10 Worst Ways Marvel Studios Wasted Great Actors

Oh, what could have been.

One of the appeals of being the hottest and most popular studio around is that actors generally line up to work with you. Such is the case with Marvel Studios, where it seems like everyone wants to get in on the action, with upcoming performers as diverse as Sylvester Stallone, Benedict Cumberbatch and Tom Holland. But then sometimes having too much talent in your films can be a bad thing. Beyond its lead superheroes, Marvel has had some trouble in crafting supporting characters that feel three-dimensional. And through no fault of the actors, everyone from villains to love interests has occasionally felt like a waste of talent. The problem is only compounded when the talent is as good as the actors are that Marvel is using. There€™s nothing more frustrating than seeing an actor you know to be exceptional being given a part that€™s beneath their capabilities. We€™re talking about Oscar winners with nothing to do but act as plot devices for the real heroes. Obviously the problem doesn't overtake every character in the MCU, but when it happens, it€™s hard not to notice it. It€™s a shame this has happened so may times but Marvel is still a young studio and hopefully they€™re learning from their mistakes. This is a problem that can be solved down the line but that won€™t mean anything for all of these actors who already gave so much only for us to see so little.

10. Terrence Howard Is Unceremoniously Replaced (Iron Man)

Let€™s be clear about something, Don Cheadle is a great Rhodey but it's arguable that Terence Howard barely even got a chance with the character. He has proved since that he is a very strong actor in his own right and to just push him out after one movie doesn€™t make a whole lot of sense. According to Howard, after the surprise success of Iron Man, despite being promised a raise, he was offered a smaller part and a pay cut to help accommodate Robert Downey Jr€™s inflating salary. His agent told Marvel €œno way€ in much less polite terms and within 24 hours, Howard was out. The whole ordeal just seems like an overreaction on both parts that could easily have been settled, which makes this all the more frustrating. Fans of the series Empire will be quick to point out how captivating Howard can be and to let him go for nothing is a waste. As War Machine, Howard could have shown a level of ability we've never seen before.

9. Richard Armitage Is Immediately Killed Off (Captain America: The First Avenger)

A few actors have had breakouts after performing bit parts in Marvel films, but none moreso than Richard Armitage. His performance as Thorin Oakenshield was one of the few redeeming features of The Hobbit trilogy and anyone who watches Hannibal will tell you how hypnotic he was as the Tooth Fairy. Ironically, he€™s now the exact type of actor they pursue for their lead villains, and that could have been the case had they not already used him as minor antagonist Heinz Kruger. In case you can€™t even remember Armitage appearing, he€™s the HYDRA spy who sabotages the super-soldier experiment and kills Dr. Erskine. It was a great sequence, but anyone could have done it, and we now know how much more Armitage could have offered. Obviously, Marvel didn€™t necessarily know he was going to break out at the time, so while they may be absolved of blame, it still doesn€™t mean he wasn€™t wasted in such a meaningless role.

8. Gwyneth Paltrow Is Just A Secretary (Iron Man)

It€™s a tough task having to share all of your scenes with Robert Downey Jr. So when an Oscar-winner like Gwyneth Paltrow is having a rough go of making her character feel essential, there might be something amiss. It€™s not that Pepper is poorly written, so much as she just has nothing to do. Sure, by the time the third film rolls around, she gets into the action, but up until then, she manages Tony Stark€™s life and not much else. She exists to simplify things for him and apparently for nothing else. Considering all of these facts about the character, they could have just given the role to anybody and gotten a similar response. But in giving it to Paltrow, the audience is aware that the character could be so much more. Pepper is still around in the MCU so hopefully the next time we see her, Paltrow will actually get a chance to show off her acting chops.

7. Edward Norton Is The Hulk In The Wrong Movie (The Incredible Hulk)

Edward Norton is an undeniably fantastic actor, but he also has a reputation as being very hard to work with. This was the case on The Incredible Hulk, where disputes between him and Marvel over whether he should receive a screenwriting credit for his rewriting efforts allegedly led to him not being asked back for The Avengers. Marvel should have welcomed his help - the film was poor, to say the least. Okay, so it worked out well for Norton, as he got to star in a range of exceptional films, like Birdman and Moonrise Kingdom, but imagine what Norton could have done in the more complex, better written role that Banner would become by the time The Avengers rolled around. That more textured role would have suited Norton far better - hence Mark Ruffalo's excellent understated performance - and he wouldn't have had to act opposite the scene-chewing Tim Roth. It's a hell of a shame.

6. Glenn Close Is Barely In The Film (Guardians Of The Galaxy)

Glenn Close€™s casting is a testament to how far Marvel has come. When they first started, they had to sell themselves to redemption cases and up-and-comers, not even six years later, and massive movie stars are coming to them, asking for roles. Close immediately helped raise the pedigree of the little-known property and fans were excited to see such a respected actress play something are far-fetched as an alien military commander. And while she clearly had fun on set, it was a shame we got so little of her. Evidently, when the role of Nova Prime was being written, James Gunn was not expecting someone as big as Close getting involved. But she was, and thus expectations were disproportionate for what we were getting. She featured very minimally in the film and the scenes she did partake in were mostly expository with little-to-no emotion or characterization. Hopefully the sequel embraces her casting and doesn€™t waste this opportunity again.

