11 Perfect Times Actors Went Incredibly Dark
Unexpectedly brilliant dark performances from Disney actors, Harry Potter stars and a clown...
While some will have you believe that the idea of "stunt casting" is in some way a dirty concept, it's no mere coincident that some of the most impressive movie performances of all time have come from unexpected places. You don't remember Sylvester Stallone for his action movies as much as for his quiet, human performance in Cop Land. You might buy more tickets to Adam Sandler comedies, but it's his dramatic roles that really leave a mark.
That's why there's such a currency in making seemingly strange casting choices or encouraging actors to really let loose and embrace the extremes of their characters. It pays off particularly well when the characters are dark, because the darkest characters are invariably the most interesting and the most lucrative for performers.
And over the years, there have been some incredible, disarming performances by actors going to the dark side...
11. Robin Williams - One Hour Photo
There's a tendency to believe that Robin Williams' film career was solely comedic, given his background as a stand-up, but after getting his start in an ACTUAL porn comedy anthology Can I Do It 'Till I Need Glasses? and starring in the disastrous Popeye, it wasn't until he went more serious in 1987 with Good Morning, Vietnam that he really broke out.
And yes, he went far more comic in the wake of Aladdin, but he'd made The Fisher King, Dead Poet's Society and Awakenings before then and had obvious dramatic chops. That still prepared nobody for how stunning he was as lonely psychopath Seymour Parrish in One Hour Photo.
Chillingly one-tone (which was most disarming because of Williams' usual vocal flamboyance), Sy was a picture of slow-burning, not-quite-right creepiness; all restrained rage and violence and Williams played him to haunting perfection.
10. Christian Bale - American Psycho
Looking back at Christian Bale's early career, he showed obvious promise from the very first days, but there wasn't a great deal in his run of Empire Of The Sun, The News Boys, Little Women and Pocahontas that suggested he had much darkness in him. Sure, he was a great character actor in the likes of Velvet Goldmine and even as Jesus in Mary, Mother Of Jesus, but his casting in American Psycho was as out-of-the-blue as it was spectacular.
Though it was originally ear-marked for Leonardo DiCaprio (they obviously wanted a clean-cut stunt casting), Patrick Bateman became the prototype for Bale's Bruce Wayne - a duplicitous, mask-wearing monster. The genius hook here, though, was that he worked against justice and there was so much delicious charm to Bale's performance that his arrogance and idiocy were forgivable and he was perversely... likeable.
So when he started torturing escorts and opening business rivals' heads with axes, it was incredibly shocking. But not as shocking as seeing the guy who'd JUST played Jesus doing it all.
9. Leonardo DiCaprio - The Wolf Of Wall Street
For all the misconceptions of him as JUST a romantic lead, Leonardo DiCaprio has always been more impressive in challenging roles that give him something to get his teeth into. And his turn as Jack in Titanic was very much a calculated diversion that elevated his profile, but which is in no way reflective of the rest of his career.
That said, for all the complexity in the roles he seeks, it took him a long time to fully embrace the darkness. Sure, he flirted, but for the most part, dark things happened to his characters, rather than him orchestrating them.
That much changed in both Django Unchained, where he was outright detestable and The Wolf Of Wall Street. And it's the latter that really deserves more attention for how DiCaprio took to the darkness of his character. Sure, his Calvin Candie is a bad guy, but morality to him doesn't exist - he is his own law - for Jordan Belfort, the law and all sense of morality is something to be negotiated to his own desires.
His hedonism and sociopathy ranks up there with Patrick Bateman and the way he romanticises his own mythology as he's writing it is as impressive as it is despicable.
8. Jennifer Aniston - Horrible Bosses
Who would have thought that Jennifer Aniston - TV's own sweetheart, Rachel Green - would end up playing a dangerous sexual aggressor who weaponises her body and attempts to destroy the target of her lust so successfully that he tries to have her murdered? That's a hell of a change of career path.
Sporting a brown wig to intentionally look different to her other roles, Aniston's penis fly trap monster is as far removed from Rachel as you could possibly imagine. She's a grotesque caricature of workplace sexual harassment, ingeniously respinning every reductive misogynist trope through a female filter. That's how you hold up a mirror.
She's not only amoral, but an outright criminal who drugs Charlie Day's dental nurse, Dale and repeatedly sexually abuses him. And yet, hers is arguably the most lauded performance in the entire film.
7. Topher Grace - Predators
Topher Grace already had some precedent with playing dark characters off the back of his move from TV's That 70s Show into movies thanks to the plum role of Eddie Brock in Spider-Man 3. Unfortunately, because that character was a bolt-on and in no way properly conceived, he was also pretty mediocre. There have been worse performances, but few have been so closely tied to why an entire fanbase felt let down.
But when he turned up in the massively underrated Predators three years later having laid pretty low in the meantime (other than an appearance in the risible Valentine's Day), he was still something of an unknown quantity. It was almost like Spider-Man 3 had wiped his slate clean.
He plays unexpected criminal Edwin as an everyday dweeb, wrongly incarcerated with monsters, until the end sees him revealed to be a worse predator than the titular aliens. The switch into a cold, callous psychopath is incredibly successful and it's everything you wish he could have brought to Venom.
