12 Most Controversial Movie Moments Of 2013

Controversy is a strange word in cinema. Some films court outrage as a form of free publicity, many stumble into moral debates by accident and, of course, Auteurs are immune. 2013 barely had a month go by without an outrageous new film gaining headlines for some reason or another, and a particular trend that grew this year, fueled by social networks, was that of the contentious comic book and sci-fi film. As such this list is effectively split in two with the second half dedicated to this growing section of outrage. Of course some of cinema's controversies were not actually in the films but came from comments made during press junkets and promotional tours so some of those have made the list too. As usual with a list like this there are many options that didn't make the cut and for those that did, tread carefully. Spoilers-ahoy!

12. Director Turns Distasteful Voyeur - Blue Is The Warmest Color

2013 Palme d'Or winner 'Blue Is The Warmest Color' has received a lot of praise from critics worldwide and is expected to do well at the major awards thanks to unprecedented success in Cannes, and yet is one of the most controversial films of the year. That controversy all comes down to the inaccurate depiction of lesbian sex, as the scene in question (which has now gone down in cinematic legend) is said to be over long, close to 10 minutes and filmed from a leering male perspective. Julie Maroh, the author of the graphic novel that the film is based on, said of the scene " a brutal and surgical display, exuberant and cold, of so-called lesbian sex, which turned into porn, and made me feel very ill at ease." The thing that made this more interesting and gave strength to these claims was the falling out between the director Abdellatif Kechiche and lead actress Lea Seydoux, which led to Seydoux accusing the director of being exploitative, saying that the scene in question was "very embarrassing" and that she would not work with him again.

11. YOLO Generation Promotes Guns & Rape - Spring Breakers

In April 2013 a film came out designed to cause controversy and revel in the public's outrage. Written and directed by Harmony Korine, the dull and rambling 'Spring Breakers' was mediocre at best and was defended only by teenage boys who liked that Selena Gomez, Vanessa Hudgens, Ashley Benson and Rachel Korine spent most of the film not wearing very much and suggestively playing with guns. Aside from general parental grumblings, much of the outrage came from anti-gun organisations who disliked the glorification of firearms and women's rights groups that accused the film of promoting rape culture and putting the emphasis on its female characters being overly sexualised and 'asking for it.' Director Korine claims the film is an arty, social commentary but knows that the parent's outrage would be enough to promote the film to the youth audience who want to see the tale of teens going bad, extreme violence, drugs and sex.

10. Diaz REALLY Loves Cars - The Counselor

Universally panned Cormac McCarthy thriller The Counselor seems to have been either not seen or disliked by most people who did venture out to see it at the cinema. Aside from being terrible, there is one scene that has been talked about more than any other, which is somewhat unsurprising given that it features Cameron Diaz having sex with a car. In the scene her character, Malinka, removes her underwear and enthusiastically gets herself off using the windscreen of a car belonging to Javier Bardem's character, Reiner, while his watches on in shock and amazement from the passenger seat. The scene, which is told in flashback, is described in much more unpleasant detail, so not even closing your eyes will save you from being traumatised. Most critics who panned the film took a special shot at this scene, which was called '0ne of the most wince-inducing scenes in years' by Entertainment Weekly. Yikes.

9. The Stark (Un)Reality Of Murder - The Act Of Killing

Joshua Oppenheimer's shocking documentary used real members of death squads to give accounts of the 1965 anti-communist slaughter in Indonesia. These men were asked to recreate the human rights abuses they perpetrated which makes for a chilling and hard film to watch, not least because the free reign of the reenactments meant they were stylised to suit various film genres. At an international screening in Berlin the film was compared to "having SS officers re-enact the holocaust," which should tell you everything about the controversy factor here. Victims of the purges have protested the film saying that the role of the military in the murders has been ignored. Survivor Astaman Hasibuan told The Jakarta Post in September 2012; "The film did not involve the military, despite the fact that soldiers carried out the massacres. I voice my protest." He went on to say that despite being interviewed for the film and reading the script he is disappointed in the direction it finally took, tarnishing the names of youths and protecting military forces.