5. Ben Kingsley€™s Mandarin Is Just An Act (Iron Man 3)

The Mandarin is traditionally depicted as an older Chinese man with magical rings, so when the decidedly not-Chinese Ben Kingsley was cast, fans were a little skeptical. Then it was announced that his rings would simply be decorative and fans got a little more worried. That was until the trailers started to roll out and this new take on the character seems to resonate with people. His bold fashion, gravelly voice and fearsome presence was all of a sudden something to be excited about, and for the first half of Iron Man 3 he was everything fans had hoped for. And then, you know what happened next. The Trevor Slattery twist has been divisive to say the least. While fans of the comics mostly objected to the way the character was changed, they were really hurt because Kingsley had been so good until the twist. If The Mandarin had truly been who he said he was, without the twist, he likely would have gone down as one of Marvel€™s best villains. Through no fault of his own, Kingsley€™s astounding performance just didn€™t amount to enough and that is unquestionably a waste.

4. Christopher Eccleston Is A Generic Bad Guy (Thor: The Dark World)

Thor: The Dark World may have been Marvel€™s worst movie to date and one of the main reasons why was its completely forgettable villain. Daniel Day-Lewis could have played Malekith and the character still would have sucked, which is astounding considering how menacing his design was and how powerful his backstory could have been. Eccleston just had nothing to work with. The character got very little screentime, almost no dialogue in English and virtually no development. He got the short end of the stick and Marvel absolutely wasted him in the role that a stuntman could have performed. The Doctor Who standout deserved better and became just another actor in a long line who had wasted on a Marvel villain. Of note is that Mads Mikkelsen almost played this role but dropped out because of scheduling conflicts. It€™s likely a similar fate would have befallen him so hopefully he€™ll get the chance to shine in Doctor Strange that Eccleston was never afforded.

3. Jeremy Renner Gets Nothing To Do (The Avengers)

Looking at Jeremy Renner€™s pedigree, it€™s not hard to make a case for him as one of the better actors around. He got multiple Oscar nominations and a range that lets him convincingly play everything from a troubled soldier, to a Boston gangster to an action hero. So naturally, people were pretty happy that an actor of his caliber was joining the Avengers as beloved archer Hawkeye. That was all until people actually saw the movie. For the majority of the film, the wisecracking comic book character became a mindless slave to Loki. And even when he was finally released, he got little characterization and his only purpose seemed to be to add another body to the action sequences. Though he would later be redeemed in Age Of Ultron, Renner still feels like an afterthought in the MCU. He could absolutely handle his own solo movie, or even a co-starring effort with Black Widow, so every supporting role he gets just keeps feeling like a waste of his talents.

2. Mickey Rourke Is Left On The Cutting Room Floor (Iron Man 2)

This one really stings. Mickey Rourke was coming off a universally acclaimed performance in The Wrestler and looked to bring an intensity to Iron Man 2 that would elevate the sequel beyond even the beloved original. The trailers painted him as a silent savage on a personal mission to destroy Tony Stark, but the film completely failed to deliver on the promises of the character. For a guy who honed a Russian accent, and spent time in the country all in an effort to add some layers to the character, it was pretty devastating that all the hard work he spoke of was nowhere to be seen. Most of these details came from Rourke after the fact, but fans didn€™t need him telling them what they missed to realize that Ivan Vanko had been portrayed as a completely one-dimensional villain. This may be the biggest case of €˜what-if€™ in the entirety of the MCU. The fully-formed character Rourke created may not have saved Iron Man 2, but it€™s pretty clear that there was a lot more that we never got to see.

1. Natalie Portman Is Thor€™s Girlfriend (Thor)

It€™s hard to believe that the captivating star of Black Swan and V For Vendetta somehow got pigeonholed into the role of Thor€™s girlfriend. Portman is an incredible actress and yet somehow she was given absolutely nothing to do in not one, but two different movies. Ostensibly Jane Foster is supposed to be a brilliant scientist but she spends most of her time staring doe-eyed at Thor. Rather than be his equal or have her own compelling story, she exists solely to boost up Thor and serve as a scientific plot device. It's mind-boggling how someone as good as Portman does not get a more nuanced or meaningful arc but apparently there was no real desire for a strong performance from her. Part of this lacklustre role stems from the fact that Portman simply doesn€™t want to be there. It€™s pretty clear she€™s doing this for the money and wanted out of the sequel when they let director Patty Jenkins go. So while she€™s partially to blame for the lack of investment, it€™s pretty clear that even if she was engaged, there would have been no way for her to showcase it with such a shallow character. Are you still mad at Marvel for wasting these talents? Who do you think got the worst of it? Let us know in the comments.

Contributor

Connor loves movies, comics, and TV, and is trying to write for people who feel the same way. When he's not sitting on the couch with his laptop, you might find him lying in his bed with his laptop.