10 Worst CGI Effects In Sci-Fi Movies

Anything but special effects.

The Matrix Reloaded
Warner Bros.

Computer-Generated Imagery has consistently helped bring some of the most iconic scenes and characters in science fiction movie history to life over the last 50+ years.

Without this tool, we would have never been able to completely immerse ourselves in the world of Pandora in Avatar (2009), been introduced to the awe-inspiring Tyrannosaurus Rex in Jurassic Park (1993) or found ourselves genuinely empathising with an ape called Caesar in Rise of the Planet of the Apes (2011).

Yet, not every ambitious sci-fi project is blessed with the sort of stunning visual effects which impressively transport an audience into a bold new world. Some are actually so painfully bad that they instantly drag fans back into reality and leave them storming away from the cinema with a seriously bitter taste in their mouths.

It must be said, nobody sets out to craft terrible CGI moments (you'd like to think) and these sci-fi effects can sometimes take years to bring to the big screen. So, it's just a shame that what we ended up witnessing in these ten movies either made us laugh, wince or cry for all the wrong reasons.

The Xenomorph deserved better, Ridley Scott.

10. Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope - Jabba The Hutt Makes A Jarring Appearance

Jabba in A New Hope
20th Century Fox

Though George Lucas has received a lot of criticism for his questionable decision to go back and alter certain visuals in his classic Star Wars original trilogy, his tinkering did actually enhance some of the scenes set in a galaxy far, far away.

His decision to insert the prequel version of Emperor Palpatine into the hologram scene in The Empire Strikes Back (1980) and the improved lightsaber effects were both welcome updates.

However, reinstating a scene involving everyone's (least) favourite Hutt in the 1997 re-release of A New Hope (1977) proved exactly how distracting bad CGI can be on its day.

Here, the Jabba we remember in all his practical effects glory in Return of the Jedi (1983) is butchered completely and made to look like a ridiculous alien/Cheshire Cat hybrid.

That original version may have been an unquestionable eyesore, but at least the character looked more realistic in the later re-releases, right?

Not exactly.

When the films were tweaked again in 2004, it still felt like you were watching two separate movies going on at the same time and Han Solo walking over Jabba's tail only reminded us just how unnecessary it was to cram this scene back into an already cherished movie.


9. The Matrix Reloaded - Neo Vs The Army Of Agent Smiths

Matrix reloaded
Warner Bros.

There's a reason the first Matrix (1999) walked away with an Academy Award for Best Visual Effects.

Neo's bullet dodging scene still stands as one of the finest special effect moments of all time and the movie proved to be a game-changer for CGI in film.

However, the film's sequel The Matrix Reloaded (2003) may have gotten a bit carried away with its near tripled budget size.

Though Neo stopping a ton of bullets with just one hand and parts of the epic highway battle are examples of the film getting its visuals right, it's hard to talk about Reloaded without mentioning that farcical 'Burly Brawl'.

When Neo was forced to take on a bunch of Agent Smith clones in a courtyard, few people were expecting to see one of the most unintentionally funny fist fights in sci-fi movie history. But, see it we did.

It was definitely admirable to attempt to pump this many versions of Hugo Weaving into a high octane punch up, but the resulting showdown became borderline unwatchable at times with its jarring cuts between authentic mixed martial arts combat and clunky slow motion CGI attacks.


8. Lost In Space - Blarp Steals The Spotlight

Blarp Lost in Space
New Line Cinema

Remarkably, in a film starring Gary Oldman, Heather Graham, William Hurt and Matt LeBlanc, the most memorable part of sci-fi adventure flick Lost in Space (1998) was the appearance of one of the worst CGI messes in cinema history; the lizard-monkey oddity known as Blarp.

To bring this dodgy creature to the big screen, the actors on set would react to an animatronic puppet of Blarp and the CGI performance was later added in post-production by the special effects team who were being supervised by Nick Allder - the person who watched over the effects in films like Alien, The Fifth Element and Hellboy. What could go wrong?

Well, for starters the actors don't even look like they knew where the creature's eyes were whenever they were interacting with it. On top of this lack of genuine connection, the digitally realised being seemed less like an alien from another world and more like a drawing you lazily doodled whilst day-dreaming at school.

