11 Comic Book Characters Who Shouldn't Have Had A Movie (And The Alternatives Who Should)

Unknown, boring, zany characters... and yet The Flash still hasn't had a movie!

When you think of the great comic book characters who've never had their own movie, it makes you wonder why some of those who did managed to get the green light. Very few of the movies granted to obscure comic book characters have been a success... yet the movie studios keep pumping them out like nobody's business. Of course, having a more popular comic book character as the titular star doesn't necessarily guarantee a good movie - there's no reason why Daredevil, Ghost Rider, Spawn or Green Lantern shouldn't have been given a good movie, for example. Done right, they could have been great. Unfortunately, in most cases, they were pretty horrendous. But it's not these types of characters we're looking at here; it's the characters for which there are reasons why their movies shouldn't have happened; Unknown characters, boring characters, zany characters, characters whose respective companies had far superior options to choose from and characters for whom the timing of a movie was questionable to say the least. Essentially, these characters suck and so did their movies. On that note, here are 11 comic book characters who should never have had their own movie (and the alternatives who should have had one instead)...

11. Tank Girl

In a world where female comic book characters like DC's Wonder Woman and Marvel's Ms. Marvel are yet to have titular movies, you have to wonder why Tank Girl has. Back in 1995, the character who appeared in UK comic magazine Deadline got a movie (starring Lori Petty) with a cast that included the likes of Naomi Watts, Malcolm McDowell, Iggy Pop and Ice-T. It was pretty reckless and ambitious to think such a minor comic with such a crazy style would work. The comics were frequently disorganised, anarchic, psychedelic and downright absurd and generally showed very little regard or interest for conventional plot or committed narrative. Other characters included Tank Girl's "boyfriend" - a mutated kangaroo named Booga - and Iggy Pop's lecherous paedophile Sam. With a $25 million budget, the film grossed $4m at the box office. Trilogy Entertainment Group shouldn't have been slightly surprised by that. Alternative movie that should have been made: Modesty Blaise. A Titan Books character like Tank Girl, Blaise is far more interesting. Indeed, a 1966 film was made about the character and it earned more than $2 million at the box office even then and, after a failed attempt at getting a television series commissioned in the 1980s, a more modern film about the organised crime leader, assassin, private investigator and seductress would have been a lot more interesting than Tank Girl.

10. Steel

Steel has never been popular enough to warrant his own movie and DC has countless superior characters to the man with the big hammer, so it was very strange that they made this movie. Even more bizarre was the casting of basketball superstar Shaquille O'Neal as John Henry "Steel" Irons. Not only was it a silly idea, but the depiction of the character was also a million miles away from the comic book version. Most significantly, he was vastly underpowered in comparison. Rather predictably, the film was a complete and utter bust in every sense of the word. It was critically annihilated and, following the use of a $25 million budget, it grossed a grand total of a mere $1.7 million at the box office. The character should have been left well alone. Alternative movie that should have been made: Lex Luthor. This film was originally dreamed up with the intention of it being a spin-off of a new Superman movie. When that movie never happened, this spin-off occurred without it. The opportunity should have been seized to make a Luthor movie that could have included his own power armour, if indeed an armoured character was something DC wanted to make a movie about. The rise of Luthor is far more interesting than anything they could have made about Steel.

9. Supergirl

Supergirl herself is a relatively popular character. Kara Zor-El, played by Helen Slater, is the cousin of Clark Kent and this movie was in canon with the Christopher Reeve Superman series of movies - but it is for that reason that this movie was a bad idea. The Superman franchise was already dwindling in 1984 when this film was made. The first Superman movie made $300 million at the box office, the second one made $108 million and the third just $70 million. It was after the third that this movie came to be and, with a smaller budget than any of the Superman films and a lesser known character as the titular heroine, it was never going to work. With a budget of $35 million, the movie pulled in only $14 million at the box office and is generally regarded by critics and the public alike as one of the worst comic book movies ever made. Alternative movie that should have been made: Wonder Woman. The Amazonian warrior is a far more popular character than Supergirl (being a part of DC's holy trinity of Batman, Superman and Wonder Woman) and was fresh in the memory of audiences in 1984, following Lynda Carter's successful live action depiction of the character in the television series that finished just five years prior.

8. Elektra

Like Supergirl, Elektra isn't an unpopular or poor character but, given that her movie was a spin-off from one that did so terribly, it never should have seen the light of day. Daredevil, in which Jennifer Garner's Elektra Natchios first appeared, did okay at the box office. It wasn't an enormous hit by today's standards, but it earned $179 million from a $78 million budget - it's just that its critical reception was underwhelming to say the least. It wasn't universally reviled but its overall review status is "mixed" at best and, given that Daredevil is a more well-known character than Elektra, it wasn't the best idea to spin-off from his movie with a movie solely about her. Elektra's box office performance was quite poor, with $56 million being made from a $43 million budget, but its critical reception was horrific. Nobody really had anything good to say about it and it's hard to say that was anything other than expected. Alternative movie that should have been made: Black Widow. Granted, it's all worked out well on the Black Widow front now but, back in 2005 when the Elektra movie came to be (off the back of a movie with a terrible reputation), it would have been better to start afresh with another character who is strongly connected to Daredevil (they've been partners in the comics), but who didn't appear in his terrible movie and therefore have a disadvantage with audiences by default.