8. Nobody Wants To See That! - Nymphomaniac

Calling out Lars Von Trier's new film as controversial is like being shocked that Tarantino's latest is full of gore and violence, or that oxygen is pretty helpful. In the case of Nymphomaniac, Von Trier has tried to create hype and sensation to promote the film for years. He has long talked about making an artistic pornographic film and now he has he is reveling in the intrigue and shock it is causing. The story follows Joe, a self-confessed sex addict who tells her troubled life story through flashbacks to an a man who finds her beaten in an alley. Rumours of the actors taking part in real sex scenes were perpetuated by star Shia LaBeouf and have since proved unfounded, which is a lot less shocking considering his more recent transgressions. Instead producers have revealed that a combination of doubles and CGI have been used, possibly to help avoid an X rating. The list of names involved is a large part of what makes it such a sensation; Charlotte Gainsbourg, Willem Dafoe, Uma Thurman, Christian Slater, Stellan Skarsgard and Jamie Bell will all join LaBoeuf in the epic five hour, two part film. The hype will keep growing with this one as reportedly shocking trailers (containing uncensored fellatio among other delights) were pulled from Youtube and promotional posters showing nothing but the actor's orgasmic sex faces become more prominent.

7. Casualising Prostitution - Jeune & Jolie (Young & Beautiful)

Francois Ozon's latest film is sold as 'a contemporary portrait of a teenage girl.' In fact this is the story of a 17 year old who, while her peers would be trying drugs and drink, chooses to turn to prostitution as an adolescent experiment. The film makes clear this is a desicion made of free will. She does not do this out of desperation, she has a good family and wants for nothing. While this is an uncomfortable premise that has caused murmurs of discontent, the outrage caused in France came when Ozon gave an interview to The Hollywood Reporter in which he stated, "I think women can really be connected with this girl because it's a fantasy of many women to do prostitution." These comments set women's groups up in arms and brought criticism from Najat Vallaud-Belkacem, France's Minister for Women's Rights who said "It's terrifying to trivialise, to give the impression that there is a casualness in prostitution. This is not true. Casualness and prostitution are contradictory."

6. BatFleck

Batfleck Having seen their rivals Marvel flourish with a string of interlinked superhero franchises and with the finale of their own Dark Knight trilogy, DC Comics needed something big to follow on from the mixed reviews of 'Man of Steel.' They came up with 'Batman Vs. Superman' which on paper sounds promising if it were to take the tone of Christopher Nolan's Batman films. The big question was who would replace Christian Bale. Fans hoping for another gritty film were confused and angry when it revealed that Ben Affleck had been selected as the next man to take on the cowl. Despite his vastly improved performances in recent years that culminated in 'Argo' many seem to have had flashbacks to his last superhero film 'Daredevil.' Former Batman George Clooney gave his support to Ben saying 'he knows what he's doing' but at the same time said 'I am the least qualified person to comment on anyone playing the role of Batman since I so terribly destroyed the part.' All we can do is wait and see what happens. Perhaps the diminished expectations will mean the film is a pleasant surprise. After all, he's got the jaw line for it!

5. Superman Kills - Man Of Steel

More superhero controversy here as the latest Superman film rehashes his origin story. The film was far too long and aside from Kevin Costner, failed to bring the promised Nolan-esque grit to Superman. The fanboy outcry came from the final scenes of the film where Superman, who is traditionally sworn to not kill, can find no solution to stop Zod killing a family with his heat vision other than to kill him. That's right Superman murders General Zod. (who quite frankly, had a very valid point in his motivations) The director and producers have tried to assuage fans by insisting that putting Superman in an 'impossible' situation is a key part of the origin and this is not yet the fully formed hero that we all know. Between resolving this and BatFleck, 'Batman Vs. Superman' has got one hell of a job to do.

