11 Actors Who Should Take Over Indiana Jones
The select few who deserve to take over the reigns.
With the release of Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull in 2008, a terrible truth was revealed. In that less-than-satisfying fourquel, the once enigmatic and timeless combination of Harrison Ford and the classic character failed. Ford looked consistently bored throughout the film and was rarely more than a shell of his former self.
Since then, Ford has gone on to deliver some of the best performances of his career. His work in The Force Awakens and especially Blade Runner 2049 was exceptional, proving he is far from past his prime. But he is getting older. And so while, with those more recent performances under his belt, there are reasons to be optimistic about him reprising his Indy role in the upcoming fifth film, there are also reasons to be aware that he cannot keep this up.
If the Indiana Jones franchise is to carry on into the next generation, someone else will have to take up the fedora and bullwhip. Even Spielberg himself seems to be keen on this idea, as the director recently hinted in an interview that though the fifth Indy film will be Ford's last, it will not be the final film in the franchise.
The character of Indiana Jones is synonymous with Harrison Ford, much in the way Han Solo is, but Hollywood is Hollywood and franchises have to keep on trucking. So, if the character is to be recast, these are the actors who could best fill the void.
11. Chris Evans
Evans is a well-established actor who has done all kinds of work but is undoubtedly best known for his role as Captain America.
Which is kind of what makes him perfect for the job. Indiana Jones is a good old-fashioned symbol of American values. He fights Nazis and is willing to risk life and limb in the interest of better serving not just his country, but the people at large. He believes that all relics and artifacts deserve to be preserved in a museum, not to be hoarded by those who would use them for less than righteous purposes.
But Indy's beliefs are dwarfed by the ever-changing world around him. Every character conflict in the Indiana Jones films essentially boils down to a conflict of values, in which Indy has to fight for what he believes is right, even when no one else seems to side with him. Which is exactly what the MCU has (cleverly) done with Captain America.
Evans plays him as a man out of time, whose beliefs are constantly being challenged by the reality he faces. He channels this conflict exceedingly well, all while deconstructing the myth of the great American hero. He could bring this exact same energy, optimism, and internal division to the character of Jones and be a more than worthy successor to the throne.
10. Sally Hawkins
Straight up, Sally Hawkins does the Lord's work.
Her performances have always been stand-outs, but her Oscar-nominated work as a mute woman falling in love with a fellow outsider in The Shape of Water was a cut above the rest. Without ever speaking a word, her performance was endearing, empathetic, and awe-inspiring.
She also knows how to expertly handle comedy, a key (if often underestimated) component of the Indiana Jones franchise. Her work in Paddington and its sequel allowed her to show off her impeccable comedic timing and deft ability to deliver gut-busting one-liners.
Strangely enough, the Paddington films also showcase a fair bit of stuntwork from Hawkins. The second film especially, as her primary character arc centers around her character getting to perform a lengthy underwater rescue towards the end of the film.
But most importantly, Hawkins feels out-of-place in this generation. Part of the reason her Shape of Water performance works so well is that Hawkins already feels like a silent film star who accidentally wandered into the modern day. As an actress, her craft is thoroughly rooted in the cinema of old, just as the bones and inspiration for the Jones franchise are.
9. Alden Ehrenreich
Ehrenreich is already attempting the impossible, so why not let him try it twice?
With the upcoming Solo: A Star Wars Story being plagued by all kinds of production woes throughout its filming, a large portion of the internet is extremely concerned about how the film will turn out. Rumors of Ehrenreich getting an acting coach midway through filming were recently confirmed in a GQ interview, and now the pressure is truly on the young star.
As if that wasn't enough already, he's also stepping into a role made iconic by Harrison Ford. This requires him to toe the line of being Harrison Ford without ever feeling like he's just doing an impression of Harrison Ford, which is not an easy task.
Despite all these concerns, there is reason to be cautiously optimistic. Ehrenreich's big role prior to Solo was in the Coen Brothers' Hail, Caesar!, in which he played an actor struggling with a part behind the scenes (a bit too prophetic now). But here's the thing: he was a revelation in the role.
