10 Worst PG-13 Horror Films Since 2010
Good PG-13 horrors are out there, but not here.
When a movie is given a PG-13, it means that it is not suitable for children under the age of 13, or that parents should at least be cautious when showing it to their little ones.
You might think that this would be a death sentence for a horror movie, as they would need a full R rating to really bring out the scares. This simply isn't true, as there have been plenty of classics that have stuck firmly to these rules.
There's Guillermo del Toro's Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark, M. Night Shyamalan's The Visit, and The Woman in Black, the film so scary it turned Harry Potter into a full-grown man with sideburns. These are just some examples from the last decade or so, but sadly, there have also been some real stinkers.
The following ten films were all released between 2010 and 2019 and were given the PG-13 rating by the American Motion Picture Association. Sometimes, the rating itself played a part in why they were so bad, but often, they would have sucked no matter who was allowed to view them.
10. Insidious: The Last Key
When the first Insidious movie hit theatres in 2010, people were very impressed with this tale of otherworldly possession and were keen to see more. Alas, sometimes you can have too much of a good thing.
The Insidious films just kept coming, with each subsequent sequel failing to reach the heights of the original. Things hit an all-time low with the fourth movie, 2018’s The Last Key, which was actually a prequel to film number one.
Elise Rainier, the parapsychologist from the first movie, takes centre stage, leading an expedition to root out the ghosts living in her childhood home. Viewers were pleased to see veteran actor Lin Shaye in a main role, but that was about the only thing they were happy about.
The Last Key was indicative of a franchise that had run out of steam. The plot was like a thousand other haunted house stories before it, the other characters were so paper thin you could see through them, and the jump scares felt cheap and manipulative. That last part couldn’t even be blamed on PG-13, as all the Insidious movies carry that rating.
9. Red Riding Hood
It’s a formula that has been done time and time again. Take a well-established public domain story, add some darker edges, and sit back and let the money roll in.
That’s what was attempted by 2011’s Red Riding Hood, based on the fairytale of the same name, but the only things that rolled in here were bad reviews.
Amanda Seyfried stars as Valerie, the Red stand-in, who lives in a village surrounded by a werewolf-infested forest. After attacks on the villagers start to increase, it’s up to Valeria to discover the identity of the furry murderer before she ends up on the menu.
Red Riding Hood was clearly trying to capitalise on the dark fantasy trend started by Twilight. It was even directed by Catherine Hardwicke, who made the first movie in that series. This wasn’t enough to produce anything close to passable, as the film was torn to pieces like Red’s grandma in the original story.
The acting was bad, the plot was all over the place, and the ending was so confusing that nobody was sure how to feel. Seyfried was good at the very least, but this was a severe case of too little too late.
8. Victor Frankenstein
With a recognisable name in the title and a cast including James McAvoy, Daniel Radcliffe, Charles Dance, and Andrew Scott, it seemed highly unlikely that 2015’s Victor Frankenstein would be a flop.
Unlikely, but, as it transpired, not impossible.
The film acts as a prequel to the well-known story, as assistant Igor (Radcliffe) tells the tale of how the once-promising doctor (McAvoy) slowly transformed into a twisted monster. There was just one problem - it was really boring.
In trying to make Victor into a suave antihero, all this movie did was expose how uninteresting he was without his most famous creation. Audiences were left waiting and waiting for something to happen, only to be greeted with a standard adventure plot that wasn’t very scary and had little to do with the original mythology.
If that wasn’t bad enough, the finale is wrapped up with a saccharin line about how Igor was Frankenstein’s “greatest creation”. Bleugh.
A massive waste of a stellar cast and a tantalising opportunity, Victor Frankenstein was left desperate waiting for lightning to strike, but the spark just never arrived.
7. The Vatican Tapes
2015’s The Vatican Tapes was Hollywood’s latest effort to mine some more scares out of the Catholic Church.
Cardinal Bruun (Peter Andersson) is called upon to help a young woman named Angela (Olivia Taylor Dudley) who has seemingly been possessed. This isn’t your average, run of the mill demon, though - the Cardinal discovers to his horror that Angela’s body is harbouring none other than the spirit of the Antichrist itself.
Even with such cataclysmic stakes and enough religious imagery to baptise a baby in, The Vatican Tapes under-delivered in every single way. It was full to the brim with every possession and exorcism cliche imaginable, to the point where you could pretty much predict everything that was going to happen after the first 15 minutes.
What’s more, it seemed to justify historical clerical abuse as a means of fighting the Devil, which is all sorts of messed up.
Viewers hoping for a fresh take on this subject matter got a classless reminder that there are far better movies out there to fill this particular need - ones that won’t make you feel nearly as uncomfortable.
6. The Last Exorcism Part II
2010's The Last Exorcism delivered an intriguing tale about a disenchanted priest attempting to hang up his dog collar, but only after one last big score. It was tense, it was original, and it had deeper themes of religion running through it.
And then came the sequel three years later.
The Last Exorcism Part II - which is already a confusing title - instead centred on the possessed girl from the previous film, Nell. Upon realising that her old demon has literally come back to haunt her, Nell (Ashley Bell) must find a way to get rid of it all over again.
