, with the sequel torn to shreds, the studio seemingly realised that selling toys should come second to a good creative vision, as they opened up the floor to some far more adult pitches for the follow-up.


4. It Changed The Perception Of What Batman Was (And Could Be)

Batman Begins
CraveOnline

It's best to consider Batman & Robin as a rich, sugary dessert - it was too decadent and too sickly sweet to really satisfy, but it was so over-the-top that you'd never consider having it again. In other words, it necessitated a palate-cleansing reboot, and it opened up the possibility of wildly different interpretations of what Batman could be.

In the wake of George Clooney's one-dimensional cartoon character, the idea of continuing down the same track looked perverse, which is precisely why Darren Aronosky's pitch was even considered despite the fact that he proclaimed that he would "Toss out everything you can imagine about Batman! Everything! We're starting completely anew."

Aronofsky's extreme vision would have removed everything we recognised about Batman - probably to a reductive degree - but it was reflective of the studio's increased willingness to consider Batman in a different way. And ultimately, it was that creative flexibility that opened the door for Christopher Nolan to make a Batman film that was almost entirely unrecognisable from traditional comic book movies up to that point.


3. It Kick-Started The Nolanverse

Batman Begins Suit
Warner Bros.

Obviously, the biggest development in the wake of Batman & Robin was that Christopher Nolan was eventually hired - in 2003 after Joss Whedon's December 2002 pitch for an origin story was passed on - and the Batman universe was completely transformed.

Without Batman & Robin's flamboyance, there's no way Nolan's stripped down, humanist superhero would have been considered - it certainly wouldn't have been in the mid-90s, anyway. But Nolan and David S Goyer's script - which went darker without the gothic influences of Tim Burton's work - was deemed a better option than any of the other irons in the fire.

Nolan's take on Batman will forever exist in a bubble: it bears little resemblance to what came before it, and even the DCEU's take on the Dark Knight feels like a conscious rail against what he created. But then that's the price of genius: anyone seeking to emulate would look foolish in direct comparison.


2. It Inspired SOME Of The Dark Knight Rises' Plot

Bane Batman & Robin
Warner Bros.

Just as the abandoned Batman Unchained apparently partly inspired Batman Begins, Christopher Nolan seemingly watched Batman & Robin when it came to putting together the story for The Dark Rises.

In both cases, the films kick off with a frozen Batman logo, Alfred sits out the main events of the plot while offering an emotional heart to the narrative, and Bane not only works for another female villain, but he also literally fights Batman on a catwalk. It surely can't be accidental...

You can read more about those similarities here.


1. It Ruined Mr Freeze Completely

Mr Freeze
Warner Bros.

The worst legacy Batman & Robin inspired was the negative effect it had on the image of Mr Freeze. Thanks to his portrayal in Batman: The Animated Series, the character was one of the cooler figures in Batman's Rogue's Gallery (after admittedly sillier early days), but it's almost unforgivable what the film did to him.

Taking The Animated Series backstory of his ill wife being his motivation, Freeze was transformed from a tragic figure into a shiny blue monstrosity, spewing puns and generally being a hugely embarrassing low-point in the franchise.

And worst of all, even though other Batman villains have had second goes on the big screen, neither Freeze nor Poison Ivy have been considered again. We might get to see Ivy in Gotham City Sirens, but it will apparently take longer to wipe out the ominous shadow of Arnold Schwarzenegger's portrayal of Freeze. And that's an absolute travesty.

Did you secretly love Batman & Robin? Do you think it deserves the hate? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.