11 Subtle Details That Make Movie Twists Obvious
You've got red on you, Bruce...
There’s nothing a seasoned cinemagoer loves more than a good twist. There’s few feelings that compare to the jolt of exhilaration the comes when a filmmaker has played out the story, drawing the denizens of the multiplex into caring about their characters, and nails the landing with a twist in the tale which leaves us reeling and reconsidering everything we’ve seen.
Sure, the last minute “throw-it-in twist” is the bane of many a director (looking at a certain Mr. Shyamalan in particular here), but good twists are set up throughout the preceding film and reward a patient viewer upon a re-watch by revealing small hints throughout the runtime.
So, this isn’t a list of nit-picks for the twists that didn’t actually make any sense when we thought about them. Instead, here’s a celebration of the movies that did it right, pulling the rug out from under us only to reveal they’d been setting up a surprise under our unsuspecting noses the entire time.
11. Verbal Gives The Game Away - The Usual Suspects
We couldn’t leave out one of the best twists in cinema history. Yes, the quality of films on this list may vary, and a lot of lesser flicks have been saved from the bargain bin by virtue of a clever last act reveal.
However, no one could claim that The Usual Suspects is anything less than a stellar thriller even before its mind-blowing ending. Taking cues from Tarantino’s twisty then-recent debut Reservoir Dogs, The Usual Suspects anchors its clever unreliable narrator reveal with a stellar performance from Kevin Spacey as unassuming small-time crook Verbal Kint.
Hell, the film’s ending was so clever, half the cast didn’t even know the twist until opening night! Despite this, upon a re-watch, eagle-eyed viewers will note that the ending is more obvious than it seems.
Verbal looks up to the Lieutenant’s coffee cup as he mentions Kobayashi by name for the first time, and throughout the rest of his “confession”, the criminal glances throughout the room before offering the next location-based improv cue. It’s a small but noticeable detail planted throughout the performance, and one which warrants repeat viewings for this crime classic.
10. Blaire’s Guilty Conscience - Unfriended
Throughout the runtime of 2014’s surprisingly-not-terrible Unfriended, the MTV horror most notable for taking place entirely on a computer screen, we learn very little about protagonist Blaire. She’s presumably heartbroken by the loss of her former friend to suicide, she’s been cheating on one unlikeable teen movie love interest with another, more unlikeable one - it’s all fairly standard “barely bothering” backstory.
Which makes it all the more impressive that the film sneaks in a few choice instances hinting at Blaire’s beneath-the-surface guilt, the sources of which is never revealed until the film’s undeniably tense closing scenes.
Blaire was the one who uploaded the embarrassing party footage which lead to a cyber-bullying campaign so intense that her former friend Laura opted for suicide as a way out. Even before Laura’s vengeful ghost begins picking off her friends, Blaire begins typing the truth to her boyfriend, never sending and sometimes never even fully writing out the message before changing her mind.
By the time the killings begin, she’s quick to play innocent and lay blame at the feet of each of her friends in turn - exactly what a coward close to admitting their guilt would resort to.
9. Lady Hideko’s Seduction - The Handmaiden
This one is a little more subtle than most, so any viewers who managed to see through Park Chan-Wook’s twisty, steamy melodrama deserve all the applause unfairly offered to anyone who pieced together Gone Girl’s mystery early.
There’s two hours left in the film, of course she’s not really dead! Anyway, moving on…
An adaptation of Sarah Waters’ Victorian mystery Fingersmith, The Handmaiden takes a few necessary (and a few more liberal) creative choices while bringing the story to the screen. Switching the setting and adding a more reprehensible antagonist (from the director of Oldboy? What a shock), the film nonetheless maintains the twisted love triangle of the original novel.
When pickpocket-turned-handmaiden Sook-hee is hired by conman Fujiwara, she believes her job is to convince the haughty Lady Hideko to marry him. Instead Hideko is far from the innocent guileless victim she plays and is actually ensnaring Sook-hee in a complex scheme while collaborating with Fujiwara too.
