10 Worst Practical Effects Movie Monsters

When keeping it real goes wrong...

Rawhead Rex
Empire Pictures

Few things unite horror purists like a loathing of CGI monsters. We may be split on whether Freddy would beat Michael Myers or who would come out on top in an Alien vs. Jason match-up, but one thing most aficionados of the genre can agree on is nothing compares to a monster conjured entirely out of practical effects.

Whether it’s Rob Bottin’s ground-breaking work on The Thing, Screaming Mad George’s phenomenal creations for Brian Yuzna’s Society, or An American Werewolf in London’s seminal transformation scene, nothing gets the adrenal glands pumping quite like a practically produced monster. The art form allows for more convincing movement, adds weight and depth to the objects of our terror, and gives actors an actual physical threat to interact with.

At least, that’s what a lot of fans would argue. However, the plethora of unconvincing CGI beasties plaguing the cineplex for the last two decades might have left us all a little rose-tinted in our view of yesteryear’s movie monsters. Practical effects are often just as shoddy and comically lame as any CGI, as the denizens haunting the VHS bargain bin and this list can attest.

10. Prophecy – Katahdin

Prophecy Movie
Paramount Pictures

Let’s start off with a controversial one. A lot of horror fans love the monster from John Frankenheimer’s 1979 eco-horror Prophecy, and the director helmed some undeniable classics in his time. Prophecy has both a stunning location and an admirable environmentalist message to go for it, long before the latter was fashionable.

However, it’s hard to deny that the movie’s monster is a bit of a mess. Most infamous for throwing a sleeping-bag-wrapped camper into a tree, the mutated giant bear struggles to convince in close-up. The monster does far better in low lighting and some night-time scenes may elicit as many screams as giggles.

Despite this, Frankenheimer’s film makes the bizarre choice to shoot a lot of attacks in daylight, meaning the bear is in full view. And what a full view it is, with a lot of lumbering, a lot of stumbling, and little in the way of convincing, terror-inducing effects. Come on, John—You made the Manchurian Candidate!


9. Monster A Go-Go – Frank Douglas (Or Not?)

Monster A Go Go
B.I. & L. Releasing Corp.

Now for something a little less easy to defend than Prophecy’s beastly bear. Where some fans claim Frankenheimer’s vintage nature horror still has a few choice scares, Monster a Go-Go is only worth watching for a laugh. The flick at least provides those by the bucketload, whether it’s the original film or the classic Mystery Science Theatre 3000 episode devoted to mocking it.

Consistently keeping a place among the bottom one hundred films on IMDB, Monster a Go-Go’s titular threat consists of an astronaut who looks like he’s spilled a bit of oatmeal on his face. The makeup is so unconvincing that the monster’s sudden unexplained disappearance at the film’s climax comes as a relief.

As for the inexplicable reveal that the astronaut he was inhabiting is alive and well? Er… We’re sure it made sense in the sixties.


8. The Thing From Another World – The Thing

The Thing From Another World
RKO Radio Pictures

One of the most upsetting monsters ever committed to film is 1982’s the Thing, the shape-shifting menace from John Carpenter’s film of the same name. Slimy, gory, and bent on twisting both human and animal bodies into a bizarre array of gruesome mutations, the eponymous threat is one of cinema’s greatest practical effects achievements.

The pale imitation of 2011’s belated prequel provides a solid defence for anyone claiming CGI can’t compare to old-fashioned latex-and-slime work. However, the original 1950 film Carpenter remade features an antagonist so unconvincing that it’s hard to imagine anyone leaving the cinema without a smile plastered across their face.

The alien menace here consists of a frowny fellow with a massive forehead, Hulk hands, and… well, that’s about it in terms of scare factor. The actor complained the make-up made him resemble a carrot and honestly, it’s hard to argue, with a swollen head and ever-present scowl falling far short of the remake’s mangled nightmares.


7. Rumpelstiltskin – Rumpelstiltskin

Rumplestintskin Movie
Republic Pictures

The nineties were a funny time for horror. CGI began to emerge in blockbusters like Jurassic Park but remained too costly for most genre fare. Meanwhile Freddy, Chucky, and friends have carved out a profitable niche by combining quips with kills, leading a pack of imitators to try their hand at conjuring up movie monsters who straddled the line between scary and campy.

Hence the world was gifted Rumpelstiltskin, a fairy tale villain reimagined as an R-rated slasher who bore a bizarre resemblance to Muppet Treasure Island’s Blind Pierre. Now we know what you’re wondering, and the answer is yes, the film was directed by Mark Jones, the same man responsible for the long-running (and somehow still going!) Leprechaun franchise.

Credit where it’s due, though: It took a few sequels before the titular leprechaun was sent to space and the hood, whereas Rumpelstiltskin’s eponymous monster was wearing shades and riding an inexplicable motorcycle before the end of his first instalment. Unfortunately for real Rumpel-heads, it was also his last onscreen appearance. Shame, we were looking forward to Freddy vs Rumpelstiltskin.


6. Bram Stoker’s Dracula – Bat-Drac

Bram Stoker's Dracula
Columbia Pictures

Not content with forcing Keanu Reeves to attempt an accent which to this day defies categorization, Francis Ford Coppola’s film also tried its hand at conjuring up a convincing bat form for its vampire protagonist. In the process the film produced more laughs than anything else.