He was funny, gripping, and positively oozed a cinematic presence larger than his stature or stardom would imply. The 'would that it were so simple' sequence features him selling the film's funniest sequence with dramatic gravitas to spare.
For all of these reasons and more, if Ehrenreich pulls it off with Solo, let him have a swing at Indy because he's just as perfectly suited for that role as he is for Han.
8. Olivia Cooke
Olivia Cooke deserves to be one of the biggest stars in the world right now.
In the past few months alone, Cooke has delivered not one but two breakout performances. Her role as a distant, unfeeling sociopath in Thoroughbreds was downright mesmerizing and her performance as Art3mis in Ready Player One was the stand-out of the whole film.
Thoroughbreds saw her mining psychological and emotional depths with the precision of a veteran actor and Ready Player One saw her balancing an emotionally-driven performance with all the stuntwork and spectacle of a Spielberg blockbuster. And both projects saw her showing off her comedic chops, albeit, in very different ways.
So she's got the acting chops, she knows how to incorporate meaning and motivation into stuntwork and action sequences, and she's got great comedic talents. And on top of all of that, she's a Spielberg nut who's been gushing about his work in every interview lately and constantly reiterated that she would give anything to work with him again. So here's her chance.
7. Joaquin Phoenix
Joaquin Phoneix is one of the most eclectic and unpredictable performers of his generation.
Sometimes he's busy starring in Academy darlings such as Her, Walk the Line, or Gladiator, and other times he's busy being so committed to a project that he's willing to actually go mad for a year and come this close to completely ruining his entire career, just for fun.
He's a wild card in many ways but that's exactly what makes the possibility so enticing.
Phoneix's take on the role would be completely different from that of Ford's and that might just be what the franchise needs. He is a more classical performer than the majority of his peers, who is sure to deliver in terms of sheer performance. Rather than trying to recapture the legacy of Ford, as Solo looks to be doing, Phoneix would take things in a completely separate direction with his performance.
It would also be a nice bit of symmetry with the franchise as a whole, as Joaquin's younger brother, River Phoneix, played a young Indiana Jones in the opening sequence of The Last Crusade. River has tragically passed since then, but having a Phoenix step back into the role would be fitting.
6. Zazie Beetz
Beetz was one of the breakout performers from Donald Glover's FX series, Atlanta and her star has been rising ever since.
In one of that show's finest episodes, Value, Beetz gets to take on the starring role and knocks it out of the park. Her performance as a struggling mother looking to reconcile the distance between her desires and her responsibilities is deeply affecting and all rooted in a genuine sense of realism.
Beetz's star is about to ascend to an even higher plane, with the upcoming release of Deadpool 2. In that film, she plays the character of Domino, and judging from the trailers alone, she looks to be getting in on more than her fair share of action sequences. Beetz is also signed up for several further Deadpool or X-Force-related films to come, set to take over as one of the leading performances in the series.
Even in the schlock-fest that was Geostorm, Beetz gave what was far and away the best performance.
She brings a sense of authenticity to every performance she gives, anchoring them in places of genuine emotion and motivation, much like Ford. Ford was never one for bells and whistles when it came to the art of performing, yet he devoted untold amounts of work into rooting each and every performance into something real and tangible.
With one action franchise already gearing up for her, Beetz would be an excellent choice to carry on the Jones franchise.
5. Natalie Portman
Natalie Portman is a badass, through and through, and she could more than pull this off.
It would also be thrilling to see her return to work with Lucasfilm, in any capacity. One of the most positive elements of the Star Wars prequel trilogy that is all-too-often overlooked is her work as Padmé Amidala. She delivered stellar performances throughout all three films, thoroughly investing herself and giving her all to each and every line. Just look at her final dialogue with Anakin in Episode III, as she pleads for him to come back to the light. It is the emotional culmination of one of the core arcs of the entire trilogy and she completely sells it.
If there were any doubts about Portman's ability to still deliver in the action department, one need look no further than her recent work in Annihilation. That film featured her artfully weaving together the role of the intellectual, grieving professor with a more-than-capable badass. A lot like the role of Indiana Jones would require.
Portman would give her all to this role and pull it off in every aspect.
