11 Sci-Fi Movies That Got Science Completely Wrong

Some of (science) fiction's most glaring mistakes.

Armageddon We Won't Always Have Paris
Touchstone Pictures

Science fiction is a tricky genre.

By its very nature, it's contradictory: mixing science with fiction is hard enough to do, and the resulting juxtaposition is likely what attracts so many of us to the otherworldly and fantastical stories of interplanetary travel, exotic aliens and the dangers of technological advancements.

While many of the biggest sci-fi blockbusters often employ scientists as consultants to lend a little credence to their scientific elements, that doesn't mean that the experts' advice is always followed.

The results are often small, throwaway inaccuracies that don't take much from the movie in general, but there are a number of occasions where science was asked to step outside so that the story might move itself forward.

The worst offenders are those movies whose entire plot revolves around a piece of particularly flimsy science. But there are also tropes that have become so commonplace in movies that audiences have come to believe them as fact. After all, why would the movies lie to us?

While many of these entries certainly made their respective movies vastly more interesting, that doesn't excuse the fact that we've been sold nonsense dressed as scientific fact.

11. Total Recall – Exploding Humans

Total Recall Cohegan
TriStar Pictures

Total Recall is a sci-fi classic. Set on Mars in the late 21st century, it tells the story of Douglas Quaid as he finds himself caught up in an ordeal that may or may not be the result of synthetic memory implants.

Towards the movie's climax, antagonist Vilos Cohaagen is ejected to the surface of Mars where he dies a grisly, cartoonish death by decompression.

His body bloats dramatically and threatens to explode, which is something that is often shown to happen when the human body is sent unprotected into the vacuum of space.

Well, that's something that sci-fi has all wrong. While it might seem more dramatic that way, in reality, the most horrific aspects of decompression would be frostbite around the eyes, nose and mouth, and your blood pressure would drop so low that your blood would literally begin to boil in your veins.

Total Recall isn't necessarily the worst offender for this, but it's become a common trope in sci-fi, owing in part to its dramatic (and untrue) depiction in the 1990 classic.


10. Prometheus - “Half-Billion Miles”

Meredith Vickers Prometheus
20th Century Fox

Half a billion miles from Earth would take the crew of the Prometheus to somewhere near Jupiter, and we're supposed to believe that these people are real astronauts?

Fans of Ridley Scott's Alien franchise had spent a long time waiting for the fifth instalment, although when Prometheus came along it didn't quite live up to its hype.

Among a number of other issues, Prometheus, despite being a part of one of the most highly celebrated sci-fi franchises of all time, was riddled with small plot holes and errors in the science department.

Disregarding the fact that the apparently highly intelligent team spend most of the movie doing remarkably stupid things, there's one particular moment that's impossible to ignore for its sheer inaccuracy.

In a line of throwaway dialogue, Meredith Vickers (Charlize Theron) mentions that she's travelled "a half-billion miles from Earth". Seems adequate to explain how far from home the team is, right?

Not at all. Half a billion miles would only place them somewhere around Jupiter, which is something that Vickers, a senior employee of the company funding the mission, should have known.

It might seem nit-picky, but once you know how wildly inaccurate the dialogue is, you can't watch the scene in the same way again.


9. Jurassic Park – DNA's Half-Life

Jurassic Park DNA
Universal Pictures

While Jurassic Park is one of the most beloved films of the last few decades, its not without its plot holes, one of the largest of which is a huge scientific error.

The dinosaurs that fill Jurassic Park (and eventually start ripping people to shreds) are all cloned using DNA found inside mosquitoes preserved in amber.

While at the time this may have seemed like a fairly scientifically solid plot device, it has since been called out as absolute codswallop by scientists.

Research has shown that the half life of DNA is approximately 521 years, meaning that the 80 million year old dino DNA would have decayed beyond the point of usefulness millions of years before Hammond and co. ever extracted it from the mosquitoes.

When interviewed on the subject by the BBC, paleontologist Steve Brusatte described the process as "pretty difficult, if not impossible," explaining that "in order to clone a dinosaur you would need the whole genome, and nobody's ever even found a little bit of dinosaur DNA."