6. Jim Carrey - Cable Guy
Jim Carrey gets a lot of heat for not being a great actor sometimes, but he's very much in the same school as Adam Sandler, whereby he was a lot better than the material his fans seemed to lap up a lot of the time.
Over the years, he's shown flashes of being a truly gifted dramatic actor, capturing that special brand of pathos that only comics seem to manage when they transition into straighter roles. And in The Cable Guy, he's arguably on his most impressive form.
Okay, so it's not got the dramatic heft of something like Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind or The Truman Show, but his Chip has way more layers. He appears to be a harmless goof, but then his reality is peeled back and despite the comedy, we're painted a picture of a dangerous stalker shaped by years of neglect who is willing to do anything to get what he wants.
Don't let the pratfalls fool you, this is a deeply dark character who plays on your perverse sympathies for him who should have informed The Riddler way more.
5. Kathy Bates - Misery
Thanks to Kathy Bates, a whole generation of film lovers can't look at a sledgehammer without wincing brutally.
When it came to starring in Rob Reiner's adaptation of Stephen King's Misery, Bates was far from a well-known name. She'd struggled to break through on the big screen despite debuting way back in 1971 because - in her words - she wasn't attractive enough and made more waves on the stage.
But then Reiner's casting team hired her and weaponised how she looked to the most unexpected, chilling results. Bates' Annie Wilkes is homely looking and comforting - the kind of face you'd absolutely want to greet you after a serious car accident. She seems gentle and amiable, excited to meet her favourite author but mostly concerned to nurse him back to health.
And then the facade is peeled back brutally and you see the real face of the monster: she's a serial killer with multiple victims to her name - including 11 babies - whose intent for him was always nefarious and Bates' flip from homely to fiery is precisely why it's still her most defining performance.
4. Macaulay Culkin - The Good Son
As the tag-line for The Good Son cheerfully proclaims, "Evil Has Many Faces" but you still would never pick the angelic face of Home Alone's pre-teen hero as one of them.
Remarkably though, Macaulay Culkin's role in Ian McEwan's The Good Son was carefully engineered by his father Kit to try and develop his son's range for roles. It came at the height of Culkin's powers (and was actually written into his Home Alone 2 contract as a guarantee) after he'd brought Kevin McCallister to the world.
Ridiculously, the script was picked up by Fox after they'd ignored it for years when Home Alone and The Silence Of The Lambs did well and the studio believed they could make a Frankenstein's monster out of both. Culkin clearly had the thirst for violence, as Home Alone had proven, but his turn in The Good Son is surprisingly great. The film's not great, but his blend of cherubic innocence and cold, casual fascination with death almost makes him the perfect precursor to Norman Bates.
3. Kevin Costner - Mr. Brooks
Kevin Costner has never received the praise his career deserves, because way too many people remember Waterworld as being way more disastrous than it ever was.
He's always been one of those dependably sympathetic heroes - the kind you want to see reconnect with the ghost of his father or to recapture his lost sporting excellence or to not needlessly kill himself in a tornado to turn his son into Superman. He boasts this sort of intangible fatherly essence that makes him delightfully relatable, like Tom Hanks.
But with Mr Brooks, Costner swung to the dark side. And while the film was largely overlooked, Costner's Earl Brooks is a genius creation. He's a normal, everyday guy, respected in his community and the head of a loving family who just happens to be a serial killer who keeps bloody souvenirs. Like Dexter if he was a proper family man.
The role plays on every other pillar of his career, using the audience's expectations against them and it's all surprisingly effective.
2. Emma Watson - The Bling Ring
Darkness doesn't always have to manifest itself in murder or outright malevolence. It can be gnawing, insidious and a creeping toxicity that personifies everything wrong with an entire vapid sub-culture. And as Emma Watson proved with The Bling Ring, it can come from the most unexpected of sources.
Having made her name as Hermione - the morally unquestionable, goody-two-shoes hero of the Harry Potter universe - Watson took a leaf out of co-star Daniel Radcliffe's book on avoiding career typecasting to play the anti-Hermione. As Nicki, she's the ultimate narcissistic, vapid Valley Girl, hungry for fame and almost enthusiastic about being able to step on others' heads to get there.
She manages to be both brainless and calculating and if it turned out in a sequel that her petty juvenile criminality had blossomed into something more deadly, absolutely nobody could be surprised.
1. Heath Ledger As The Joker - The Dark Knight
How could it be anyone else? No reflection on surprising, brilliantly effective dark performances would be complete without mention of Heath Ledger's transformative take on the Joker for The Dark Knight.
Heralded with a tidal wave of confusion and apathy, Ledger's casting was as controversial as Michael Keaton's had been a couple of decades before hand and it was just as successful in the end. In fact, Ledger's measured portrait of a man well beyond breaking point was so complex and impressive that it has continued to inspire analysis years after it first screened.
While discourse rages around why he is as he is, we shouldn't overlook the majesty of the way Ledger plays him. He's creepy, intoxicating and danger personified - a coiled spring without a discernible trigger who seems to revel in our inability to classify him. He's Batman's most terrifying screen foe because he's such an unknown quantity and the fact that all of it came from Ledger is still incredibly strange and wonderful.
Which other dark performances belong on this list? Share your suggestions below in the comments thread.