10 Worthwhile Asian Horror Films Currently Without Remakes

Before the success of Paranormal Activity made found-footage horror the next "big thing" in fright flicks, Hollywood's go-to place for ideas was eastern Asia. Following the 2002 smash hit The Ring, based on Hideo Nakata's 1998 Japanese success Ring, no fewer than 10 additional wide release American features based on Asian horror films were released up through 2009, with four in 2008 alone. Some - The Grudge, mainly, and The Ring Two to a lesser extent - were big hits, while others like Pulse disappointed at the box office. With critical reception no better than any other horror subgenre (2008's One Missed Call remake got a pitiful 0% on RottenTomatoes) and dwindling consumer interest, the fad died off after the early 2009 release of The Uninvited.
Although it's not totally over - the Japanese film Apartment 1303 has a 3D remake coming to limited release and on-demand services this summer - this period ended before many other interesting offerings from the region got the chance to be redone for Western audiences.
Here are ten Asian thrillers worth a look that, for better or worse, were never given a Hollywood do-over...
10. Nightmare

9. Suicide Club

8. Phone

7. Acacia

6. Marebito

5. Infection

4. Voice

Year: 2005 Country: South Korea Director: Equan Choi
Voice is the fourth in the unconnected Whispering Corridors series of Korean horror films, with a title literally translated as Girl's High School Horror 4: Voice. Like the other films in the franchise, it's set at an all-girls high school and involves some ghostly goings-on but does not follow the story of any other film. This particular installment is about Young-Eon, a dedicated music student who is killed by a ghost in her school. She comes back as one herself, but she is invisible - and only her best friend Seon-Min and the weird loner girl Cho-Ah can hear her. Furthermore, she cannot leave the school building, and her memory is fractured and unreliable. The story predictably moves into an investigation of the ghost who killed her in the first place, but surprisingly that's not the movie's only main focus. At its core, Voice is a film about the grieving process. Seon-Min can only hear Young-Eon's voice because of the strong emotional attachment she still has to her dead friend. Even as the mystery behind the other ghost unfolds, the true main conflict is Seon-Min's internal struggle with her friend's death and her decision on whether to let her go or cling to her last remnants in the mortal world. Although it's sold in America with a hilariously inaccurate DVD cover showing bloody hands clawing their way out of a screaming mouth, Voice is far from a shocking gore-fest. It's not even really scary, and there are only a handful of scenes where it actually tries to be. However, its intriguing mystery elements and surprising emotional depth make it well worth a watch.
3. Cello

Year: 2005 Country: South Korea Director: Woo-Cheol Lee
Unlike many of the films in this article which were understandably not remade since they didn't fit the standard of Ring-inspired Asian horror movies, Cello is a perfect cousin to that film and its many imitators (or, less charitably, a rip-off). There's a long-haired ghost girl, spooky haunted recordings, a creepy little kid, a big final twist, and all the other tropes associated with the subgenre. But that doesn't mean it should be counted out immediately; it's actually a pretty well-done example of the format. The story is about Mi-Ju, a part-time cello instructor whose life is falling apart. In addition to the stress of raising a family which includes a mentally-handicapped daughter, she has a spiteful former student stalking her, a creepy new maid with a tragic past, and she's getting mysterious text messages. Things only get worse and worse, building to deaths, ghostly encounters, and the revelation of a dark secret in her past. The movie is capably-made and manages to have a decent selection of effective scares, despite its obvious similarities to earlier films. If anything makes the movie stand out, it has to be how utterly cruel the ghost is to Mi-Ju - the events in this film go far beyond creepy nightmares and a curse that will kill her in so many days. It's not a bold new direction for horror, but if you liked Ring and its ilk and are interested in seeing more like it, Cello is easily worth a look.
2. Reincarnation

Year: 2005 Country: Japan Director: Takashi Shimizu
Another entry from Grudge director Takashi Shimizu, this one is considerably more conventional than Marebito but still a welcome change from his most famous franchise. Reincarnation tells the story of an actress, Nagisa, who lands a part in a new horror film based on the true story (in the film universe, not reality) of a mass murder at a hotel. She is plagued by ghostly visions of the murder victims, which only get worse when the cast and crew visit the real hotel and build an exact replica to film on. She even seems to remember things she should have no way of knowing... The title obviously gives away one of the key plot elements, but there are still more surprises and twists to come. Reincarnation has some effective scares - anyone freaked out by creepy dolls will be especially traumatized - and is rather intelligently-written, which is a nice departure from the often haphazardly-plotted Grudge / Ju-On films. It's well-made and just different enough to stand out from the pack of overly-similar Ring cash-ins that tend to get a lot of attention (especially from American studios).
1. The Victim

Year: 2006 Country: Thailand Director: Monthon Arayangcoon
Thailand isn't considered an A-List country for Asian horror by Hollywood, with only one big American remake to its name (2008's Shutter, which was confusingly set in Japan and directed by a Japanese man). But The Victim is a strong entry into the subgenre that's well worth checking out. The story is about Ting, an aspiring young actress who lands a job working in re-enactments of violent crimes staged by the police for the media (a real practice in Thailand). She is good enough at her job that the spirits of the real victims take notice. When she is entrusted with the role of Meen, a supermodel who was apparently murdered by a scorned lover, she thinks of it as her big break - but Meen's ghost is haunting her, desperately trying to help her uncover the real truth behind her death. The Victim is effectively scary in places, and actually even has some satisfying comedic elements in the beginning. It's fast-paced and never boring. But the real reason to watch it is for its great, jaw-dropping twist. I won't dare reveal it here as it's something that really needs to be experienced, but it's easily the best I've seen in a long time. The rest of the movie doesn't really quite live up to that element, but it's still an enjoyable horror romp with a very memorable revelation.