This one is easy to overlook given Jurassic Park's sheer entertainment value, but it's certainly comforting to know that we'll never be hunted down by a pack of velociraptors. Hopefully.


8. Waterworld – How Much Ice Was There?

Waterworld Kevin Costner
Universal

Waterworld isn't a movie known for its success.

A legendary box office flop, Waterworld tells the story of an aquatic dystopia after the polar ice caps melted and drowned civilisation as we know it.

Though global warming might threaten to do just that, the polar ice caps only actually contain enough ice to raise the entire world's water levels by around 200 feet. This would certainly prove devastating for coastal towns and communities, but the vast majority of the world would be largely unaffected in the way that Waterworld attempts to portray.

While in the mid '90s it might have seemed like a good way to scare up a decent story, the inaccuracy of the movie's premise only serves to undermine an already flimsy piece of entertainment. Unless Waterworld took place in an alternate reality where the polar ice caps were much, much bigger, it's exactly the sort of movie pseudo-science that grates on anyone with any real knowledge in the field.

It's a shame, though, because we were really looking forward to our gills and webbed feet.


7. Lucy/Limitless/Countless Sci-Fi Movies – Grey Matter Matters

Lucy Scarlett Johansson
EuropaCorp

It's hard to limit this entry to a single movie, because the truth is, it's become such a common sci-fi trope that the vast majority of the world has accepted it as fact.

"Humankind only uses 10% of our brains." Well, maybe whoever came up with that did, but the rest of us use much more than that.

In fact, the average human uses every part of their brain on a daily basis, although not all at once.

The simplest way to look at it is that different parts of the brain are all used for different things, and while you might not use all of them at once, it doesn't necessarily mean that you're doing everything more efficiently. For example, you might use every part of your brain to walk, sip coffee and text all at once, but would you use your every part of your body to do each of those things individually?

The "science" behind this one is flawed on multiple levels, because not even the concept really works when you think about it. So why on earth do movies insist on continuing to use this as a plot device?


6. X-Men – Evolution Doesn't Work Like That

Hugh Jackman X-Men Wolverine
20th Century Studios

The X-Men are an iconic part of both the superhero and the sci-fi genres, although a key part of their backstory is nonsensical on closer observation.

The idea behind the X-Men's powers - that super-powered mutants hiding among us are a result of evolution - borrows real science and warps it so dramatically that it's a wonder Charles Darwin hasn't rolled right out of his grave.

The vast majority of the world have enough knowledge of evolutionary theory to know that mutated super-powers don't really fit into Darwin's theorem. While X-Men's writers do their best to explain it away as "leaps in evolution", it'll never be anything more than a lazy appropriation of actual science.

The simple fact is that if the human race was evolving to have something akin to super-powers, you'd see it happen so incredibly slowly that it would be hardly noticeable at all, and we'd all be developing the same powers, generation by generation getting a little closer to becoming Wolverine or Magneto.

Yes, it's an awful way to manipulate fact to fit fiction, but that shouldn't take anything away from the years of entertainment it's given us (just not The Last Stand - that one can get in the bin).


5. Gravity – Using The Force

Gravity sci-fi movie
Warner Bros. Pictures

2013's Gravity was hyped as an ultra-realistic astronautical thriller, although it only really delivered on 2 out of those 3 promises.

Gravity's realism - and much of its credibility - went out of the window long before the movie's climax. Ryan Stone (Sandra Bullock) and Matt Kowalski (George Clooney) are in the middle of a routine spacewalk when disaster strikes, causing their shuttle to be irreparably damaged. While attempting to reach the safety of a Soyuz capsule, Stone becomes tangled, and Kowalski begins floating off into space.

Believing that his momentum will doom the pair, Kowalski bravely decouples their tether and floats away, saving Stone's life.

Or, that's what we're supposed to believe.

In reality, all it would have taken to save Kowalski would be a gentle tug from Stone, who was attached to a solid object. The scene is an insult to basic physics, and asking audiences to believe it as the movie's emotional core is even more insulting.

Put simply: how did the two end up in space if they don't understand how physics will work once they're out there?