You can't even blame these terrible visuals on a small budget or lack of top level technology as films like Jurrassic Park (1993) and Men in Black (1997) managed to produce next level CGI creatures with similar budgets at that time.

Blarp is simply a blip most people would prefer to forget.


7. Star Wars Episode II: Attack Of The Clones - Anakin Goes Shaak Surfing

Much of the CGI on show throughout the highly divisive Star Wars prequel trilogy is among the very best to be thrown into a sci-fi feature set in space.

The jaw-dropping dogfights in space, menacing General Grievous and outstanding pod race still hold up all these years later and the various detailed environments such as Coruscant, Kashyyyk and Mustafar all felt like places our characters were legitimately living and breathing in.

Yet, there was the odd CGI clusterf*ck which quickly undid some of that sensational work.

One of these moments took place during Anakin and Padme's now infamous romantic vacation on Naboo in Attack of the Clones (2002). Taking a break away from discussing his view on politics, the young Jedi decides to ride a grass eating herbivore known as a Shaak.

The act itself was enough to leave any audience member cringing in their seats, but the shoddy CGI used to create the beast took this agonising scene to a whole new level of awkward.

Thankfully, other alien creatures like the Reek, Acklay and Nexu were all convincingly revealed later in the feature. Yet, no amount of epic face-offs with six legged monstrosities could erase the memory of young Skywalker being trampled by a poorly crafted potato with legs.


6. I Am Legend - Will Smith Takes On Jarring Infected Darkseekers

I am legend Alternate Ending
Warner Bros. Pictures

Will Smith has had multiple encounters with the world of CGI creatures and effects during his career and the results have been, well, varied.

Films like I, Robot (2004) and Men in Black (1997) were both equipped with top standard digital creations, whereas the likes of Gemini Man (2019) felt like unfortunate steps backwards for both the actor and visual effects as a whole.

Yet, it's hard to look past I Am Legend (2007) as the Smith-starring film with the most disappointing CGI visuals to date.

During the film, Smith puts in a deeply compelling and moving performance as Dr. Robert Neville, a U.S. Army virologist who is immune to a virus which has killed off 5.4 billion people and turned the majority of those left into infected Darkseekers.

However, once the aforementioned Darkseekers reveal themselves, the audience's fear of those who lurk in the dark and attack the uninfected is replaced with apathy. Director Francis Lawrence has since admitted that he wished he'd been able to use actors and practical effects to produce the infected humans, but the footage he shot with '50 dancers and parkour guys' early in production wasn't up to standard so he was forced to go digital.

Sadly, the out of place CGI Darkseekers which made their way into the finished product completely distracted audiences from one of Smith's career best performances and made I Am Legend something of a bittersweet experience as a whole.


5. Tron: Legacy - Young Jeff Bridges Fails To Deliver

Tron Legacy Clu Jeff Bridges
Disney

Much of the talk going into Tron: Legacy (2010) centred around the ground-breaking CGI de-ageing of star Jeff Bridges.

This was one of the first times filmmakers had attempted to convincingly de-age an actor for a role, with other films such as The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (2008) and X-Men: The Last Stand (2006) also dipping their toe into the CGI time travelling pool around this time, too.

Yet, despite the rest of the film's effects definitely delivering, the ambitious effects used to roll back the years for Bridges' digitally created character of Clu still looked noticeably artificial and quickly pulled people out of what was an aesthetically pleasing feature up until that point.

The tool of de-ageing has come on heaps and bounds in the decade since Legacy was produced and everything from Gangster features (The Irishman, 2019) to Middle-earth adventures (The Hobbit series 2012-2014) have used this ever-growing technology to produce convincing younger iterations of their performers.

However, this early de-ageing experiment ultimately failed upon Legacy's release and now acts as a clear reminder of just how jarring de-ageing can be if it's not pulled off effectively.


4. Men In Black II - Locker Universe

As we've mentioned a few times in this list already, the first Men in Black (1997) received critical acclaim for its high quality visual effects, used to create characters like Edgar the Bug in the sci-fi action comedy. Also, MiB even earned an Academy Award for its fantastic use of make-up to bring certain aliens to life.

