11 Movies Which Got Geography Completely Wrong

"Nobody ever went broke underestimating the intelligence of the American public." – H.L. Mencken

Transformers Geo
Nobody ever went broke underestimating the intelligence of the American public. €“ H.L. Mencken
Every film has mistakes in it. There€™s a section for each film called €œGoofs€ on the Internet Movie Database (IMDB.com) web site, which lists the flaws for all to see. Sometimes the mistakes are technical, sometimes they involve continuity, and sometimes they involve dialogue. But there€™s one set of mistakes that in retrospect, seem totally baffling: geographical. American script writers, directors and producers are banking on the fact that most Americans are illiterate when it comes to geography. They aren€™t likely to know or even care that a car can€™t be driven over a thousand miles in a scene change. They€™re at the theater for entertainment, not a geography lesson. Besides, if they need to go somewhere, their GPS will tell them how to do it. But when that film goes overseas, and it encounters people who actually know how far it is from Beijing to Hong Kong, it makes them wonder: Can anyone in America read a map? Do they even own maps? If these American films are any indication, the answer is no. Some directors, like Michael Bay and Roland Emmerich are very good at skewing geography to meet the needs of their story. But some of these you wouldn't think were issues unless you'd personally been there. Warning: spoilers ahead. If you don't want to know, skip that entry.

11. Godzilla (2014)

The MUTO grabs a Russian submarine and takes it to a deserted jungle in the mountains above Honolulu to munch down its reactor. Army commandos converge on the spot. Godzilla uses his built-in MUTO radar to start heading toward Waikiki, passing (dramatically) under the US Navy task force on his way. The commandos and Air Force aircraft engage the MUTO, and it responds by knocking out power on the island using its EMP burst, including the airport, where Ford Brody is trying to catch a flight home. A tsunami plows through Waikiki, heralding the arrival of Godzilla. The power comes back on, and Brody€™s tram starts moving again. The MUTO suddenly appears, destroying the tram. The MUTO then proceeds to wreak havoc on the airport. Godzilla appears and engages the MUTO. Succeeding scenes show the two battling it out in Waikiki.
First of all, the only place a MUTO could hide and still be that close to Honolulu is the Honolulu Watershed Forest Reserve, about seven miles from the airport. Yet when the MUTO fires off his EMP, it appears to be less than a mile from the airport and almost overhead. Brody looks up and sees the explosion about a mile above him as his tram stops.
The power goes back on (strange, as an EMP destroys all electronics, not just knocks them out temporarily), and the tram starts up again. Brody looks over and sees the MUTO crossing the train tracks, destroying them in the process. The MUTO then proceeds to start tossing things around, destroying airplanes. Godzilla shows up, apparently having made the six-mile trek from Waikiki to the airport and engages the MUTO. After the two have done their damage, they move on. The beach in front of the Hilton Hawaiian Village is set up as an aid station. So, if Honolulu and Waikiki are that destroyed, how did Brody make it the eight miles (unlike Godzilla, he can€™t take the direct route) to Waikiki? Wouldn€™t the authorities have set up an aid station at the airport?

10. Godzilla (2014)... Again

The second (female) MUTO has torn its way out of the storage facility at Yucca Mountain, Nevada. It then rampages Las Vegas before heading to San Francisco to meet up with its mate. Las Vegas is about 92 miles southwest of Yucca Mountain. The commando looks thorough his binoculars and sees the MUTO heading for the Las Vegas Strip. Those are some pretty damn good binoculars, as they can not only see objects clearly from that far away, but also through solid mountain ranges.
The MUTO is responding to the call of its mate, who is flying up from Hawaii at the moment. The Navy, tracking both the male MUTO and Godzilla, have determined that they are heading for San Francisco. So why does the female MUTO go in the wrong direction? Las Vegas has no nuclear power plants; it gets all of its electrical baseload from the nearby Hoover Dam. There€™s plenty of nuclear fuel stored in the Yucca Mountain repository; it could get a meal there. The reason is, of course, is the tell-tale shot of the gamblers busy working away at the slot machines, oblivious to the threat on the casino TV screens until it rips the roof off the casino. Oh, and that shot above means the MUTO went to the south end of the Strip, then ploughed north on Las Vegas Boulevard.