It’s a shocking midway plot twist, until you re-watch the film and realise Hideko’s entire innocent persona is clearly an act designed to fool Sook-hee and beguile her, with her calculated cluelessness leading Sook-hee to initiate a sexual “awakening” which leaves Sook-hee enraptured with her and happy to collaborate in her plotting.
8. Marie’s Mind - High Tension
Alexandre Aja’s debut is a landmark in New French Extremity, the boundary-breaking movement which lead to the popularisation of “torture porn” horror in American horror cinema and facilitated the death of the interminable, sanitised post-Ring PG-13 remake trend.
It’s a taut, terrifying, and viciously violent slice of suspense cinema, peerless in its messy execution of an unsparingly brutal hunt-and-chase narrative.
For the most part. Then comes the infamous twist ending, an unlikely swerve so poorly planted it almost derails the entire film and, for some critics, was enough reason to ignore its finer moments entirely.
The hulking, faceless trucker meting out horrific fates to all he comes across is revealed to be a split personality of our hitherto hyper-resilient protagonist Marie, a slight and quiet young French woman who looks more built to wield a withering look than a ton-weight bookcase.
As silly as the twist is, it is actually fairly well-established throughout the film, with the cross-cutting of Marie and the Trucker’s masturbation scenes (albeit with very different endings), the mention that Marie has never had a boyfriend, and the early dream sequence in which she is depicted running from… Herself.
Subtle stuff there, Alexandre.
7. Hans’ True Intentions - Frozen
Frozen may be remembered for more than its killer twist, but for a Disney offering the film packs a pretty stellar shock in its closing act. Benevolent love interest Prince Hans is revealed to be a power-hungry maniac, bent on taking over Princess Anna’s kingdom by marrying the innocent royal.
He’s quick to admit he never loved or cared for her once Anna becomes politically expedient, and the early promise of their romance is revealed to be a calculated ploy. Ice cold, Hans. Get it? Because it’s Froz - Never mind.
On re-watching the much-loved 2013 smash, though, the twist is telegraphed in a subtle and clever touch early on when Hans turns away from Anna as proclaims he’s “always wanted a place of my own” - a line which he says while ignoring her and opting instead to gesture at the massive kingdom she stands to inherit.
Clever, Hans, that’s about as subtle as the “Frozen” pun earlier.
6. Everything Charles Does - A Beautiful Mind
A Beautiful Mind was met with mixed reviews upon its release, with critics roundly applauding its technical merits and the superb acting showcased throughout, but some dissenting voices questioning the film’s depictions of mental illness.
And yes, a couple of decades later, the film is a little clumsy compared to later works addressing similar territory. But the stellar performances from Russell Crowe as mathematician John Nash and Paul Bettany, Ed Harris, and Vivien Cardone as figments of his imagination make up for the film’s shortcomings and it’s an important milestone in cinematic discussions of both mental instability and social attitudes toward sufferers.
However, as successful as the film is in tricking viewers the first time around, the framing of Nash’s delusions - and his roommate Charles in particular - makes the central conceit a lot more transparent upon another viewing.
Dramatically tossing a desk through a stained-glass window would probably provoke more than a raised eyebrow in the hallowed halls of an Ivy League institution, sure. But the more subtle and persistent clue is the framing of Charles, who is often only seen in empty doorways, conveniently obscured from onlookers.
5. Angela Can’t Swim - Sleepaway Camp
It’s hard not to feel bad revealing the twist to Sleepaway Camp. Despite the classic slasher being released some decades ago, the explosive closing shot is predicated on a reveal so dramatic that it remains controversial even in the usually unflappable circles of horror movie nuts.
Alright, here goes. The film makes it obvious throughout its runtime that the killer must be odd child Angela, who is bullied and excluded, only for violent vengeance to befall her many adversaries in various gruesome fashions.
The film is smart enough to include a potential red herring in the form of Ricky, who becomes Suspect Number One because—well, because Angela is just way too obvious. The ending soon reveals that Angela is, in fact, the killer—But she’s also Peter, the little boy who the audience presumed died in the opening scene. Forced into another gender Peter snaps mentally and dissociates, leading to the deluge of bloodshed and fryer-related mishaps which follows.
