12 Actors Whose Careers Were Destroyed By A Single Movie

Play Superman, you say? What could possibly go wrong?

Sometimes an actor we all know and sort of love will just disappear from our cinema screens. One minute, they'€™re in every sort of movie under the sun, but before you know it they€™re gone, reduced to voicing a supporting character in a Dreamworks animation. Sometimes an actor will just slowly slip from notoriety, picking increasingly obscure projects by choice, until they eventually declare it€™s over. But often it'€™ll take only one film for someone to go from the peak of the A-List to the base camp of the Z-List.

Here we give you twelve actors who had their career ruined by one film. Some of them went gallantly, realising their time was up and honourably quitting. Others were less so; trying their best to cling on to what semblance of fame and ended up as desperate as a Superman fan attempting to find something good in Man Of Steel.

I'm not going to cover actors who've had a slow decline (Tim Robbins, Robert De Niro) or who Hollywood think are still big when audience€™s would beg to differ (Will Smith, Tom Hanks).

These are all people who have one major offending movie, with its poster on their dartboard and a Golden Raspberry (the terrible movie equivalent of the Oscars) proudly on the mantle.

12. Sean Connery - The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Allan Quatermain League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen Sean Connery
20th Century Fox

The Actor: Despite being over thirty when he hit big, Sean Connery's had quite a career. Playing some of the most defining roles in cinematic history, Connery will always be remembered in the annals of cinematic brilliance. But unlike his octogenarian counterpart Clint Eastwood, Connery's been notably absent from our cinema screens recently.

The Film: Alan Moore is the comic king of concepts. Starting with the revolutionary dystopian sci-fi V For Vendetta and going on to redefine the superhero with the alternate reality Watchmen, he'€™s proven incredibly capable of turning good ideas into great graphic novels.

Making these ideas into films have proven more difficult. Before the marginally successful adaptation of the previously mentioned titles, Hollywood went with Moore€™s still in progress Victorian literary team-up, The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen. The film sank with critics and barely scraped a profit.

What Happened Next: You could argue Connery was already sliding into retirement before LXG, but with the occasional film coming out, it was definitely the last straw. In 2005 he announced his retirement, disillusioned by those in power and memories of LXG still strong in his mind. It wasn't all bad though - LXG also killed director Stephen Norrington€™'s career too (along with much of the supporting cast).


11. Mike Myers - The Love Guru

Mike Myers The Love Guru
Paramount Pictures

The Actor: Despite visibly helming two successful comedy franchises (Wayne€™s World and Austin Powers), Mike Myers is best known for playing Shrek, a character it€™'s nigh on impossible to make out as him. What€™'s funny is that these three series aside, Myers, a highly regarded name in comedy, doesn't have many films to his name. His career was pretty much made on the back of Austin Powers, which he's seemed unable to follow on from.

The Film: Now technically this all started with The Cat In The Hat, but many chalked that up as a minor mistake to make a quick buck. It was with The Love Guru, with Myer€™s returning to adult comedy, that he really fell from grace. A putrid exercise in taking the easy route for laughs, audiences and critics despised it in equal measure. As writer and producer also, the faults were all on Myers.

What Happened Next: He'€™d already filmed a role as an English general for Inglourious Basterds (Tarantino felt like giving someone else a pointless cameo this time), but The Love Guru has literally spelled the end of his career. Shrek has finally stopped and with his last successful live action film over a decade ago, it looks like Hollywood have learned something they seem unable to with Will Smith and realised success in the nineties does not translate to success today.


10. Chris O'Donnell - Batman And Robin

chris o'donnell batman robin
Warner Bros.

The Actor: Chris O'Donnell already had a Golden Globe nomination to his name before he took on the role of Dick Grayson in Batman Forever, but after that threequel€™s impressive box office haul he looked ready to reach the big leagues. Of course, Forever was incredibly derivative, adding a neon glow to the increasingly tired gothic nature of Burton€™s Batman, But with a sequel on the way, things were looking up.