9. Transformers: Age Of Extinction

Joshua Joyce has just had the Seed delivered to him and takes it to Bejing to complete his Transformium project. Cade Yeager calls him on his cell phone and convinces him that Megatron has infected his Galvatron project, and intends to use the Seed to cyberform a major city, using it to create enough Decepticons to wipe out humanity and take over the planet. Joyce actually listens to Yeager, and tells Harold Attinger that he wants to delay implementation of the Seed. Attinger orders his henchman James Savoy to kill Joyce and get the Seed at any cost. Megatron takes over the Galvatron shell and orders the other KSI prototypes to get the Seed. Joyce escapes Attinger and Megatron, with his associate Su Yueming driving him to Hong Kong
China is a rather large country, with a land mass fairly close to that of the continental US (minus Alaska and Hawaii). And even though the major cities are chock-a-block full of cars, most distance traveling is done by rail or air. Google can€™t even create driving directions from Beijing to Hong Kong. The best it can do is show the air route or the twice-daily train route. Yet Yueming manages to drive Joyce the 2,000 kilometers from Beijing to Hong Kong in record time.

8. Karate Kid Part II

Daniel LaRusso€™ mentor, Keisuke Miyagi, receives a letter from an old friend on Okinawa, Japan; his father is dying. Daniel accompanies Miyagi on his return trip home. On the plane, Daniel is trying to find Tomi Village on the map.
Miyagi: Find Naha. Head south. Daniel: I keep running into the air base. Miyagi: Maybe Tomi Village will be there in the morning.
Later, when they are in a cab, trying to get to the village, they encounter a U.S. Air Force airman who tries to help him. He tells them they€™re on Kadena Air Base. As you can see, Kadena Air Base is north of Naha, not south. You have to travel 18 kilometers to get to Naha from Kadena on the main north-south road, Highway 58.
It€™s been remarked that Daniel was holding the map upside down. However, that doesn€™t explain the scene in the cab. And just for the record, there are no mountains that tall on Okinawa. It€™s actually the Koolau mountain range on the north side of Oahu, Hawaii that you see behind the airman and in all scenes in the village.
Author€™s note: I was stationed with the U.S. Army on Okinawa from 1985 to 1989. I went to see this film in an Okinawan theater, with the local populace. It was in English, as the Japanese prefer subtitles to translation. As I was walking out, I noted that the locals were shaking their heads in bafflement, muttering €œHollywood.€

7. The Blues Brothers

Elwood: It€™s 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it€™s dark € and we€™re wearing sunglasses. Jake: Hit it.
Jake and Elwood Blues have just managed to acquire the $5,000 they need to rescue the orphanage they were raised in from the tax assessor. However, Jake is wanted for violating his parole, and Elwood for his 114 unpaid parking tickets and 56 moving violations. They€™ve got to get through the police gauntlet and have the money at the Cook County Assessor€™s office when it opens the next morning. Never mind that the location for the concert, Lake Wazzapamani, doesn€™t appear to exist. The concert was actually filmed at the Hollywood Palladium, and the exteriors were filmed at Chicago€™s South Shore Country Club.
While earlier examples on this list expected travel to be too quick, this one is too slow. Even given their lateness, the Blues Brothers left the show during the second song. That means it was probably between 10 p.m. to midnight. At the speeds they were leading the Illinois State Police on the interstates, it€™s improbable that they were able to last that long on the road and not make it to Chicago at 3 a.m. instead of dawn. Even if they chased around the city limits until it was closer to opening time for the tax office, they would have run out of gas long before then.