7. Barb Wire

It is quite easy to see why Polygram thought this might have worked in 1996 - at least on a financial level - given that they signed 29 year old Pamela Anderson to star in it as the scantily clad bounty hunter from the Dark Horse comics. However, it was never going to be a critical success with an actress lacking in talent as much as Anderson and, given that it didn't even draw the crowds, despite Anderson's obvious assets, it was an all-round failure. Even factoring in the undoubted sex appeal of the combination of Pamela Anderson and Barb Wire, it was always going to be a risk. Barb Wire's audience is comparatively minimal, when you're comparing her to the more popular characters from the likes of DC and Marvel, and that ended up backfiring terribly. After spending $9 million on making the film, only $3.8 million was brought in at the box office. Alternative movie that should have been made: Babe. Another Dark Horse title (that was set in the same continuity as Hellboy, incidentally), Babe had a far more compelling premise whereby a gorgeous super-strong and super-durable redhead appears out of nowhere on a beach, naked. Kidnapped by aliens, she escapes and fights to discover her origins. As ridiculous as it sounds, it's a case of "if they produced a Barb Wire film and managed to make it so ridiculous, they might as well have gone all out".

6. Jonah Hex

Jonah Hex is actually a pretty decent and engrossing character whose comics and adventures are fun and interesting to read - he just isn't widely known enough to warrant a movie. As an anti-hero, he's a rarity in comic books (he isn't, by any stretch, the only anti-hero out there, but that line between hero and villain is something that is rarely trodden in comparison to outright heroes and villains) and that makes him kind of unique - especially given that he's a cowboy. In the event that a movie was made, it needed to be a hell of a lot better than the one Legendary Pictures rolled out in 2010. The cast was top quality - stellar, in fact - with Josh Brolin in the lead role and the likes of Megan Fox, Michael Shannon, John Malkovich, Michael Fassbender and Will Arnett supporting, but the movie was downright garbage. Giving Hex a supernatural power in the movie was a stupid idea as well. It essentially made the movie as much of a wild west misfire as... well... Wild Wild West. And that's saying something. A budget of $47 million wasn't even close to being offset by an $11 million box office return and the general consensus amongst critics was that the movie was a waste of their time. Alternative movie that should have been made: Nightwing. This could have been used as a means of expanding the Nolanverse with a more well-known dark character. Batman Begins and the Dark Knight could have been used to hint at it and, by utilising the success of those films in the marketing, the turnover at the box office would have offset the budget in a manner that Jonah Hex could only dream of.

5. The Green Hornet

There was a time and a place for the Green Hornet - and 2011 wasn't it. A traditional-style character who originated in the 1930s on a radio show and flourished in a 1960s television series was never going to be taken seriously in the new millennium. And although the film was never portrayed as anything other than a comedy, Seth Rogen was horrendously miscast and nobody was ever going to take it seriously as a piece of performance art. That said, with a cast that included the likes of Rogen, Christophe Waltz and Cameron Diaz, it was always going to draw some crowds and it did okay at the box office - making up for the $120 million budget with $228 million in takings. Critics hated it, calling it unfunny, boring and disappointing - and they weren't wrong. Basically, the Green Hornet was of a certain era and aimed at people from a certain era - that era and those people weren't in the year 2011. Alternative movie that should have been made: Shock Gibson. Another hero who appeared in Harvey Comics (like Green Hornet himself), Shock Gibson is scientist Robert Charles Gibson. He perfects a formula that allows people to directly store, generate and control electricity and tests the formula on himself. The formula increases his strength, gives him the power to fire bolts of lightning and grants him flight capabilities. He then goes on to fight in World War II (a concept that we know works from seeing Doctor Manhattan fighting in Vietnam in Watchmen). It would have been a really interesting movie, about which people wouldn't have had any pre-conceived ideas of the titular character being dated.