4. The Matrix – Humans Don't Make Good Batteries

The Matrix Neo Wakes Up
Warner Bros. Pictures

The Matrix carved a strange niche for itself when it perfectly fused martial arts with sci-fi, and it certainly paid off for the Wachowskis, the movie's writer/directors.

The Matrix's premise is legendary: what if your entire life is just a well-constructed lie?

In the distant future, the world is dominated by a war between humans and machines, and humans are kept in stasis pods wired into the Matrix, an elaborate simulation of the world as we know it. The movie's reasoning for this is that the machines are harvesting the humans - using them as batteries to further their own vague and probably nefarious ends.

But the issue with that is that humans make awful batteries. We barely produce any heat or electricity, and the amount of energy that the machines would have to expend to keep the humans alive and successfully wired into the Matrix would far outweigh any potential benefit.

This one is especially ridiculous when you consider that the machines, being man-made, would have known this before ever hatching their strange, inefficient plan.


3. Armageddon – Were They Even Watching The Sky?

Armageddon Crew
Touchstone Pictures

Discovering an asteroid the size of Texas just 18 days before it hit the Earth? What exactly were the world's astronomers doing in the months (or years) leading up the events of the movie?

1998 sci-fi disaster movie Armageddon is hopelessly riddled with plot holes.

Aside from the obvious "why not just teach astronauts to drill?", the biggest plot hole is actually one that would preempt the entire movie.

Armageddon tells the story of a drilling crew sent into space in order to break up a massive asteroid on a collision course with Earth.

The movie opens with NASA discovering the "Texas-sized asteroid" just 18 days before its projected impact, which would wipe out all life on Earth.

The truth of the matter is, an asteroid that big would have been visible for months, if not years, so what exactly were all of Earth's astronomers doing in that time? It's a little hard to believe that they were all looking elsewhere.

It's an error so large that not only does it make the plot seem suddenly ridiculous, but it negates all of Armageddon's emotional weight, too. It's really hard to care who might die saving the Earth when you know that if just one single astronomer looked into the sky it all could have been avoided.


2. Star Wars – Single Biome Planets

Armageddon We Won't Always Have Paris
Touchstone Pictures

Star Wars might be one of the most successful and popular sci-fi franchises of all time, but that doesn't excuse it from following certain rules.

While George Lucas cleverly skirted around being limited to our own familiar sciences by setting his story in a galaxy far, far away, it's still not enough to render the entire franchise immune to scrutiny.

Let's start this by stating that the planets in the Star Wars universe all seem to follow the same basic laws of physics as Earth, but that's not really the issue. The issue is the environmental conditions of those planets.

Each planet is part of a star system, and as a result, they should all have weather systems. And they do. Except they always (or mostly) appear to the same across the entire planet.

While the idea of an ice planet, a desert planet and a forest moon are nice and easy to wrap our heads around, scientifically, it's absolute nonsense. Planets would have areas with vastly different climates, much like our own, and if their conditions were extreme enough to warrant the entire planet being nothing but scorched desert, we can't help but wonder if life should exist there at all.


1. The Martian - The Dust Storm

The Martian
20th Century Fox

The Martian depicts astronaut Mark Watney's struggle to survive after a storm leaves him alone on Mars with no means of contacting Earth.

In a movie set extensively on Mars just a short way into the future, it's easy to pick apart the science behind the story.

While there are a few scientific inaccuracies, the worst offender is actually remarkably early on: the dust storm that causes Watney's crewmates to evacuate and leave him for dead.

Dave Lavery, an executive for Solar System Exploration at NASA, who also served as a consultant on the movie, explained the mistake best:

"Dust storms certainly do occur on Mars, they get winds in excess of 100 mph (160 km/h), but a 100 mph wind on Mars, because the atmosphere is so thin, has the same inertia and dynamic pressure down at the surface as about an 11 mph (18 km/h) wind on Earth. It’s not going to have the sort of energy to move large objects the way that is portrayed in the book and the film.”

To be fair, The Martian was adapted from a novel by Andy Weir, so, technically, the fault lies with him.


Contributor
Contributor

Antisocial nerd that spends a lot of time stringing words together. Once tried unsuccessfully to tame a crow.