10 Worst Modern Comic Book Character Adaptations

Great characters aren't necessarily great comic book adaptations...

Bruce Wayne Batman
Warner Bros.

For the last 20 years comic book movies have played a role in pop culture that none could have predicted. Ever since the introduction of the X-Men and Spiderman to our movie screens the comic book movie genre has only gone up and up in terms of sheer gross and potential. From time to time however there are some decisions made about the characterisations of some characters which are questionable at best.

There are many reasons that the characterisation lent to the character on a film screen may leave a bad taste in the mouths of the viewers. The reasons can be varied: straying too far from the comic book routes, overpowering or depowering a character for the purpose of storyline, backstory inaccuracies and just plain ridiculousness.

Comic books seem to be being adapted more and more every year, so it would be impossible to create a comprehensive list of the worst characterisations with only ten entries, the focus here will be on big names from the last three decades of comic book films and the terrible impact that they have had on the genre.

10. Dr Doom (Fantastic Four 2005, 2007 And 2015)

Julian Mcmahon doctor doom
20th Century Fox

Dr Doom of the comics has stolen the power of the Gods, made the all powerful Galactus his herald and even taken on Mephisto using science. He is second only to Dr Strange when it comes to magical ability, he is the King of Latveria and his genius knows literally no bounds. The Dr Dooms in both film iterations can manipulate energy and are constantly outwitted and outshone by nearly all on screen characters in those movies.

Portrayed as a disgruntled executive in the first two Fantastic Four movies then an egotistical shut in in the following movie, it's safe to say that Dr Doom is in serious need of some character rehabilitation.

For the sake of scaling him down to a reasonable threat for Marvel's first family, he is depowered to a laughable degree. Losing all of his magical abilities, his ability to communicate with technology and his beyond genius level intellect, he is left a shell of his comic book self. There is no doubt that in order to make the stakes believable for the big screen that depowering a character is sometimes necessary, what wasn't necessary is also taking away motivations and any idea that such an enduring character is not a long term threat.

From his motivations to his power, all big screen adaptations of Victor Von Doom have been horrible, all we can hope for is that the boffins over at Marvel Studios can rehabilitate him and give him the outing that he deserves.


9. Deadpool (X-Men Origins: Wolverine)

X-Men Origins Wolverine Deadpool
20th Century Studios

What did Ryan Reynolds do to the screenwriter for this monstrosity to occur. The merc with a mouth lost his mouth, had kitanas implanted in his arms and was supposedly the amalgamation of multiple mutants powers.

Let's all be thankful that he was never brought back in this form.

Brought into existence by William Stryker using the DNA of mutants from Cyclops to Nightcrawler, 'Deadpool' is a powerful villain and actually puts on a good showing against both Wolverine and Sabretooth, the major let down however is that he just doesn't live up to the name.

There is no need to explain the comic book version of Deadpool thanks largely to the two successful Deadpool movies in existence. Perfectly portraying the smart ass that is Wade Wilson with the mutant power of healing and utilising his well practiced mercenary abilities to become one of the deadliest characters in the Marvel Comics Universe (he once killed the entire Marvel Universe).

Deadpool has become a much beloved character since his recent resurgence and that is the only reason he is not number one on this list.


8. Batman (Batman Begins, The Dark Knight And Dark Knight Rises)

The Dark Knight Quiz
Warner Bros. Pictures

You may find yourself asking how Nolan's Batman found his way onto this list, quite simply put Nolan's Batman trilogy was an amazing film trilogy yet it was a mediocre superhero film trilogy. Many aspects of the character that make him a 'super' hero are watered down and he finds himself as more of a high tech S.W.A.T officer with wings than the superhero we all know and love. Batman seems neutered in these films due to the dilution of the very characteristics which make him the superhero he is.

Batman is perhaps the most cunning tactician in all of DC Comics, so far ahead of his compatriots in the Justice League that he has a plan of action for if any (or all) of them go rogue, this is just not shown in the Nolan trilogy. Throughout the whole trilogy he is constantly being outwitted by his antagonists, he constantly reverts to the underdog position rather than being five steps ahead. He also displays a rather rash and impetuous behaviour which is very unlike The Dark Knight. Jumping headfirst into situations where the comic Batman would consider all options and take the least dangerous and most effective course of action.