4. The Phantom

Like the Green Hornet, the Phantom is incredibly old school... and very corny. Even in 1996, he was too dated for a live action movie and, by casting Billy Zane in the lead role, Village Roadshow Pictures were doing themselves no favours (he's no Downey Jr. or Bale). Even with (relatively) big names (and very attractive women) like Catherine Zeta-Jones and Kristy Swanson on board, the film couldn't be salvaged. The titular character was in his pomp in the 1930s and made a brief return in comics and the animated series "Defenders of the Earth", but he was never popular enough to warrant a movie. The box office takings of $17 million were testament to the error made in making this movie - especially from a $45 million budget. Alternative movie that should have been made: Flash Gordon. Sixteen years after the original Flash Gordon movie, 1996 was certainly long enough to have waited for a remake (why on Earth haven't we had one yet, in 2014?!). Both characters were published in comics under the King Features Syndicate imprint and had featured together in the classic animated television series "Defenders of the Earth", so the film-makers would certainly have been aware of the character. It makes you wonder why they opted for the far less popular Phantom. Although Flash Gordon only brought in $27 million at the box office (after spending $20 million on the movie's creation), it since became a cult classic - even by 1996 - and a remake would undoubtedly have drawn the crowds (and "Gordon's Alive" would have become a popular saying amongst a new generation, which would have been no bad thing).

3. The Rocketeer

Despite being an "old school" character (who was created in homage to the Saturday matinee serial heroes of the 1930s-1950s), the Rocketeer didn't actually first appear until 1982. He was a popular character amongst his readership - but his readership simply wasn't very big and making this 1991 movie was unlikely to end as a massive success story. Casting relative unknown Billy Campbell in the titular role was a mistake in itself, because if there's one thing an unknown character needs to bump up his popularity it's a big actor playing him. Even a supporting cast that included Timothy Dalton and a young Jennifer Connelly wasn't enough to sway the movie in to the realms of blockbuster territory. The film actually did okay, with earnings of $62 million from the box office - a $20 million profit on the budget - and average to slightly above average reviews. That said, it didn't blow anyone away and with all the other heroes out there, the Rocketeer shouldn't have made it to the big screen. Alternative movie that should have been made: Buck Rogers. For starters, the character has a more familiar name. Even if you never actually watched or read anything about the character, you've generally heard of him (and Daffy Duck's "Duck Dodgers" character assisted with that fact). But the key factor is that the concept of Buck Rogers, despite him being a World War I veteran, is that the character is kept in suspended animation for half a century, awakening in 2419. A new 1991 depiction of how 2419 might look could've made the film a modern, high-tech adventure, despite the character's origins.

2. The Shadow

You can't help but think that the release of The Shadow a mere two months after The Crow (who is a far superior character in every sense) was an attempt to capitalise on it. It almost feels as though Bregman/Baer Productions had heard about Dimension Films' making The Crow and, following the previous success of Batman, thought they'd jump on the "dark heroic warrior" bandwagon. Unfortunately, their attempts failed dramatically. The Crow, with a budget of $23 million, earned $144 million at the box office. The Shadow, with nearly double that budget ($40 million), earned a mere $48 million and was critically slammed universally. Alec Baldwin, who took the titular role, isn't necessarily a bad actor, and the film had a decent supporting cast in the form of Tim Curry and Ian McKellen, but it seemed to be rushed (probably to bash it out in The Crow's shadow - no pun intended) and it failed dramatically as a result. Alternative movie that should have been made: Doc Savage. Savage is a fellow Street and Smith Publications character who combines Indiana Jones' sense of adventure, Captain America's peak physical conditioning and Batman's martial arts/inventing abilities. Essentially, he has the traits of a number of characters who have all now proven to be successful at the box office by themselves. Although he isn't a particularly well-known character, he has a very memorable name and an extremely interesting and popular general concept, so it's hard to see how a movie could have failed.

1. Howard The Duck

This is, by far, the most baffling of all the decisions to release a movie about a particular comic book character. The reason? Well, because Marvel have thousands of characters to choose from and, in 1986, they chose to release one about an anthropomorphic duck with skills in a martial art known as "Quack Fu". Nearly thirty years later, we're still waiting for films about the likes of Black Panther, Doctor Strange and Namor, yet three decades ago we were presented with one about a god-damned talking duck. The movie made its budget of $37 million back at the box office but it took an absolute pounding from critics. It also showcased one of those most awkward and downright weird bedroom scenes in the history of cinema. Awful. There's no other word for it. Tim Robbins is still probably ashamed to be attached to this abomination. Alternative movie that should have been made: Literally anything. Any street-level hero who wouldn't have required a major budget for Thor/Hulk/Iron Man-esque special effects would have been better than this. Howard the Duck was simply an absurd choice for a live action movie. Moon Knight, Black Canary, U.S. Agent, Hawkeye, ANYONE would have been more suitable than this guy! So there you have it - eleven comic book characters who never should have had their own movie (and the alternatives who should have had one instead). Do you agree? Or should every character be given a chance to shine on the big screen? Let us know in the comments box below. And please feel free to follow me on Twitter!

In this post: 
Supergirl
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm a Tottenham Hotspur fan who loves comics and comic book movies.