6. 2012

Jackson Curtis picks up his two kids from his ex-wife Kate, planning to take a camping trip to Yellowstone National Park. There, they run into Charlie Frost, a conspiracy theorist who tells Jackson about the Mayan 2012 prediction that the world was coming to an end, and that the world€™s elite were going to escape it, somehow. Jackson blows him off at first, but upon the family€™s return to Los Angeles, he€™s tasked to go pick up the brats of his Russian mobster boss, Yuri Karpov. They taunt Curtis about their survival while he and everyone else is going to die.
Even though the map says it take only 14 hours, 21 minutes to drive, it€™s based on the idea that you aren€™t stopping for anything. Anyone who€™s taken kids on a road trip knows that ain€™t happening. At best, that€™s a 17-hour drive, with stops for gas, food and potty breaks. Yet Curtis seems to make it there and back with relative speed and quickness. Curtis starts to put things together and comes to the conclusion that Frost was right. He rushes back to pick up Kate, the kids and her boyfriend Gordon. The foretold disaster starts then, with earthquakes ripping apart L.A. Curtis and his family make it back to the airport and steal a private plane, taking off as L.A. falls into the sea in giant slabs underneath them. They fly to Yellowstone to get Charlie€™s map of where the elites are going, then narrowly escape the explosion of Yellowstone€™s supervolcano. They make their way to Las Vegas, where Yuri is unable to get his private plane out. They steal a Russian Antonov cargo plane, narrowly escape the destruction of Las Vegas, and head on to Tibet, with a planned stop in Honolulu for refueling.
As you can see on the map, it€™s a lot more efficient to do the hop over the North Pole than it is to fly to Hawaii, and the Antonov has sufficient range (provided that it was fully fueled). Given the current state of emergency in the world, what makes them think they€™ll be able to get fuel in Hawaii, anyway? There€™s also something strange about the plot point that the earth€™s magnetic points have shifted. They made it to Hawaii okay; did the earth shift in that four hours since they left Hawaii? And even if they did, that shouldn€™t affect distance traveled. It€™s still a long way to Tibet from Honolulu.

5. Star Trek II: The Wrath Of Khan

The USS Reliant is scouting potential sites for testing of the Genesis Device, a program that reorganizes a planet€™s matrix, wiping out everything on the planet and replacing it with a virgin, terraformed planet. Their latest stop is Ceti Alpha V, which appears to meet the qualities needed for the test. However, a scanner picks up evidence of a life form, and Captain Terrel and Mr. Chekov beam down to see if they can €œtransplant€ it. Unfortunately, they meet the murderous Khan Noonien Singh, who is hell bent on revenge on James T. Kirk for leaving him and his crew there some 15 years previously. Khan tells his captives that Ceti Alpha VI exploded six months after they were dropped off, destabilizing the orbit of Ceti Alpha V, killing off most of the planet€™s life and his crew, including his wife.
Forget that Chekov wasn€™t on the show during the Space Seed episode. Let€™s talk stellar cartography. We know that Ceti Alpha has at least six planets. We also assume that they€™re in the same configuration as our own solar system, on a reasonably flat plane and the planets are in reasonably concentric orbits. We can safely assume that if Starfleet had assigned a name to the system, they had done a scan and recorded how many planets were in the system, along with their types. We can assume that Kirk updated it when he dropped Khan off 15 years earlier. We can also assume that an approach scan was made by the Reliant upon arrival to the system. Why didn€™t anyone notice that the system had one less planet than it did the last time someone checked? A simple script change would have fixed this problem. If the Reliant had been aiming for Ceti Alpha IV instead, and Khan had said that Ceti Alpha IV had exploded, the approaching Reliant would have assumed that Ceti Alpha V (Khan€™s planet) was in fact IV, and that VI was in fact V.