The Film: Batman And Robin is a film that, if it hadn't been such a public disgrace, many wouldn't believe even existed. As camp as the Adam West Batman, it makes the merchandise focused Star Wars prequels look positively reserved. Now if there€™'s one person whose career Batman And Robin destroyed is would have to be Joel Schumacher; try as he might his recent films are met with little fanfare. But we'€™re talking actors here and as George Clooney somehow survived, it€™s his co-star who took the brunt of it.

What Happened Next: Clooney aside, most of the cast suffered, but unlike Uma Thurman (who went on to Kill Bill) and Arnold Schwarzenegger (who became the Governator before returning to acting), O'€™Donnell'€™s career spiralled downwards. There'€™s nothing of note in his CV, which looks like money grabbing at best. He managed a few cameos on long running TV series, but the promising young actor€™s career was dead by the time Gotham melted.


9. Terrence Howard - Iron Man

Iron Man Terrence Howard
Marvel

The Actor: It€™'s hard to imagine Iron Man ruining anyone€™'s career; Robert Downey Jr. is once again a Hollywood player thanks solely to Tony Stark. What€™'s even more amazing is that Terrence Howard was the highest paid actor on the the film that created the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Following up from the ensemble Crash with a universally adored performance in Hustle And Flow, 2008 seemed like the perfect time for Howard to jump into blockbuster movies.

The Film: We all know Iron Man and what it led to, but Howard was an altogether forgettable part of it. When it came to a sequel, Marvel realised no one was fussed about Cpt. Rhodes when compared to Stark, so Howard€™'s pay check was severely cut. Shocked that his generic turn as an army type wasn't getting him more money, Howard left, leading to Don Cheadle taking up the War Machine armour.

What Happened Next: Since then, Howard€™'s done next to nothing; he€™'s appeared in a fair few minor films, including George Lucas€™ perplexing Red Tails, but nothing compared to the award noticing performances before. The actor€™'s actually blamed Iron Man for his fall from (near) the top, but while that film was the catalyst, the real cause was his undeserved greed.


8. Ben Affleck - Gigli

Ben Affleck Jennifer Aniston Gigli
Columbia Pictures

The Actor: After the award success of Argo, Ben Affleck will have to make sure he learns from his previous mistakes. His career started well; working up through Kevin Smith films, he had a screenwriting Oscar before he was twenty five. Then things went bad. A string of poor decisions (Pearl Harbour, Daredevil) hurt his acting career greatly, but he still had enough charm to survive. That was until...

The Film: Gigli. A bad romantic comedy shouldn't be enough to kill a career (just look at Matthew McConaughey), but this one offered something different; Affleck and his co star, Jennifer Lopez, had been dating for a year when the film came out. The traditional celebrity obsession, coupled with a director fighting to keep the film his way put Gigli on the map, making its appalling performance incredibly high profile.

What Happened Next: He only went and pulled it back. Out of all the actors on this list, Affleck is the one most people would have put money on to stay dead. Obviously we now know Affleck€™'s career wasn't destroyed by Gigli, but I think the dire years following that film€™s release constitute a acting death. But then some bright spark suggested a career switch to directing and things have exploded from there. And with his follow ups to initial hit Gone Baby Gone, he'€™s back to lead actor and director status, showing to all the failed career€™s we'€™ll see, there can be hope.


7. Brandon Routh - Superman Returns

Superman Returns Brandon Routh
Warner Bros. Pictures

The Actor: Like Henry Cavill, Brandon Routh looks like the ideal Superman. All chiseled features and rippling muscles, Superman Returns should have been the breakout role for Routh. With no previous jawdropping performances to note, it was clearly his looks that bagged him the role.

The Film: I never understood the hate levelled towards Superman Returns. It may not have been the best superhero film of Bryan Singer€™'s career, but there was a reverence for the original films and no one can deny the plane scene isn't flat out awesome. But as with the likes of The Phantom Menace, which likewise got good reviews on release, fanboy disappointment has coloured the film€™s long lasting reputation.

