10 Ways The DCEU Films Nearly Turned Out Completely Different
The Snyder Cut isn't the only DCEU 'what if?' that could've changed everything.
Making a comic book movie is a nightmare. But you know what's harder? Creating a comic book movie universe to compete with the MCU. After years of brainstorming, script rewrite after script rewrite, directors getting hired and replaced, and producers retconning everything at the last minute, the DCEU could've turned out very differently, for better or for worse.
Of course, there are people who don't give a second thought to what could have been. What they saw on the big screen was the finished product. I mean, it's not going to change, is it?
But after the Snyder Cut of the Justice League was officially announced, DC fans were fascinated that the original director's vision would finally see the light of day. After seeing the trailer depicting clips that were nowhere to be seen in the Josstice League, viewers were curious what else had been changed in the DC Extended Universe.
How different was the original script for Wonder Woman? Who was meant to be the main villain in Birds of Prey? And whatever happened to Man of Steel 2?
10. Black Manta, The Dead King, And Batman - Aquaman
Even though Black Manta is Aquaman's nemesis, he plays second fiddle in the live-action film while Aquaman's brother, Orm serves as the central antagonist. However, Manta originally had a bigger role in the story. According to the Fire & Water Podcast (Via ScreenRant), the audience felt like the movie was overstuffed with content, forcing the director to sacrifice some of Manta's scenes.
Also, when Aquaman attempts to retrieve Atlan's trident, he must prove himself by facing a sea monster called the Karathen. But in one script, the aquatic superhero faced off against a reanimated version of Atlan called The Dead King to prove he was worthy to wield his weapon. This was probably changed since watching Aquaman surfing on a leviathan looks a lot more cinematic than teaming up with a bearded water zombie.
According to some concept art, Batman was meant to make an appearance because... I mean, every film is automatically better by inserting Batman.
He was meant to fly through Sydney in his jet and stop Atlantis' forces from invading the city. This sequence was probably scrapped after DC executives became more wary about shoehorning in iconic characters to pander to audiences.
9. Black Adam - Shazam
Because Black Adam is Shazam's nemesis, everyone was expecting him to play a prominent role in the live-action film. And since Dwayne Johnson was already cast (waaaaaay back in 2009 for a completely different production and again in 2014 for the DCEU), his appearance in David F. Sandberg's Shazam seemed like a sure thing.
Apart from popping up as a hologram for a few seconds, the black sheep of the Marvel family was nowhere to be seen in Shazam. Although Adam was meant to be the antagonist, he was substituted for the wicked scientist, Thaddeus Sivana. As mentioned on Collider, the producers believed Adam's backstory was so complex, it would be been better to introduce the character in his own film.
Shazam actor, Zachary Levi, said it was a good move not to introduce his arch-enemy too early since the franchise would have nowhere to go. At the moment, Shazam and Adam aren't set to cross paths until the third movie in the series. But due to the uncertain future of the DCEU and Adam's solo film being delayed (again), it's not clear when the champions will meet.
8. A LOT Of Characters Were Cut - Birds Of Prey
With the announcement of Birds of Prey (I'm not saying the whole title), fans wondered if Jared Leto would make an appearance as the Joker. Sadly, ,Mistah J only made an appearance in archival footage and with a body double from behind.
But that wasn't always the case. The stand-in for the Joker, Johnny Goth, shot a whole scene where his character breaks up with Harley. The scene was canned to avoid pulling focus from Harley's relationship with her crew.
But the Clown Prince of Crime wasn't the only one axed. Batgirl, Katana, and Lady Shiva were also intended to appear but were ultimately written out. However, the biggest difference between the pitch and what we got on the screen was the main villain. According to The Wrap reporter, Umberto Gonzalez, the Penguin was intended to be the big bad of Birds of Prey.
But after Colin Farrell was cast as the Penguin in Matt Reeves' The Batman, the Gentleman of Crime was swapped out in Birds of Prey for Black Mask. This decision probably worked out in the film's favour since, for all of Bird of Prey's faults, Ewan McGregor's performance as the masked sociopath was a highlight.
7. Zod Lived - Man Of Steel
The DC Extended Universe has been bathed in controversy since its inception. One moment that fans still argue about to this day is Zod's death in Man of Steel. As the maniacal Kryptonian prepares to kill a group of civilians, Superman is left with no choice but to break Zod's neck. Because Superman is known for never taking a life, millions of viewers believed his actions contradicted his character.
But if the producer, Christopher Nolan, had his way, this scene would've been nixed. As screenwriter, David S. Goyer, explained in an interview with Empire (via Huffpost), Nolan was instantly against this decision, stating it was uncharacteristic of the iconic superhero.
Instead, he wanted Supes to hurl Zod back into The Phantom Zone during the climax. But Snyder said having the Boyscout superhero consciously taking a life was integral for developing the character and so, wouldn't budge with the idea.
It's intriguing how different the DCEU would've been if Nolan got his way. Not only would Man of Steel received far less flack, it would've had a snowball effect on future movies since Superman's decision to kill was a pivotal plot point in the follow-up.
6. A Dark, Gritty Adaptation - Shazam
Even though the DC Extended Universe started off as broody and serious, Shazam was a nice change of pace since it embraced the campy wackiness of the comics. Yes, it was cheesy and some of the dialogue is a bit corny but it felt like the movie wouldn't have worked any other way. I mean, could you imagine the Big Red Cheese in a dark and gritty adaptation?
But that's almost what we got! Screenwriter, John August, told MTV that he was hired to write the script for a Shazam film adaptation back in 2008. But when Warner Bros. saw Speed Racer bomb at the box office and The Dark Knight bank a billion dollars, they put Shazam on hold.