4. Close Encounters Of The Third Kind

Roy Neary is an electrical lineman in Muncie, Indiana, for the local power company when the power goes out one night. He is told to get in his truck and investigate. On the way, he has a Close Encounter of the First Kind: contact with a UFO. Along with the members of the local police force, he gives chase through tunnels and mountains and across the Ohio state line until the UFOs finally fly into the cloudy sky.
Muncie, Indiana has no mountains, no tunnels and is 170 miles southwest of the Indiana Toll Road, which becomes the Ohio Turnpike at Perrysburg, Ohio. It€™s also been noted that the stars are inappropriate for the season and latitude of Muncie. That€™s probably because all of the scenes were filmed in Georgia. While playing the five tone song the aliens have sent to them, a series of numbers appear on their computer monitors and printers. David Laughlin notes that the coordinates are geographical coordinates. A globe is found, and the coordinates show Wyoming. A geodesic map is ordered and a location to meet the aliens is mapped.
Trouble is, the aliens were off by four degrees latitude. The coordinates given, 44°36'10" N by 104°44'30" W, actually point to a spot over 300 miles to the south, near Ault, Colorado.
What it should have read was 40°36'10" N by 104°44'30". That would put them about a mile northwest of Devil€™s Tower. However, even with their geodesic map of northeastern Wyoming, the scientists still had the location wrong. They put their landing field southeast of the tower. Good thing that the aliens bothered to look for the big bright landing strip.


3. Moonraker

While riding atop a 747 from Los Angeles to London, the Moonraker shuttlecraft is hijacked and flies away, leaving the carrying 747 to fall to the ground in a burning fireball. James Bond is tasked to find out why there is no trace of the shuttle in the wreckage, which landed in the Yukon.
The standard route from Los Angeles to London does fly over Canada, but nowhere near the Yukon, which is up in the northwest corner, adjacent to Alaska. If the shuttle had flown over the pole, it might have crashed in the Yukon, but it would have been taking a route rather close to the Soviet Union, and the Cold War was still in full force at the time (1979).
Bond traces the shuttle€™s disappearance back to Hugo Drax, the billionaire inventor of the shuttle. He tracks down a lethal gas produced in one of Drax€™s laboratories, and it is determined that it originates from a rare orchid growing in the Amazon jungle in Brazil. Q issues Bond a boat that will get him to the location, but he is attacked by Jaws. Out of options, Bond deploys a hang glider escape device and flies away as his boat (and Jaws) go over the Foz do Iguaçu waterfall.
One thing, though. The Foz do Iguaçu waterfall is in Brazil, but it is in Parana, not the Amazonas, which is a sizable distance away.

2. Deep Impact

A comet is about to impact off the Eastern Seaboard of the United States. Journalist Jenny Lerner, who uncovered the government€™s attempts to keep the knowledge secret, is fortunate enough to be selected to join the Ark, an underground shelter in Missouri. However, two hours before impact, she gives up her seat on the escape helicopter that would take her away from Washington, D.C. to a co-worker and her young daughter. She then goes to Cape Cod to join her father as he waits on the shoreline, ready to embrace death when the giant tsunami caused by the comet arrives on shore, destroying everything in its path.
The journey from Washington DC to Cape Cod would take nearly eight hours, and that€™s with roads that aren't jammed with desperate people trying to get to higher ground. Even flying from Washington to the Cape would be nearly three. She could have watched the impact from her window seat, assuming that her flight survived the massive turbulence that the comet would leave in its wake.

1. The Sound Of Music

At the end of the film, the von Trapp family escapes the Nazis by hiking out of Salzburg, Austria, across the Alps, to freedom in Switzerland. It makes for good old-fashioned 1965 musical storytelling, but it doesn€™t really take into account practical geography.
It€™s 210 kilometers from Salzburg to the closest border with Switzerland, and that€™s traveling in a straight line. That route doesn€™t take into account the fact that this area is some of the most mountainous terrain on Earth. The von Trapps may have sung €œClimb E€™vry Mountain,€ but they would have been hard pressed to stay hidden and make this particular trek. In fact, the first mountain they crossed would have brought them to Berchtesgaden, where Hitler had his summer home. Not the place you want to go if you€™re trying to escape the Nazis. Any that we missed? Let us know and we'll save them for the sequel.

Contributor
Contributor

Mr. Thomas is primarily a graphic artist for the San Antonio Express-News, but also finds time to write the DVD Extra blog for the paper’s website.