It’s an unexpected turn made even more surprising by the manner in which its revealed, a full-frontal view of “Angela” which exposes her secret double life. However, the film peppers clues throughout its runtime, including a repeated insistence that Angela refuses to swim or shower with the other girls—because either activity would result in her secret being made public.
4. Marla’s Frustration - Fight Club
Boasting a career-best turn from Brad Pitt, David Fincher’s Fight Club is a classic, and its genius ending deserves the acclaim it still enjoys over twenty years after its initial disappointment at the box office.
The reveal that the nameless narrator and Tyler are the same person is foreshadowed by a handful of subtle celluloid scratches early on in the flick which, when freeze-framed, reveal momentary glimpses of the imaginary anarchist friend. But you knew that one, and the more impressive foreshadowing comes at the level of character; specifically, the frustration expressed by on-and-off love interest Marla Singer.
Relying on a superb performance from Helena Bonham Carter, Fincher plants a few clues as to the protagonist’s duel nature by having her complain about his mercurial personality, his insufferable tendency to think, act, and talk differently depending on the day, and his inconsistent commitment to their flirtations.
3. Billy And Stu’s Trip To The Video Store - Scream
Horror icon Wes Craven didn’t just deliver a vicious blow to slasher movie clichés—and in the process, a reviving jolt to the heart for the subgenre itself—with 1996’s Scream. The starry meta-horror also pulled off one of the cleverest killer-reveals in the history of whodunits, with (spoiler alert, obviously) both brooding boyfriend Billy AND his immature slacker accomplice Stu behind the spate of grisly murders.
The rule-bending didn’t start there, not after the still-shocking opening scene killed off superstar Drew Barrymore, and it didn’t end there either, with Sidney upending the Final Girl conventions by having sex and not only surviving, but dispatching both baddies with style.
While some of the sequels are pretty solid, none of the uneven series could come close to ingenuity of this literal killer combo. And it’s a twist improved upon by repeat viewings, where it becomes obvious that everything providing Blatant Suspect Number One Billy an alibi, from the prison phone call to his fake-out death, hinges upon the theory that he must be killing unassisted.
Not only that, but the scene wherein Billy and Stu team up to playfully interrogate Randy in the video store takes on a far more sinister tone when you realize the two aren’t messing with him for their amusement, but rather attempting to ensure he won’t be able to uncover their plot.
2. The Staff On The Island - Shutter Island
Scorsese took an unexpected dip into psychological thriller territory with 2010’s pulpy Shutter Island, a Denis Lehane adaptation which eschewed the sombre tone of Mystic River for something far more Gothic and sinister. Centring around a typically superb turn from Leonardo DiCaprio, the film is a woozy, twisty thrill-ride, a Hitchcock homage which keeps audiences bamboozled until its final frames.
And maybe beyond there - he was crazy, right? This wasn’t a big conspiracy everyone else was in on to convince him - No, never mind, it’s fine.
Of course, upon re-watching the flick, a lot of subtle early cues fall into place. Chief among these is the staff in the eponymous asylum’s treatment of DiCaprio. The orderlies and doctors not only offer no deference to the officer, but listen to his theories with a combination of condescension, scorn, and outright threat.
All of which adds up when you consider the fact that he’s not an officer at all, but rather just another patient whose delusions they are sick of entertaining.
He is just another patient, right?...
1. You've Got Red On You - The Sixth Sense
Ask most cynical viewers of The Sixth Sense and they'll tell you that the twist was obvious: after all, how could we have missed the fact that the only person that interacts with Bruce Willis' melancholic child therapist is the kid who can see ghosts? He's telling us right from the get-go what his secret is.
But any reading like that is a little self-serving and actually misses the even more obvious hints at Malcolm Crowe being a ghost. Because M Night Shyamalan basically painted his scenes with handy visual clues.
Throughout the film, whenever there's a ghostly presence, we're primed for it subconsciously with the use of red. Cole's jumper when he's locked in the cupboard with the ghost of the servant is red, so is the balloon he follows up there, so is his bedroom fort... And there are lots more besides - including indicators around Malcolm too.
The doorknob he can't open is red, his wife's dress at their silent anniversary dinner is red... Once you start looking for them, you can't fail to miss them.