12 Actors Who Have Basically Just Become Cartoon Characters

Some actors like to chew the scenery. Hamming it up is mostly a fun alternative to grimly spewing out dull lines, but even Shakespeare's plays can work well with an actor who's prepared to commit to the most overdramatic interpretation possible (take Richard III). Still, there's a difference between overacting on occasion and playing all your roles as if you're in a Warner Bros. cartoon, and all of these actors crossed that line a long time ago.

When you see these actors onscreen, you aren't seeing the character they're playing but waiting impatiently for the bizarre line reading or grandiose monologue which you know is coming. It's sometimes a welcome distraction and sometimes it takes you right out of the film. Some of these actors have made a whole career out of their stylised performances, and others are wasting their talent by refusing to take any role seriously. Prepare yourselves for a countdown of twelve of the most over the top actors in the business today.

12. Malcolm McDowell

Malcolm McDowell's somewhat unhinged performance in Stanley Kubrick's film adaptation of A Clockwork Orange is perfect, but also marks the origin of McDowell's reputation as a "boisterous" actor, to quote his Wikipedia page (which is slightly bemused in tone). If you've somehow not seen him in a film, McDowell is likely to be a) very English, b) evil or c) quite possibly insane, and usually all three at once. He's spent a lot of time perfecting this approach to acting in film and TV, in roles ranging from 'a British person' in South Park to Dr. Loomis in the Halloween reboot to Metallo in Superman: The Animated Series, in which he sneeringly utters the line, "Sorry, Steel, I've still got some business in the 'hood." He's not so much an actor who has become cartoonish as one who always was, but now the public is waking up to it, as if from a drug-addled dream. In the clip below, McDowell plays Caligula in the 1979 historical drama which was panned for its gratuitous sex and shambolic structure. Still, it features McDowell baaing like a sheep. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NJvVEt6F_Xw

11. Antonio Banderas

Did someone call for a sexy Spaniard? Antonio Banderas would like to oblige, in almost every film. An early example is 1994's Interview with the Vampire opposite Brad Pitt and Tom Cruise, in which his character was once a boyish Russian in Anne Rice's novels. Needless to say, that's all subsumed beneath Banderas' brooding presence. Perhaps Banderas' most famous role amongst a certain generation is his starring turn as Zorro, where he uses all his swashbuckling charm to great effect. He is also literally cartoonish in the Shrek films as Puss in Boots, or Zorro in animated feline form, and there are probably corners of the Internet where that's still a swoonworthy performance. Then we get to the films in which Banderas is flat-out crazy and yet can't resist striking a somewhat sexy pose. The launch of the PS4 recently saw the revival of this clip from the 1995 film Assassins. Just what Banderas was going for is anyone's guess, but after emitting a high-pitched noise like a tortured animal he leans backwards and pouts in a manner worthy of Zoolander. I guess if you're going to be remembered for any one thing, it may as well be for your irrepressible sexiness.

10. Sir Ben Kingsley

You mean Oscar-winning Sir Ben Kingsley? You look for an article announcing his casting in Iron Man 3 and his Oscar for 1982's Gandhi will likely be mentioned at some point, because Kingsley has somehow become known as the British theatre veteran who now shockingly stars in a lot of B-movies or, worse, sci-fi films. It probably has a lot to do with his alleged (now refuted) demands to be called 'Sir' after his knighthood in 2001, cementing Sir Ben's image as the old-fashioned master who'd die for his theatrical art. Either way, Kingsley is the epitome of an actor who just should not be in that terrible Prince of Persia adaptation you've found on TV late at night €“ and yet he is. Kingsley actually just seems to enjoy starring in both heavy dramatic hitters like Schindler's List and the likes of BloodRayne, below in all its terrible glory, on which he later commented cheerily, "I have always wanted to play a vampire." He makes the most of it too, overacting as if he was in an amateur theatre group on opening night. Nonetheless, the reaction to Sir Ben appearing in anything other than a Best Picture nominee will be met with shock and surprise. He only won the Oscar that one time, you know. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jnQUfI10pAs

9. Al Pacino

Much like Malcolm McDowell's Wikipedia editors, those responsible for compiling Al Pacino's IMDB biography seem to have struggled to find words for his acting style, and eventually settled on "forceful dramatic presentation". In other words, Pacino pretty much gave up on understated with The Godfather and proceeded to chew the scenery like there was no tomorrow in every subsequent film. He has no indoor voice either, which is useful for big monologues such as the speech which forms the keystone of his Oscar-winning performance in 1992's Scent of a Woman. The clip below is from the 1979 courtroom drama ...And Justice for All, in which Pacino plays a morally righteous but hot-tempered defence attorney. It's a pretty famous scene in which Pacino just throws caution to the wind and decides to deafen the extras and presumably most of the cast and crew. It can't be transcribed without excessive punctuation and capitalisation, so please, watch it instead.

8. Helena Bonham Carter

Women seem to be more resistant to the tendency to play grotesques instead of characters, probably because many of the actors on this list are middle-aged or older and sadly there are still far fewer parts for women over forty. Helena Bonham Carter has carved herself a niche as the gothic English matriarch of Hollywood, and usually turns up on the red carpet in fairly odd ensembles as well. In 2012, Bonham Carter inevitably played Miss Havisham in Great Expectations, a role which presumably wasn't much of a stretch. When she's playing a villain, which is often, Bonham Carter takes the opportunity to take that trademark eeriness right off the charts and alternates between hissing and screeching like a banshee. For children (and adults) across the globe, this is her most memorable performance. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mY12VzDhWiA