Whilst the first film was presented as a pseudo-documentary in found footage form, this one was just a normal film, which immediately cost it points. Then it actually started, and fans of the original outing were horrified to see that concept turned into a completely bog-standard psychological slog without any of the flair of what had come before.
Despite a great performance from Bell, the results were pretty poor across the board, and a planned third feature was eventually cancelled.
5. The Lazarus Effect
Those who know their biblical history will have probably figured out that 2015’s The Lazarus Effect is about raising the dead.
A secret university programme creates a special drug that can bring people back from the Great Beyond. However, there are side effects - when aren’t there? - including increased aggression, which is not good for the poor souls working in the lab.
There’s nothing particularly original about this concept - Re-Animator did pretty much the same thing in the 1980s - but there was still potential for a good story here, especially with the likes of Olivia Wilde, Evan Peters, and Donald Glover on board.
Sadly, it ended up being more like a biblical disaster than a miracle.
The Lazarus Effect never got out of first gear, constantly retreading the same tired ground as every single resurrection story you’ve ever seen. The cast were fenced in by their utterly forgettable characters. and the slow pacing and lack of frights made it drag and drag and drag.
The only nice thing to say about The Lazarus Pit is that it turned a good profit at the box office, but otherwise, it deserves to be buried and left for dead.
4. Ouija
Ouija boards have always had a place in the horror genre, but, in 2014, someone finally had the idea to make them the sole purpose of a movie.
After an incident with one of the boards kills her best friend, Laine Morris (Olivia Cooke) decides to try and communicate with her… by using a Ouija board. Laine is clearly not very bright.
This results in her and her friends being haunted by the various spirits that inhabit the occult toy, as they each slowly succumb to possession followed by a horrible demise. It’s a formula that’s been done many times over in horror, but very rarely as badly as this.
Every single scare attempt in Ouija felt exactly the same. The room goes quiet, then a loud noise happens, rinse and repeat. This wasn’t good enough for a majority of the people watching and, considering the story boiled down to “it’s a Ouija board”, there was little else to keep viewers entertained.
There is a happy ending to this story though, as a sequel - Ouija: Origin of Evil - came out in 2016 and performed much better with critics.
3. House At The End Of The Street
In the same year as her breakout role in The Hunger Games and her Oscar-nominated performance in Silver Linings Playbook, Jennifer Lawrence also appeared in a horror movie, and there’s a reason you don’t hear about that nearly as often as those other two.
This was House at the End of the Street, in which J-Law plays a young girl who, along with her mother, moves to a new neighbourhood that sits in the shadow of a house where a gruesome double murder was committed.
It’s the one at the end of the street, in case you hadn’t already figured that out.
There’s more to this movie than meets the eye, as Lawrence’s character learns that the facts of the past crime aren’t as true as everyone believes. There was potential here for a fun, twisty-turny kind of mystery, but the movie got every single step completely wrong, leading to an end product that was bloated, messy, and hard to follow.
Also, the House at the End of the Street committed the ultimate horror movie sin - it wasn’t scary.
Never mind, Jenny. Two out of three ain’t bad.
2. Spiders 3D
Good luck trying to track this 2011 film down, because it has more names than a Brazilian footballer.
Sometimes called Spiders 3D, Spiders in 3D, or just Spiders, this movie starts with an old Soviet satellite falling to Earth. Its purpose was to perform experiments on a group of huge, mutant arachnids, and when it crashes, the creepy-crawlies are free to seek their revenge.
When it comes to movies like this, filmmakers can go one of two ways. They can try and make it a genuinely frightening creature feature or lean into the ridiculousness and go for that “so bad, it’s good” vibe. Spiders 3D does neither.
Somehow, a movie featuring enormous bugs rampaging through the New York subway manages to be sleep-inducing. The special effects aren’t strong enough to be scary and aren’t naff enough to be funny, the dialogue is earnest whilst also being pathetic, and none of the actors seem to know what the plan was, assuming there actually was one.
Spiders 3D could have become a cult classic, but instead, it will be left to gather dust whilst the likes of Sharknado have all the fun.
1. Polaroid
Think of all the great horror movie weapons that have been used throughout history; Freddy Krueger’s glove; Jason Voorhees’ machete; Leatherface’s chainsaw. Now, get rid of all of those and replace them with an old camera. It doesn’t quite have the same effect, does it?
2019 saw the release of Polaroid, which was based on a short film of a similar name and concept. After a teenage girl stumbles across a vintage Polaroid camera, she starts taking pictures with it, only to discover that anyone photographed goes on to die under horrible circumstances.
Cameras aren’t scary at all, but this movie makes absolutely no effort to try and change that. The attempted frights get nowhere near the heights they need to overcome a PG-13 rating, and the characters are so bland and underdeveloped that it’s almost impossible to get invested in them properly.
Polaroid was almost unanimously slammed for being one of the most boring horror movies in quite some time. Some even called it the “worst horror movie of all time”, and whilst it might not be that bad, it’s certainly up there with the worst efforts of the 2010s.