What Happened Next: The film admittedly performed poorly at the box office, failing to keep afloat in the middle the blockbuster saturated summer of 2006, but it€™'s the audience distaste that really hurt Routh. Despite any issues with the film coming from Singer's directing, he€™'s the scapegoat used whenever the film'€™s quality is raised. He managed a large camero in Chuck and popped up in Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World, but in both cases he was there as 'the guy who was an OK Superman once'. Other than those two projects, everything else has been small roles, often in straight-to-DVD movies or deleted before the film hit cinemas.


6. Kevin Costner - Waterworld

Waterworld kevin costner
Universal Pictures

The Actor: Kevin Costner has regained some of his plaudits after a film stealing performance in Man Of Steel, an achievement lessened when you consider that his only real competition was Russell Crowe in a sequence existing only to sell toys. But he€™s still nowhere near the heights Dances With Wolves put him at and although there€™s a sequence of bad movies that brought him to this point, one film started it off. The Film: Anyone bemoaning creativity of current blockbusters can be shut up with the mere mention of Waterworld. Using simplistic Hollywood science, it€™s set in a future where all the ice caps have melted, engulfing the entire Earth in water. And boy did it bomb. With a troubled production, the budget ballooned, leading to a horrific loss when the film underperformed in cinemas. What made the flop worse was the amount of high profile merchandising; a novel, a game and three theme park rides. What Happened Next: Costner€™s absence from all things mainstream should answer this for you, but Waterworld, which he also directed, sparked the beginning of the end for that part of his career. The Postman and string of Razzie nominations simply reaffirmed this and shortly afterwards, likely due to shame, the release of his films slowed dramatically. But if you thought Waterworld was bad, just you wait for the next entry.


5. John Travolta - Battlefield Earth

Battlefield Earth
Warner Bros.

The Actor: It was originally Grease that ended John Travolta€™'s career, until Quentin Tarantino made the brilliant decision to pair him up with Samuel L. Jackson in Pulp Fiction. Now his failings at looking like a high schooler had been negated by actual acting ability, the future looked bright for Travolta.

The Film: Enter Battlefield Earth. If you ever wondered what the point was when his style went from Vince Vega to identikit Euro action look no further than this misguided sci-fi you should be ridiculed for even watching. Travolta was instrumental in the film getting made - as a Scientologist he had a big desire to see a novel by it€™s founder, L. Ron Hubbard, on the big screen - and really should have realised he was onto a loser when no major studio would plump up any money for his script. The film was universally panned and performed terribly, bankrupting it€™s production company in the process.

What Happened Next: Hairspray. And just about nothing else. Travolta'€™s heavy involvement in the film hurt him bad, leading to a decade of cheap films necessary only to pay the bills. His role in Hairspray got some plaudits, but mostly as part of the bigger cast. Look out for him later this year in Killing Season alongside other has-been Robert De Niro. Boy, I can wait.


4. Halle Berry - Catwoman

Halle Berry Catwoman
Warner Bros.

The Actor: I personally never really liked Halle Berry. Every time she touches a popular franchise her performance always comes across as a bit, meh. Jinx was a bland Bond girl saved only by the even worse quality of the rest of Die Another Day and her Storm was one of the few mutants in the X-Men films that felt really forced. But clearly studio bigwigs disagree, as in 2004 they had her head up Catwoman.

The Film: Now in the early Naughties it was assumed just about any top tier superhero would translate into a successful movie. We now know different, but that wasn't before we had a few major misfires. Although Daredevil was seriously bloated and Fantastic Four was criminally boring, it'€™s Catwoman that came out worst. Disregarding the character from the Batman comics, we were presented with a Catwoman making up for what she lacked in seduction with literally acting like a cat.

What Happened Next: Razzie€™s galore. Just three years after her Oscar€™s win for Monster€™s Ball, Berry was deservingly awarded the Worst Actress award, with the film getting three more. She took it with humility, riffing on her Oscar acceptance speech, but the damage had already been done. Aside from X-Men movies the work dried up, with appearances in dour comedy ensembles New Years Eve and Movie 43. Her status as a has-been was affirmed last winter when she starred in Cloud Atlas, the definitive guide to Hollywood actors who were past it.