4. Alicia Vikander
Vikander's star-making turn in Ex Machina proved that she could act the hell out of any role. That film centered solely around conversations and interactions, in one of the most minimalist styles one can imagine. And yet, Vikander's performance made the film feel huge. Plus, she expertly played the audience just as she played Domhnall Gleeson's character within the film.
Since then, Vikander has gone on to star in action franchises such as the recent Tomb Raider reboot and done an incredible amount of practical stuntwork. Rather than allowing the effects department to dub things in or allowing her stunt double to perform the work, Vikander prefers to do things authentically and herself. Which would be an incredibly valuable asset to the Indiana Jones franchise.
Some of the most thrilling action sequences ever committed to film have been in the Indy films. But the reason a sequence like the truck chase in Raiders works so well is that it feels so real. There is an actual man being thrown out of and then climbing underneath of a moving truck and the audience feels the tension and danger because they can't see the seams.
Compare that to a sequence like the CGI-laden forest chase in Crystal Skull, and it is easy to see just how quickly an over-reliance on digital effects can deflate an action sequence. Understandably, Ford can't perform stunts quite like he used to. But bringing in Vikander could ensure that the future of the Indiana Jones franchise remains practical, all while securing a phenomenal actress to embody the role.
3. Donald Glover
Just a few short years ago, fans were starting online petitions to get Glover cast as Spider-Man. Now, big franchises are begging Glover to agree to be part of their cast.
Glover's star has been on the rise as of late, thanks in no small part to his excellent television series, Atlanta. Glover writes, directs, and performs on the show and has regularly demonstrated his adept ability to blend together the world of comedy, drama, and surrealism to create something coherent and gripping, both in his writing and in his acting.
As of late, Glover's performances have been much more dramatically-driven, as he shows off a range that few would have guessed Troy from Community was harboring with him. But his roots are very much in comedy, as he started out as a comedy writer and performer.
Not to mention the fact that Glover has also taken on a hugely daunting task in taking over the role of Lando Calrissian in the upcoming Solo film. From the brief glimpses the trailers have offered, Glover's take on the role is already inciting praise.
Between the excentric comedic talents, the dramatic heft, the courage in the face of taking on a pre-established role, and the ability to meld genres together through performance alone, Glover is perfectly qualified to take on the role of Indiana Jones.
2. Zoe Saldana
Saldana has made a name for herself over the last decade-or-so playing physically demanding, badass roles. From Neytiri in Avatar, to Uhura in Stark Trek, to Gamora in the MCU, she has continuously demonstrated why she is a force to be reckoned with.
The most comparable of these to the role of Indiana Jones would have to be the way she has approached her take on Uhura for the rebooted Star Trek films. In taking over a pre-established role that was already beloved, Saldana has continuously taken creative risks and liberties with her performance that set her apart from her predecessor, while still having reverence for what has come before.
Her acting is continuously top-notch, she's never been one to shy away from an action sequence, and she knows to play in the world of blockbuster cinema and reboots. In many ways, her filmography reads like a stepping ladder leading up to a headlining role in an action franchise such as this. She would make for a perfect Indiana Jones and it would be wonderful to see Saldana finally out of the side role and truly leading a blockbuster franchise for once.
1. Idris Elba
For years, Idris Elba has not gotten his due.
He is far and away one of the most talented actors of his time and yet he is regularly mitigated to supporting roles or lead roles in tremendously underwhelming features. His latest headlining role in a blockbuster feature was that of The Dark Tower, which featured great work from the veteran actor, even as the film around him quite literally fell apart.
Elba has been a fan-favorite pick to play James Bond forever now but between Craig's indecisive nature and that franchise's own struggles, it's looking less and less likely. Which is a shame, because he'd be absolutely perfect for the role. So instead of playing Bond, why not allow Elba to settle just like Spielberg once did?
Having Elba take over the role would be a thrilling change and a great chance to see him in a starring role. He would be more-than-capable of pulling off every part of the performance with his own uniquely rogueish charm, his dramatic acting chops, and his love of stuntwork and action sequences.
If anyone truly deserves to take over the role of Indiana Jones, it has to be Idris.