7. Brian Blessed

Brian Blessed We couldn't make it through the article without mentioning perhaps the most famous scenery-chewer in the UK, whose mere presence in a film is a guarantee of lots and lots of loud and unsubtle overacting, which is without exception entertaining. His most famous role is Prince Vultan in the camp 1980 Flash Gordon film, but Blessed is usually recognisable whether he's dominating a scene in a TV series or doing the voiceover for an advert. He's even been asked to record his voice for a satnav. Blessed was classically trained and pops up in bit roles on TV in the late 60s and early 70s with a far less conspicuous manner, but now if he's hired, it's because the film is in need of his bear-like charm. The clip below is from 1976's I, Claudius, which stars Blessed as Augustus, the first Emperor of Rome, who's just finding out that his daughter Julia isn't a saint. It's a little slow to start, but if you bear with it the full force of Brian Blessed's voice is unleashed to terrifying effect. If he ever stars in a film with Pacino, we'll all have to wear earplugs. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LhsY5XEqTWY

6. Johnny Depp

Like Helena Bonham Carter, Johnny Depp has in the last decade made an impression with several bizarre performances, and his other work has faded into the background. Since the first Pirates of the Caribbean film in 2003, Depp has starred as Willy Wonka (2005), the Mad Hatter (2010) and the vampire Barnabas Collins in Dark Shadows (2012), interspersed with the Pirates sequels. On top of his previous form as Edward Scissorhands, that's a lot of well-known characters to play with similarly quirky attributes, and Dark Shadows' lukewarm reception implies that it's getting repetitive. Depp's more conventional roles in The Tourist (2010) and The Rum Diary (2011) weren't well-received either, suggesting that we may be about to see a career U-turn, but until then Depp remains defined by his most lurid performances.

5. Jeremy Irons

Jeremy Irons is another Oscar winner like Ben Kingsley who crops up unexpectedly in a number of films for the money; he's unashamedly admitted as much. Whatever his part, he will play it with melodramatic excess which is in direct proportion to the film's quality, i.e. if it's bad, Irons will be matching every awful line he's forced to say with some of the most overzealous acting ever committed to the screen. He's earned himself a reputation for sinister villains in the process, so he's essentially a cartoon character for hire. Of course, Irons is the most famous animated villain of them all, Scar, but he's also matched Alan Rickman's Hans Gruber for villainous moustache-twirling in Die Hard with a Vengeance and played the infamous Pope Alexander VI in TV's The Borgias. However, the video below is from his performance in the awful 2000 Dungeons & Dragons film, in which even his facial expressions are ridiculously evil. Someone's compiled over 15 minutes of his best moments, but watch the first 60 seconds and you'll be convinced. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OL4w__Vqdjg

4. William Shatner

William Shatner is still best known as Captain James T. Kirk (despite his part in Boston Legal a few years ago), and he knows it. Although initially resistant to the typecasting, he's since embraced it and his trademark overemotional delivery, so that you know that he'll take the most ordinary line and insert dramatic pauses into it at random intervals. Once you notice it, you won't be able to watch an episode of Star Trek without picking up on it. He's also known for his ego, and although he mended friendships with the original Star Trek cast some time ago, Shatner plays up to his reputation more often than not. Perhaps the best examples are his legendary spoken-word performances for which he's routinely mocked, such as this notorious 1978 interpretation of Elton John's Rocket Man. It was repeated on Family Guy years later by Stewie in one of the show's great gags. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lul-Y8vSr0I

3. Jack Black

jackblackgl Jack Black's contrived comedic persona, which usually depends on fat jokes and musical interludes, is beginning to wear thin. In his more understated roles in Shallow Hal (2001) and the saccharine romantic comedy The Holiday (2006), he's very watchable, but at some point in the last few years we lost interest in the caricature we loved in School of Rock (2006) and Kung-Fu Panda (2008). Since then, Black's made a number of duds. Black can make a good job of a more complex comedic part, so he falls squarely into the category of actors whose cartoonish personalities onscreen just aren't working anymore. It's most evident in the dire Year One from 2009, in which Black's overacting can't really compensate for just how terrible the film is.

2. Robin Williams

You will probably fall into one of two camps with your opinion of Robin Williams: either you think he's highly overrated and always difficult to watch, or you think he's a talented actor who's lost his touch recently. Evidence for the latter includes his excellent performances in Good Morning Vietnam (1987) and Dead Poets Society (1980), and his incredibly creepy role in One Hour Photo (2002). His skill at improvisation is well-known, but it's a tired shtick if reviews for his new sitcom The Crazy Ones are to be believed. Williams plays serious dramatic parts well when he restrains his comedic ability, so although he's been hit-and-miss in the last few years, a couple more films like One Hour Photo could rid him of the audience's expectations for good. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vjIBX5RrG4Q

1. Nicolas Cage

Ah, Nicolas Cage, the most cartoonish of cartoon character actors whose credentials for the top spot of this article are unparalleled. Every performance is imbued with a maniacal glee regardless of whether the character calls for it or not. It's tempting to suggest that Cage, like Williams, should take more serious roles and remind us of his acting ability, but unlike Williams he's still undisputedly fun to watch when his eyes are popping out his head with the effort of hamming it up. It's difficult to pick a single Cage film which encapsulates his bizarre style. 1988's Vampire's Kiss is famed for the scene in which Cage runs wildly down the street shouting, "I'm a vampire! I'm a vampire!" 2006's The Wicker Man generated meme after meme. Then there's Cage's performance as Johnny Blaze/Ghost Rider, where irrespective of the terrible script he delivers every line with absurd intensity. Maybe one day Cage will decide that he's had enough fun and earned enough cash to turn his hand to a nuanced performance. Until that day comes, an intrepid YouTuber has put together a film of Nicolas Cage's best moments. Enjoy. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JrQkgLLL9XQ

Contributor

Grace Murray hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.