3. Mark Hamill - Star Wars Episode VI: Return Of The Jedi

return of the jedi
Lucasfilm

The Actor: As we enter the top three, we€™re sticking to one movie franchise here; such is the effect of Star Wars on it€™s lead actors (watch out future star of Episode VII). Now the two that follow are obvious, but this one is a bit more ambiguous. Mark Hamill had next to no experience in acting before he became Luke, but was quickly catapulted into the big leagues once George Lucas€™ space fantasy revolutionised cinema. But it€™s fair to say the series was also the end of him.

The Film: Return Of The Jedi closed off the Star Wars trilogy in relatively repetitive fashion, but did help cap off what is still one of the best trilogies of all time. It marked the end of Luke Skywalker'€™s evolution from naive farm boy to confident hero, although Han Solo was still coolest by far (likely part of the problem). By the time it came out, Harrison Ford had already done one Indy film, with another well on the way and Carrie Fisher had a handful of smaller projects on the horizon, but poor Hamill had nothing

What Happened Next: It'€™s hard to pin the blame on ROTJ directly, but it was this film that was Hamill'€™s last major on screen appearance. The issue here is that he was Luke too long; he didn't carve out another niche like Ford and ended up indistinguishable from the character. Hamill did get a relatively successful career in voice acting, defining the character of the Joker as much as Jack Nicholson or Heath Ledger. Still, looking at Harrison Ford, he could have gone much further.


2. Hayden Christensen - Star Wars Episode III: Revenge Of The Sith

Star Wars Anakin Skywalker Hayden Christensen
Lucasfilm

The Actor: When Lucas decided Attack Of The Clones was going to be set ten years after The Phantom Menace, a new actor was needed. Hayden Christensen had already had some fame in his native Canada, starring in a succession TV films, but was in a similar rut when he moved to the US, until he eventually gained a Golden Globe nomination for Life As A House. Lucas could have gone for a lot worse.

The Film: Attack Of The Clones had the unenviable task of regaining the love of the increasingly fickle fans after The Phantom Menace. Obi-Wan playing detective and an all out Jedi assault did that, but left an even bigger problem for the final prequel; so many loose ends needed to be tied up. And while it succeeded in most things (if a little forced at times), popular consensus is that Anakin€™s turn to the dark side was just too whiney.

What Happened Next: I feel like I'm writing the Chris O€™'Donnell entry again. While many of his co-stars survived, Christensen (and his director) both did very little following Revenge Of The Sith. The representation of the Anakin was heavily lambasted, despite the behind the scenes documentaries showing it was much more Lucas€™ direction than Hayden's acting that was at fault. He headed up a couple of light sci-fi films, before dropping into obscurity.


1. Jake Lloyd - Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace

Jake Lloyd Anakin Skywalker Phantom Menace
Lucasfilm

The Actor: Could it be anyone else? Just like his counterparts from the other films, Lloyd hadn't had much of a career before The Phantom Menace; the only appearance of note being Arnold Schwarzenegger€™s son in Jingle All The Way. The sheer hype for the film catapulted Lloyd into the public eye faster than even Daniel Radcliffe with Harry Potter. As the young Darth Vader, he was in a prime position to shape the character. And in a way he did.

The Film: An awesome short film of an epic lightsaber battle showcasing groundbreaking special effects unfortunately hampered by a lumbering two hour introduction, The Phantom Menace remains the most anticipated and retroactively disappointing film of all time. So many things had people let down with this return to the Star Wars galaxy, but the big one was it€™s representation of Darth Vader. Young, whiney and unbelievable as a character, the problems with Anakin that Christensen had to deal with started here.

What Happened Next: Nothing. Star Wars was the beginning and end of Lloyd€™'s acting career. Following the extreme fanboy backlash and bullying at school he decided to quit acting, however he's still in the industry, looking at a job in editing. Lloyd even still does conventions and is happy to talk about Star Wars, but as with most child actors, it'€™s something long in the past. The sad thing is that, as with Christensen, it wasn't really Lloyd€™'s fault for the quality of the character. But whereas they both had their opportunities as an actor decimated, George Lucas just made $4.05 billion from selling what destroyed them.


Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.