The most glaring problem with Bale and Nolan's Batman however is the addiction to realism. Putting so much emphasis on the debilitating toll that being Batman will take on your body let's down the fun factor of the Batman franchise. Let him be the best a human can be without putting the idea out there that being Batman is a short lived endeavour.

Batman in the Nolan trilogy is a great movie character, he is not a great adaptation of the comic book character however.


7. Venom (Spiderman 3)

Venom Topher Grace
DC Entertainment

Venom is one of the most iconic non universal villains in all of comics, from his size, to intimidation factor and strength he is truly a high level threat when it comes to Spiderman's rogue gallery. Enter Topher Grace.

Skinny, anemic and whiny with absolutely no intimidating features other than a wide toothy grin, the movie Venom is but a shadow of his comic book self. Lacking the strength and independence to go up against Spiderman on his own he enlist the assistance of Sandman and despite the numbers advantage they still struggle throughout most of the third act climax.

While immature at times in the source material and even playful, the underlying theme is that Venom is a true threat to the earth of the Marvel Universe which is in no way portrayed here. Had the filmmakers taken a less Spiderman like approach to the final design of Venom and perhaps embellished his features, made him more of a threat then there would be some tension in the final act.


6. Juggernaut (X-Men: The Last Stand)

Juggernaut X-men 3
Marvel Entertainment

The only reason this truly horrible character is not much further up the list is his limited screen time. Standing out as one of the worst parts of the much maligned X-Men: The Last Stand (that says a lot).

The Juggernaut is known for his unstoppable momentum, being the step brother of Charles Xavier and holding the Crimson Gem of Cyttorak, none of which is held onto for this iteration of the character. Throughout the movie we are given the impression that the Juggernaut is in fact a mutant, despite the fact that in comic lore he is simply empowered by the Crimson Gem. During the third act we see his powers negated by the mutant Leech, whose power is to take away any mutant's power within range. Simply put the Juggernaut is not simply another rogue in the gallery of the X-Men, because his power originates from another source foreign to mutation.

The omission that the Juggernaut is in fact the step brother of Professor X takes away a lot of backstory for the villain and makes him seem like just another minion in the grand scheme of things. Had it been stated that he is in fact related to Charles Xavier, his character would have been instantly more fleshed out.

The Juggernaut deserved a lot more than he received in his 2006 outing, unfortunately he will be remember for perhaps the single most cringeworthy line in all of comic book movie history, "I'm the Juggernaut b**ch!". Honestly just that line is explanation enough as to why he is on this list.

Juggernaut was never the most articulate character in comics but he was definitely greater than his 2006 outing.


5. Steel (Steel)

Steel Shaq
Warner Bros.

That picture is real, as hard as it may be to believe it's not Shaquille O'Neal in a terrible, off colour Batman mask.

Steel is a character best described as a very physically capable human who has power equal to Superman when wearing his eponymous Steel suit. As a human (in the comics) he is at near peak levels of strength, agility and technological genius, unfortunately all of these have been forgotten for this adaptation. The powers and qualities that made Steel a good character were replaced with cheesy dialogue and terrible acting.

The film version of Steel is quite literally Steel by name only. He shares very little with his comic book counterpart other than his name, race and ability to create powerful weapons. Originally being pitched as a spin off to the potential 'Death of Superman' movie of the 90's, this film went ahead despite the lack of the aforementioned movie and as such completely lacked context and backstory which becomes painfully obvious from the very first scenes of the movie.

While being a serviceable comic book character with interesting potential, the only movie iteration of Steel we have so far seen will go down in history as perhaps the most forgotten superhero ever adapted to cinema.


4. Mr Freeze (Batman & Robin)

Mr Freeze
Warner Bros.

The comic book Mr Freeze is a tragic character, perhaps one of the most intriguing and conflicted villains of DC Comics. Having a back story similar to Walter White of Breaking Bad fame, Victor Fries must turn to the creation of a vast criminal empire in order to help prolong the life of his wife and try and bring her back to health. In the 1997 film 'Batman & Robin' he wants to help his wife but also make every single ice related pun possible while laughing his way through the entire movie.

The tragedy of Mr Freeze is one that has resulted in an unashamedly mature character for older and more mature fans of comic books to appreciate and as such should be handled with dignity and respect. Unfortunately in Joel Schumacher's neon coloured nightmare the legacy of Mr Freeze is so trampled upon that there has been no attempt to revitalise him on the big screen since.