The rubber suit and elaborate makeup turned Gary Oldman’s count into less of a foreboding terror and more a human embodiment of the phrase ‘bingo wings’. Loose skin aside, the choice is said to have come from Oldman’s insistence that he would not be sufficiently scary without an outfit. Well, kudos to the actor for proving himself wrong—his Dracula is definitely a lot scarier before this school musical tier costume makes an appearance.

Despite this misstep the film isn’t all bad, and it’s well worth a watch if you’re in the mood for some corny gothic horror. Just don’t expect too much from cinema’s least loved incarnation of Batman.


5. Werewolf – Werewolf

Werewolf 1996
A-Pix Entertainment

Oh, Werewolf. Where to start on this one? A decade and a half before Werewolf’s 1996 release, 1980 played host to an era-defining FX battle between Rob Bottin’s work for The Howling and Rick Baker’s efforts in An American Werewolf in London. Both films featured extraordinary werewolf transformations, with the work still touted as some of the best in cinema history.

Despite this, some later lycanthropes managed to earn a seat at the legendary VFX table. Werewolf… was not one of them. Best known for the classic MST3K episode spent tearing it to shreds, the film was produced on a shoestring budget and boy, does it show. The titular terror barely appears onscreen, changing colour each time he does.

Sometimes, the makeup consists of a few stray cheek hairs, and at other times the monster itself is replaced by a large dog (yes, really). It needs to be seen to be believed, but Werewolf manages to earn its title by producing easily the worst cinematic example of the mythical monster.


4. Skinned Deep – Brain

Skinned Deep
Center Ring Entertainment

Around 2004, cinemagoers were plunged into a world flooded with CGI ghosts as the emerging technology proved it could create cost efficient—if deeply unimpressive—scares. With stiff competition in the crap villain rankings from the likes of Stay Alive and Boogeyman, a film would need impressively terrible practical effects to prove CGI stood a chance at longevity in the genre.

Luckily, Skinned Deep managed exactly that. Somehow squandering a relatively sizeable budget, the film featured a brood of pscyhos clearly modelled on the Texas Chainsaw massacre’s killer family, and the effects used to realize them were bad enough to put anyone off their popcorn. Somehow managing to look both disgusting and unconvincing, the only description Skinned Deep’s antagonists didn’t earn was ‘scary’.

Special mention must go to Brain, whose prosthetic head enhancement looks… Well, like something other than a brain, to be quite honest. The actor assaying the role was arrested during filming for public nudity, proving filmmakers will do almost anything to distract from some woeful effects.


3. The Night Of The Demon – Bigfoot

Bigfoot Night Of The Demon
Columbia

The video nasty era is a dark mark for British cinema, with a bevy of controversial classics being hastily banned by misinformed censors to sate a misguided moral panic. A great many of the films cut were masterpieces of practical effects and celebrated artists such as Tom Savini had some of their finest work sliced out of releases during this era.

However, not every film destined for the BBFC chopping block was such a misunderstood masterpiece. Enter 1980’s Night of the Demon, where the titular monster is an iteration of Bigfoot who makes Harry and the Henderson’s cryptid look terrifying. The human-animal hybrid is given little screen time, but this does little to mask just how lame the costume is.

Even the film’s impressive gore quotient can’t cover up how unconvincing its central baddie is—no matter how many kills the monster racks up, there’s no getting past his resemblance to a hairier Lou Ferrigno. Bizarrely, much of the film takes place in broad daylight, resulting in an often completely exposed bigfoot costume which is more Suburban Sasquatch than nightmare fuel.


2. Rawhead Rex – Rawhead Rex

Rawhead Rex 2
Empire Pictures

Alright let’s set one thing straight, before anyone is accused of coming for the king and missing—Clive Barker is a national treasure. The iconic scribe has a place beside Stephen King in the pantheon of twentieth century horror fiction, and his creations have given rise to great movies from the iconic Hellraiser to the inventive and underrated Nightbreed.

That said, not all of Barker’s literary efforts have been so lucky. This entry may be one of the more controversial on this list, but without nostalgia goggles it’s hard to deny Rawhead Rex is a less than impressive practical effects achievement. With a headpiece that’s never far from flopping off his oversized shoulders, the titular demonic entity is goofy and ungainly but may convince in some low-lit scenes.

However, like an earlier entry the filmmakers often make the inexplicable mistake of shooting the monster in broad daylight where its rubber-suit origins are both visible and risible.

Still, spare a thought for the designer tasked with this one—Barker was unhappy with the monster not because the effects but because it diverged from his vision of the pagan ghoul as a toothy, nine-foot-tall phallus. Like I said, a national treasure.


1. Robot Monster – Robot Monster

Robot Monster
Astor Pictures

Well before the king of killer robots himself would grace our screens in 1984’s The Terminator, another breed of Robot Monster has already made its less auspicious debut at the multiplex. Like so many on this list, the titular Robot Monster of this 1956 B-movie is most famous for being roundly roasted by the MST3K crew.

Unlike anything on this list—or anywhere else in cinema—this robot monster is less android and more man in gorilla suit wearing an inexplicable astronaut helmet kitted out with television antennae. The blame for this one lands squarely on the costume department rather than prosthetics and makeup, mainly because there’s none of either to speak of on-screen.

Despite—or maybe because of—the laughs prompted by its appearance, the monster went on to become an ironic icon of B-movie banality, even inspiring John Landis’ 1973 debut Schlock. Nonetheless, this monster—if indeed it has earned that title—remains a pretty damning indictment of just how ineffective practical effects can prove when the filmmakers’ hearts aren’t in it or the technical ability just isn’t there.


In this post: 
Rawhead Rex
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Cathal Gunning hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.