The studio assumed modern audiences were no longer interested in colourful, fun comic movies and so, pressurised August to rewrite Shazam so it was more in line with Christopher Nolan's Batman trilogy.
When August left the project, Warner Bros. considered abandoning the whole film and instead, making an animated series about the World's Mightiest Mortal. It would've been a massive shame if Shazam. went down this route since we would've missed out on the funniest movie in the DCEU.
5. Metallo Was The Main Villain For Proposed Man Of Steel 2
Before Zack Snyder decided to make Batman v Superman, the follow-up of Man of Steel was going to be very different. Originally, the villain would've been John Corben.
In the comics, Corben was a journalist who was killed during a scientific experiment. However, he was resurrected when his mind was transferred to a cybernetic body fuelled by Kryptonite. When he turned to a life of crime, he became known as Metallo, The Man with the Kryptonite Heart.
When Snyder decided to incorporate Batman and Wonder Woman into the film, he was still set on Metallo playing a part of the story. The cybernetic supervillain was meant to be created from the remains of Wallace Keefe; the paraplegic who was blown up during the Congressional hearing.
Even though this plot was abandoned, Metallo's creator, Emmet Vale, does appear in the movie.
It's a pity Metallo was discarded since he's a really interesting character. Because he is powered by the one thing Superman is weak to, it would've been cool to see the Last Son of Krypton rely on his wits rather than brute strength to defeat his foe.
4. Wayne Manor In Man Of Steel
Because Man of Steel was the first chapter of a brand new cinematic universe, comic fans weren't exactly sure what to expect. Would the movie contain cameos from iconic characters and references to future storylines like the MCU or would it tell a self-contained story?
Apart from some blink-and-you-will-miss-it Easter eggs like a Wayne Enterprises satellite and a Lexcorp skyscraper, Man of Steel barely acknowledged its lore outside of Superman. But things could have been different. In an interview to an EW (via cinemablend), Zack Snyder shared that he wanted the film to end with a scene showing a crate of Kryptonite being delivered to Wayne Manor.
Once Snyder said this idea aloud, he became obsessed with having the follow-up revolving around Batman and Superman duking it out. It's not certain why Snyder didn't include this scene but it may be because the DCEU was just getting started at the time. It would've been sensible to see how Man of Steel fared before setting up massive storylines for future movies.
Adding this scene probably wouldn't have changed the direction taken in Batman v Superman but it would've been a masterful cliffhanger.
3. The Joker Scenes - Suicide Squad
Suicide Squad was an unfortunate victim of executive meddling. Scenes were cut or inserted in the eleventh hour and the film's tone was changed late in production.
But the biggest issue that people had with the movie was the fact it contained far less Joker than we were promised. Based on the promotion and trailers, filmgoers assumed the green-haired jester would serve as more than a glorified cameo. Even in the extended cut, the Joker only appears for 12 minutes.
We were meant to see the the tattooed gangster breaking out of jail, killing victims with his crew, and offering his services to the Enchantress. Although the film concludes with Harley agreeing to rejoin the Joker, she chose to stay with the Suicide Squad in the original script.
According to Variety, there were enough scenes of Jared Leto's character left on the cutting room floor to make a whole other movie. The director, David Ayer, admitted that viewers' criticisms about the cackling clown's absence were justified and and he would've made the Joker the main villain if he had another crack at the film.
2. The Crimean War - Wonder Woman
After Wonder Woman learns Ares has encouraged mankind to wage war on one other, she leaves her home of Themyscira, and ventures into human civilisation for the first time. Having the story take place during World War I was a great idea since Diana witnesses the worst of mankind firsthand, emboldening her even more to safeguard the world.
But Zack Snyder had other plans. As we know, Wonder Woman made her live-action debut in Batman v Superman. In one scene, Bruce Wayne sees Diana in a century-old photograph and realises she is immortal.
Snyder originally wanted the picture to be taken during the Crimean War in 1853, since it was one of the first wars to occur after photography had become commonplace. He also wanted Diana to be more brutal and have scenes of her hacking off the heads of her victims. (If you look closely at the photo, you can see Diana clutching three decapitated heads.)
The original director, Michelle MacLaren, wasn't a fan of this setting or tone and so, had the time period and style changed before Patty Jenkins took over the project.
1. There Was A Completely Different Script - Justice League
In 2012, Will Beall was hired to write the script for Justice League. This was one year after production began on Man of Steel so it's clear this movie was meant to be a part of the DCEU.
First revealed by The Wrap, this Justice League would've been the craziest film ever. The first scene included Batman, Superman, KGBeast, Killer Croc, and DeSaad. (If that sounds nuts, that's only the beginning.) The plot itself revolves around Darkseid's general, Steppenwolf, kidnapping Superman and using his power to destroy 80% of the world's population, crippling mankind.
The story then jumps 11 years later where Batman, Wonder Woman, and Lex Luthor join forces to reverse time to ensure Darkseid never turns Supes into a weapon. It would've concluded with the heroes emerging victorious but Lex learning of Superman's secret identity.
The film would've included a staggering cast including Deathstroke, Cheetah, Solomon Grundy, Hawkman, Tattooed Man, Copperhead, and some of the iconic Green Lanterns. It also would've included Bruce Wayne and Wonder Woman's son, Clark Wayne!
It's hard to say whether this Justice League would've been better or worse than what we got. But it definitely would've been like nothing else we have seen before.
Watch Next
You'll Never Get 100% On This Justice League Quiz!