Spewing out forced pun after pun we are introduced to Arnold Schwarzenegger in the guise of Mr Freeze, a completely dumbed down and simplified version of the tragic character. Adding humour to this certain character would have been acceptable had the humour been tasteful and perhaps witty, instead we were subjected to pun after horrible pun. The fact that Schwarzenegger had any sort of career following this movie is a miracle.


3. The Mandarin (Iron Man 3)

Iron Man 3 Mandarin
Marvel Studios

The Marvel Cinematic Universe is usually the standard by which all other adaptations and characters are compared, that's why it was such an unwelcome surprise seeing what they had done to The Mandarin.

Throughout the first and most of the second act we were led to believe that the enigmatic Mandarin played by Sir Ben Kingsley was the real deal. Cold and menacing with just the right amount of mystery about himself, he could have been one of the great villains of the MCU. When Tony Stark comes across the Mandarin (now Trevor Slattery) exiting the bathroom all of the build and tension surrounding the character dissipates instantly.

The Mandarin of the comics is perhaps Iron Man's best villain, conniving and ahead of Stark constantly he is a worthy adversary to the man that has everything. Leader of the Ten Rings and bane of western society he is truly a menace that deserved better.

Now if you were to make the argument that Aldrich Killian is the real Mandarin then once again you are let down as the character shares little more than his supposed name with the villain of the source material.

Overall Iron Man 3 suffered due to the convoluted nature of the storytelling and overdoing it with the villainy. Had the Mandarin been the true villain of the movie, Ben Kingsley was the man to bring charisma and notoriety to the role. Instead we were given a drunken oaf who couldn't even stay awake.


2. Galactus (Fantastic Four: Rise Of The Silver Surfer)

Galactus Fantastic Four Rise of the Silver Surfer
20th Century Studios

Galactus of the comics is not purely a villain, doomed to roam the cosmos constantly in need of sustenance due to his size and powers he is in fact seen by some of the higher in universe powers as a necessity. Keeping balance in the universe is often quoted as one of Galactus' responsibilities, just this makes him an intriguing and well developed character, but in 2007 we were given a giant and angry space cloud.

Given little backstory other than The Silver Surfers exposition dump about Galactus destroying his home planet, we are left with the impression that Galactus is simply a powerful being who requires so much energy he must consume planets. There is no development of the character, no effort to give him a recognisable form and no effort to make him the literal force of nature that he should be and ultimately this serves the film in the worst way, by deflating the third act completely.

There is a reason that despite his size, Galactus is given a humanoid shape in comic books and that reason is to be relatable. It is hard to depict him any differently as if he was given a truly out of this world appearance this would make it difficult to depict any hero going toe to toe with him. Albeit there is still the great size difference but the humanoid shape and communication that this grants would allow for a mental showdown of intellect or at the very least the comprehension that the heroes don't realise what they've gotten themselves into.

The most important job of a villain is to give the heroes something to fight for and ultimately Galactus has nothing to do with the plot of this movie other than to deliver the threat of The Silver Surfer who is allowed to be the hero and dispatch the true villain of the story. Ultimately though this depiction will go down as the worst villain of modern comic book movies due simply to the fact that he was in no way like his comic book form be it appearance or motivation.

And before you mention Parallax, AT LEAST HE HAD A FACE!


1. Catwoman (Catwoman)

Halle Berry Catwoman
Warner Bros.

Apologies for making you remember this movie but unfortunately it wasn't just a bad dream.

Catwoman as portrayed by Halle Berry in 2004 was without a doubt the worst big screen adaptation of a comic book character, ever. Retaining nearly nothing of the source material other than the name and cat's ears, this iteration is an embarrassment to cinema.

Despite the calibre of talent involved in this film, there was no saving it due to the backlash regarding it's lead. Portraying 'Patience Phillips', a meek and shy graphic designer who is killed by her villainous boss only to be revived by an Egyptian Cat God, Halle Berry did all she could to make this character work. Unfortunately there was truly no saving this, with a completely laughable backstory and relying on shoddy CGI coupled with shoddy story elements, this iteration is better off forgotten.

The Catwoman that it was trying to imitate did not rely on supernatural powers or convoluted storytelling, the original was a simple antithesis of Batman. Using her intelligence, skills and seduction to her advantage she takes as she wants and very rarely relies on brute force to resolve a situation.

Unfortunately the 2004 Catwoman exists and there is nothing to be done about it, other than pretend it never happened.


Contributor

Pros: Able to write awesome content Cons: Terrible at writing about myself