4. "The Mandarin" - Iron Man 3

In the Iron Man comics the Mandarin is Tony Stark's main nemesis, think the Joker to Batman for comparison. All the promotional trailers, clips, posters and interviews for Iron Man 3 seemed to be set up to bring this huge character into the film franchise at last. Sir Ben Kingsley was named to be playing The Mandarin which brought some grumbles but the fury came halfway through the film when instead of being a super villain, it was revealed that he was actually an actor hired by Killian, the real villain of the film and that the whole concept of The Mandarin was made up as a public face for the terror attacks taking place worldwide. Fans were furious that such a vital character was turned into little more than a comedy bit for Ben Kingsley to play, but it for the rest of us it was a brilliant twist that gave a standard 'superhero versus super-villain' story a refreshing shake up.

3. Khaaaaaaaan! - Star Trek Into Darkness

For what was intended to be a standard blockbuster sequel to J.J.Abrams' hugely successful Star Trek reboot, 'Star Trek: Into Darkness' turned out to be one of the most controversial films of the year. It was a huge critical and box office success but very soon a backlash against certain aspects of the film began to form, illogical changes to lore and trampling over touchstones of the franchise's history were too much for some fans. So much so that a vote at a convention declared 'Into Darkness' the worst Star Trek film ever made. Amongst all the niggles, including the grammar of the title, there were two major controversies that reached beyond the hardcore fans; The first problem was the gratuitous and totally unnecessary shots of Alice Eve stripped to her underwear for no reason at all. The idea of 'something for the dads' is very outdated and this came across as cynical and sexist. Writer Damon Lindelof has since taken to twitter to apologise for the scene coming across as gratuitous. Next Cumberbatch as Khan... or is he? Yes, he obviously is, which made the mystery of Cumberbatch's character being named as John Harrison a bit of a farce before even seeing the film. Later in the film the iconic cry of 'Khaaaaaaaaan' from Wrath of Khan was recycled and given to Spock instead of Kirk which made the film feel like a bad patchwork of old Trek moments.

2. Rubber Faced Actor Suddenly Hates Violence - Kick-Ass 2

Kick-Ass 2 failed in every place that the original had excelled and the box office reflected this worldwide. It is unlikely that his statements affected this in any way but almost a month before release possibly the biggest name in the film, Jim Carrey, came forward on Twitter to distance himself from the film because of its violent content; "I did Kickass a month b4 Sandy Hook and now in all good conscience I cannot support that level of violence" he wrote. From this point on he withdrew his support for the film and refused to take part in any promotion for it, which some might suggest was more thanks to having actually seen the film than any moral reasoning. What is surprising is that the Twitter-led response to this was largely against Carrey. Despite his condemnation of it in the press he was happy to keep his hefty fee from the film. Ironically, his boycott brought far more interest to the film than if he had just taken part in the press junkets.

1. Author's Homophobic Slurs Resurface - Ender's Game

In the weeks and months leading up to the release of the highly hyped sci-fi adaptation 'Ender's Game,' the film became secondary to the outcry over the beliefs of author Orson Scott Card in relation to the gay community and, in particular, gay marriage. While his opinions had been out in the open for years, when it came time for Hollywood's promotional behemoth to move into action it was met by an online campaign to boycott the film in protest. As a result of the pressure Lionsgate put out a statement distancing itself and the film from the writer's own, personal views. Since then director Gavin Hood and actors from the film including Harrison Ford have also spoken out to distance themselves from Card's opinions. In the end the controversy garnered more attention than the film, which made a mediocre $28 million on its US opening weekend. Did we miss any controversial moments from 2013 that deserved to be on this list? Share your own picks below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

I have one golden rule: There is no such thing as a guilty pleasure. Any song or film that makes you feel good doesn't need justifying.