Yet, when the sequel Men in Black II hit our screens in 2002, the increased budget size didn't necessarily lead to substantial CGI improvement as far as the various intergalactic creatures were concerned.

One of the most disappointing digitally created moments came at the end of the feature and involved the idea of entire universes being crammed inside of lockers found in an alien train station.

The concept seems ming-bending and hilarious enough, however the terrible execution leaves much to be desired.

It felt like a great deal of effort had gone into crafting the furry little creatures we'd seen earlier in a Grand Central Station locker. Unfortunately, the lazily designed video game-esque extra terrestrials we saw wandering around in the alien train station during the final shot of the film felt like a rushed last minute addition.

If you want to avoid complete and utter disappointment, stick to the alternate ending which sees Will Smith's Agent J blasting off to the furry aliens' world instead.


3. Mad Max: Fury Road - The 3-D Steering Wheel

Mad Max: Fury Road (2015) didn't solely rely on CGI to produce a staggering piece of sci-fi cinema.

In fact, the majority of the high octane action we saw on the big screen was legitimately performed on set, with 150 stunt people taking part in extraordinary sequences and even the film's stars getting their hands dirty when the time called for it.

That's what made the decision to add a distracting piece of random CGI into one of the film's most impressive stunts so baffling.

Of course, CGI had been used to get rid of cables and safety rigs in post-production, and also to produce terrific moments like the other worldly sandstorm we see in the flick. Yet, director George Miller also weirdly chose to digitally add the sight of the War Rig's steering wheel (and a guitar) soaring towards the camera after Nux (Nicholas Hoult) had heroically sacrificed himself to save his friends.

If the effect was as realistic as the others we'd seen in the sci-fi western on wheels then we probably could've forgiven Miller for this peculiar choice. But, the frustrating attempt to immerse the audience in the climactic crash with poorly made 3-D projectiles stuck out like a sore thumb and is one of the few annoying blemishes in this near-perfect experience.


2. The 5th Wave - A Sea Of Crappy CGI

Rick Yancey's sci-fi young adult novel The 5th Wave was warmly received when it landed on bookshelves in 2013 and opened the door for sequels in the form of The Infinite Sea and The Last Star in 2014 and 2016, respectively.

So, as with any popular YA book, it was only a matter of time before a production company tried to turn the series into a lucrative movie franchise.

However, unlike the hugely successful Twilight and Hunger Games films, The 5th Wave (2016) didn't really find an audience. The predictable script and rotten visual effects on show definitely can't have helped.

Early on we witness a fairly bog-standard tsunami wipe out a city, but things only go from bad to worse as soon we get our first look at the supposed true form of The Others thanks to some x-ray equipment.

Through Ben's (Nick Robinson) eyes we see what looks like a discount face-hugger-like creature probably designed to freak out the younger members in the audience. Instead it likely elicited jolts of unexpected laughter from them and became yet another stick to beat this weak adaptation with.


1. Alien: Covenant - Soulless Xenomorph

Speaking of face huggers!

After the success of Ridley Scott's return to the Alien universe with Prometheus (2012) fans were over the moon to hear that the legendary director was on board for the sequel titled Alien: Covenant (2017).

Yet, instead of building on the practical effects which often made Prometheus and his original Alien (1979) film such a believable and therefore even more terrifying experience, Scott relied more heavily on CGI for Covenant.

Sure, Prometheus featured its fair share of CG wizardry. But, a large number of the creatures we saw on screen were practical and created thanks to excellent make up and animatronics.

Sadly, when it came to finally bringing the iconic Xenomorph back to life in Covenant, Scott decided to mostly use CGI and what we were left with was a hugely dissatisfying alien monster which felt like it belonged in the 90's.

The worst moment came during the scene where the famous creature was attacking the Covenant space ship attempting to take off. Instead of making us genuinely fear this acid-blooded alien, Scott snapped us straight out of the moment and forced us to focus on what appeared to be a Xenomorph taken straight out of one of the many Alien video games.

Covenant still boasted a few decent practical monstrosities, but our beloved Xenomorph deserved more than the clunky CGI treatment it eventually got in the end.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!